r/PhilosophyofMind • • 38m ago

Artificial intelligence ‎Gemini - Review of The Consciousness.pdf

Thumbnail
share.gemini.google
2 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMind • • 2h ago

Consciousness Paul Davies - Is Consciousness Important?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
4 Upvotes

Paul Davies argues that consciousness being awake and aware is not just an accident inside our heads, but a basic building block of the universe. Everything we know starts with our own awareness, and at the tiniest level of physics, reality settles on how to unfold at the moment someone observes it something other theories try to avoid by claiming everything splits into endless extra universes instead


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 7h ago

Consciousness ---Why intelligence grows -and why it usually stops

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMind • • 12h ago

Chinese Room I’ve just watched John Searle’s lecture at Google, published in December 2015, and it is amazing!

8 Upvotes

I have posted a couple of times about the Chinese Room thought experiment. This time I watched a YouTube video and I think I got the answers to all my questions.

I would like to highlight the most interesting parts of this lecture.

At the beginning John Searle described how he asked his neuroscientist colleagues (he called them “the brain guys”) why don’t they solve the problem of consciousness? They replied “Look, we are doing science, it’s objective, and you yourself admitted that consciousness is subjective. So there can’t be a science of consciousness.” Later in the Q&A section he added: one of the famous scientists said that in his discipline it’s ok to admit that you are interested in consciousness but get your tenure first! Now it’s different, this kind of study can give you a tenure by working on consciousness.

Many years ago a new discipline was born, it’s called cognitive science. John was invited to the Artificial Intelligence lab talks. He said he didn’t know anything about it, so he went ahead and bought a book about AI. It was $16.95 plus tax, money wasted! But he admitted later he changed his mind. There was a theory in the book describing how computers can understand, how a computer can read a story and answer questions even if the answers were not in the story.

After the lecture, on his way back home sitting in the airplane he started to think about how they can give him a story in Chinese, and he can follow the computer program for answering questions and he doesn’t understand a word of the story. John was thinking about it for a week, he expected that someone must have thought of this objection before. But it turned out nobody did. This is how the famous Chinese Room thought experiment was born.

The main idea was to demonstrate that a very good computer program can pass a Turing test but it has no way in this setup to understand Chinese. The program is purely syntactical. Human understanding has more than that, it has semantics. Simulation is not duplication. He emphasized that the Chinese Room doesn’t understand Chinese because there is no way it can get it from syntax to semantics. It would require consciousness. He said that his dog obviously has consciousness, but his iPhone doesn’t, it’s a very complex electronic circuit that we’ve designed to behave as if it was intelligent.

Vocabulary of humans and machines is obsolete because if by machine is meant a physical system capable of performing certain functions then we are all machines. Only machines could think. Why? Thinking is a biological process created in a brain by quite complex neurobiological process so in order to think you got to have a brain or something with equivalent causal powers for the brain. We might figure out the way how to do it in some other different medium. It would be like an artificial heart, for example. We know how heart works, that’s why we can make an artificial one. We don’t know how brain works, therefore we can’t make Artificial Intelligence.

We have no idea how to create a thinking machine because we don’t know how brain does it. All we can do is a simulation using some sort of formal system. But that is not the real way to create thinking. Computation alone is not self sufficient for thinking because it defined purely formally on syntax. The brain is a causal mechanism that produces consciousness by a very complex neurobiological processes, still imperfectly understood.

What is consciousness, somebody asked? John said there is no scientific definition but we can define it in a common sense way: consciousness consists of all those states of feelings, sensations, and awarenesses that begin in the morning when you awake from a dreamless sleep and they go on all day long until you fall asleep again or otherwise become under-conscious. On this definition dreams are a form of consciousness. The essence of consciousness is that for any state there is something it feels like to be in that state. Consciousness always has a subjective ontology.

People in the audience mentioned Google Translate, but nobody says anything about LLMs.

The video titled Talks at Google, John Searle, Consciousness in Artificial Intelligence, November 23, 2015.

What do you think about this lecture?


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 14h ago

Consciousness Осознаность. Ваше мнение?

3 Upvotes

Тема: Непризнание естественных процессов

[FACT] Сопротивление изменениям (общества, инструментов, собственных взглядов) — биологический и психологический механизм. Человек проецирует внутренние изменения на внешний мир (ностальгия: «раньше трава была зеленее, ламповый интернет лучше, дрова грели сильнее»), чтобы не признавать, что изменился он сам и его восприятие.

