r/Plato • • 2d ago

Why do people say Plato is one of the easiest philosopher to understand ?

13 Upvotes

Hello I am currently reading Plato, I've already read all of his early dialogues + cratylus, euthydemus, meno and I don't understand why people say it is easy to read or easy to understand.

I usually face a lot of troubles reading and understanding Plato.

First of all, the subjects of dialogues are very abstract and what follow from this is usually more abstract and when it comes about the demonstrations, it become a semantic nightmare. I usually have difficulty to deeply understand a demonstration developped on 4-5 pages. And what is even harder is, after the demonstration ends, Socrates interlocutor will change subject and try to prove something completely different. For example, I didn't understand a single thing during Protagoras dialogue, when Protagoras suddenly decide to tall about poetry, I didn't understant what was his point, what this had to do with the precedent subject or what he was trying to say. :(

There is two other thing I have difficulties with : I can't go past the aporia and can't figure out by myself what plato really meant. I have to read the explanations from the author of the preface to understand every false aporia. Idk if it is normal or if I'm just too dumb to understand what Plato meant after some aporias :(

And last thing is, sometimes I just can't understand the point of some dialogue : especially the Menexenus and the Euthydemus, I just didn't understand what was the point of those two dialogues, why did he wrote that ? What was his point after a complete bullshit dialogue between euthydemus, dyonisodorus and Socrates ?

So I am wondering, am I too dumb or Plato is more difficult than what people say ?


r/Plato • • 2d ago

Discussion A disposição e interesse - filósofo poeta Baldé

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Plato • • 3d ago

Resource/Article Why Plato Wrote Dialogues | Very Bad Wizards podcast

Thumbnail
open.spotify.com
4 Upvotes

David and Tamler model philosophical conversation for their listeners by discussing Drew Hyland's excellent essay "Why Plato Wrote Dialogues." What possibilities does the dialogue form open up for Plato? Could his ideas be captured in a more straightforward treatise or essay? Or does philosophy involve more than just propositions and arguments? Plus, Blexas and the midterms, and a new study on how golfers perform in a group with people on the other side of the aisle.

Hyland, D. A. (1968). Why Plato wrote dialogues. Philosophy & Rhetoric, 1(1), 38-50. [jstor.org]


r/Plato • • 3d ago

Discussion Plato Got Vision Totally Wrong

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/Plato • • 3d ago

Meditation experience

0 Upvotes

During meditation I see a light that shines upon these darkly veiled forms or figures. Is this a common experience for people who do visual meditation? I felt like I was accessing another dimension: the platonic realm.


r/Plato • • 3d ago

How does Plato think we lost knowledge at birth?

4 Upvotes

Hello, I wanted to ask a question about Plato's epistemology. In a text such as Phaedo, Socrates mentions that we must have lost our knowledge of the Forms at birth and subsequent learning of their existence and nature is recollection. However, I am confused as to how Plato or Socrates conceive of the soul losing knowledge at birth; why does this happen? How do they think it happens?

Thank you


r/Plato • • 3d ago

Irony of Aristotle and Plato

2 Upvotes

I am studying Anaxagoras, who places the nous as the ordering principle of the cosmos.

As far as I understand, for this he received the appreciation of Plato and Aristotle, who however also criticized him:

Plato, whose idea interacts with matter is not understood, accuses him of making little use of the nous and of finding material explanations.

Aristotle, who posited the unmoved mover to solve the problem of infinite regress, defines his nous as a deus ex macchina.

It seems to me that these two are making criticisms of Anaxagoras that they could easily direct at themselves, don't you think?


r/Plato • • 3d ago

Plato of the gym

Thumbnail
tenor.com
0 Upvotes

r/Plato • • 6d ago

Di ko matanggak itong mantsa sa plato ko

Post image
7 Upvotes

Ginamit ko na lahat. Mainit na tubig, asin, sponge, basta lahat ng maisip mo.


r/Plato • • 7d ago

Question Confusion over the claim that increases to the immortal (if possible) must emerge from the mortal in Plato's Republic

10 Upvotes

I'm reading through George Grube's translation of Plato's Republic, and I'm a bit stumped on the claim Socrates makes during the ending portion of his argument for the immortality of the soul.

Passage 611a:

And if it is so (that souls are immortal), you realize that the souls would always be the same, for they could not be made any less by the death of one soul, nor become more numerous, for if anything immortal is increased, the increase must come from what is mortal, and everything would be immortal in the end.

I can see the general argument he makes here, but I'm confused on his justification for the bolded part. Why should an increase in the immortal necessarily emerge from the mortal? Is there something I missed?


r/Plato • • 9d ago

Does pop-philosophy over-apply the allegory of the cave?

5 Upvotes

(21M. I wrote this a little mad, maybe, and I like directness and obsolescence- maybe good maybe be bad…but anyways lmk what you think)

I think platos allegory of the cave is misrepresented. I think people overapply it.

The allegory was to say Athens could not accept the wisdom of Socrates. But people make seem as though “…this analogy shows that if you have “seen the light and truth”/if you have reached an epiphany, it isn’t guaranteed the people you let know will accept it”. This is misleading because it reinforces a person subjective perspective, or worse yet, it makes people believe in their delusions.

The allegory can be SOCIALLY interpreted that changing the status quo (of which is you have deduced is inefficient, unjust or unequal) will get you killed lol
It isn’t easy for society to forego a fundamental reality, so radical change that questions one’s existential position will not sit well with people.

