r/PhilosophyofReligion • u/[deleted] • Feb 17 '18
r/PhilosophyofReligion • u/[deleted] • Mar 02 '21
Metaphysics of religion Is materialism to blame for the rise of mental illness and suicide?
I was listening to a program on Kant's view on suicide, and, if what I learned is correct, Kant basically says that suicidal tendencies result from you taking away your humanity and viewing yourself as nothing more than an object. That made me think, could our increasingly materialistic perspective on the universe be to blame for the increases in mental illness and suicide because we think more and more of ourselves and everything around us as simply objects?
r/PhilosophyofReligion • u/psych_researcher89 • Jun 01 '20
Religious epistemology Is anyone interested in the psychology of religious and supernatural type beliefs? I am studying it for my PhD and I need some input
So the discipline/topic I am interested in is how our brains evolved to believe in Gods and the supernatural. I have designed a study using a few existing measures to examine a possible link between pre-existing cognition (agency detection in the environment) and supernatural/religious belief. If you're interested, please consider taking part in the study. Let me know what you think of my topic too.
If you are interested, please use the link which will take you to the information sheet and online study:
r/PhilosophyofReligion • u/Bill_from_Muskeege • May 18 '18
Religion and science Dark Matter is God
Let me preface this by saying I’m neither an expert on natural law or religion. I only have a very rudimentary understanding, so with that being said let’s continue.
I googled and scientists believe that 80% (or something like that) of the universe is made of dark matter. Dark matter is the non existence of matter that scientists cannot identify or measure. I hope that came close, either way, the gist is scientists believe in this dark matter they cannot see or identify because there has to be something according to their research.
Now let’s compare that to religion, more specifically the belief in a higher power. Religion is the belief in a higher power that cannot be seen or measured but the faithful believe it has to exist.
Now, I surmise dark matter is the origin of the higher power. Our bodies are made of matter and eventually return to their base elements. I think our “souls” or the essential spark that make us human is comprised of dark matter and therefore has never been able to be measured before by science. I propose that when we die our “soul” composed of dark matter returns to the larger conglomeration of dark matter. In religions this is moving on to the after life.
Now I have long suspected each major world religion to have a piece of the puzzle but not the whole picture. Each religion was bestowed with a piece of the puzzle and instead of putting them together to view the picture they created a religion around the one true piece they had. With this being said I will explain my comparison.
The judeo-Christian faith starts with, “in the beginning there was darkness.” Maybe there was only dark matter, and God or this being of the darkness is either able to create matter or shape it. Now that explains the judeo-Christian view but what about other religions? I admit I am not familiar with many other religions. However, when I explained earlier that we are all composed of dark matter in our souls and we eventually return to dark matter should sound a lot like Brahman in Hinduism. We are all waves made of dark matter in a larger dark matter “sea.”
I also submit that just as matter needs energy so does dark matter. Maybe the energy that powers dark matter are the things humans need beyond our physical bodies such as love, friendship, and acceptance. And if this is taken to be true maybe this is where the Buddha’s middle way comes into play in the puzzle picture. Maybe the middle way is the best way to obtain the energy needed, people walking the middle way are most content and foster the energy needed.
Again, this was thrown together with no research and is my attempt at answering the bigger questions. I do hope and believe that research into this might lead to some more interesting ideas. I do believe that all the major religions got it partly right and that if one analyzes them through this lens I submit that they may find connections. All in all it’s a fun thought and I’d love for their to be a grain of truth to this beach of bullshit. Thanks
r/PhilosophyofReligion • u/LightEndedTheNight • Mar 29 '23
Religion and ethics Are Christian missions unethical and morally wrong?
I'm not sure if this is the right place for this question, but I've been working on a project over the past few weeks where I have been helping a well known Christian mission organization enhance its digital presence. I can't quite articulate why, but it feels wrong to me that people visit the most vulnerable people in the world with the main intent to convert them to Christianity.
Sure, there is some good work being done to help these vulnerable people, but the main agenda is to turn them into Christian soldiers. That feels wrong to me.
Is this an inherently wrong practice? I'm curious to know what others think.
r/PhilosophyofReligion • u/linr19 • Jun 17 '20
Divine nature and attributes Is God above "existence"? Does God also determine its own existence?
Once we define God as the foundation of being with all of those divine properties (all-powerful, all-knowing, etc. ), does it infer that God is above existence?
Then "Does God exist?" is not a valid question since existence is created by God, and God (foundation of the world) can even decide whether itself exists or not. Then there is no point to argue whether God exists or not.
If my idea is wrong, which part goes wrong?
r/PhilosophyofReligion • u/_Malinatusik • Jan 22 '23
What is everyones opinion on Maltheism?
Maltheism is the belief that there is an Evil God who enjoys our suffering and is toying with us.
People also believe that there is a hell that was made by this god and will send us there after we die.
The god or deity is described as malicious and evil.
Is is an evil God likely to exist, given the amount of suffering that happens on our planet?
Peace out
r/PhilosophyofReligion • u/PW33B3 • Aug 28 '20
Religious epistemology Can you choose what you believe?