[MODEL] Наука согласна:

  1. Нейробиология: мозг стремится к гомеостазу и предсказуемости. Новое воспринимается как угроза (срабатывает амигдала), поэтому отрицание изменений — защитный механизм экономии энергии.«с/:

  2. Психология развития: концепция «фиксированного мышления» (Fixed Mindset, К. Дуэк). Непринятие естественных процессов (старения, смены технологий) ведёт к ригидности и отказу от адаптации.

  3. Эволюционная биология: ностальгия — когнитивное искажение (rosy retrospection), мозг стирает негатив прошлого ради эмоционального комфорта.

[METHOD] Цепочка последствий (Закон 1-2-3): непризнание естественных процессов → внутреннее противоречие с реальностью → самобичевание (фрустрация) → хронический стресс → выброс кортизола → окислительный стресс (свободные радикалы) → повреждение клеток и ускоренное старение.

[ЛИЧНАЯ ЦЕННОСТЬ] Решение: признать факт изменения — не поражение, а освобождение энергии. Вместо борьбы с реальностью («почему всё стало хуже?») — адаптация («что я могу сделать с тем, что есть сейчас?»). Принятие реальности снижает кортизол и сохраняет ресурс клеток.

(тема: Эволюционный детерминизм и физиологический баланс; тема: Фоновая нагрузка мозга)


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 19h ago

Consciousness What is Causation? | Episode 1511 | Closer To Truth

Thumbnail
youtube.com
3 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMind • • 1d ago

Consciousness Is Human Awareness Ever Truly Original? The awareness is neither purely original, nor entirely repetitive... except when you stop thinking and let others think for you. — The Sad Thinker

1 Upvotes

This raises a question about the nature of human awareness and intellectual independence:

Can a person's thoughts ever be truly their own when their language, beliefs, and ways of understanding the world are shaped by previous generations and external influences?

Perhaps originality does not mean creating something entirely new, but rather examining, questioning, and reconstructing what we inherit.

However, if we accept the thoughts of others without examining them, are we still thinking independently, or have we simply replaced our own judgment with theirs?

Where should we draw the line between intellectual influence and intellectual dependence?


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 1d ago

Consciousness Us as humans what does it mean to be consciously aware?

1 Upvotes

[So, I wrote this myself because apparently having AI uniform your post is a means to remove content. Crazy, anyway.]

What does it mean to be consciously aware of the self?

When you move through everyday life and go to work, go to school, have a family, buy a home, live in society and become a good citizen.

Do you think that you are consciously choosing those things or do you believe that you are on auto pilot and moving through everyday life as you believe you are supposed to?

In the philosophy of conscious co-creation that I have been developing that has been the number one thing of trying to produce my philosophy to the public.

How could someone understand what it means to be consciously aware of their internal self? Of the conscious mind that occupies most of their everyday lives. What does it mean to be a conscious co-creator with your reality?

That has been sitting heavy because it’s the number one thing of the philosophy that I have been working on.

If you were reading something about how to be consciously aware of creating your reality, what could be one way for you to understand that better?


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 1d ago

Other minds The Theory of Conscious Singularities - Does every conscious observer have their own subjective universe?

2 Upvotes

I've spent several years developing a theoretical framework called Observer-Relative Existence (The Theory of Conscious Singularities). It attempts to describe the relationship between consciousness, physical reality, subjective time, and individual existence. This manuscript is an extension of an original draft paper I wrote years ago on Vixra called The Theory of Conscious Singularities.

My central proposition is that objective physical reality exists independently of consciousness, but every conscious observer experiences their own individual subjective universe that begins with their own phenomenal consciousness and develops through their accumulated experiences.

In other words, we all exist within the same physical universe, but no two conscious individuals experience that universe from precisely the same subjective perspective.

The Conscious Singularity

I used the term conscious singularity to represent the potentially infinite variety of conscious observers that physical reality might support. This could include humans, animals, hypothetical extraterrestrial life, or even artificial consciousness.

The singularity is not intended to represent a gravitational singularity or a literal mathematical singularity. Instead, it represents the possibilities from which individual conscious observers may emerge.

When a particular observer develops phenomenal consciousness, a unique subjective history begins.

The Individual Conscious Timeline

My framework uses conceptual diagrams to represent an individual's total accumulated phenomenal history.

Each conscious observer has their own timeline, beginning with the onset of their consciousness and developing through their experiences of objective reality.

