r/PieceOfShitBookClub • u/-burgers • Aug 02 '25
r/PieceOfShitBookClub • u/taytek • Jul 16 '25
Book Got my partner a signed copy of "This Hoe got Roaches in her Crib" by Quan Millz
r/PieceOfShitBookClub • u/glowingominously • Aug 06 '25
Book I can finally talk about the book that made me gasp out loud in Barnes and Nobel
I don’t have a photo from B&N so I looked it up online. If I recall from flipping through it, there are drinks inspired by both killers and victims. Maybe it’s just me but if I was brutally murdered and someone made a cocktail inspired by the case I would haunt them so badly it would make the Exorcist look like Casper
r/PieceOfShitBookClub • u/fleshrags • Aug 03 '25
Book Oh man, can't wait to see what booksamillion have on sale... nevermind.
r/PieceOfShitBookClub • u/Hermit_187_purveyor • Aug 04 '25
Book Homosexuality: Legitimate, Alternate Deathstyle by Dick Hafer - An anti-gay comic blast from the past of 1986. One of the more bizarre and fascinating anti-gay books in my collection to behold and gawk at.
I must, first and foremost, give credit to the Seanbaby article, The 4 Most Homophobic Comics Ever Created, which he wrote for Cracked back in 2011. Ah, remember when Cracked used to be entertaining and funny to peruse? I fondly recall the halcyon days of the late 2000's/early 2010's. Now the site is a shell of its former self, relying on listicles and no longer even allowing comments (Even though comments were also a big draw to the articles). Oh, well. Anyways, it was his very funny article that drew me to this comic book that I would eventually purchase and read many years later. Buckle up, folks. We're going back in time to the 1980's for some anti-gay propaganda at the height of the AIDs crisis.
It begins with a short, stocky man named Chester (Also referred to as Chet) sitting on the steps of his front porch, reading the newspaper and grumbling about how a high school for gays was opened in New York. A neighbor, Larry, who is tall and dressed like a dad out of a 1950's sitcom, approaches and asks him about what he's so bothered about. Chester responds with:
"Oh, hi, Larry! Yeah...I sure am bugged! It says in the paper that New York has a high school for fags! What in the world do they teach 'em?!!"
As they continue discussing the strides homosexuals have made (With a lot of grumbling), a flamboyantly gay postman (Who is never given a name) appears to deliver a package. He overhears what the two are talking about and takes great offense to it.
This then leads Larry to take the two men around town (Presumably, at least), discussing what homosexuals are, what deviant acts they commit, political organizations they're involved with, rattling off statistics, quoting Bible verses, chastising the gay postman every once in a while, etc. Chester will be more educated in his hatred of the gays and the postman will feel guilt and want to turn away from such a "deviant" lifestyle and towards a proper Christian existence.
Even by the standards of anti-gay books, this book is truly something else. Even its setup of being educational feels off. Larry, who is presumably straight, is the character providing all these statistics, describing various gay sex acts, and whatnot. He talks like a dad from a 1950's sitcom (Picture something like a bigoted Ward Cleaver from Leave it to Beaver), only instead of providing some sort of lecture or life lesson to his kids, it's to espouse bigotry and describe gay sex acts to an ignorant dipshit and a flamboyant gay guy in denial. Chester is all piss and vinegar when talking about the "fags" yet seems to have no concept of anything gays do in the bedroom. Meanwhile, the postman is nothing but a flamboyant stereotype who eventually sees the "error" of his ways (With gayness not only being considered a sin, but also having it compared to drug use, stealing, and other crimes).
Right from the get-go, we get a firsthand glimpse into the minds of the very target audience of this book when Larry poses this question at the start of his anti-gay education:
"Do you know what a homosexual couple is?"
Chester responds with:
"Uhhh...maybe one does the cooking and one does the cleaning?"
Larry's response:
"No...it's two men that prefer to have sexual relations with each other, rather than a woman!"
Naturally, Chester is utterly revolted, having discovered that gay men prefer...having sex with men. Huh? What did he think they do considering how much he hates them? He even goes as far as to say, "It's not only sick - it's impossible!"
Larry then corrects him and the gay guy's rebuttal that sex between men is beautiful by saying sex between men is indeed possible, but not by "normal" biological standards.
"But they substitute some truly gross practices that are unhealthy and degrading! I'll get into the ugly details in a few minutes!"
So begins our journey where the "straight" Larry begins a rundown of the history of homosexuality in 20th century America and rattling off statistics.
Such shocking statistics include that 85% percent of gay men had their first sexual experience be...homosexual. Or that 96% of straight men had their first sexual experience be...heterosexual. Have you gotten up from being blown out of your chair by such mind-blowing statistics? Who would have thought for a vast majority of people, their first sexual experience was related to their sexuality? It also stresses at the end of this panel about how the first encounter was important. So, what's it's saying is that 15% of gay men tried to be straight and it didn't work out? It's almost like...being gay isn't a choice. No, no, that can't be true at all. Maybe I just have to try fooling around with a woman and I'll be cured of such sinful desires!
We are then brought to the section describing various gay sex acts, again, by Larry.
Larry: "Not only are their habits disgusting, but they are incredibly harmful and damaging!"
Chester: "Such as?"
Larry: "Kissing."
Chester: "UGH."
Larry: "Most of the contacts involve kissing - and that means saliva exchange. Many sexual and non-sexual diseases are spread through saliva."
Saliva is exchanged during kissing? As opposed to what else? The life force of whoever you're kissing to attain immortality? It should also be noted that lesbians are only brought up a handful of times in this book. It's mainly gay males who are the targets. The author was probably one of those types who thinks, "Two women getting it on? That shit is hot. Two dudes getting it on? That shit is gross." But, yes, the idea that gays kiss? That's apparently shocking to learn.
Larry then helpfully lists and describes fellatio, eating ass, anal sex, golden showers, fisting, and glory holes.
After all is said done and vomiting a few times into a nearby trashcan, Chester then says:
"Enough already! Let's move onto some other area of sodomy!"
You know for two straight characters, Larry and Chester sure seem to discuss gay sex and gay sex acts a lot. From my experience being around mostly straight guys in my life, being the shy and introverted gay guy I am (Whose gayness is rarely detected), this is not something that straight guys are prone to do. Having to essentially blend into the background (For fear of being ostracized and general shy behavior), the most it amounted to were gay jokes or perhaps asking a guy who was more open what kind of stuff he did (But not too much detail). It certainly NEVER got to this level of detail.
We then move onto to discussions about AIDs, other STDs, bath houses, cruising, gay bars, s&m, bondage, discussions about gay rights in politics, the church, child molestation (I'll give you this, Mr. Hafer, NAMBLA can indeed go fuck itself and members should be scorned and shunned in society), and more...all detailed by Larry (Seriously, Larry, what the fuck?).
We then get to a list near the end of the book that is quite troubling. There are a couple points I can agree on, regardless of sexuality (Criminal prosecution against those who knowingly transmit diseases like AIDs and testing blood donors), but the other things listed to combat homosexuality are very troubling and something out of a dictatorship:
"A ban against homosexuals working as food handlers, bartenders, doctors, dentists, nurses and medical technicians, teachers and aides in day care centers for infants and young children.
"A demand that our tax-supported public schools stop being tolerant, or outright supportive of 'alternative lifestyles' and that textbooks reflect this new attitude.
"Close, or monitor tightly, homosexual meeting places, such as restrooms, parks, bath houses, gay bars, etc.
"Make practice of sodomite acts a crime."
This book is definitely one of the more militant anti-gay books I've come across, which is why I wasn't surprised to see a quote of praise from Beverly LaHaye on the back of it (Her husband, Tim, wrote The Unhappy Gays which I covered on this subreddit):
"Americans need to wake up to the facts regarding the Homosexual movement. Dick Hafer exposes the depravity of their lives in his book, Deathstyle. This is a book which needs to be read by all of those concerned about society and our nation."
Joke's on you, Beverly, you and your husband were alive long enough to see gay rights expanded and gay marriage legalized in all fifty states.
