r/Pitchfork • • Feb 05 '26

Anyone else think this blowback is wildly out of proportion?

4 Upvotes

I’ve been a Pitchfork reader for about a decade now. As far as I am concerned, Pitchfork remains the strongest and leading voice in music criticism today. Stereogum, Rolling Stone, NME, etc are just not as high-caliber IMO, full stop.

Of course, it’s nice that we all got to read high quality music journalism for free over the years. But in a time when the profession is rapidly eroding and journalists cannot make a living doing this work, is it really so crazy that Pitchfork dare to charge an exorbitant $5/month in order to read their reviews and have full access to their site?

I agree that the pitch that the subscription allows you to rate albums too and leave comments is dumb. But most other media outlets (ex. Rolling Stone) already have paywalls and charge even more.

It seems to me that this is a broader issue of consumers getting accustomed to art and media being free in the age of the internet and streaming. 20 years ago, a $10-20/month subscription for a magazine would be normal.


r/Pitchfork • • Aug 12 '26

Alphonse Pierre must be fired!

0 Upvotes

What is this guy's deal? Is he literally trolling? How can an ostensibly serious music critic have such a terrible taste? I started noticing this last year when I tried listening through his end of year best rap albums list. I gave an earnest shot to the bizarre, sloppy, repetitive, unappealing albums he selected. The entire process actually made me angry.

I usually check stuff out if it's on "Albums Out this Week You Should Listen to Now," so I did listen to the new Nino Paid album earlier this week. It was not my cup of tea, and I could not get through it, nor could I really even see the appeal to it. The beats are wack, the lyrics are boring, the flows are all the same, and his voice sounds terrible. Okay that's fine. I can live with an album being bad.

But going to pitchfork today and seeing that shitty album emblazoned with "best new music" and the inevitable byline... this is the last straw. Good lord. You cannot pay somebody to be a music critic when this is the crap they like. If there were any reason to keep reading pitchfork, i think I'm done with it now


r/Pitchfork • • 5d ago

Can someone explain why Pitchfork hasn’t dropped QOTSA’s “Perfecth” album review yet?

1 Upvotes

They included the album on a recent “Albums to listen to now” list, yet still haven’t posted the review and in the meantime reviewed multiple less-known bands. Some kinda power play, huh? Too busy for “rock music”, boys and gals?


r/Pitchfork • • 2d ago

Here's one option: ignore Pitchfork's Top 100 Indie Rock albums

0 Upvotes

I'm a fervent "indie rock" fan, however it's defined, and a longtime reader of Pitchfork but I've decided to opt out of their pointless Top 100 Indie Rock albums list entirely. I haven't read it and haven't participated in any debates over its content, other than to underscore that I'm sitting this one out.

And really, I've been disappointed to see some bands participate in the shameless cross-promotional circlejerk that these lists are meant to generate: "Hey, look our album from 20 years ago made number 17 1/2! Isn't Pitchfork the definitive voice on indie rock!"

No thanks.

NOTE: There's a clear distinction in ignoring the content of the list while making points about the existence of the list as such and the way it feeds into Pitchfork's inflated sense of importance and a lame cross-promotional cycle. Its unfortunate that people keep trying to score points off of a non-existent contradiction in this stance rather than engaging in the substance of my point, but that's Reddit I guess. If this post annoys you, please feel free to keep scrolling -- you and I can both agree that this is not a big deal.


r/Pitchfork • • Apr 01 '26

7.6 for y2k 3.4 for bully

0 Upvotes

Pitchfork is cooked


r/Pitchfork • • Sep 19 '26

My Tier list for all albums Pitchfork have given a 10.

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Thoughts?