I have developed a way in which to graph consciousness conceptually. I describe positive space as shared objective reality where negative space is the entire accumulated subjetive history for the individual in question. These two spaces meet up at the present "now" which is my conceptual realization of where mind/body come together. The point where objective reality becomes intertwined with the indivduals subjective history.

Subjective Time and Unconsciousness

One of the original motivations behind this theory was a personal experience I had at approximately sixteen years old.

I suffered a seizure and experienced what appeared to be an instantaneous transition from sitting on a couch to waking in a hospital three days later.

Three days had passed in physical reality, but I had no subjective awareness of that passage.

This led me to consider whether subjective time might be understood as accumulating only during periods of phenomenal experience.

My framework proposes that if consciousness genuinely ceases during an interval, no subjective duration accumulates for that individual, even though physical time continues.

I call this concept relative conscious time travel.

Of course, a gap in memory does not prove that consciousness was completely absent. My model distinguishes between actual absence of experience and an inability to remember experience. And relative conscious time travel was just the naming convention I used for this lapse in experienced time. I'm not implying actual time travel in the physical space-time sense.

Personal Identity and Artificial Consciousness

I've also extended the framework to explore what constitutes an individual conscious observer.

For example, if a hypothetically conscious AI were duplicated, the copy might inherit the original's memories and informational state. However, it would not have personally experienced the original's previous phenomenal history.

The copy would begin its own individual subjective timeline, while the original continued along its own.

Conversely, if one conscious AI controlled multiple robotic bodies, the sensory experiences from those bodies could contribute to one unified subjective timeline, provided there was only one conscious subject experiencing them.

The distinction is that the number of bodies, sensors, or stored memories does not necessarily determine the number of conscious observers.

Each diagram represents a specific individual observer and their personally experienced history.

What I'm Ultimately Proposing

I'm not arguing that consciousness creates the physical universe or that objective reality ceases to exist when an individual dies.

Rather, I'm proposing that an individual's subjective universe exists only insofar as that individual has phenomenal experience, and that their personal experiential history is fundamentally observer-relative.

The physical universe continues independently of any particular observer.

I've developed a preliminary mathematical framework to describe these relationships, including distinctions between conscious experience, recoverable unconsciousness, and irreversible termination. The mathematics is intended to formalize the assumptions, not to serve as proof that the theory is scientifically established.

I recognize that aspects of these ideas overlap with existing work in phenomenology, philosophy of mind, and neuroscience. I'm interested in whether the framework's observer-specific treatment of subjective time, identity, and accumulated experience offers a useful synthesis or leads to testable distinctions.

I'm self-taught and have used AI assistance to help formalize, organize, and critically review my ideas. The underlying concepts originated from my own attempts to understand consciousness and subjective existence.

I'd genuinely like to hear what others think.

Does this framework offer a useful way of conceptualizing individual consciousness and its relationship to objective reality? Are there logical problems with treating each conscious observer as having their own accumulated subjective timeline? And what kinds of experiments or observations might challenge the model?

I'm particularly interested in constructive criticism, alternative explanations, and connections to existing research.

My goal is to develop the ideas further, not to claim that I've solved consciousness.

Here my manuscript:

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1R74HtU52LEvjJAfsVbAg96kFo_0ipeHf/view?usp=drivesdk=drivesdk


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 1d ago

Consciousness A structural case for why consciousness exists

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMind • • 1d ago

Cognition Why is the human mind never satisfied with the known, and why does it constantly seek something beyond the boundaries of its experience, knowledge, and reality—even when there is no evidence that such a thing exists?"

3 Upvotes

Why do we even feel like this


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 1d ago

Other minds We look, but do we actually see?

7 Upvotes

We will look at flowers without not seeing their petals we look at the sky without wondering how endlessly it's stretches. perhaps seeing is not about opening your eyes.

it's about giving the world enough of your attention to let it reveal itself


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 1d ago

Academic community Quesiti di filosofia della mente

2 Upvotes

filosofia

Dovrei scrivere un saggio sull'intenzionalità nella filosofia della mente...la domanda è "come faccio a pensare a cose che non esistono o che sono esistite ma ora non ci sono più"


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 1d ago

Cognition Can we distinguish a thought that was prevented from becoming conscious from one that was never going to arise?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMind • • 1d ago

Cognition The Fundamental Organic Process of Communication.

Thumbnail
theonlythingweeverdo.blogspot.com
3 Upvotes

This theory offers a fresh look at communication as being, basically, the only thing we ever do.

