r/PhilosophyofScience • • Dec 01 '22

Discussion Science can’t explain consciousness because science is being done by consciousness

0 Upvotes

It is directly observed that mind creates matter. Any claims of a mind-independent reality are mothers of all assumptions. The greatest myth of science is that it can divide reality in such a way that you paradoxically come out with the whole. Science will continue to run around in circles until enough people realize no model can possibly explain how a sense of being comes about because sense of being is primary. Reality is consciousness, you are consciousness. The irreducible infinite singularity you get when you try to “look at the back of your own head”. Non-duality is the most accurate pointer for what reality is: Absolute truth = that which is = not-two. ABSOLUTE TRUTH IS WHAT REALITY IS BEFORE YOUR MIND SUBDIVIDES IT IN ANY WAY (science, philosophy, etc.)


r/PhilosophyofScience • • May 21 '16

Why science needs to break the spell of reductive materialism

Thumbnail
aeon.co
0 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofScience • • Mar 18 '24

Discussion Science and Religion should not be compared because they exist in different realms

0 Upvotes

edit: the best response from below which encapsulates what I mean is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-overlapping_magisteria posted by u/ronin1066

People often hold hotly argumentative 'debates' on this argument as if one supersedes or is more correct than the other. I think they're more of an Unstoppable Force vs. Immovable Object and too incompatible to compare.

Science:

  • Is a method, (not a subject,) encouraging repeated experiments to reach consistent conclusions.

  • Changes and encourages changes in doctrine. Gravity has had 3 major revisions (ancient, Newtonian, Relativity) and is actively looking for another. Other scientific fields seek this level of research to replace older doctrine.

  • Predicts the future when combined with math. You will know how much fuel you need for a rocket to reach a certain distance or altitude with math, for example.

Religion:

  • Written (or spoken) doctrine based on its depiction of events. Doctrine is written (or spoken) and unchanging. (This is in general, as there are revisions and versions of doctrine which I am not an expert on. There are minor changes over centuries or millennia, but in general it is consistent on major depicted events.)

  • Faith based on doctrine and is unchanging. (In general) discourages alteration/modification/updates.

  • Religion is generally untestable for science. Mysterious observations are explained by deity/deities, especially those which science cannot explain. These are generally applied at the end of known knowledge where the question is asked "why does something occur?" Such as, why are we here, why does the universe exist, or is there life (or other existence) after death.

Replying to this post with any argument of one over the other fails to recognize above points. Bill Nye vs Ken Ham was, in my opinion, philosophically immature. The debate results reflect my statements above where neither Bill Nye nor Ken Ham accepted each other's statements. Religious people may say "doctrine says..." and that is true. Others will say "Science is used by religious people" and that is also true. But they are applied in different ways. Science will recognize and explain patterns, religion will provide prayer (hope) and rules for society (based on doctrine.)

apologies if this is off topic note: i'm not a theologian or scientist, i'm a college dropout stating my opinion on the matter.


r/PhilosophyofScience • • Aug 27 '25

Discussion Has the line between science and pseudoscience completely blurred?

4 Upvotes

Popper's falsification is often cited, but many modern scientific fields (like string theory or some branches of psychology) deal with concepts that are difficult to falsify. At the same time, pseudoscience co-opts the language of science. In the age of misinformation, is the demarcation problem more important than ever? How can we practically distinguish science from pseudoscience when both use data and technical jargon?


r/PhilosophyofScience • • Sep 19 '12

Science & God: Will Biology, Astronomy, Physics Rule Out Existence Of Deity?

Thumbnail
huffingtonpost.com
0 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofScience • • Oct 24 '21

Discussion Demotivated to learn science after learning about the philosophy of science.