Which of the albums that I haven't heard should I listen too?


r/Pitchfork • • Dec 07 '14

Pitchfork vs. Wu-Tang

Thumbnail
squawkback.tumblr.com
0 Upvotes

r/Pitchfork • • Jan 20 '26

Pitchfork introduces subscription plan

Thumbnail
pitchfork.com
22 Upvotes

TL;DR: As announced a couple of months ago, starting 2026 readers will be able to comment on reviews and rate albums themselves. Today, Pitchfork announced how that will work and it will be subscription-based. Prices are $5/month or $50/year. Pitchfork is also limiting access to the reviews catalog to subscribers, and only 4 new reviews can be read by non-subscribers per month. So, how do we all feel about it?


r/Pitchfork • • Feb 07 '26

Do Pitchfork scores still carry the same weight?

Post image
10 Upvotes

Do you think Pitchfork scores matter more or less now than they did 10 years ago?

Not asking if they are right or wrong, just curious how much influence people feel they still have.


r/Pitchfork • • Jun 12 '26

I cannot see the number score for Olivia Rodrigo's new album. I'm not a subscriber, but I can see other scores.

8 Upvotes

I cannot see the number score for Olivia Rodrigo's new album. I'm not a subscriber, but I can see other scores. I can go into Private/Incognito mode and see scores for other albums. But Rodrigo's score is still blurred. I've tried it in multiple browsers.

People who subscribe: Can you see the score? I'm wondering if this is a lame attempt by Pitchfork to gain subscribers.

Pitchfork: I don't care that much. I'm just curious about the "why".


r/Pitchfork • • Aug 21 '18

Ouija Beach one man gothic surf punk project,

1 Upvotes

r/Pitchfork • • Feb 07 '26

Any Cameron Winter Fans That Don’t Enjoy Geese?

Post image
20 Upvotes

I recently watched blustre’s YouTube video where he ranked his top 10 albums of 2025, and Heavy Metal was in his 10 spot. However, he admitted he enjoyed Getting Killed but not nearly as much and only returns to a few songs. I thought this was surprising because, although I prefer Heavy Metal as well, I feel like most people’s biggest complaint about it Geese is Winters nasally vocals, and those nasally vocals are especially prominent on Heavy Metal. Anyway, which album do yall prefer? Anyone love Heavy Metal but don’t enjoy Getting Killed, or vice versa?


r/Pitchfork • • Sep 30 '25

Turnstile Pepper Spray Incident/ Pitchfork Article - That was MY KID - the Biggest Turnstile Fan of ALL TIME! Let's show the Sheriff's Department that THIS COMMUNITY DOESN'T FLY ALONE? Email your thoughts to the Richmond Sheriff's Department at [email protected]

5 Upvotes

My son, who is a minor, was the child seen on video being directly pepper sprayed in the face by law enforcement at the Turnstile show in Richmond. He did not say a word to the officer.  He was doing what everyone else in the crowd was doing - and the spray was completely unprovoked. Afterward, the officer (Michael Ames) sadistically smirked and immediately left the area without offering any medical help or assistance.  

The band members of Turnstile were the first to show concern and provide assistance.  The deputies stood and watched - providing NO CARE and NO CONCERN.  Turnstile truly lived out their lyrics - “Birds weren’t meant to fly alone”. 

As his parent, I want people to know this is not a “crowd control” issue - this was my child who was harmed. We are aggressively pursuing our options to ensure accountability and to protect my son’s rights. Thank you to those who have reached out with support and who are sharing the video - your voices matter in making sure incidents like this are not ignored. If anyone has additional video or interactions with the officers, please let us know! Also, please feel free to email the Sheriff's department to show support to our family and the biggest Turnstile fan of all time - my kid. Email: [email protected]. Let's show them THIS COMMUNITY DOESN'T FLY ALONE


r/Pitchfork • • 6d ago

Indie Rock Album List - is it white enough for you?

0 Upvotes

I’m not like surprised, but maybe confused is a better word? How many albums on this new list are by people who are not white? Like . . . huh?


r/Pitchfork • • Jun 17 '26

If Pitchfork Fest Chicago still existed, who do you think would be playing this year?

5 Upvotes

Just because I’m missing it - what do you think? Here are my musings.

The XX - Feels like an appropriate nostalgia act, but possibly too big? Although optically, I’d imagine they’d prefer to come back to be the sole headliner at Pitchfork, rather than be the secondary headliner at Lolla again.