This is a book only for the morbidly fascinated. It may be a window view to 1986, but these are views that are still held today. It should be studied to make sure things don't slide backward, and as such, also preserved. It's a prize specimen in my collection of oddities. It's a fascinating glimpse into the minds of people who spend an inordinate of time thinking about how people like me partake in and enjoy gay sex. May such ilk wail and shudder the next time I'm going to town on a guy's hairy crotch and loving it.
r/PieceOfShitBookClub • u/[deleted] • Aug 15 '25
Book The MTV book so bad that the author yanked it from print and completely rewrote it... if you can find the original version, it's a riot.
r/PieceOfShitBookClub • u/[deleted] • Aug 03 '25
High Quality Shit Behold, my glorious childhood copy of an early 2000s novel trying to be something bigger than it was. The book seriously has a holographic sticker on the dust jacket that punches up on the Harry Potter series. Also has a character named "Gasman" whose namesake is basically from that he farts a lot.
r/PieceOfShitBookClub • u/ddddaikon • Aug 05 '25
Book Just stumbled upon this sub and I have a doozy of a turd for y'all
Found this in the goodwill clearance last year. I couldnt bear to leave it there so it came home with me for the sweet sweet price of 99¢
I have no fucking idea why the cover looks like liv tyler????
r/PieceOfShitBookClub • u/Hermit_187_purveyor • Aug 02 '25
Book In Real Life by Onision - An angry, rambling, unfocused autobiography where the author mostly talks about failed relationships and crushes, speaks of but dodges actually addressing allegations against him, constant moralizing, and odd tangents. A terrible chore to read from beginning to end.
From exiled content creator, failed musician, and wretched author with a litany of allegations against him, comes Onision's In Real Life. I've never really viewed his content when he was on YouTube, but was well aware of his shenanigans that have gotten him into a great deal of legal trouble (Grooming and abuse allegations, mostly. He has also rated the bodies of underage female fans who sent him pictures, tried to allegedly start a cult when he was younger, and more) and even gotten the attention of Chris Hansen of To Catch a Predator fame (An investigation that eventually stalled due to variety of reasons). When not facing potential criminal penalties, Onision has also been at the receiving end of lawsuits. When all was said and done, he became a pariah of social media and in real life, largely exiled from both in the aftermath of these allegations. Only his most die hard supporters have stuck around.
Most of my exposure, however, has come from his "literary" works, if we're being charitable in describing his books. They're basically fanfic stories based loosely around real life events while stroking his ego of having a hero complex and being misunderstood by all the frauds and fakers. Stones to Abbigale was a horrendous high school fantasy of his that threw in a school shooting and sexual abuse trauma. This is Why I Hate You was an even worse book, being a fantasy of his high school years, his daddy issues, and time in the Air Force. Reaper's Creek can most kindly be described as a literary abortion that sprinkles elements of his childhood and upbringing, while throwing in aliens and rants about religion (All the while being virtually incomprehensible because of how badly written it was. Even proper spelling, grammar, and syntax were all thrown to the wind). He also wrote the children's picture book, Stinky Duck, which can be taken as a metaphor for his rejection in real life and finding true happiness elsewhere.
I suppose it was only a matter of time before he would be narcissistic enough to write an autobiography. This was actually released back in 2023 as an e-book. It was only recently released in a physical format, which is how I came in possession of it (I prefer physical copies of books, films, video games, and music). As such, I knew if he ever were to release it physically, I would end up reading it. Since I've read his other works, here I am again. Let me tell you the tale of woe that is reading this terrible, dreadful book.
Right from the introduction, we're off to a promising start:
"For some time, I have wondered if I am a highly capable writer, or if I am a silly fool aspiring for the impossible. Through high school I was deemed a superior writer. Without request I was recommended to advanced placement solely in the field of English Literature by my teacher, who at the time prided himself on the fact that he looked like the now deceased Joseph Stalin. I suppose he did, I mean, how could I not feel he looked like that once fierce man? My teacher had a picture on his wall next to his desk of Joseph Stalin, big bushy mustache, and all. My teacher would stand to the side and say 'See Gregory? I look just like him!' and I have to say, he could have been the man's grandson for sure."
Assuming this story is true, damn you, Stalin-lookalike. Either you're a liar or an idiot - maybe both. Superior writer, my ass. I've read this "superior" writer's other books. And is it just me, or does this book already feel unfocused? If not, it certainly will be soon. I hope you enjoy many random tangents because Onision cannot keep ANYTHING in focus. This is just the opening paragraph.
He then goes on, talking about how his previous books are infamous, basically attributing their many, many bad reviews to people who hate him. It's also where he starts to tread water when talking about his reputation and allegations (But never expect anything in-depth. He'll just skirt around the issue and bring up someone or something else instead - particularly his father). He makes up an example of a hypothetical creator that aptly demonstrates how he'll only speak about issues, but not actually address them:
"Let us use 'Timmy Jones' as an example. Timmy Jones is a made-up person, not real, just simply exists for me to use as a fabrication instead of a real person so I can never get sued or anything for this possibly alleged alias and other aliases I plan to use throughout the book.
"Timmy Jones is a very popular YouTuber, mostly known for his works in the Mega Fighters United organization, which is not a real thing as of June 28th, 2022, I hope, because of course I would not want a company to sue me for using their name either *laughs*.
"Alright, so Timmy Jones was accused of murdering his own dog. Insane right? Accused means he must be guilty right? Well, no, not at all, want to know why? Because you, everyone reading this, is a... car thief.
"That is right, by reading this, you are now all accused car thieves. See how easy that was? Accusations are often nonsense when they lack proof. Unless you disagree... but why would I care if you disagree? You are a filthy car thief after all. *laughs*"
He then goes on to say that what Timmy Jones is being accused of is on par with randomly accusing the reader of being a car thief. Then comes more rambling, saying people hate him just because of accusations, lightly treading the accusations (While claiming emotional blackmail from accusers), and more rambling about how he is now a pariah.
Onward, we get to learn about his birth, like how he has two full-blooded sisters and one half-sister from a prior relationship of his father's. All of them are older, and it seems only the half-sister speaks to the father. Apparently, a doctor advised his mother to get an abortion due to Onision's large head size, which she refused. Meanwhile, his father wanted him circumcised, which his mother refused. We then get to go on a tangent about Onision's thoughts about circumcised penises. I will provide some snippets, as Onision goes on a MULTI-PARAGRAPH tangent about the topic:
"Imagine if child abusers were people who got unnecessary butcheries performed on their kid to permanently disfigure them through applying a torturous and damaging procedure requiring the bleeding, cutting and mutilation of their genitals. Would that just be... common sense to classify those parents that way? I would take a slap to the face over that any day, and I in fact, did. Thanks Mom. Better than losing bits of my penis for sure. Could have done without the slap, but ok.
"But if you disagree, ok, keep chopping baby junk up, so long as it is legal, what can I do to stop you? Welcome to America. Land of the free, home of the baby penis mutilators."
Awesome. I now know that Onision has an uncircumcised penis. That's a mental image I've always wanted (And now you get to share it with me, unfortunate reader). These are just two of seven paragraphs about the topic I've shown. We also know Onision's passionate stance against circumcision. Having fun with such random tangents? Don't worry there are plenty more of these random tangents peppered throughout the book.
Continuing onward, we get to learn that Onision's home life sucked, particularly with his father who was eventually out of the picture. Onision even throws out his own accusations against his father, stating that he sexually assaulted two aunts, a cousin of his, and even a child. It feels cruelly ironic, given what Onision has been accused of and how out of touch he is when throwing these accusations out about his father. Much like Onision, his father's legal troubles would quietly vanish without severe repercussions. Pot, meet kettle.
On top of these accusations, according to Onision, his father was also physically abusive, as was his mother at certain points. His middle sister bullied him until he fought back when he was older, etc. Basically, coming from a broken home of fucked up parents who also had less than stellar partners after their divorce.
From here on, we get a LONG rundown of his time in schools. He was a social outcast with few friends, was bullied constantly, had some fights, stood up for kids who were bullied, was a chivalrous white knight defending girls against leering boys, all the girls he dated and broke up with, losing his virginity, all the girls he never asked out, etc.