0 Upvotes

After reading Kuhn/the history of science and learning about the history of how relativity overtook Newtonian Mechanics I personally just don't feel like learnings cine. If in 1000 years our current understanding of EM. elemental theory and evolution will be resigned to a history book and new theories are out there what is the point of learning about science currently? The imagology that really got me to think like this was that of a tree in an extremely large forest. Currently humanity is looking at 1 tree whilst due to limits in resources/cognitive abilities/bureaucracy we know nothing even a drop in the water of the forest in general. Can we really say we understand biology if 99.999% of fossils have been persevered nor their genes hell the Christians may be right and common descent might not even be true. How much do we know about the universe or if relativity is even true if we don't even know about weather or not Kessler syndrome is true or not which is literally in earths backyard forget about the rest of the universe.

Essentially what I'm saying is that I lost all motivation to learn science after I found out that what ill spend energy learning is probably not even true.


r/PhilosophyofScience • • Mar 01 '20

Discussion Infinity is an Illusion

1 Upvotes

[EDIT: Deleted first few lines for reasons discussed in the comments]

When I really began thinking deeply about reality and my place in it, I needed a firm starting point from which to begin. The title of this post comes from my first assumption. Delving into the ramifications and qualifications has been a wondrous journey for me. The closest I've come to hearing a choir of angels came after understanding Cantor's Diagonality Theorem.

The idea of infinity has proven not just useful, but critical for the advancement of science. Calculus introduces the concept, manipulates the result, then extracts any instances again, leaving a residual of new (to us) information. Numbers don't make any sense with finite constraints...there is no highest prime. There is also no end to the possible ways anything can go wrong.

The utility of an idea, however, doesn't give it credence as an actual aspect or description of reality. This is as dualist as I get: we can hold something in mind that has no concordance with anything that can directly affect the body (which is an actual description of reality). The universe is the way the universe is, regardless of our explanations, interpretations or beliefs. Unfortunately, these are pretty much all we have to rely on to commit philosophy and the idea of infinity has wormed its way into all of them. Root it out! This is wonderfully applicable to the philosophy of religion, but that's a different subreddit.

Neil deGrasse Tyson has a marvelous discussion of infinity throughout history. Its most common usage has been papering over ignorance, basically saying "Here there be Dragons". In almost every case, we have learned more by expecting something explicable (i.e. finite). The exception is, of course, quantum gravity, which spews so many infinities it makes dividing by zero look like stubbing your toe.

Another way of saying we hold something in mind with no concordance is "illusion". If you disallow notions of infinity in your explanations, interpretations and beliefs, you're far more likely to arrive at practical, more accurate conclusions. Is the world infinite? No, so stop polluting. Are we infinite? No, so cherish your time here and don't be mean. Is the universe infinite? I don't know and neither do you, but the perceivable universe certainly isn't and anything more doesn't matter.

Recently there has been a wild resurgence of infinity in the philosophy of science. Guth's inflationary model is the hands-down favourite hypothesis for the start of it all. A consequence of the math is the idea of the multiverse. While this is handy for side-stepping the Anthropic Principle, it doesn't provide much in the way of understanding our place here and now. Few scientists voice credulity, but Lee Smolin and Sean Carroll are two shining beacons from the ivory tower. We can do better, they say. I can but nod and smile.


r/PhilosophyofScience • • Mar 25 '13

Could the reddit model replace the current scientific publication system?

Thumbnail
randalolson.com
3 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofScience • • Jan 11 '23

Discussion should we listen to scientific consensus?

0 Upvotes

Should we care about what the scientific consensus says? Like for example: the consensus on evolution and climate change?


r/PhilosophyofScience • • Apr 23 '14

Creating the Multiverse in the Mind, does our consciousness (as defined by Michio Kaku) create multiple universes?

Thumbnail
masonsmusings.wordpress.com
0 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofScience • • Oct 13 '25

Discussion Why is panpsychism not more popular?

0 Upvotes

I'm working on writing a "why you should believe in panpsychism and why it matters" blog post (not an academic) and would love thoughts on what the biggest objections to it are.

