r/PlayTemtem • u/Lon-ami • Feb 17 '20
[Discussion] Rising prices won't stop inflation, or how the rich get richer and everyone else stops playing the game
I don't think anyone around Crema has MMO experience. Not now, not from their previous jobs, not from their own gaming. Which is fine, no one is born knowing, and this is Early Access after all.
I say this because they're repeating many of the mistakes other companies did, years, even decades ago. In this day and age, rookie mistakes.
The way they initially handled bans was a big red warning; and don't get me wrong, I'm very glad they went back, but they should have never crossed that line. Now we're watching how they're singlehandedly destroying the economy and the fun of the game.
Part 1: The three types of players
Let's start by defining the three prime types of MMO players:
Hardcore: If the game has multiple modes, they usually spend all their time on one of them. They are the best players, the top of the top, and they barely pay any attention to anything outside their bubble.
Dedicated: They spend a lot of time ingame, and play multiple game modes and activities at once. They aren't as good as the hardcores, but they know the overall game better. Completionists and guild leaders are prime dedicated players.
Casual: Plays now and then, they never get too engaged, and they're kinda trashy, but they're the lifeblood of the game. Without them, the game would be pretty much dead.
The three types are equally important, period. It's vital to keep the health of the three groups balanced.
Part 2: Why taxes can't be universal
So there's this good farming spot. Some players abuse it, farming 24h. So you obviously nerf it to the ground. Fine, right?
No. You just fucked it up, big time.
In a situation like this, you have to observe the whole picture. Yeah, there are some hardcore farmers there, but there are also many casual and dedicated players having fun around the place. If you only look at the hardcores and how to stop them, you're gonna ruin the whole game for everyone else.
The true solution? Diminishing returns. The farm is still there, same drop rates, but it stops working after a fixed period of time.
Part 3: Applying this principle to Temtem
I want to keep the thread short (I could talk hours and hours on game design, specially MMO game design), so let's get straight to the point:
Breeding Temtem: DNA Strands are cheap once again. The biggest part of the breeding costs have been moved to the act of breeding itself. The first 10 eggs are really cheap. 11 and forward get exponentially more expensive. This rule has a weekly reset.
Luma farming: The first luma of the week is 1/2000. All the next ones after that are 1/8000. Want to farm one per week? Somewhat reasonable. Want to farm 20 per week? Extra effort required. Unlucky catch? Try next week, or farm harder.
FreeTem rewards: The current numbers are insane, marginalizing both casual, dedicated, and non-farmer hardcore players. Tune them down, and make them progressive. Free 20, get x1 reward. Free 60, get x1 of the same reward. Free 250, get x1 of the same reward. 20 gets 1, 60 gets 2, 250 gets 3; and everyone can participate and get their rewards.
The point is to allow farming at healthy levels, but start to restrict it when it gets too insane. This way, both the casual and dedicated crowds can have fun, without letting the hardcores run wild.
This principle is no different than applying difficulty modes to the same piece of game content. Single difficulty levels always alienate a part of the playerbase, but selectable difficulty modes with progressive rewards make everyone happy. Nowadays raids (classically hardcore-exclusive content) are accessible by anyone through easy/normal/hard modes, and PvP game modes have leagues where you'll be matched against people of your skill level. Loot is no different.
Don't confuse diminishing returns with time sinks or time gates, those are the exact opposite of the current problem we have, ruining the experience for hardcore players instead.
Simple, yet effective. You don't need global nerfs just to stop hardcore players from getting too effective at what they do. Complete nerfs aren't good in general, but that would be worth its own thread, maybe for another day.
I hope the community starts rallying behind these kind of changes, making Crema value the insight and reconsider their stance. I want to have fun at the game without having to farm like crazy, but that doesn't mean I want free handouts either.
PS: La declaración de la renta tiene tramos, aplicad el mismo principio al loot del juego y os ahorraréis muchos disgustos en el futuro. No dejéis que medidas de control económico a la desesperada como las que habéis tomado últimamente arruinen el resto del juego. Ánimo y adelante.