I'm the only person in my family that does not believe in God and they all tell me that I just need to choose to believe. I've asked them to explain how I can choose my beliefs but they have trouble explaining their position.
I define belief as "being convinced that a claim is true". I think you can choose to act as if something is true; I think that you can choose how much time and effort you put into researching the evidence behind the claim; you may also be able to brainwash yourself into believing in spite of a lack of evidence; but I don't think you can just choose to genuinely believe that a claim is true.
To help explain my point to my family I've told them to believe that I have an invisible deity that floats above me wherever I go, and that deity will give the winning lottery numbers to those it judges to be worthy of them. They may say that they believe me in order to prove their point, but if someone truly believed that claim they would bring all their friends and relatives to me in hopes that they were worthy of the winning numbers. This good news would be too good not to share.
Do you think you can choose to believe something? If so, how?
r/PhilosophyofReligion • u/Earl_Sean • Feb 13 '21
Theistic philosophers of religion why are we so bad at convincing people?
I have been thinking about this i heard atheist and other philosophers say that our arguments are unconvincing. Why is that?
r/PhilosophyofReligion • u/Proteusiq • Feb 10 '14
Is Atheism Irrational? Plantinga interviewed
r/PhilosophyofReligion • u/[deleted] • Jul 14 '20
If a body can exist without a mind, is it really so senseless to question if a mind can exist without a body?
If a person were to lose their voice, we wouldn't believe that their capacity for linguistic communication stopped existing. What if someone losing their body worked in the same way?
r/PhilosophyofReligion • u/Zachz106 • Sep 17 '19
When an atheist & a Christian become real friends
I'm a younger pastor who's just a few years into ministry, but I wanted to share this. Around 8 years ago, while I was in seminary, I worked a job doing overnight security, and my boss was an agnostic/atheist who knew TONS about Christianity. We ended up discussing my faith and his skepticism at GREAT lengths. The conversations were always friendly, respectful, and inquisitive in nature, instead of being the standard atheist/theist game of "gotcha."
I learned so much from this experience, and even became an avid reader from the process since I began reading C. S. Lewis, Tim Keller, and many other Christian books, to better understand the reasons for my faith. I even read his favorite books, and the other popular atheist authors like Dawkins, Harris, Dennett, Hitchens, and many others. Though we ultimately disagreed with each other's beliefs, this experience led me to a respect for those who doubt, as well as an understanding of the atheist's worldview that I never could have received inside the walls of a church or seminary! I gotta say, if you want to understand atheism, the best way is, without a doubt, is by becoming good friends with several of them - especially the more thoughtful, respectful, intellectually minded ones.
Another thing happened that I never believed would have happened in a million years, I ended up taking everything I learned from this and wrote a book on atheistic humanism/Christianity that came out last week! It only took 7 years... I even recorded the audiobook myself for it (which was a nightmare to do!).
So whether you're a Christian or an atheist, make friends with each other, and try to have real conversations where you are truly trying to understand their beliefs/worldview - it might (WILL) change who you are and the way you think about the other camp.
r/PhilosophyofReligion • u/Last-Socratic • Dec 10 '21
Meta What advice do you have for people new to this subreddit?
What makes for good quality posts that you want to read and interact with? What makes for good dialogue in the comments?
r/PhilosophyofReligion • u/[deleted] • May 30 '21
If you think God exists than why should you be a theist instead of deist?
when people think that there are strong arguments for God why do they become a member of a religion.Why it is necessary for you to be a member of a religion instead of being a person without a religion.Many people when they stop being an atheist they just went back to the religion they were born to.I don`t understand that cosmological arguments and teleological arguments only say that God exist but they don`t tell you that christian God exists or Muslim God exists.
r/PhilosophyofReligion • u/[deleted] • Aug 16 '20
Shouldn’t all atheism lead directly to nihilism?
The title is pretty self-explanatory.
However, one of the most common responses to the direct link between atheism and nihilism is this: just because atheism doesn’t subscribe to an external meaning (God/religion), it does not follow that atheists can’t create meaning on their own and ascribe it to themselves.
Now the issue with this argument is that the ‘private meaning’ that every atheist ascribes to their life is impossible. This is because this ‘private meaning’ is properly known only to the atheist himself. There’s no objective criteria to determine the validity of this meaning. This is basically Wittgenstein’s critique of private language.
Hence, if atheism is to be saved from nihilism, then it must accept objective meaning. But then, only religion can provide this.
r/PhilosophyofReligion • u/darchie85 • Mar 15 '20
Youtuber Mr Atheist is asking callers if children should be raised in religion
The youtuber Mr Atheist has a call in show on Sundays, where he typically speaks to theists. This week he is asking if children should be raised in religion. It's on Sunday, 8pm EST. https://youtu.be/oZ_3D1q8ZBo This is the number in their description: +1-720-619-2288
r/PhilosophyofReligion • u/24xPhilosophy • Jun 07 '21
Free MIT philosophy course - 'God, Knowledge, and Consciousness' - starts June 10
self.philosophyr/PhilosophyofReligion • u/OwenFrancis1 • Jan 28 '20
What could God say to the question “Why is there something rather than nothing” ?
r/PhilosophyofReligion • u/Dr_Platypusman • Mar 15 '12
Can non-theists avoid nihlism?