I see it like this, starting from a prior of physicalism:

  • you need (some form of) strong emergence to explain consciousness without (some form of) panpsychism

  • strong emergence is somewhat incoherent as a concept

  • panpsychism is not the most human-intuitive answer but is clearly what our study of reality is yelling at us

Like where exactly do you draw the line between humans and particles for subjective experience? Whatever it is, doesn't it feel wrong that there's a hard line in the first place? If there's no hard line then how is that not panpsychism? (A common place is between living organisms and chemicals, but even then you still have viruses and RNA, and if not RNA then life had to start somehow etc. Life and nonlife are not two fully separable categories, they just look like that in today's world)

For me it feels way easier to think about consciousness from a computation / information lens than thinking about qualia or the color red or whatever.

I also believe that p-zombies are at least as incoherent as strong emergence. If some system looks to have the same computational processes as another from the outside, then it has to have at least the same computational abilities as the original system. You get to have p-zombies if you can explain what element of what happens inside brains is not computational, which also seems nonsensical.

I'm not confident on specifics but it seems reasonable that forces on particles (or whatever quantum causal effects - I know forces aren't real) are analogous to our senses and the subsequent path of the particle (motion or turning to other particles or whatever) is analogous to our motor actions.

What part of this do people disagree with the most?

(Not that it's super relevant here - I hope you all think it matters! - but as for the why it matters part, I believe consciousness is in the "unexplainable and unfalsifiable today, but not forever" category, which is a good enough reason to care about it, and also it might have very important moral implications)

edit: I'm very glad at all the discussion this has caused even if many are just dunking on me. earnestly, thanks!


r/PhilosophyofScience • • Oct 10 '11

Knee Jerk Rejection of 6-sigma confirmed faster than light Neutrinos. Try that with a Vaccine or Climate study. Science a Corrupt Belief System in Decay.

Thumbnail
science20.com
3 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofScience • • Feb 24 '13

THE ULTIMATE QUESTION: What is a question?

1 Upvotes

Plain and simple (or so it might seem!)... What is a question?

Things to possibly consider:

-are questions simply constructs created to assist the process of inquiry?

-what is inquiry?

-do questions exist in the same way that rocks and/or people exist?

-are questions more like processes or objects? Or both, or neither?

-is there a physical analogue to a question?

-is there a physical analogue to the process of questioning?

*Edited to improve appearance of text


r/PhilosophyofScience • • Mar 27 '11

New Atheism: A Disaster Comparable to the Tea Party

Thumbnail
chronicle.com
12 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofScience • • Nov 12 '14

Would Science Exist Without Religion?

Thumbnail
psmag.com
4 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofScience • • Apr 23 '11

Imagining the Tenth Dimension [YouTube]

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofScience • • Jun 14 '26

Casual/Community Did Schrödinger believe in his cat theory?

2 Upvotes

Unsure if this is the right sub for this, but I was wondering what Schrödinger actually thought about his impact on the field of quantum mechanics.

It seems like it was just a thought experiment he came up with to make fun of Quantum mechanics, but the scientific community took him literally and actually applied it to their models.

I’m fascinated by the idea of dualistic states of existence, but it does seem completely science fiction to me.


r/PhilosophyofScience • • Jul 25 '13

r/atheism had nothing to say about my views on the importance of falsifiability - hopefully r/PoS can foster a better discussion

1 Upvotes

In response to http://csua.berkeley.edu/~ranga/humor/science_v_faith.html :

This is not an accurate summary of the scientific method. That people think science works this way is exactly why there are the claims that "Well the evidence supports the Bible too". But the ordering of the flowchart is wrong. In order to have a successful scientific theory, it must not only be consistent with all previously-performed experiments, but also make predictions about future phenomena that have not yet been observed. In this sense, the theory precedes the experiment, not the other way around as this chart indicates. This is important in science because there could be many theories that all are consistent with the observed evidence in previously-performed experiments, but if your theory predicts the outcome of a new experiment, then it has effectively predicted the future. And that is the reason that the truth of science is so compelling.

