r/PMsFeedback • u/AgAuSeller • Feb 18 '21
[NEGATIVE] sidewayslipper (update)
—You can refer to my previous negative posts on this user for the background information. I am going to provide a couple of updates from some blogs that I have written as I think this process may shed some light on the use of PayPal for precious metals purchases.
Post 1: I often see it debated in these precious metals forums if precious metals are covered by PayPal goods and services buyer‘s protection program. I have recently completed pre-trial mediation and a 4 hour trial where I sued Paypal concerning a transaction resulting in such a dispute. If allowed by Admin, I will gladly post what I have learned through my experience in the Comments upon approval. Thanks in advance.
Post 2: I have just recently completed pre-trial mediation and a four hour trial with PayPal concerning a transaction of precious metals that I had with a buyer. At this time, I am awaiting the judges deliberation and decision. I do not have an idea how long that will take. In the event I am offered an acceptable settlement from PayPal, I would also expect that they will include a nondisclosure agreement. Therefore I will go ahead and post my story.
On Reddit, I sold a few thousand dollars worth of precious metals in the form of bullion to a buyer in Canada. I shipped to the address that he specifically told me to multiple times in our correspondence. The package was tracked through the USPS and Canada Post and subsequently marked as successfully delivered. In spite of it being marked as successfully delivered, the buyer claimed he did not receive the package. He had paid through PayPal goods and services and subsequently filed a claim with them through the Buyer’s Protection Program. PayPal, to my surprise, sided with the buyer and reversed the transaction out of my account. I subsequently appealed the decision, but they again refused to refund the money they had taken from me and told me I had no additional course of action. As this did not sit well with me, I subsequently filed a lawsuit against PayPal. I have no legal training whatsoever and no legal experience. I filed this lawsuit for a cost to me of approximately $70 in filing fees. I spent about 30 minutes of prep time to prepare for this trial. I represented myself. At pre-trial mediation and subsequently at trial, I was met by a specialized attorney representing PayPal. They also called another attorney as a witness during the course of the trial. With my lawsuit, I was simply seeking approximately $6000 in damages, the max that I was allowed by the court where I filed. The attorney let me know that PayPal took my lawsuit very seriously and he had billed well in excess of my $6000 asking price in order to defend this lawsuit. I was offered a lowball offer in order to dismiss the suit at mediation. I would’ve also been expected to sign a non-disclosure agreement if I had accepted that offer. The money in this case is of little consequence to me. I proceeded more based on the principle and the ability to share my experience with others in the precious metal forums.
I will share some of the lessons that I learned through the course of my lawsuit. First, if you ever have an issue with PayPal, they are going to assume that you have read in its entirety the user agreement for PayPal service, which is an approximate 60 page document. This user agreement will also make reference to a privacy statement, an acceptable use policy, and an electronic communications delivery policy. They will also assume that you have read the entirety of these three documents for a total of about 100 pages of documentation. As I mentioned, I spent about 30 minutes prep time for this trial. I had not even read these documents in their entirety. And still have not to this date.
According to the acceptable use policy, PayPal requires pre-approval to accept payment for precious metals. They do provide an email address in order to obtain this permission. I seriously doubt many people have ever obtained prior approval before they conduct a transaction involving precious metals with PayPal as payment. Simply entering into an agreement to buy and sell precious metals without prior approval is a breach of the contract with PayPal. The judge seemed to state that both parties were in breach, yet I was the only one being punished by PayPal. Hopefully that bodes well for me.
According to the PayPal user agreement, shipping of a package with a value of $750 or more requires a signature confirmation. If the buyer were to make an item not received claim, the seller has to provide either proof of shipment or proof of delivery. Without a signature confirmation, they will not consider it proof of delivery. You still can provide proof of shipment. In my particular case, the buyer had a different address listed on his email transaction form that was different from the one he gave me in our correspondence. Since I shipped to the one that he directed me to in our correspondence, I shipped to a different address than what was on the Paypal transaction form. They tried to argue that I did not have proof of shipment as I did not ship to the address that was on the proof of transaction form. My arguments were that signature confirmation has not been collected since the start of the pandemic. Given shipments that I send or receive that are registered, restricted delivery have not been obtaining signatures. This is the highest security form of shipment through the US PS and how confidential government documents are shipped through the USPS. The judge also seem to dismiss the address discrepancy as irrelevant as the buyer was not claiming he did not order the product or it was shipped to him without his prior consent. He simply states he did not receive it at the address he was expecting it. The judge seemed to side with me on this point.
