r/PickyEaters • • 7h ago

šŸœ Safe Food Saturday: what’s everyone eating on repeat? šŸ˜‚

2 Upvotes

What’s on your safe food rotation right now? šŸ’œ By safe food, this thread means food that feels familiar or manageable to eat, for example because of its texture, taste or ease of preparation. It doesn’t mean allergy-safe.

šŸ„” What’s keeping you fed lately?

šŸ§€ Does it need to be a certain brand, texture, temperature or prepared in a particular way?

šŸ„„ What makes eating easier when your energy is low?

šŸ’” Has a former favourite suddenly become something you can’t stand?

Share the nuggets, survival snacks and very specific toast requirements. Please respect people’s food choices and allergies, and offer nutrition or treatment suggestions only when requested and within your expertise.

I’m nosy. What’s on repeat? šŸ‘€


r/PickyEaters • • 7h ago

Picky eater

1 Upvotes

I have been a picky eater since i was a kid, everytime meat touched my mouth i would get goosebumps and giant gag reflex. I didnt eat many stuff like till this day i havent eaten fish, i tried crab sticks the other day big accomplishment, i dont have a texture thing problem, js that some food genuinely make me gag so bad. Ever since i was a kid i didnt like eating food, i was always too skinny, but now i live off of snacks so im overly fat, currently im 59 kg and i have a slight double chin and everyone points out my weight. I dont really get the picky eater hate, i genuinely cannot touch food bc it makes me gag, why dont people get that? Its not a big problem either. I dont eat way more than half of my countrys cousine, i started hated pelmen thingys bc the meat inside had like cartilage of animals, that made me throw up instantly, now i found some expensive ones and i can like finally chew meat without anything making me gag.


r/PickyEaters • • 16h ago

Anyone else get tired of eating the same meals but struggle to try anything new?

4 Upvotes

I feel like I’m stuck in a cycle of eating the same meals over and over again. I get tired of them eventually but whenever I try to think of something new, nothing sounds appealing.

Sometimes I’ll even crave something, prepare it, and then suddenly not feel like eating it anymore.

Does anyone else experience this? How do you find new foods or meals that you actually enjoy?


r/PickyEaters • • 23h ago

Discussion does anyone else have a few safe meals they could honestly eat every single week?

13 Upvotes

i have a handful of meals that i keep coming back to, and honestly, i never really get tired of them. if i find something i like, i'll happily eat it several times a week rather than risk ordering or making something completely different and ending up disappointed.

my family sometimes jokes about how predictable my food choices are, especially when everyone else wants to try a new restaurant or experiment with different dishes. i do try new things occasionally, but there's just something comforting about knowing exactly what i'm getting with certain meals.

i'm curious if other picky eaters are like this too. do you have specific meals you keep going back to, or do you eventually get tired of even your favorite foods?


r/PickyEaters • • 2d ago

Question Is it normal to like something but not?

5 Upvotes

I feel crazy. I like a pizza place but I don’t like it, yes it tastes good but it doesn’t taste good. Yk?


r/PickyEaters • • 2d ago

Question Is anybody else like this too?

7 Upvotes

I don’t really consider myself picky, I actually can eat any vegetable, fruit or ingredient by itself.
I just can’t stand when food is not properly cooked or done, i.e.: undercooked onion, watery/overdone spinach, minced meat with hard pieces, under salted or bland food, food that tastes like dishsoap or has fridge odor, bad quality ingredients, burnt oil taste, moist pie crust… and i could go on
Also I get tired very quickly of repeating meals. And sometimes I will get sooo tired of all foods that I don’t even know what to eat anymore.


r/PickyEaters • • 3d ago

Need Advice Can’t try new foods

3 Upvotes

I’m 19 and I’m a little overweight. I’ve always been a picky eater and also have an extremely heightened sense of taste. I only like stuff that seems to be bad for me. The foods that are healthy that I do like are usually meat and certain kinds of fruits and veggies and the only grains I eat aren’t whole grain. I’ll get to the point. Every time I try a new food I gag really bad and sometimes throw up. My family has grown very impatient and I’m worried about it too. I’m looking advice or if anyone has had a similar experience.


r/PickyEaters • • 3d ago

Question foods i may be able to try based on these??