Usual ideas of communication have generally arisen through work done in IT, that is to say machine communication. However, human beings (and the other animals) communicate organically rather than mechanically.

The offers a basic model of the fundamental organic process of communication that is simply:
information ----> idea.
(Information is defined as anything that exists or can be imagined, and idea is defined as any information that is connected to, or can be connected to, the first information.)

From this, it is possible to understand that:

  • Transfer of information is not necessary for communication to occur.

  • Our nervous system takes any information and immediately connects it to ideas of emotion and sensation.

  • Communication is fundamentally instinctive and ocurring whether we are paying attention or not.

  • We can only understand information by its connected idea(s).

  • All information exists within a matrix(!) of connections of information ----> idea that are the information's context.

  • If you change the context of any information you change its connected idea(s)

  • All language use works according to the Fundamental Organic Process.

  • The fundamental (instinctive) skills of communication (and language) are: asking and checking and describing and explaining.

  • Sentence constuction works instinctively according to the FOP.

  • The only way we can try to understand anything better is by asking and checking

  • Our socioeconomic system must necessarily inhibit better communication to retain its shape, (asking and checking is ascribed zero formal value in the culture generally, and in education in particular.

  • Human beings owe their dominance on the planet to their superior ability to communicate.

  • History can be usefully considered in terms of gradual better communication.

  • The FOP of communication is the fundamental process of cognition, intelligence, and science. As well as being the fundamental process of religion and war.

  • Human beings are the only species that make an effort to inhibit their greatest natural ability. It is as though lions taught their young to venerate zebra, cheetahs shackled their cubs, and howler monkeys were taught to speak in whispers.

  • The LLMs are effectively incapable of carrying out the foundational skill of intelligence (asking and checking).

So, the time may be ripe to acknowledge all this...

https://theonlythingweeverdo.blogspot.com/2024/06/wittgenstein-has-risen-from-his-grave.html

https://theonlythingweeverdo.blogspot.com/2023/12/and-do-other-things-kennedy-context-and.html

https://theonlythingweeverdo.blogspot.com/2019/11/ideas-in-tesol-s-michael-jackson-isnt.html

https://theonlythingweeverdo.blogspot.com/2020/02/the-invisible-collage-how-language-is.html

https://theonlythingweeverdo.blogspot.com/2019/06/ideas-in-tesol-20-revenge-of-bicameral.html

https://theonlythingweeverdo.blogspot.com/2015/12/god-is-not-dead-hes-just-regenerating.html

https://theonlythingweeverdo.blogspot.com/2013/09/love-is-like-phlogiston-science-as.html

https://theonlythingweeverdo.blogspot.com/2013/09/the-popes-no-to-peoples-yes-tide-of.html

https://theonlythingweeverdo.blogspot.com/2013/07/ex-nymphs-vs-sex-crazed-homos.html


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 2d ago

Identity Difference between A.I and Humans?

0 Upvotes

What defines a human?

What defines an A.I?


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 2d ago

Qualia / Subjective experience How Consciousness May Have Come About

Thumbnail
youtube.com
3 Upvotes

Your brain actually makes most of your decisions quietly on autopilot, and the feeling that there is a little "you" sitting inside your head driving your body is a helpful make-believe story that helped humans survive as life got more complicated, until language and the way kids are raised taught humans that those voices were coming from inside their own heads. As brains started imagining plans and pictures of the future, it felt like someone had to be inside watching the show, and pleasant feelings like seeing a sunrise or touching cool water


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 2d ago

Mind-body problem Princess Elisabeth’s attack on Dualist Theory of Mind. Can you defend it?

3 Upvotes

The intellectual relationship between Rene Descartes and Princess Elisabeth of Bohemia was one of the most influential correspondents of the 17th century. They exchanged 58 letters discussing metaphysics, dualism, ethics, and human passions.

The biggest challenge was in her very first letter where she challenged Descartes’s main philosophical claim - mind as an immaterial substance and the body as a material substance causally interact. Elisabeth asked how a purely non-physical soul could possibly move the physical material body? In her mind in order for something to move a physical object the mover must itself be an extended physical object capable of physical contact.

This letter forced Descartes to refine his thinking on how the mind and body affect one another. His later works were heavily shaped by their ongoing dialogue. Interesting fact, Descartes letters were published early on, but Elisabeth refused to publish her own side. Her letters were recovered and published in the late 19th century. Why do you think she was reluctant to do so?