A big part of my argument relies on the user agreement specifically excluding financial product or investment of any type from protection from the buyer’s protection program. In the past, in earlier versions of this user agreement, it specifically mentioned precious metals and bullion. They do periodically update it. I strongly argued, and I believe convincingly, that Canadian gold maples have a face value, are legal tender, are a financial product, and are an investment. This alone should prove that PayPal‘s decision was in breach of contract. PayPal attempted to argue that my lack of proof of delivery or proof of shipment superseded this point.
The bottom line: if you enter into an agreement to buy and ship precious metals without prior authorization or without prior approval for a transaction exceeding $750 or without signature confirmation of delivery, you are in breach of contract. As a buyer, if you enter into an agreement to purchase precious metals without prior approval, you are in breach of contract. If a dispute such as mine arises, PayPal may be forced to take a side one way or the other. Regardless of PayPal‘s actions, there will be a party that is impoverished or harmed, and can seek legal remedy. Of course, this only becomes an issue if a dispute arises. Utilizing the goods and services features of PayPal in no way alters the contractual obligation. It may help PayPal to side with the buyer initially, but I will have to await the outcome of my verdict to see if that holds up. whenever I see debate back-and-forth about if precious metals are covered by PayPal‘s policy. I understand the confusion. They are specifically excluded per the user agreement. But, that may only be one factor that PayPal takes into consideration.
Sorry for the length of this. Hopefully, some may find it useful. The fact that the judge has asked for time to deliberate his decision hopefully means I put up a formidable fight. I was outmatched in legal knowledge. Nothing will replace dealing with reputable people with a proven history.
Post 3: So I went back to court today with the impression that I would have a quick and simple trial with the buyer. A couple of amateurs. It was before the same judge as my trial with PayPal. So the judge consolidated the two cases. So I was again met by a high-priced attorney representing PayPal. We end up in the court room for another 2 1/2 hr trial in what can only be described as a legal menage a trois between myself, Paypal, and the buyer. Three different parties, three different interests. To open, PayPal‘s attorney presents about an inch thick file with all of the research and case law as he sees pertains to the previous trial that is still under consideration. At one point, the judge made a comment that PayPal has to have spent more than $14,000 to defend a small claims case. I suspect that PayPal is taking this so seriously because for $70 and no experience, I think I have made a worthy case to punch holes in their user agreement. I suspect this may have much larger implications and consequences on the line for them.
I found it somewhat awkward and put me at a disadvantage to first have to argue that I fulfilled all of my obligations to the buyer as a seller. There are many unnecessary details to this case that I won’t go into detail here, but in our communication, the buyer was offered insurance and declined and agreed to be responsible for the risk of shipping. So I had to argue that he was responsible for any potential loss. At the same time, I had to argue that the transaction between the buyer and myself was complete. It was PayPal who came in after the fact to reverse those charges and take the money from me. And I argued that this was done in breach of their contract as it specifically does not cover financial product or investment of any type. The buyer argued that since he paid with PayPal, he believed he was under the terms of PayPal which required confirmation of shipping, signature confirmation, etc. The judge also made the comment that the buyer could say he completed his obligation by making payment. It was PayPal that took the money from me, not the buyer. This was something he would have to consider. PayPal argued that because we were both in breach of contract and had a dispute between us, that it is their right to arbitrarily decide.
In short, it is a triangular mess but with some important points to consider for the judge and PayPal as a whole that could have much wider ranging implications. The judge states that he will have to research the decision and it would be 3 to 4 weeks, at a minimum, before he would have a written decision. In any event, I get the feeling that should this decision go against PayPal where they would be liable for the charges, I suspect that they may file an appeal to a higher court. Let’s keep running up the legal charges for them. STICKING IT TO THE MAN, 2021!