Post image
3 Upvotes

right now i have a lot of food options, many more than i used to have, and while im happy with that i want to try find some healthier foods i may like that are still kind of like these if that makes sense?? thank you


r/PickyEaters • • 4d ago

Discussion does anyone else have foods they like separately but hate when they're mixed together?

36 Upvotes

one thing i've noticed about my eating habits is that sometimes i can enjoy two foods individually but the moment they're combined, i suddenly don't want either of them. it's not always about the taste either. sometimes it's the texture or just how everything feels together.

for example, i can enjoy certain vegetables on their own, but when they're mixed into a dish with too many other ingredients, i lose my appetite for it. even knowing that i like everything in the meal doesn't really change my reaction.

i sometimes feel like explaining this to people makes me sound unnecessarily difficult about food lol. does anyone else have oddly specific food combinations that they just cannot tolerate, even if they like all the ingredients separately?


r/PickyEaters • • 5d ago

Success / Progress Expanding safe foods, cheese ravioli

Post image
118 Upvotes

Personal win on expanding my safe foods, cheese ravioli. Yes it’s just my pasta and cheese safe food put together but I’m pretty happy haha


r/PickyEaters • • 4d ago

Need Advice I don't think I can eat onions anymore.

10 Upvotes

One of the foods I've gotten really into the past couple years was onions, and it's been a major win in broadening my food taste. They were my #2 go-to vegetable, after potatoes. Super good, and made my diet a lot more healthy.

Unfortunately, I think I've been developing an allergy/intolerance to them, resulting in some pretty bad nasal blockage and painful bloating.

This wouldn't be a big deal if I wasn't incredibly picky. The only other veggies I eat are potatoes, peppers, and lettuce. I've been eyeing other alliums like leeks as a replacement, but I don't know if I'll have the same response to them. Does anyone have some suggestions for things that could possibly replace onions in my diet?


r/PickyEaters • • 5d ago

Question How do I find more food I actually like?

9 Upvotes

I'm a picky eater, and definitely not by choice. I have a lot of stomach issues, and I've been trying to cut back on tv dinners and Mac and cheese. But I also struggle with the transition of doing whatever and then having to cook. I can't figure out what I can make thats quick, I might like, and doesn't have cheese. Does anybody have advice? I don't really know how to cook. I can cook pasta good but I feel like pasta and cheese (at least for me) go hand in hand. Does anybody have their own recipes they can drop? Or recommendations for apps to figure out what I might like? Or anything else

Edit: thank you all for your responses, I don't think I will respond to anymore but I genuinely appreciate everybody's advice! It's been very helpful and I'm going to try to remember to make a list in the morning so I can try all the suggestions at some point!


r/PickyEaters • • 6d ago

1 year old super picky only beige food

3 Upvotes

Our 1 year old has always had some food challenges - dairy allergy, trouble with nursing then bottles. He was great with solids than super regressed and was doing great again for a month or so and now at 1 basically only eats beige. Dinner is the worst. He’s often in tears. We try to get him out of the seat as quickly as possible when he cries so the negative associations don’t build but it’s hard bc he needs to eat. Is this normal? Should we be worried about a sensory issue or some emerging neurodiversity? Suggestion, thoughts, tips?


r/PickyEaters • • 6d ago

Need Advice How to make myself actually want to drink protein shakes??

4 Upvotes

I am currently underweight, and one of the ways I've been trying to gain weight is with protein shakes, but I HATE them. I currently drink the fairlife vanilla shake, as it's the one that tastes the best, but my brain still sees it as a chore, and the sublte aftertaste still effects me. I have adhd, so I was hoping there would be some way to trick my brain into seeing it as less of a gross boring drink and something I actually want. Please give me any and all advice!!


r/PickyEaters • • 6d ago

Sweets with food

4 Upvotes

I normally dont like to eat sweet stuff with my regular carb filled meals.

It usually works vice versa where I dont like carbs/regular meals with my sweet stuff.

Is that abnormal. Also its not like I never intermingled one or the other just a preference to keep them separate


r/PickyEaters • • 7d ago

Food

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

I love food more than anything, at the same time I'm a picky eater. I can't explain this most of the time to people.


r/PickyEaters • • 7d ago

I hate meat

12 Upvotes

I don’t like most meat. My only exceptions are bacon and, thin sliced sandwich meat. I don’t like it because of its texture, I love the flavor though it’s too squishy and I hate the fat, but even if the fat is removed and it’s well done. I still don’t really like it.


r/PickyEaters • • 7d ago

Misc anyone else’s safe foods vegetables?