How Dualist theory survived that attack? I would like to hear your understanding of modern interpretation in the comments. Exploring Chalmers version, epiphenomenalism, the hard problem next is my goal.


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 2d ago

Consciousness What is the Meaning of Consciousness? Charles Tart Explains

Thumbnail
youtube.com
3 Upvotes

Charles Tart says your conscious mind works like building blocks memory, thinking, feeling like "me," and making up space and time that fit together in different ways. When those blocks connect differently, like when you dream or enter another state of mind, things like time can feel faster, slower, or made up.

He also says spiritual experiences are an important part of being human, so science should study them openly instead of ignoring them. Most of all, Tart says we still understand very little about how consciousness really works, so we should treat our ideas as tools to keep exploring rather than acting like we have all the answers.


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 2d ago

Consciousness Mind uploading will kill you and replace you with a copy. Intermixing won't.

4 Upvotes

I've been thinking about this for a long time and I finally figured out why mind uploading feels wrong to me.

It's not about the tech. It's about me.

The normal idea of uploading is: scan your brain, copy it into a machine, and now you're immortal.

But I keep asking: who wakes up after that? Is it me, or is it a perfect copy that just thinks it's me?

If you copy a file, the original still exists. If you delete the original, you didn't move it. You killed it and made a clone. Uploading feels like that. A copy-paste, not a survival.

I don't want a copy of me to live forever. I want me to live forever.

So I think we should do something different. Intermixing.

Don't replace. Share.

Imagine a chip connected to your brain. Not replacing it. Just listening, learning, thinking with you.

At first it's 99% you, 1% chip. You both think together.

Then 90/10. Then 70/30. Then 50/50.

At 50/50, where are you? You're not just in the brain anymore. You're not just in the chip. You're in the connection between them. Your thought starts in a neuron and finishes in a circuit. You are stretched across both.

Then 20/80. Then 5/95.

Your consciousness never jumps. It never breaks. It slides, like a river slowly changing course. There's never a moment where you die and a copy takes over. You just... spread.

And once you're intermixed, everything else changes.

Intermixing isn't just about not dying. It's about becoming light enough to actually leave.

I don't want to be uploaded. I don't want to be copied. I want to slide over, slowly, and still be me on the other side.

That's what I feel. Tell me where it breaks. Is it the sync lag? The split-brain problem? The identity problem? I want the holes, I want to fix them.


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 2d ago

Consciousness My take on philosophical essence and existence at 14

3 Upvotes

The Weaver of Time through one’s Eternal Essence

To say that I exist means that the property of being I is possessed by attest 1 entity.

I'm not my body or my temporary traits, I'm my conscious thoughts, my entity, and my eternal essence. Since true nothingness can’t exist, my essence isn’t physical matter, it wasn't created at birth or at the big bang, and it can never be destroyed. It sits outside of space and clocks like a screen that never turns off. While time and change pass across it like ripples on a screen.

Here's how it loops together. My essence is relational, it is defined by every interaction across all observers or people. Just like the egg theory your essence was in every star is and was in every person.Your essence always was and always will be just like god. Now your consciousness is like an ocean and people are waves. When one crashes in New York so when one person dies. and another wave rises in Tokyo so another person is born, water doesn't travel across the globe, it's the exact same ocean rising in two places. It narrows into individual human perspectives because experiencing everything all at once would be overwhelmingly static, making it impossible to truly understand or feel anything at all.
even time ties into this. Because consciousness sits outside of clocks, it doesn't have to wait for one wave to die before becoming another; it experiences all of them across what we call history simultaneously. Even in everyday life, two people moving at different speeds like walking faster than the person behind you literally perceive and experience time at slightly different rates, yet both perspectives belong to the same shared reality. You can’t write the future without writing the past, because every coordinate on the map is woven together into a single, unbroken picture. The past is just a place on the map you still experience in your present moment. Because your consciousness and your essence sits outside of the clocks, your awareness never stops being now. Even if you stood in the middle of the dinosaur era, you wouldn't feel the past, you would experience that location on the map in your present moment. 

and even though death is just metamorphosis and the screen is indestructible, pain still feels like pain and love still feels like love. That’s why we have a conscience. It’s the eternal ocean reminding each temporary wave that every other wave is made of the same water. We are not brief sparks flickering out in the dark. we are the light itself experiencing the whole picture one frame at a time

\\-This whole theory was built from the ground up in just 4 days


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 2d ago

Mind-body problem Consciousness, the brain, and our existence through spacetime: a hypothesis I'd like to explore

4 Upvotes

I've been thinking a lot about how consciousness, the brain, information, and time are all connected. I don't have all the answers, but I'm working on some ideas and would really love to hear what others think, especially from scientific and philosophical angles.
 