Some of these events would find their way into his novels, like him going to third base with a 15-year-old girl when he was only 11-years-old (Then the girl going all the way with another boy a year later who was also aged 11), him getting into a violent altercation with his father during a road trip which involved Onision kicking him in the face with combat boots, and a girl whose beauty would be the basis for Abbigale in Stones to Abbigale. He's also edgy, misunderstood, and goth like the self-insert protagonists of these books.
Detailing his relationships feels like a repetitive, boring conga line. Ask out girl, she says yes. If she's a bad kisser, break up immediately (This happens more than once, by the way). If she's not attractive up close, still ask her out anyway. Then break up later. Have an on again, off again relationship with a goth girl. Few of these relationships last, while also getting occasional lurid details, like one girl (The one who turned out to be unattractive up close) having a urine smell down below when he tries to take her pants off during a make out session. A goth boy has a crush on him. Onision is straight, but offers the boy a chance to kiss him in a store after receiving a love letter from him. Boy decides not to, becomes a Christian, and worst of all...a PREP (Oh, Tara Gillespie, I pine for thee and My Immortal right now). Many girls turn him down, and like a number of break ups, Onision laments that he would have made for a better partner/spouse choice in their dating lives (Nah, man. They dodged a bullet, Matrix-style*,* getting away from you). He also has the hots for a number of other women, like a teacher in her mid-forties he believed wanted to have sex with him (Yes, Onision, I'm sure this woman TOTALLY wanted to sleep with you like you're in a sleazy 70's porno) and a sadistic but sexy drill instructor during his time at basic training in the Air Force. It's so ridiculous, I couldn't help but be reminded of the Catholic High School Girls in Trouble sketch from The Kentucky Fried Movie (1977), but without anything that made it funny or self-aware of being a parody.
There will also be plenty of time spent moralizing (Outside of his thoughts about circumcision). Here's one where he offended a teacher because he refused to finish reading a story that involved a man trying to seduce his niece. What was the story? Don't know. However, he proceeds to go on a tirade about art, which, given his creative output, feels very ironic:
"Most art actually sucks, objectively, including, music, movies & comedy. Most people aren't talented, funny, or otherwise blessed. All they really are is: relatable. People mistake relatability for talent when it's not."
Art may be subjective, Onision, but you are neither talented or relatable. You are also not interesting beyond accusations and how deluded you are as a human being. The most this book and the others you've written can offer is a glimpse inside the mind of a deluded, idiotic, untalented narcissist. A person could film themselves taking a dump on camera and it would have more artistic merit than anything you've ever done.
His critique about art is followed by moralizing about sex as he goes on a tirade about what he perceives to be sexual depravity (Again, given the allegations against him, feels like another stroke of cruel irony):
"And I know all about how widespread perversion really is. Especially with the majority of woman (and men, but women get lumped out of this stereotype when they are in fact a big part of it). Not too long ago (from modern day) I saw a bunch of test results from people who took 'Bondage' or 'Sub/Dom' quizzes. Essentially, they test how 'Kinky' you are, and everyone scored much less 'Vanilla' than I did. Me scoring something like '62% Vanilla' means the type of love scene you see in an average R movie, is what I'm into. What it means to not be vanilla? Many folks are way creepier than I could ever imagine."
This is coming from a man who has detailed his dating life with lurid details and how, later in his life, has had threesomes and foursomes. You like having sex that's kinkier than what you'd see in an R-rated film? You know, what actual sex ends up being? According to Onision, you're a filthy sexual deviant. Foreplay, at best, is R-rated. Really getting it on? That is NC-17, Onision (The Motion Picture Association is notoriously prickly about sexual content. They take great umbrage at the sight of an exposed erect penis, too much thrusting, or even things like simulated cunnilingus). Good golly, Onision, you're making the moral panic pastors of yesteryear look sex positive by comparison (Even Tim LaHaye would tell you to stop being such so damn prudish).
More dating, more personal life details follow. Then the final two chapters devolve entirely into angry rants where he compares his struggles to celebrities like Michael Jackson and Johnny Depp. His anger can be summed up in this one line since these last two chapters are basically the same thing: fuck people, fuck losers, fuck liars, look out for yourself, etc.:
"I don't talk to people like you in real life... so why the fuck would I write a book for you? Lol."
There are a lot of rants and ramblings to be found in the book (Like his tirades against Christianity, due to his father), but I've already covered quite a few things. Even as lengthy as this post is, it's a very condensed version that I've tried to make somewhat palatable and digestible. It's a terrible chore to read this horrendous book.
r/PieceOfShitBookClub • u/[deleted] • Aug 05 '25
Book I picked it up because of the author controversy, and it's literally just a gender confused kid being abused the whole time. Zero character development or agency. The author tries to spin it like it's not a fetish of hers, but it pretty much is, and she's previously stated as much.
r/PieceOfShitBookClub • u/Hermit_187_purveyor • Aug 16 '25
Book And We're Off by Dana Schwartz - a tale of a dull, vapid narcissist with artistic ambitions taking her overbearing mother on one of the dullest Eurotrips and journeys of self-discovery ever written. An exasperating and irritating bore of literature.
I've had prior exposures to this author, even before reading this dreadful book. The prior exposures have not gone well, either. One was a book while the other was her involvement in a television show. I read The White Man's Guide to White Male Writers of the Western Canon and hated it. It was her attempt at satire, lampooning white male authors and stereotypes about white male readers/budding white male writers. It was a boring, unfunny disaster that had absolutely nothing interesting or insightful to say about anything (The satire can be summed up as, "White guys...am I right?" This turd of a book was over 240 pages and that was the gist of the satire. I kind of like the illustrations at least. It's not like there was anything else worth looking at, as her words had less depth than the paper they're printed on. I imagine it's only funny in the super progressive crowds Schwartz runs in and appeals to no one else).
My second experience was through the television show, She Hulk: Attorney at Law, in which she wrote the episode, Mean, Green, and Straight Poured into These Jeans. It was also terrible, though to be fair to Schwartz, it's not like her episode was the worst (Pick your poison. Every episode of She-Hulk: Attorney at Law was terrible. It was a horrid rip-off of Legally Blonde and various romantic comedies, stretched into a television show, and given a superhero skin suit).
We're not off to a great start to say the least. A god-awful satire and participating in a god-awful television show doesn't exactly inspire confidence. Still, I was willing to give her another chance, so I decided to read And We're Off. Well, that was a mistake.
In this novel, we follow 17-year-old Nora Holmes, an aspiring artist who hopes to one day be as famous and acclaimed as her grandfather, Robert Parker, who is a world-renowned artist. For now, she does commissions on Tumblr and has a blog called Ophelia in Paradise. She mainly does fan art such as:
"...the drawing I'm working on of Harry Potter and Draco Malfoy making out."
Yes, that kind of fan art. Other kinds as well, but no one really remembers the more family-friendly material.
Much to her delight, Nora has been accepted to be part of an exclusive summer art program in Ireland - the Donegal Colony of Young Artists (Or "The Deece" to be annoyingly trendy), in which only a very small handful of students from around the world are accepted. Not only that, but before even getting to Ireland, she'll spend a few days in Paris and Ghent (Belgium) After Ireland comes Florence and London - all paid for by her grandfather.
What could be more exciting than a trip to Europe at such a young age? Plus, it'll give her some time to escape from her personal life troubles. Her mother, Alice, is overbearing and still struggling to come to grips from getting divorced two years prior. Her father has remarried (His new wife is Nora's former math teacher) and is moving to another state. She still pines after a boy named Nick, who took her virginity and then wanted nothing more to do with her. Now Nick is dating her best friend, Lena (Who has no idea Nora and Nick hooked up) and Nora can't help but stalk Nick's social media posts. She also has to decide on her future, such as her college ambitions while her mother chews her out for wasting her time on art and the awful green streak dyed in her hair.
The fantasies about traveling Europe, meeting other young people, and perhaps even finding a Prince Charming abroad all suddenly screech to a halt when Alice decides she'll be accompanying her daughter on this trip to Europe, much to Nora's confusion and irritation (With Nora taking too long to figure out how her mother's law office could possibly allow for a weeks-long trip to Europe on such short notice). Oh, well. Her mother promises to only be there for part of the trip, and Nora has been given folders from her grandfather that are labeled for each city she's set to visit. Each one is some sort of assignment and she is not to open the folders until she reaches these places.