I think the idea of science presented in this chart is best summarized as an analogy to how truth is determined in law. In the courtroom, there are two equally valid theories, that the defendant is guilty or he is not guilty. We examine the evidence, and try to determine if the evidence is more consistent with guilt or innocence. In some cases, the evidence is consistent with both, and that's when we need a rule like "Innocent until proven guilty". But never do the two competing theories actually make predictions about reproducible experiments, such as how the defendant will respond to certain questions - the circumstances are always too complex to allow that kind of rigor. Thus until we find evidence that contradicts one of the theories, we must assume that both are equally valid.

It is this kind of thinking that leads people to believe that "God created the universe" and "The universe was created by the Big Bang" are equally valid theories. The evidence is the existence of the universe - and the evidence is consistent with both theories. But science does not work the same way as law. Even before considering any evidence, those two theories are not equal. "The universe was created by the Big Bang" makes predictions about observable phenomena, such as the Cosmic Microwave Background, as well as explaining all previously-observed phenomena, in particular the existence of the universe. "God created the universe" does not make any predictions. Thus it can be immediately rejected as a reasonable theory. The more people understand this the easier it will be to convince them of their false beliefs (in anything, but particularly in religion).

Sometimes evidence does precede theory. And in fact many of the great advances in science have indeed been spurred by phenomena that are unexplained under the contemporary paradigm. This is true about the development of quantum mechanics and relativity in the early 1900s. But the success of those theories can not be solely attributable to their explanation of previously unexplained observations. The reason the scientific community felt compelled to accept quantum mechanics and relativity as fact was because they made accurate predictions that ended up being true - for quantum mechanics, an example is the double-slit experiment, and for relativity, an example is the 1919 expedition by Sir Arthur Eddington to measure the bending of light during a solar eclipse. Any theory which ends up effectively predicting the future is immediately worthy of consideration - and conversely, any theory which makes no attempts to predict the outcomes of reproducible experiments is immediately discardable.

Notes: The history of science is obviously much more complicated, with big experiments occurring before, during, and after the formulation of theories. Also different forms of the same theory can make ambiguous or contradictory predictions. Everything in the moment is quite muddled but we can view history with 20/20 vision.

Another thing to note is that predictive power is very compelling, but there are other ways for a theory to be compelling. For example, QED predicts the electric dipole moment out to arbitrary precision. We've measured that quantity out to something like 12 decimal places - one of the most accurate measurements ever done in the history of science - and every single one of them is consistent with QED. That is just as strongly compelling.

For further reading: http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/scientific-progress/ http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/pseudo-science/ http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/popper/

Tl;dr: The key component of of a valid scientific theory is falsifiability, or the ability to predict the outcomes of reproducible experiments. For compelling scientific theories, the theory actually becomes before the experiment, in contrast to the order presented in this chart. The reason religion is not a valid ontological theory is that is not falsifiable - it makes no predictions about things that are reproducible.

Full thread: http://www.reddit.com/r/atheism/comments/1iyh2y/science_vs_faith/


r/PhilosophyofScience • • May 03 '14

What are the objective, quantifiable benefits that psychology has brought to humanity, if any?

3 Upvotes

Title sums it up. I've no agenda and am not trying to troll. I'm genuinely curious.

Edit: I do believe it when people say that there are benefits to psychology (I'm not a Tom Cruise loon), but I did note that no one cited a source.


r/PhilosophyofScience • • Sep 11 '15

On the Philosophical Inadequacy of Modern Physics and the Need for a Theory of Space (2015) | Henry H. Lindner

Thumbnail cosmosandhistory.org
0 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofScience • • Feb 27 '26

Discussion Should physics move away from or get closer to philosophy?

6 Upvotes

There’s a line often attributed to Richard Feynman that says, “just as birds don’t need to study aerodynamics to fly, a scientist doesn’t need to study philosophy of science.”

Many people link science to what is measurable and observable. Anything outside that area gets lumped into philosophy (metaphysics, beyond physics). So topics like God, love, ethics are usually seen as outside the scientific scope.

The question is, does science only talk about, or should it only talk about, what is observable and measurable? Is that a useful practice or harmful to science?

Are there examples that support each position?

Are physicists better scientists if they study philosophy, or is that a waste of time?


r/PhilosophyofScience • • Jul 28 '14

Some philosophers think maths exists in a mysterious other realm. They’re wrong. Look around: you can see it

Thumbnail
aeon.co
8 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofScience • • Apr 10 '12

So I was trying to explain that's it's hard to answer "where are you from?"

0 Upvotes

At work, with a coworker from Algeria who asked me if I was "only from Quebec", I tried to give him an idea that it was a very difficult question to answer, so to give him an idea, I did a quick calculation with him that I think everyone should know to relativise their "origins", from a more scientific then nationalistic/emotional point of view.

So the average generation is about 25 years.

Why?

Because a woman usually gives birth around that time, sometimes 20, sometimes 30, now more and more 40 are able to but before it was closer to 20 then 30, so the accepted approximation is 25 years.

Now let's take an easy round number and talk about the last 500 years, where your ancestors came from. So, for 500 years, we got 20 generations (20 x 25 = 500).

Now let's just try and calculate how many ancestors we each have, as an average, for the last 20 generations, or 500 years before our birth.

I have 2 parents, 4 grand-parents, 8 great-grandparents... you get the idea, so it goes like this: 2 + 4 + 8 + 16 + 32 + 64 + 128 + 256 + 512 + 1 024 + 2 048 + 4 096 + 8 192 + 16 384 + 32 768 + 65 536 + 131 072 + 262 144 + 524 288 + 1 048 576 = 2 097 150

So in order to say "where I'm from", i.e. talking only about all the ancestors for the 500 years before my birth, I would have to be aware of the whereabouts of around 2,1 million people...

So next time someone tells you "all my ancestors were from England", allow yourself a little room of doubt ;)


r/PhilosophyofScience • • Feb 18 '14

Is a computer capable of love?

0 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofScience • • Sep 06 '12

What if our world is one dimensional. Does it even matter?

0 Upvotes

It doesn't matter how the universe actually works. This is just a thought experient, or a mental model for those, like me, who are not that proficient with math.

Any number of dimensions can be represented as in one dimension IF we also define which particles are neighbors. It's will essentially be same thing. Not telling you anything new here.

In a 1 dimensional space all particles would have 2 neighbors.
In a 2 dimensional space they would have 4 (or 8 counting diagonally placed neighbors)

It's still the same data. But instead of giving each particle X and Y coordinates, we store a list of which particles are neighbors.

A 2 dimensional space of 3x3

0 1 2
3 4 5
6 7 8

may be represented as a list, like

Particle 0 <=> Particle 1
Particle 0 <=> Particle 3
Particle 1 <=> Particle 2
Particle 1 <=> Particle 4

And so on. We do not have to define that Particle 1 is to the right of Particle 0 to recreate the 2d representation. That information can be deduced from the other connections. Like in a doubly linked list (or a partially ordered set?), nodes just need to know about their own neighbors.

Let's introduce some action-at-a-distance and say that all particles have the possibility to be connected to any other particle in the list. We can still express it using that list above, or as a multi-linked list with a variable number of pointers.

With this mental image in place it's easier to imagine strange effects caused by adding another connection between a pair of particles. Let's say that Particle 3 becomes connected with Particle 8:

Particle 3 => Particle 8.

That connection would make it incompatible with a pure 2d space (impossible to convert back)

I don't think that it is likely that this is how our universe works. But if this could work in a theoretical universe behaving like ours it would be interesting if those 'extra connections' could explain other phenomena except from our three dimensions.

If the list of connections was dynamic/mutable new dimensions could appear, grow and shrink (invisible if a group of particles did not have any connections linking them with us).

With a separate list of connections between nodes/particles it is easier to imagine why there could be hidden dimensions or particles seemingly appearing and disappearing from nowhere (particle always there, just a new connection).

I am not trying to convince you that our universe is working like this. It's just a thought experiment and a simple mental model without the math.. And it's a cool thought that the same mechanism that give rise to our dimensions could cause other effects as well.

I have no clue how time would fit in. Part of the system represented just like those dimesions? I haven't given it much thought yet.