This is assuming you have somehow thoroughly analysis the global sociopolitical and economic landscape, and have someone contoured the best foundations for an optimally functional society, which I do not believe most people can do.

The allegory is good and its vivid, and so its pattern is seen everywhere. But that wasn’t its point. Its point was to show that propositions of change are hard to pass and may possibly lead to death (the Socrates murder is happening in the background of this concept).

But PHILOSOPHICALLY, the freed prisoner is the philosopher, and his “return to the cave …”to educate”” is his going against heteronormativity and present the “true living” he has thus witnessed. As such, he is seen by the cave-dwellers as useless or as a threat. This allegory was laid out to Glaucon, and was also meant for like readers.

It isn’t a “rejection is proof of the legitimacy of my epiphany” metaphor. You’ll will die under the mental pressure of your inconsistent and incomplete beliefs.

This allegory was a lesson for the philosopher, to warn him of the responses and possible consequences of his words. It was also a calling out of the ones claiming “truth” without having gone the needed gruesome journey of the philosopher who has “seeing the light” through that exact journey.

Pop-philosophy has turned this into another quasi-self-help, self-affirming individualist masturbatory concept without the weight Plato intended for it.


r/Plato • • 9d ago

Resource/Article The myths of Plato by John Alexander Stewart (PDF 1921)

Thumbnail
studyebooks.com
3 Upvotes

The object of this volume is to furnish the reader with material for estimating the characteristics and influence of Plato the Mythologist, or Prophet, as distinguished from Plato the Dialectician, or Reasoner.


r/Plato • • 10d ago

Reading Group Plato’s Sophist, on Truth, Falsity, & Seeming — An online live reading & discussion group starting Nov 7, weekly meetings led by Constantine Lerounis

Thumbnail
reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/Plato • • 11d ago

Question What books give the best comprehensive overview of plato

3 Upvotes

Im looking to under platos ideas without necessarily reading the primary works, all I can find online is people saying platos complete works by john cooper,does anyone have a book recommendation that gives a comprehensive introduction to his entire philosophy and ideas without it just being the primary text(i also dont mind recommending multiple books for it)


r/Plato • • 12d ago

Question Is there a recognized tradition of "Existential Platonism"? How do existential accounts of agency intersect with Objective Idealism (e.g., Schelling)?

1 Upvotes

I've recently been thinking about the tension and potential bridge between Existentialism and Platonic Realism/Objective Idealism.

Existentialism often asserts that "existence precedes essence"—that we have no predetermined blueprint and must construct meaning through action. However, it seems to me that one's primary, authentic act of free will can be a deliberate commitment to seek objective order, wisdom, and the Good (in a Platonic sense). Under this view, objective forms or values are not static constraints imposed from the outside, but targets we freely choose to align our lives toward.

This seems to mirror Schelling's Naturphilosophie and his later Positive Philosophy, where the self-conscious human agent acts within a living, objective order, using free will to bring rational harmony out of chaotic raw existence.

My questions are:

Which historical philosophers or contemporary commentators have explicitly attempted to synthesize existential freedom with Platonic or Schellingian metaphysics?

Is it coherent within academic philosophy to hold that an individual's "essence" is existentially forged through an intentional commitment to objective Platonic forms?


r/Plato • • 13d ago

Resource/Article I started reading Plato. Then I left my husband.

Thumbnail thetimes.com
5 Upvotes

As an evangelical mother and Christian pop star, Julianna Glasse hid books around the house, fearing they went against her family’s lifestyle. They ended up being her escape.

No paywall link: https://archive.ph/1HmQ9


r/Plato • • 14d ago

What Socrates used to talk about

Thumbnail
reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/Plato • • 15d ago

Question I wanted to start reading phylosophy , is this book an good for beggingner ?

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/Plato • • 16d ago

was plato neurodivergent?

0 Upvotes

Starting this off by saying i have aspergers and adhd, i really enjoy reading platos writings i find him funny but i cant help but question if he was neurodivergent, specifically aspergers, (now before anyone comes at me for nazi shit, i cant help that he was the one that distinguished the differences between autism and aspergers, not his beliefs or thoughts or anything quite literally the differences he in his professional opinion found), just the way platos thought processes read and specifically how he writes, if that makes sense, comes across as autistic, just wondered if anyone had any similar thoughts or thoughts as to why i might just be reaching, a dunno theres a vibe there i feel.


r/Plato • • 16d ago

Plato seems awfully reluctant in his writings to directly talk about the source, or principle, of all things. And yet he also gave a public lecture on the topic. What is going on here, and what can we learn about his metaphysics from this?

Thumbnail
platosfishtrap.substack.com
21 Upvotes

r/Plato • • 16d ago

Has anyone here tried “Exploring the Greats” book club on Plato’s Republic?

1 Upvotes

I’m reading it for a course I’m taking. I just stumbled across it and thought it could be interesting, but wanted to hear from others before subscribing.


r/Plato • • 18d ago

What does Plato mean here on Book 5 of The Republic?

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/Plato • • 19d ago

Must reads before Plato

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/Plato • • 22d ago

Há 2.400 anos, Platão previu o nosso noticiário de hoje. Ele só não sabia que tudo começaria na mesa de jantar.

Thumbnail
azankiev.itch.io
0 Upvotes