So begins a journey of self-discovery, very brief tours of Europe, exploring the arts, young love, and reconnecting a distant relationship between a mother and a daughter.
There's a good idea here. It's just that Dana Schwartz never actually assembles anything compelling out of these parts. Any of these individual parts could have made for something good, yet not a single aspect of the plot works.
The first mistake is the main character herself. I hated Nora Holmes every step of the way from beginning to end. She's an insufferable, faux quirky sort of character who thinks she's so special, when in reality, she seems to be built entirely out of the most annoying stereotypes of millennial and Gen-Z girls. So much so, she could have come from a factory assembly line. For starters, here's how she describes what she hates and what she likes, which happens near the end of the story as she writes one final letter to her Irish love interest, Callum Cassidy, before departing for Florence:
"Things I Hate:
The color orange
The smacking sound my mom's lips make before she's about to say something
Boys with gauges in their ears
Chalky fingers after using pastels
Jazz music, the fast kind that makes me anxious
The thin, pasty, flat strands that stick to a banana after you peel it
"Things I Like:
Brie cheese
The ding from a text message
Wearing a bathrobe after a shower
Ginger tea
Squeezing paint out of an aluminum tube
Maybe you. Probably you. Definitely you."
Nora, even if I hadn't read the rest of the book leading up to this point, I'm still bored by you. There's more to list, but I assure you, she impressively becomes more vapid and boring. This is made worse by the author herself. She's part of the crowd who complain about portrayals of women in media and other things, yet has crafted a character who is indistinguishable from a number of females from romantic comedies - worse yet, from the BAD romantic comedies.
Other things I've learned about Nora:
She loves Taylor Swift music. Wonderful, the embodiment of generic pop music. Such taste, Nora. Even as someone who enjoys the Spice Girls and enjoyed musicals like Xanadu (1980), Grease 2 (1982), and Spice World (1997)...dear God, get better taste in music. So dreary is Nora's taste in music, I had to listen to the Cocteau Twins, Suzanne Ciani, and the soundtrack to Waiting to Exhale (1995) to get through this book. As I type this review, I'm entertaining myself by listening to Madonna's True Blue (1986) and Like a Prayer (1989) albums because even thinking about this book and Nora's dreadful taste in music is so boring. It should be noted that I am also drinking wine. That's how dreadfully boring this book is. By the time I finish this review, I will probably be drunk.
Donnie Darko (2001) is her least favorite film ever. Why? She never explains herself.
She could never get into The Lord of the Rings, having never read the books and only seeing a few minutes of one film, only to be scared away by some creepy image.
Who's her favorite artist? I don't know. She only really seems to talk about her grandfather. There are mentions of Frida Kahlo, Vincent van Gogh, Eugene Delacroix, and Pablo Picasso, but they're mainly brought up in a joking manner or a brief reference rather than any sort of meaningful discussion. For an aspiring artist, Nora seems utterly unknowing about any artists, their work, their techniques - nothing. She is a complete dullard when it comes to the topic. For fuck's sake, Dana, would it have killed you to pick up a goddamn art book and peruse through it?
She's an extremely judgmental bitch, primarily basing her thoughts on people based on how they look or being jealous and petty towards others who are more talented than her (Like Maeve, who is also in attendance for the summer DCYA program).
Nora also seems oblivious to European countries having their own postal/delivery services.
Her best friend is Lena.
Nora and her equally stupid friend, Lena, seem to believe that people in Europe don't wear jeans or sneakers.
She enjoys referencing things like the Lifetime Channel, Dr. Who, and other pop culture references.
She finds her mother overbearing and annoying.
She has a habit of doing things even if her brain is telling her not do such things. So quirky.
She likes to have imaginary conversations and scenarios, like how she imagines her mother, a friend, or a love interest will respond to her. Too bad all her fantasies are so dull.
I hope you're as fucking riveted as I am by this character.
Unfortunately for the reader, Nora is the type of character the author has to tell us is so awesome and interesting, rather than showing us. This is a fatal error in judgment and an insult to the intelligence of the reader. What we're told versus what we're shown reveals a tremendous discrepancy that no amount of quips or faux quirky self-awareness can undo. This snippet sums up how the character is supposed to be perceived. This comes from Lena before Nora leaves for her trip:
"You're great, honestly. You're going to do amazing stuff. You'll probably be the best artist there by a long shot. And then you're going to meet some hot Scottish boy and fall madly in love and go off and be an art couple like Frida Kahlo and Geraldo Rivera."
Barring the failed joke of using the wrong name for Frida's husband, this is just the start revealing how utterly unknowing Nora is about art or artists. Bringing up Frida Kahlo and Diego Rivera was a big mistake. For one, she's not nearly as talented as either of them (I have to look more into Diego's paintings, but my favorites of Frida's works are "The Suicide of Dorothy Hale" and "The Broken Column") Second, she's also nowhere near as interesting. And third, yeah, sure you want their kind of marriage. Constant affairs (Thankfully you don't have a sister, Nora. If you married someone like Diego Rivera, he's going to fuck your sister whether you want him to or not. Also, weird standards with a Diego-like lover. You have affairs with women? No problem. You have affairs with other men? He's getting the gun), getting divorced, remarried, numerous arguments, being involved in great political turmoil (Like being kicked out of the Mexican Communist Party and harboring Joseph Stalin's exiled nemesis, Leon Trotsky, who would eventually be assassinated in Mexico after getting brained by an ice axe. Frida also had an affair with him) having your husband's exes hang around (Also, when you both die, one of his mistresses will be made the executor of your estate, including your works of art), and more. They had a very complicated and intensely interesting life together.
Look at that, just that one rant about bringing up Frida Kahlo and Diego Rivera already demonstrates how you should be reading about them and studying their works instead of reading And We're Off.
Art is fascinating as are the people who create it. Somehow, Schwartz manages to create an artist who is fascinating neither in their work or their personal life. Even if you're a layman about art (I myself am no expert, but am quite fascinated by it even as a lowly plebeian), you know more about it and appreciate it more than Nora and her creator, Dana Schwartz. And be sure not to miss Nora's mother, Alice, saying that Leonardo da Vinci's "The Mona Lisa" is "overrated." They never visit the Louvre, this is based on Alice's experiences when she went to Paris in her twenties. Such insight. I truly trust the tastes of these dullard characters.
This annoying, wannabe artist bleeds into additional problems: And We're Off makes the world of art and traveling Europe boring as fuck. Now combine these issues with the cliched "teenager clashing with parent/s about living their own life" and you've got a mess that's not only boring, but irritating as well.
Let's start with the Eurotrip, which begins in Paris. The first day is uneventful, which is fitting, given they've just landed and a long air trip like that would be tiresome. What about the next day? Nora opens her folder and her grandfather instructs her to visit the Musee d'Orsay. She also wants to visit the Delacroix museum. Can't do the first museum, it's closed today. So, the Delacroix museum it is, but Nora's mother insists on accompanying her. The day consists of eating a nice breakfast, Alice being bitchy to a waitress over the coffee having cream instead of skim milk, buying a purse, looking at the Notre-Dame Cathedral, and not making it in time to the Delacroix museum before closing. Day 3 is the Musee d'Orsay with Nora being required to draw someone while sitting a cafe, as per her grandfather's envelope instructions. Nora and her mother get into an argument later.
Now comes Belgium. Virtually nothing happens and it's dismissed as a "fake country." Nora and her mother do crash a military wedding to look an altar piece in a church after they ditch a tour group. Even this detour is boring.
Paris and Ghent are so poorly written about and rushed in this book, it's a wonder why they were included AT ALL. All it felt like was padding that involved eating food, getting lost, arguing, and being insufferable tourists.
Now, onward to Ireland. Okay, so this is the bulk of the Eurotrip described in this book. A colony of young artists in the beauty of Ireland near the sea. New characters to meet and perhaps a peek into the works of the artists as they learn new techniques and hone their craft. Should be an exciting, romanticized aspect of the book to set the reader's imagination loose. NO.
Schwartz absolutely refuses to provide any interesting details. At best, yet get fleeting glimpses of the beauty of Ireland and what classes are like at the DCYA. Who are the other people? Mostly just some other people, aside from Callum, who can be described as a friendlier Irish version of Nora's crush, Nick, back in the U.S. They talk some pop culture (Like Callum's love of The Lord of the Rings and how Avengers: Age of Ultron is his least favorite film ever. Oh, sweet summer child. If only you knew just how terrible the Marvel Cinematic Universe would get) and have some generic meet-cute moments that would not be out of place on the Hallmark Channel (Except with some naughty words the Hallmark Channel would never approve of). Unfortunately, he also still likes other girls, so he's not a one-woman man by the time Nora leaves Ireland.
You would think for the DCYA that there would be more development about how things work and the people that inhabit that space. For example, I adore Joan Lindsay's Picnic at Hanging Rock (As well as the superb 1975 film adaptation by Peter Weir. I even have the Gheorghe Zamfir music on vinyl. "Miranda's Theme" is spellbinding and wonderful, but I digress). Beyond the central mystery (The disappearance of students, Miranda, Irma, and Marion, and the arithmetic teacher, Miss Crawford, while having a picnic at Hanging Rock on Valentine's Day, 1900), an important aspect is Appleyard College. You get to look into the lives of Headmistress Appleyard, the students, the teachers, and even the various servants of the school. I learned who was popular (Miranda, the "Boticelli Angel"), who was the smartest (Marion), who came from wealth to add to the school's prestige (Irma), the school dunce (Edith), the orphaned girl who is the target of Mrs. Appleyard's wrath (Sara), and a whole lot more. I even learned about others pulled into the mystery such as visiting Englishman, Michael Fitzhubert, and the coachman for the Fitzhubert family, Albert Crundall. I loved all the moving parts and all the people I got to follow around as I read the story. It was an endlessly fascinating, beguiling, and hypnotic story that still haunts me and lingers in my head. I adore it. It also never directly explains things and there are so many things going on that can be interpreted in a seemingly infinite number of ways. It was also a shorter book than And We're Off, yet has more going on in its opening than the entirety of And We're Off.
I had no reason to care about anyone at the DCYA and all I learned is what the author just spelled out to me through the eyes of Nora. In short, telling me instead of showing me why I should give a shit about this place or any of these people. Bad move. Thou shalt not tell instead of show.
Another missed opportunity is the clash of the Old World versus the New World (Europe versus America) and the culture shocks that come with that. For this, I'm going to stick it to the smug author and her smug book by using an author who she lampooned in her terrible satire book: Henry James. This was a subject he tackled several times. I have yet to read a number of his books, so bear with me for not mentioning some of them (I haven't read The Portrait of a Lady yet. I know, I'm missing out. I have it, I just haven't gotten to it yet. I have to finish The American, which also has the Old World versus the New World theme. So far, it's marvelous).
One of my earliest exposures to his work was The Europeans (My copy is a paperback tie-in for the release of the 1979 film adaptation, which I enjoyed. It is adorned with a picture of Lee Remick who plays Baroness Eugenia Munster in it. The novel is better, though). In it, two European siblings, Eugenia Munster and Felix Young decide to visit their American cousins, the Wentworths, in Boston. Eugenia is a baroness on the verge of divorce from her German husband while Felix lives a bohemian lifestyle of traveling around and painting. Meanwhile, the Wentworths and their extended family are more staunchly conservative and are taken aback by the ways and manners of their European relatives. Felix becomes smitten with Gertrude, Eugenia seems interested in Robert Acton, the local minister, Mr. Brand, is enamored by Gertrude who has no interest in him, Gertrude's sister, Charlotte, is in love with Mr. Brand while pestering Gertrude for her non-conforming ways (Like skipping church and rejecting Mr. Brand), etc. It's a marvelous, classy, funny comedy of manners. Despite its short length, it, too, has a great deal going on as the reader observes the back-and-forth clashes of family, love interests, and differing cultural norms and manners. Everyone learns something from one another by the end.
None of that is present in And We're Off. Instead, Nora and Alice are terrible, insufferable tourists who learn absolutely nothing about other cultures or appreciate the sights available to them. Instead, the reader is trapped in a bland journey of self-discovery, thirsting after boring men, an experience of the arts through the eyes of someone with no artistic vision, and more. I hate it.
The parent-child dynamic is also a failure. Nora and Alice can hardly stand one another, spend most of their time arguing, eating food, and then all their issues are neatly resolved at an art gallery in Florence by the end of the novel with a dramatic, sappy reunion (Nora ditched Alice to head to Florence alone after yet ANOTHER argument). You know what that means, Ms. Schwartz? More Henry James just for you.
This time, I'll be using Washington Square, which I also adore. In it, we get a cruel, yet clear-eyed view of a dysfunctional parent-child dynamic that is absolutely heart-breaking. Dr. Austin Sloper is a well respected doctor and community member for his philanthropy. He also has a tragic backstory, as he had a son who died at a young age and then became a widower when his wife gave birth to a daughter named Catherine. A son to carry on the bloodline and a seemingly idyllic wife are now dead. Still, he carries on with his practice and raises his daughter and takes in his widowed sister, Lavinia Penniman.
However, Catherine never amounts to anything he wants. She's not talented like her mother nor even as beautiful. There is a quiet contempt for this life circumstance and belittles Catherine to others for being so plain and unremarkable. Never really to her face, aside from an offhand remark, as he seems to view her as a poor invalid who will live out her days as a spinster on the inheritance he intends to bequeath her. Even his poor widowed sister is not immune, as he feels she has ideas that are too romantic and fanciful (Though he's not entirely wrong, as the reader comes to realize, as she meddles in Catherine's life). She, too, is the subject of belittling to others and offhand remarks. But why be upset with him? He's putting a roof over their heads and they're essentially charity cases he can use to prop up his status as a pillar of the community. It's very quietly cruel and shows just how two-faced people can be, especially those who are so quick to say how good they are and talk of the good they do.
Dr. Sloper immediately becomes suspicious when a man named Morris Townsend begins showing interest in Catherine. She's too plain and boring, how could a man possibly have interest in her unless he just wants her money?
It is not a sentimental novel, nor is it melodramatic. It's astonishingly level-headed, calm, and brutally honest. It's a novel that has stuck with me, along with its superb 1949 film adaptation, The Heiress. It made a very strong, haunting impression on me.
Okay, so perhaps that's a bit too much for a story that wants to be light-hearted and have all the problems be solved by the end. I don't have a problem with that. For example, I have a great big soft spot for the 1988 romantic comedy/drama, Mystic Pizza, which I feel is a very underrated gem. However, despite being lighter in tone, what made it work for me is that it is populated with characters I actually care about and root for their happy endings. I wasn't rooting for any of the characters of And We're Off. In fact, I actively wished someone would throw Nora and Alice out of whatever they were being transported in, so the misery would end (Out of the plane, the bus, the car - I don't care. Get rid of them, please).
In the end, I hated the characters, I hated the trip to Europe this novel took me on, I hated the dim-witted exploration of the arts it took me on, I hated the padding (So much eating and arguing), I hated the pop culture references (This will never be a portrait of a time long past with themes that transcend time. It is already decayed and outdated with no compelling themes), I hated the smug attitude that hung over the book like being hot-boxed in a car by multiple people farting at once, I hated the faux quirky aura it tried to project - I hated virtually everything about this book.
r/PieceOfShitBookClub • u/AdmiralFartmore • May 07 '26
Book The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas by John Boyne - A misguided, poorly researched "fable" about the Holocaust
Alongside the text review below, check out the podcast discussion on our blog, on Spotify, on Apple, or wherever you get podcasts.
When it comes to the Boy in the Striped Pyjamas, it’s hard not to feel a little late to the party. I was just out of high school when this book came out. Bush was a lame duck president, TED Talks were saving the world, and I was too busy taking myself too seriously with my first Haruki Murakami to read some children’s book about fashion.
Apparently it was a massive hit, but it never really crossed my radar. Over the years, I had some idea about it. The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas sat in my mind as “some book about two boys with a sad ending.” Reading it for the podcast last week, I realized I always thought this and Bridge to Terabithia were the same thing. Now I know they different, but I don’t know what Bridge to Terabithia is about. I suppose it’s about bridges, and maybe… some sort of Italian dessert, or liqueur? Sounds breezy. Maybe I'll check that out when I need a pick-me-up.