If a theist ever asks a non-theist why they don't go around murdering people, I think they ought to respond this way:
"Because I am a product of my culture and natural selection. There were selection pressures applied to the development of Homo Sapiens that favoured group cohesion. I have inherited instincts towards empathy and cooperation. These instincts, like everything else, vary between individuals but they are the rule rather than the exception. Even if I did overcome these instincts, I have grown up in a culture that has imprinted these values into me. Because children are genetically programmed to develop this way, I have absorbed and accepted these values. That is the reason I don't murder people, even though I do not believe in hell."
Now, I think this story is true, but there's still something a little uncomfortable about it. Isn't it admitting that it's just some arbitrary evolutionary history that led me to this particular flavour of 'moral'? It's not as if rape and murder are always bad for some cosmic reason, as the theist may argue. Had the selection pressures been different, you and I would have been given a very different set of moral instincts, and we would have been holding those just as high.
So does this lead the non-theist straight into nihlism? I mean, we can all pretend for a moment that those values are objective and not just the product of some arbitrary environmental pressures. If fact I think pretending is exactly what we do. But I know that it's all just an illusion, and there's no objective 'right' and 'wrong'. The good news is that the illusion is hard-wired and very difficult to overcome (although I think the military has some training videos that work pretty well).
I would be very interested in hearing some of the non-theistic moral foundations people might have. I'm familiar with Kant, Mill, Aristotle, and even modern moral theorists, but I don't like any one of them. Besides, I don't think most people who claim to have good moral foundations have ever heard of those things. I would be much happier to hear ordinary people and how they ground their moral foundations.
r/PhilosophyofReligion • u/[deleted] • Oct 11 '21
Burden of Proof Arguments Are Lame (Looking at you, Space Teapot and Flying Spaghetti Monster)
Burden of proof might be a useful concept in a conversational setting or debate setting, but in a broad, philosophical sense, honest inquiry in the pursuit of truth simply asks: "Is this proposition true?" or "Is this proposition justified?" Not "Whose job is it to show this proposition is true?" So I've always frowned a bit on burden of proof moves in philosophy. They seem second rate.
That's one reason Russell's Teapot and the Flying Spaghetti Monster have always struck me as weak when they are deployed as arguments that belief in God is unreasonable.
The other reason the Teapot and FSM strike me as weak is because the analogy only gets off the ground on the assumption there is no evidence for God (just as there is no evidence for the existence of the Teapot and FSM.) But of course, the theist is going to push back on that assumption.
Lastly, even if you can get the theist to concede that the evidence for/against God is a wash, it's not at all clear that the Teapot or FSM supports atheism more than a neutral agnosticism, and getting into the details involves getting into the many complications of prior probability.
Here's a video that explains why atheists should drop the popular use of the Teapot and Flying Spaghetti Monster as arguments against reasonable belief in God and instead focus on arguments with real teeth like God's hiddenness, or evil, or the incoherence of divine attributes.
When you've got a quiver full of good arguments against God, why reach for the crooked arrow? (Sorry—was reaching for a punchy, closing analogy there! 😎)
r/PhilosophyofReligion • u/[deleted] • Jul 23 '21
Do Christians have an answer to why are there so many religions, with only one leading to salvation?
This is a problem I could never contend with. According to Christians, only accepting Christ as the Redeemer can lead one to salvation. Yet, Christ was present at a specific place and time in the world, which made it extremely unlikely, if not impossible, for many souls to reach salvation. Now, this COULD be accepted if God had certain limits: if He could only display itself in so many ways and so many times. But it is simply not compatible with the image of a God that is both omnipotent and omnibenevolent to simply not provide the avenue to a huge number of the souls it created to salvation. This could only stand if God was not omnipotent in the sense that most Christians think it means.
r/PhilosophyofReligion • u/[deleted] • Apr 22 '20
Animal suffering poses a serious problem for religions that claim there is an omnipotent, omniscient, and omnibenevolent god.
r/PhilosophyofReligion • u/[deleted] • Jan 15 '21
If we found a race of mechanical robots on another planet, do you think they would believe they had a creator who built them?
Or would they perhaps believe something different?
r/PhilosophyofReligion • u/Senior-Cap-7248 • Aug 12 '26
Theism, atheism and agnosticism Why are most philosophers atheists nowadays?
Is it because they already were atheists when started philosophy, or because philosophy studies influenced their opinion? Or because they found arguments for theism unconvincing?
r/PhilosophyofReligion • u/[deleted] • Jun 13 '23
Serious question please don’t make fun of me
Could the existence of multiple religious traditions and beliefs, each claiming to be rooted in divine revelation, suggest that God reveals different aspects of Himself to different cultures and individuals?
Edit I thought more about this and what does that mean for religions with more than one god i guess it means either there is more than one god or god can split himself into different personalities
Edit 2
To clarify the reason I am asking this is because I really don’t see why any one religion is “more true” or “more believable” than others i think all religions are to some extent based on the truth