11 Upvotes

Didn’t tag as an actual question cuz its just moreso personal curiosity!

I got ADHD and while i don’t think i am necessarily too picky of an eater (started cooking for myself at a young age and got joy out of trying new things), I def have a lot of silly hard ā€˜no’s with food, like overcooked pasta i just cannot ever stand it 😭

That being said personally for me a lot of veggies are my safe food! raw carrots almost always have the same flavor and texture, and steaming broccoli is easy and again i always know what it will taste like, which is just personally a flavor i enjoy

Is anyone else the same? Idk how much of an oddball these safe foods are


r/PickyEaters • • 7d ago

Need Advice How do i quit spicy food?

2 Upvotes

Im 28 and have gastrointestinal issues really bad. The acid reflux i get is so bad i feel like my chest and back are aching. I need help to stop eating spicy foods. It sounds simple but it isnt, just stop right? I cant, meals do not feel complete without some cayenne pepper or siracha, it feels incomplete and not fufilling and i LOVE food. Maybe i need to work on flavor profile or stuff i cook with? I need to stop but i cant.


r/PickyEaters • • 8d ago

Anybody else have this problem? Safe foods hard to eat unless delicious.

20 Upvotes

We all are familiar with having great difficulty or being unable to eat foods we don't like. Classic picky eater. Well I have another level to it. Foods I like, and have eaten a million times. If it's even slightly bland, or off, or not cooked right, even just barely, it's almost like a chore to eat.

I guess I have 3 levels of food.

  1. Safe and delicious: I can eat this until I'm full and possibly beyond.

  2. Safe and bland/off: I can make myself eat this at least until I am not hungry anymore, but as soon as I lose the drive to eat I lose interest.

  3. The rest: Foods I can/will only eat if there is no other option, or won't eat at all. Can't even swallow some of them

Anybody relate?


r/PickyEaters • • 8d ago

Picky eater friendly protein powder

4 Upvotes

Hello! My 5 yo son (ADHD & possible autism) is an extremely pick eater (food aversions) and were trying to find a protein power that doesnt have that protein-y flavor in it. We've found the Shamrock Farms Rockin Protein shakes are great but can get expensive in liquid form.


r/PickyEaters • • 8d ago

Need Advice Need to drink my medicine and eat

2 Upvotes

I'm insanely picky about food and certain flavors, Its especially bad when I'm sick cassu I can't eat most foods I like. For ex; can't eat salad (I threw up last time I did), can't eat neither chicken (the smell is disgusting) nor beef (too fatty), I can't eat most pastas (too oily or too saucy), hell sometimes I can't even eat bread!!!!

I'm sick rn, the pill is too big for me to swallow without vomiting right after drinking it, so I crush it up and drink it w water. Thing is, it's fucking nasty. It tastes like mint and i hate the taste of mint. The only mint flavored things I've ever liked are (non alcoholic) mojitos and mint tea.

How the hell am I supposed to drink this damn medicine? Is there anything I can sneak it into? Also, is there any way to get myself to eat stuff? Cause I've just been forcing myself to eat and hoping for the best which has been working like 50 50, I threw up yesterday but I didn't today)


r/PickyEaters • • 10d ago

Partner of a picky eater I want to help

6 Upvotes

I have an online friend. They struggle with a lot of anxiety stuff, and one is them eating the same thing day after day.
It has caused a vitamin deficiency and some problem with their teeth. I want to help, but I’m not near, and they don’t seem very open to try new stuff.

I suggested them having their comfort meal with a side or something, or variation of that same safe meal. Even so, they’re scared to try new things. I don’t know what to do.

Any advice on what I could suggest them? How can I help? Something small


r/PickyEaters • • 10d ago

Need Advice Why does food taste more bland?

1 Upvotes

The food I’m eating doesn’t taste any different but something feels off. I don’t feel the same joy I used to from eating and I’m kind of dissapointed about it. I’ve accidentally lost some weight recently because I’m loosing interest in food.

I know most of my posts are shit posts, but this one is serious.