The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas is a book about the Holocaust. The problem is, the book also tries really hard to not to be about the Holocaust. In fact, it might be the least “about the Holocaust” thing that I’ve read about the Holocaust.
The book is actually about a boy named Bruno, who is about nine and runs about Auschwitz without knowing about the death camp, about the war, about Nazis, about Jews, or even about Germans. For Bruno, that’s all much ado about nothing. This is confusing for the reader because Bruno is the son of the Nazi commandant running Auschwitz.
Bruno is only nine, but Boyne writes the character so cartoonishly innocent that it becomes ignorance. He witnesses the suffering on the other side of the fence and thinks it is a performance. He sees thin, decrepit hands of concentration camp victims, wonders why they look like that and then quickly moves on. He literally never heard the word “Jew” before. He doesn’t know what job his dad does. When Bruno says “Heil Hitler,” he assumes it’s just another way of saying “goodbye for now, have a pleasant afternoon,” even though he has previously met Hitler. Bruno also only refers to the Fuhrer as “the Fury,” he calls Auschwitz “Out-With.” If I could guess, I think Boyne might have thought these were each a clever play-on-words, but that doesn’t really make sense in the logic of the book where Bruno speaks German. It also makes little sense in a regime where Nazi ideology was imbedded from kindergarten.
Over the course of his stay, the befuddled Bruno befriends a young Jewish boy on the other side of the fence named Shmuel. Shmuel is a Jewish boy the same age as Bruno. After around a year of regular conversations, one day Bruno sneaks into the camp to help Shmuel find his father, who has gone missing. Shortly thereafter, they are both suddenly rounded up and killed in a gas chamber. Structurally, the book builds to that sudden ending, followed by a quick family epilogue reminiscent a fun summer camp story. Except in this case, summer camp is history’s most notorious deathcamp.
So, the book just takes place during the Holocaust but really, it’s more about friendship – that is the defence that Boyne has landed on, at least. That doesn’t really stack up, as Bruno and Shmuel neither build a deep friendship nor do they really act as good friends. When Shmuel is threatened by an SS officer in Bruno’s house, Bruno betrays him. This is despite Bruno challenging the officer at various other points in the book. When Bruno wants to climb under the fence into the concentration camp to help Shmuel look for his father, Shmuel obliges. This is despite Shmuel knowing full well the danger that presents. As u/beaudashington brought up on the podcast discussion, it’s probably because Boyne wrote the whole thing with what he thought was a killer ending (a German boy, a Jewish Pole, both executed together holding hands) and he submitted the whole book to that purpose.
This commitment to the specific set-piece ending flattens the characters and hollows out the entire story. Outside of anything relating to the Holocaust, Bruno is a smart, precocious and articulate boy. Shmuel is probably just as smart, but he’s left to mutter away the reality of his situation because it would disrupt the ending Boyne needed to maintain.
Don’t believe me? After Bruno sells Shmuel out to the SS officer that Bruno previously saw beat another man to death, the next time they meet Shmuel is covered in bruises. Bruno wonders if Shmuel fell off a bicycle, and Shmuel waves it off.
This leads me to question Boyne’s “fable of friendship” defense on the matter of friendship. If the goal were to write friendship that breaks prejudice, would the story not be that Bruno came into the camp deeply bigoted and learned to see Shmuel for who he was despite indoctrinated hatred? Same so, Shmuel may have connected with a young individual who showed him kindness, even if that boy was from the people eradicating his family. But that would be a more challenging story to write. I couldn’t write it, just like Boyne couldn’t, but I’d try to write something less subservient to the exploitative, sentimentalist ending here.
Bruno doesn’t learn across the novel. From the point that he moves from Berlin to Auschwitz to his impromptu death in the gas chambers, he remains about as ignorant of the situation as he was at the start. There’s no great unveiling. He dies as an innocent, and despite the fact he’s a child, you’re left scratching your head a little at why you are following a character that learned nothing.
Among the handful of secondary characters, Boyne chooses to focus most on their implied or explicit opposition to, you know, what’s going on. Bruno’s mother and maid don’t like it. Eva Braun even makes an appearance as a beautiful, sweet woman. It all comes together to portray a Nazi Germany where a few bad men were going too far and everyone else was confused, ignorant, or opposed. This misses hard on the more important historical lesson of how society at large can be mobilized and embrace the darkest of evils. Unintentionally, Boyne tells a story of denialism.
It’s a cheap, exploitative and sentimentalist story from Boyne. It’s really a lot worse and more irritating than I expected, and the educational and cultural influence of the book are a bit unnerving. To some degree, I’m not sure how much he is responsible for broad miseducation about the Holocaust, because at least initially, he was just a guy that wrote a bad book, not someone on schoolboards or teaching in classrooms and he probably had no idea how widespread the influence would be.
That said, he is still cashing the cheques, and Boyne’s response to criticism is weak. He blames controversy over his TERF stance as the reason this book gets criticism, which is absurd. He handwaves direct criticism from the Memorial Museum of Auschwitz. He defends the book as fable, but fables don’t take place in the real world. He says it’s a story about friendship, but it’s not about the characters at all. He must be a smart enough guy, so these defenses are too willfully ignorant to believe – a little bit like Bruno.
I didn’t love reading or reviewing this. There are many angles to cover, I've touched on a few, but I still feel a little out of touch with the rise and fall of Boyne. For what it's worth I think The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas could still have a future in classrooms, not in history or discussion of the Holocaust but in English class critical discussions. It is an accessible book for teenagers to unpack and discuss “what’s wrong with this?” The tonal, structural, and historical flaws are all quite clear.
Speaking of teenage minds, we had a fine time discussing it on the podcast either way.
Review by u/admiralfartmore
Podcast links:
If you enjoy the project, please review and share.
PS: I've finally recovered the 80+ reviews from the old site dating back to 2014, which are now archived at posbookclub.com if you click See All. Still fixing formatting on them, but we won't go gently into that good night.
r/PieceOfShitBookClub • u/_camjam_ • Jul 21 '25
No way this has 4 and a half stars
and the reviews are politically charged?? who is this man
r/PieceOfShitBookClub • u/Hermit_187_purveyor • Jul 21 '25
Book Does God Love Michael's Two Daddies? by Sheila K. Butt and illustrated by Ken Perkins - a blast from the not-so-distant past of 2006. In short, the message is repent, only straight marriages, do as the Bible says, and being gay is a sin. A relic to be preserved and morbidly fascinated by.
This short book for kids is about twins, Seth and Sara, who, on their first day of school, meet another boy named Michael. While doing a puzzle together in class, which shows a family with a mom and dad, Michael says that his family doesn't look like that. He has two daddies and no mommy. His daddies have also asked him if he would like it if they got married, to which he is unsure. This is quite strange to the twins, who, after school, bring up the subject at the dinner table.
The parents are taken aback by this, and daddy proceeds to explain that sometimes two men or two women live together like man and wife, but that it's actually a sin to live that way. God only planned for men and women to get married. God still loves people like Michael's two daddies, but they cannot truly be at one with God and get into Heaven if they're living in sin. So, they must repent and try to make up for that sin. And remember, kids, always do what the Bible says.
As this is an illustrated book, there are various scenes depicting what God really wants. One image shows one of Michael's daddies reading the Bible with a look of dismay on his face (Is he only now figuring out that Christianity disapproves of homosexuality? This is set in the U.S. - anyone under the LGBT umbrella would already know that, having that fact, in many cases, instilled by a religious upbringing, yours truly included. Many religions as a whole disapprove of this. Where have you been, sir?). The next image of this daddy is him with a look of anguish while kneeling and reaching up to Jesus crucified on the cross. Sounds standard, for what this book preaches. One odd image, however, is when Seth and Sara are picked up by the mother and they wave to Michael as he is riding home on the bus. Is this image supposed to imply that GOOD parents pick up/drop off their children while BAD parents make their kids ride the bus? Others basically show Adam and Eve, happy straight families, church gatherings, getting into Heaven, and another image of repenting that involves a boy/young man stealing from a shop and coming back to pay for what he stole.
