Hey! My name is Ben and I've used many many Android phones the past 7-8 years and I got a fairly good understanding on what phones are generally good to get and what phones are not.
In this guide I will show you what features you should look out for, no matter what your price range is. I will categorize this guide into three parts.
Features you should be looking for in general
Most important attributes for every budget
Some examples
First part:
One of the most important things in your phone is it's longevity, and I'm not talking about battery capacity. I think most of us want our phone to perform as good as if it were new, even if it is 2-3 years old. On iOS it is pretty simple, because there is only one version of it on every device but on Android we have many third party skins. A Google Pixel looks and feels incredibly different from a Xiaomi Mi Mix or a Samsung handset, yet they might be running the same android version deep down.
The longevity depends on multiple things. First of all, how you handle it. You don't want to install 3 antivirus and 200 apps , because it will slow it down significantly. But let's assume you keep things pretty clean. The next thing: Stock Android (Stock = What Google makes. An OS without many modifications.). In general, the closer you are to stock, the smoother and faster your device will be. I recently installed a custom OS on my old LG G3 and the OS size was 300 MB while an OEM OS like Samsung's UX can take up to 3-4 GB. The bigger OS size results in more unused junk, that overall makes your phone slower overtime.
Memory: You don't need 8 GB. If you have 3-4 gigs your device should rarely reload apps. You shouldn't pay extra for that much memory.
Processor: The rule here is to get something from Qualcomm. MediaTek processor tend to be cheaper but they are much worse. You want to look for phones with current gen processors. The Snapdragon 660 is almost as good as a SD (SD = Snapdragon) 821, which is a 2 year old flagship processor, but it is much more efficient. Mid-range chips have come a long way and they are much much better than a few years ago.
With that said, if you want nice performance you should be looking at the new SD 400 series at least and nothing less.
Screen: This is important too. If you like a phone try to look up a review where outdoor visibility is mentioned. Trust me, a bright screen worth so much more that anything in a display. And btw 1080p is still enough.
IP rating: It doesn't really matter what IP rating it has, it will survive a splash. Don't base your decision on this. IP 67 is basically the same as 68 and even 58 is not far behind.
Reputable brand: If you want to save yourself from a lot of trouble, pick a phone from a reputable brand with decent customer support. If you buy some janky Chinese crap, you might not be able to get a repair or a replacement. Just to name a few brands with good customer support: Samsung, Huawei, OnePlus but the best is Sony. They repaired my brother's phone for free, out of warranty.
Second part:
Now that we have seen what are the most important things, take a look at each price range, and what you could expect in them. Keep in mind, I'll be talking about new, off-the-shelf phones. You can always get used phones for crazy low prices and I would recommend picking up a 2 year old flagship new as opposed to a brand new cheap phone. Remember, that phone used to be the top end.
Low-end (0 - 200$): You shouldn't expect anything fancy. Try to go for the basics, a decent processor, close to stock android and sufficiently bright screen. Forget about an amazing camera. Recommended phones: Nokia phones, Xiaomi Mi A1
Mid-range (200 - 400$): You have much more flexibility here. You should still be focusing on the basics but you can go and look into some extras, like a better camera or water resistance or a nice build. Recommended phones: Still Nokia, if you can find older, but still new Sony or OnePlus phones.
Upper-mid-range (400 - 600$): This is OnePlus territory. You can get almost everything in the high-end market. Processors are reaching the SD 8XX range, which means amazing performance. These phones are the sweet spot on the price to value chart. Recommended phones: OnePlus 6, Nokia 7+, Pixel 1
High-end and Premium (600$ - ): You get the idea. The more you pay, the more wiggle room you have for you needs. These phones have the best cameras and build and will probably last the longest. You get features like VR and with the Note series the S pen or you get a translucent back with the HTC U12+, or a 120 Hz display with the Razer Phone. Recommended phones: Sony XZ2, Samsung S9, LG G7 (bright display)
Third part:
Let's take a look at some of my personal recommendations in-depth, phones that I've used or had friend who used them and found to be great.
Xiaomi Mi A1: Well this is a really basic phone, but it gets the job done. Has stock android and decent battery life, plus the modding community is pretty great for it. Recommend it as a really low end option or a secondary device.
Nokia 5, 5.1, 6, 6.1: They are better in many aspects than the Mi A1 and offer a better overall experience. Would recommend to budget users as a solid option.
Nokia 7+: If the OnePlus 6 did not exist, this would be the perfect mid-range phone. Everything is just really solid about this phone. Recommended.
OnePlus: Yes, they copy the iPhones but they are also really good. The SD 845 is a beast and you get an amazing package. Best bang for the buck
Sony phones: They are underrated so much. They run close to stock and they have an amazing battery saver feature. They only charge the battery to 90% overnight and reach 100% by the time you wake up, and this preserves the heath of the battery. They are also fast and reliable and get fast Android updates.
Samsung: From my experience you should only get the high-end ones. The skin they have is so bloated that it will slow down on lower-end ones but the flagships are amazing. Their screens are magically beautiful and the build is amazing. The cameras are decent too.
LG: A bit worse than Sammy imho, but the G7 has a super bright display which I looove. Go for it if you like it.
Pixel: The king of the camera and speed. This is the best option for me personally. I am waiting for the Pixel 3 now. They get the first updates, take the best photos and have the best performance overall.
I hope this guide helped you:) Don't forget, these are my preferences. If you don't value a long-lasting phone, because you change them every 6-12 months, your recommendations could look different.