Geese - Big enough to headline?

Addison Rae - The first sub-headliner. Would be very polarizing, cause heated discourse

Grace Ives - Later in the day than 2022

Yousuke Yukimatsu - Closing blue stage?

Rico Nasty - Instead of Riot Fest

Ninajirachi - Even though her fan base skews younger, I feel like her and the other artists at Lolla’s Grove stage are Pitchfork-adjacent (Frost Children, Slayyyter, Oklou, HorsegiirL) and would skip Lolla in favor of this.

What are your thoughts, feelings, concerns?


r/Pitchfork • • Oct 29 '14

[BNM] Run The Jewels 2 9.0

Thumbnail
pitchfork.com
2 Upvotes

r/Pitchfork • • Oct 29 '19

my dream is to get a 2/10 from pitchfork

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/Pitchfork • • Jun 18 '20

Was the re-writing of The 200 Best Albums of the 1980s a positive or negative attempt?

2 Upvotes

Pitchfork almost took back their best albums of the 1980s list and did a new one. Back then, Sonic Youth's Daydream Nation was their top pick. Now it's Prince's Purple Rain.

When they tried to explain the reason behind this, they wrote:

That list was shorter, sure, but it also represented a limited editorial stance we have worked hard to move past; its lack of diversity, both in album selections and contributing critics, does not represent the voice Pitchfork has become.

To me personally, it was the last straw. I completely lost respect for them. I occasionally still find good articles here there on the site. But as a whole, this is a publication that has given way to identity politics and desperately tries to be "correct".

So, a very negative attempt indeed. But what do you think?


r/Pitchfork • • Jan 26 '26

When did the nosedive start?

17 Upvotes

I am curious to hear back from the community on this one. Pitchfork have decided to shoot themselves in the head, again, with this $5 paywall thing. Normally when a website introduces a paywall they are hiding EXTRA features behind it. They don't hide their biggest asset behind it i.e. Pitchfork's scores. Looking at the amount of reviews on each album it isn't even a lot. I think I saw one that had about 36 reviews on it. My question is when did all this bad decision making start? Was it when Schreiber left? Was it when Puja became EIC? Long before that? Genuinely curious to know if their is a consensus on when the site started dying.


r/Pitchfork • • Jul 31 '18

Wrote this about my coworker, my work found out then I got fired

Thumbnail
soundcloud.com
3 Upvotes

r/Pitchfork • • Sep 01 '26

News "Miley Cyrus Rebrands as Miley" - proceeds to exclusively call her "Cyrus"

38 Upvotes

r/Pitchfork • • Jan 29 '26

RIP Pitchfork - Shit Cat

7 Upvotes

r/Pitchfork • • Jan 27 '26

Favorite Pitchfork review/article/moment

12 Upvotes

Yesterday I made a post asking for opinions on when Pitchfork's downfall started. Today I am asking people share their favorite Pitchfork review, article or moment. I will start.

01/05/2009.

Pitchfork releases their review of Merriweather Post Pavilion by Animal Collective.

It felt like months of build up surrounding the most hyped "indie" album of all time (at that time) culminating in the highest review score Pitchfork had given in a long time. I remember the review of "Brothersport" leading up to it. I remember so clearly seeing the review score for the first time and feeling a weird sense of pride. Anco was my favorite band at the time and it was my most anticipated album ever. I genuinely felt happy the band got such a good score. It felt like the peak of that era. Things were just...brighter.

Is is crazy to think back to those times. I loved the website so much. It felt like a secret even though I knew they had a ton of readers then.

Anyway, anyone else want to share?


r/Pitchfork • • May 14 '18

Bad hip hop

4 Upvotes

Has anyone noticed that 90% of pitchfork is now really bad hip hop/rap? This shift was probably noticeable in the last year or so. I don’t know if they’re trying to fill a quota, but I miss when they covered more indie rock. Does anyone have recommendations of another site I can go to for something geared more towards that?


r/Pitchfork • • May 18 '21

2021 LINEUP ANNOUNCED!!!!!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes