In response to http://csua.berkeley.edu/~ranga/humor/science_v_faith.html :
This is not an accurate summary of the scientific method. That people think science works this way is exactly why there are the claims that "Well the evidence supports the Bible too". But the ordering of the flowchart is wrong. In order to have a successful scientific theory, it must not only be consistent with all previously-performed experiments, but also make predictions about future phenomena that have not yet been observed. In this sense, the theory precedes the experiment, not the other way around as this chart indicates. This is important in science because there could be many theories that all are consistent with the observed evidence in previously-performed experiments, but if your theory predicts the outcome of a new experiment, then it has effectively predicted the future. And that is the reason that the truth of science is so compelling.
I think the idea of science presented in this chart is best summarized as an analogy to how truth is determined in law. In the courtroom, there are two equally valid theories, that the defendant is guilty or he is not guilty. We examine the evidence, and try to determine if the evidence is more consistent with guilt or innocence. In some cases, the evidence is consistent with both, and that's when we need a rule like "Innocent until proven guilty". But never do the two competing theories actually make predictions about reproducible experiments, such as how the defendant will respond to certain questions - the circumstances are always too complex to allow that kind of rigor. Thus until we find evidence that contradicts one of the theories, we must assume that both are equally valid.
It is this kind of thinking that leads people to believe that "God created the universe" and "The universe was created by the Big Bang" are equally valid theories. The evidence is the existence of the universe - and the evidence is consistent with both theories. But science does not work the same way as law. Even before considering any evidence, those two theories are not equal. "The universe was created by the Big Bang" makes predictions about observable phenomena, such as the Cosmic Microwave Background, as well as explaining all previously-observed phenomena, in particular the existence of the universe. "God created the universe" does not make any predictions. Thus it can be immediately rejected as a reasonable theory. The more people understand this the easier it will be to convince them of their false beliefs (in anything, but particularly in religion).
Sometimes evidence does precede theory. And in fact many of the great advances in science have indeed been spurred by phenomena that are unexplained under the contemporary paradigm. This is true about the development of quantum mechanics and relativity in the early 1900s. But the success of those theories can not be solely attributable to their explanation of previously unexplained observations. The reason the scientific community felt compelled to accept quantum mechanics and relativity as fact was because they made accurate predictions that ended up being true - for quantum mechanics, an example is the double-slit experiment, and for relativity, an example is the 1919 expedition by Sir Arthur Eddington to measure the bending of light during a solar eclipse. Any theory which ends up effectively predicting the future is immediately worthy of consideration - and conversely, any theory which makes no attempts to predict the outcomes of reproducible experiments is immediately discardable.
Notes: The history of science is obviously much more complicated, with big experiments occurring before, during, and after the formulation of theories. Also different forms of the same theory can make ambiguous or contradictory predictions. Everything in the moment is quite muddled but we can view history with 20/20 vision.
Another thing to note is that predictive power is very compelling, but there are other ways for a theory to be compelling. For example, QED predicts the electric dipole moment out to arbitrary precision. We've measured that quantity out to something like 12 decimal places - one of the most accurate measurements ever done in the history of science - and every single one of them is consistent with QED. That is just as strongly compelling.
For further reading: http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/scientific-progress/ http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/pseudo-science/ http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/popper/
Tl;dr: The key component of of a valid scientific theory is falsifiability, or the ability to predict the outcomes of reproducible experiments. For compelling scientific theories, the theory actually becomes before the experiment, in contrast to the order presented in this chart. The reason religion is not a valid ontological theory is that is not falsifiable - it makes no predictions about things that are reproducible.
Full thread: http://www.reddit.com/r/atheism/comments/1iyh2y/science_vs_faith/