This book feels standard for its time, especially when acceptance for LGBT folks was increasing, but most in the U.S. still didn't approve, per say. My copy of this book also appears to have come from a church library, as there is a stamp indicating as such (I won't name the church, to be respectful of privacy. But a search of the church's name turns up in Tennessee) and a sticker that it's in honor of two people who I presume attended this church (Maybe donated the book? I'm not sure).
It's a relic I was fascinated by when discovering its existence, and being a purveyor of odd things, including books, I knew I had to get a copy of it for my own personal collection. It also demonstrates why children should be kept out of politics as a whole - let them be kids. I don't care if the book is meant to be right or left-leaning. Keep them out of the quagmire as long as possible. That's what I think at least, having grown up in a house with strong political leanings. It can be difficult and at times, inescapable, but I do believe that. Better yet, here's more sound advice across the board: just try to be a decent person, regardless of whether or not you lean more left or right. Try to treat others how you want to be treated. Simple in concept to understand and with a greater chance of being carried over into adulthood. As they grow up, they can come to their own conclusions about things. Things are much more complicated in life than what religious text (In any religion) can properly describe. It's important to remember that fact as well.
And no, despite the author's last name, I will not be making an easy joke. It is tempting, but I will not do so. Besides, the book itself offers more to gawk at peruse over. It would certainly make for an interesting conversation piece. Alas, few share my odd tastes and fascinations. Oh well. Just another oddity for my collection, I suppose.
r/PieceOfShitBookClub • u/Wolfie-Woo784 • Aug 01 '25
Book Just Found This Subreddit, Which Means I Have A Chance To Whinge About This Book I Hated In High School
The Ballad of Sir Dinadan by Gerald Morris. I'd been assigned The Once And Future King by T.H. White for a class, loved it, ended up on a big Arthuriania kick and went looking for more, and found this. I was left sorely disappointed.
If there's one thing I cannot STAND in a creative work, it's the author having a desperate need to be "clever" and "subversive" with no respect or even fascination for what they're trying to subvert. And Morris seemed to be that exact self-mythologizing type.
The protagonist, and the story itself, seemed hateful and loathing of the entire concept of a chivalrous romance, or just, fun in general?? It was so cynical and bitter and just felt masturbatory in a "oooh I'm so smart I'm better than these lame fairy tales" kinda way.
Imagine if Don Quixote sucked, and that's what it felt like. A juveline, whiny, Don Quixote rip-off. It was probably groundbreaking in 2003 when it was published, but to me, lame and played out.
r/PieceOfShitBookClub • u/Hermit_187_purveyor • Jul 10 '25
Book The Way of the Shadow Wolves by Steven Seagal and Tom Morrissey - a preposterous, nonsensical thriller starring Seagal's self-insert Mary Sue role-playing as a Native American lawman who takes on the deep state, the cartel, and jihadists. It's awful, strangely fascinating, and unintentionally funny
Yes, Steven Seagal co-wrote a book. Then again, he is a man of many..."talents." He's an "actor" with numerous films under his belt of questionable quality (My personal favorites are Today You Die, Into the Sun, Out For Justice, Mercenary for Justice, and Hard to Kill. They're all so bad they're good to me), a martial artist of dubious credentials (According to his first wife, he only earned his black belt in aikido because the master who tested him was notoriously lazy. The master apparently fell asleep during Seagal's testing and then gave him a black belt anyway), has three citizenships (U.S., Serbia, Russia), has a litany of sexual assault and harassment allegations against him, is a "musician" with a hilariously bad song catalogue ("Strut" is one of the most hilariously awful songs ever created with such lyrics as "Me want the punani"), is apparently a man who changes ethnicity like some sort of shape-shifting entity (Despite being half-Irish and half-Jewish, he has been Italian, Japanese, Chinese, Native American, black, and claimed to be a Russian mongrel), a law enforcement officer (Even getting a television show, Steven Seagal: Lawman), a businessman and spokesperson, a Buddhist, a martial arts instructor (Earning his Serbian citizenship from teaching aikido to special forces in the country), is a special envoy for Russia-U.S. relations, a tough guy who's just so badass (Like claiming that while living in Japan with his first wife, he managed to fend off the Yakuza. According to his first wife, there were no Yakuza encounters, only chasing away drunks from the dojo. He did, however, have a real life encounter with the muscle of a New York mobster in the 2000's...where he was scared, cried into the shoulders of the officers who came to his aid, and apparently held a security blanket while testifying against the man at trial), and more. He is a man of many hats, however questionable they may be.
Since his acting career has largely gone the way of the dodo bird (With his last film being 2019's Beyond the Law), he tried his hand at writing a novel with help from Tom Morrissey, who, if the back of the book is to be believed: "...a retired Chief Deputy US Marshal, martial artist, veteran of the US Army, musician, author, political leader and activist." The culmination of this endeavor is The Way of the Shadow Wolves: The Deep State and the Hijacking of America. Yes, this book is terrible. But if you've seen any number of Steven Seagal films (Of which I have seen over twenty of his films. He and his films are just so fascinating to me), you probably already guessed that would be the outcome.
For this novel, Seagal channels a less-remembered phase of his career: his Native American phase with such films as On Deadly Ground (1994) and The Patriot (1998. No, not the film starring Mel Gibson. That one was released in 2000. Believe me, you would have noticed if Seagal had been in that one). It's a curious choice, but it also leads to a novel with depictions of Native Americans so absurd and over the top, they make the whimsical Disney animated film, Pocahontas (1995), look like a documentary film (But there will be no beautiful imagery, good performances, or delightful songs).
The basic gist is the story is about a member of the tribal patrol unit, the Shadow Wolves, named John Nan Tan Gode (Which sounds like a weirdly stereotyped Asian name), who uncovers a deep state conspiracy to smuggle Jihadists across the border through Maricopa County, Arizona, with help from the Mexican cartel. The plan is to commit terrorist attacks across the U.S. to give rise to a new Islamic caliphate with backing that goes all the way to the White House (The novel refuses to say Obama, but it's clearly about him, mentioning such things as the Fast and Furious scandal and questioning his place of actual birth. It should be noted that this novel was released in 2017...after Obama's second term concluded). John and his fellow Shadow Wolves must do everything in their power to stop this from happening and try to blow off the lid on this conspiracy.
In skilled hands, this sort of plot would be difficult to pull off. It would require great care and putting on a high-wire act that could go wrong at any moment of writing it. Put it in the hands of Seagal and Morrissey and it's handled with all the delicacy and nuance of holding a bullfight at Tiffany's. Despite wanting to be a serious political thriller, the end result is so ridiculous, it makes Zoolander (2001) look like The Manchurian Candidate (1962).
For starters, the characterization is abysmal, to put it charitably. Seagal's self-insert is the only character with any depth (As is the sin of many fan-fiction stories). It's his usual tough guy persona that he has played many times over, but with absurd depictions of Native American mysticism sprinkled on top. Take a gander at this passage at the beginning of the story when John is being tracked by mysterious men at night. I want you to picture Steven Seagal acting out this scene. And before you get to the end, yes, this is one paragraph.
"About twenty feet from where John was standing was a rise in the land. He proceeded with what he was doing despite the action behind him, moving slowly toward it while shaking his fist in the air. This was his grandfather's 'old ways' method of bidding the sun a good-night and asking it to return in the morning. As he was ceremonially dancing and chanting towards the rise, he suddenly dropped to his knees. There he began his shaman-natured ritual celebrating the spirit of the wolf, the dominant creature of the night. As he chanted, a shadowy wolf slowly approached him out of the encroaching darkness, kissed his forehead, and stood there for a moment, watching him. After a moment, the animal turned and looked at the men who had stopped dead in their tracks as they approached from behind. The mysterious wolf's fierce eyes glared at them as they froze in place. He then slowly turned his glance back to the kneeling Native American, kissing his forehead again before disappearing back into the shadows. At that point, John heard movement coming from what sounded like three men. He got back to his feet and continued dancing his way into the darkness. He went behind the rise from where he was able to observe them, but they could not see him. He was a Ghost Warrior known as a 'Shadow Wolf.' One who could easily blend with the night. Disappear into the darkness at will."
The other heroes of the story end up blending into each other, because they are given virtually no traits, aside from Alicia, who is a fellow Shadow Wolf who just so happens to be sleeping with John, because he's just so hot (Ladies, take a look at that book cover. Like what you see?). For villains it's much of the same problem, only this time they have less subtlety than the villains from Saturday morning cartoons back in the 80's and 90's. Here's a snippet from a corrupt federal agent meeting with other corrupt federal agents:
"I know it's tough with all the OTMs, and every federal, state, and local agency trying to bag as many illegal aliens as possible, but this is how we earn our Cayman Island end-of-the-year bonuses, so I need for each of you to double-down."
What are OTMs, you may ask? Don't worry there's a glossary of terms: Other Than Mexican. Anyways, yes, that is an actual line and not done in jest, either. These bad guys make Krang and Shredder, along with their imbecile sidekicks, Bebop and Rocksteady from the 1987-1996 Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles series look like the bad guys from the underrated 1960 Akira Kurosawa masterpiece, The Bad Sleep Well by comparison.
Here's this line after the corrupt federal agents get beaten up by John at a diner and slink away, plotting their next move:
"This son of a bitch needs a 'girls' night out.' And now he's going to get one."
There is then a later chapter called Girls' Night Out, which involves trying to get a hot girl to seduce John and lead him into a trap to be assassinated. Naturally, his gut tells him to turn her down. There's still a gunfight outside, but he and his friend live, while the girl used as bait dies. You can bet your ass that while reading this chapter, because of its title, I was absolutely listening to Cyndi Lauper's "Girls Just Want to Have Fun" to set the mood.
These are just a few highlights, as most of the novel is bad dialogue, bad writing, muddled plotting, uncovering conspiracies by dumb luck and plot convenience, political diatribes, bad drama (John had a younger brother who eventually committed suicide, which makes the reader think he'll form some kind of attachment to the character Sweet Tooth, who's an informant and who's older brother is involved with the cartel. Aside from providing intel, there will be no real character development), fight scenes Seagal's self-insert easily wins, gun fights, Native American mysticism with visions of his beloved dead grandfather, following his "gut" which is never wrong, and piles and piles of bodies. It should also be noted Seagal describes his character as lean (Something Seagal has not been since Under Siege...from 1992) and his mother is alive and only in her sixties (In the year of this novel's publication, Seagal would have turned 65. I guess he turned back the clock on himself by twenty-odd years).
For me, this book had just enough bad amusement to keep me interested (It barely crossed the thresh hold of so bad it's funny for me, but it made it), but I would NEVER recommend anyone read this book unless you are are also a masochist for Seagal and studying his shenanigans and oddly deep lore and back story. He's a living parody of a human being and tough guy persona. For others, it will be a crushing bore with confusing plotting and bad political messaging.
r/PieceOfShitBookClub • u/wild_muses • Aug 11 '25
Book "Opposing Viewpoints" Series on Sexual Violence - a collection of essays arguing different sides of issues related to sexual violence. NSFW
The point of this series seems to be promoting freedom of speech on the grounds that you can't understand your opposition if they aren't allowed to publish their arguments. I can understand this existing for, say, a sociology student examining cultural attitudes about sexual assault, but jesus christ. Publishing someone's essay about how sometimes SA is the victim's fault is something else.
Found at a sidewalk sale from a used bookstore under new ownership clearing out the old inventory. There were a lot of doozies there, lots of religious stuff and very outdated relationship type books.
r/PieceOfShitBookClub • u/[deleted] • Aug 06 '15
Book I found this collection in the hallway when my neighbor moved out of his apartment, apparently he was quite the intellectual...
r/PieceOfShitBookClub • u/Hermit_187_purveyor • Jul 29 '25
Book Stinky Duck by Onision and presumably, also illustrated by Onision as well. However, neither a writer or illustrator is credited. Yes, Onision wrote a picture book for children. Aren't you glad you have eyes today?
Stinky Duck or The Stinky Duck (Apparently, Onision can't quite decide on a proper title since the latter title appears after opening up the book), is about a stinky duck. This duck is given no name, but we are only informed that for whatever reason, he is stinky.
The story follows his misadventures trying to find friends or do much of anything without being shunned for being so stinky. He's insulted by a cow, insulted by a farmer he's trying to buy pickles from, other ducks leave the pond he tries to swim in, receives an eviction notice on his front door because of his smell, floats down a stream, and then befriends a pig who thinks he smells good and wants to be friends. He finally finds a place of acceptance, a new friend, and lives happily ever after.
The basic gist is that there's always a place to go and friends to be accepted by. Not a bad message by any means. Without knowing anything about the author, and since the book is uncredited, no one would be the wiser. They would mostly be put off by the terrible Microsoft Paint artwork which looks like the paintings done by the character, Janey, from Not Another Teen Movie (2001). But don't expect any funny satire or even guilty pleasure laughs like those found in the aforementioned film.
Examining this odd work from the author's perspective makes it oddly and morbidly fascinating, as Onision is now an online and real-life pariah (Running the gamut from grooming allegations to abuse allegations. Oh, and when he was younger, he may have also tried to start a cult). Much like the stinky duck of this story, no one wants to go near him, they'll insult him for his off putting presence and demeanor, and he's largely been driven away. His only real place of acceptance are among his die hard fans.
It is also his finest literary achievement yet. It seems he has finally learned how to mostly write coherent sentences and spell properly. Though, this is helped greatly by the fact that this book contains so few sentences and dialogue. While not saying much...at all...Stinky Duck is miles ahead of his novels (Stones to Abbigale, This is Why I Hate You, and Reaper's Creek). By comparison, it reads like Leo Tolstoy or Henry James.
But don't worry, for Onision wrote another book: In Real Life. This one is about himself, giving the reader a glimpse inside his mind and who knows what else. I have it, and you can bet your ass I'm going to read it and probably put it up here. In the mean time, I'm sorry if your eyes bleed from just looking upon the cover. I assure you, the artwork inside is even worse.
r/PieceOfShitBookClub • u/RikiOh • Aug 06 '15
Book Bearillionaire: He's a billionaire, and a bear, and he'd never let anything happen to his mate... (A BBW shapshifter romance ... of course)
r/PieceOfShitBookClub • u/hatefulnateful • Jul 18 '25
Book Thought it be scary but it's just people arguing
r/PieceOfShitBookClub • u/KieranWriter • Jul 19 '25
I found this book in the street when I visited NYC and I was so intrigued I took it back to England with me. Is it a piece of shit? Apparently you’ll be asked at the gates of heaven if you read this book.
r/PieceOfShitBookClub • u/bartelbyfloats • Sep 09 '25
High Quality Shit Sheba — The Seductive Russian Spy
This is one of the worst things I’ve ever read, and I loved every second of it.
A bit of backstory: my partner’s friend used to work for Borders. After hours, he and his co-workers would read the self-published books out loud to each other, and that is how they discovered Kurt Humphrey’s SHEBA - THE SEDUCTIVE RUSSIAN SPY.
This book has everything. Russian spies. Descriptions of sex that sound like an alien wrote them. Chemical plant explosions. Weapons deals. Assassinations. Detours to Las Vegas and a lesbian subplot that always pivots away from actual same-sex love because the author is clearly uncomfortable with it. There are two young Russian agents, who are never named, that just fight each other all of the time like they’re in a screwball comedy. And midway through, Mr. Humphrey introduces a subplot involving magical gargoyle paintings and ancient mystical tomes from the 15th century.
The main character’s name is Kirk. (The author’s name is Kurt.) Kirk is in a love triangle with his ex-girlfriend Cheyenne and this seductive Russian spy he meets in a park. He gives them orgasms just by standing near them. Often, foreplay involves the lovers throwing food at each other. Sheba’s desire to settle down with Kirk is constantly derailed by increasingly insane spy missions (which Kirk is completely unaware of.)
There’s a lot of talk about how Sheba is an expert in seduction. In one scene, she distracts a guard by literally shoving his face into her tit, and then she murders him.
I’d love to know more about Kurt Humphrey, but I can’t find any info about him. His descriptions of love and sex indicate he’s never experienced a relationship before. In fact, it sounds as if he’s never met another human in his life.
Anyway, has anyone else stumbled upon this gem of a book in their travels?