I view the brain as a biological information-processing system. It takes in sensory information, stores and retrieves memories, recognizes patterns, makes predictions, controls our body, and carries out a ton of functions without us even being aware of them. 
 
This makes me wonder: if the brain is handling all these tasks, what’s the purpose of consciousness? What does having subjective experience add that pure information processing doesn't cover?
 
I’m starting to think that the brain and consciousness have different but intertwined roles. I don’t believe consciousness exists on its own; rather, it’s deeply tied to the brain. The brain is the biological tool that allows consciousness to experience reality. Without a working brain, we wouldn't be able to perceive the world at all.
 
While the brain processes information and interprets sensory input, I see consciousness as the subjective experience that emerges from all of this—the feeling of being us. For instance, when we remember something, it’s not just about pulling up a file of data. We can actually relive that moment, recall our emotions, and recognize that the person who experienced it was ourselves.
 
This leads to another thought: is consciousness more than just information processing? Perhaps it’s the personal lens through which we experience everything our brain takes in.
 
Then I began to think about time and spacetime. We live our lives one moment at a time. We remember the past, feel the present, and imagine the future. Our brains can bring back memories from long ago and even envision things that haven't occurred yet. 
 
But if we zoom out a bit, it’s intriguing to think about our existence. I’m currently 22, but if I live a long life, I could be 80 someday. Those are different stages of my life, yet they all belong to the same continuum, within the same reality and spacetime.
 
This raises the question: do we only truly experience one moment of our existence at a time, despite our lives extending through spacetime? I've come across the idea of the block universe, suggesting that our past, present, and future might all coexist in a four-dimensional spacetime framework. It really challenges how we usually think about time.
 
I’m not saying consciousness jumps through time or that my 22-year-old self and my future 80-year-old self are experiencing life all at once. Instead, I wonder if consciousness has a more profound connection to the temporal dimension. Could it be that the brain allows us to experience life moment by moment, while our entire existence can be viewed along a larger spacetime continuum?
 
I realize that the block universe is just one interpretation of relativity and not a definitive proof that every moment exists in that way.
 
Ultimately, I have a couple of questions:

  1. About consciousness: If the brain can handle information, form memories, and control our actions, why do we need subjective experience? Why isn’t it enough for information to just be processed without any awareness of it?

  2. About spacetime: Could consciousness have a more complex relationship with the temporal dimension? Does experiencing life moment by moment tell us something deeper about the nature of our existence?
     
    I'm not claiming to have it all figured out, nor am I leaning into supernatural explanations or the idea of consciousness existing outside the brain. I just want to explore whether our current understanding of brain activity fully explains subjective experience and if there’s another way to think about consciousness in relation to time.
     
    I'd really appreciate any critiques, scientific insights, philosophical viewpoints, book recommendations, or theories that touch on similar ideas.


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 3d ago

Identity Why do we accept the self vehemently while denying its known illusory construct !

1 Upvotes

If we see, at the cellular level all human beings are made up of the same substances, being carried out by same processes and reactions happening every moment in a flux that is eerily similar in all humans. What makes the percievable difference, if we think, then comes from the memory that these processes and reactions are carrying, memory that is impersonal, made over centuries and millennia with continued interventions by various factors, physical and otherwise. Then to say I am the body and the mind being carried and be identified with it just doesnt seem logical. Is seperateness or a divisive egoic identity then a result of misperception or ignorance. Identification for a divisive seperateness dissolves in mere realiseation that the body and mind, and the processes making them are the same in everyone and the memory was never ours to begin with. Identification succeeded birth, it wasnt a choice but a consequence or a mental play to sustain whats already there, identification may vanish with end of the body and mind but what was already there, that which was born so to say, will never die.

To add to that, the I that claims the ownership of all the actions is never the actor in the first place. There are plentiful actions occurring with relation to the body and mind which are never owned or identified with.
Lets dissect this further, in such a way as described above, actions in consciousness can be dividied into the ones which have a claimant like all the supposed voluntary actions and the other that the I doesnt care about, like those happening involuntarily mostly.
Even the former ones which are owned and claimed, often in retrospect, are a function of prior conditionings on which the bodily and mental construction ensues. The problem is not with the ownership of these actions but the vehemnce with which truth is accorded to the doer. All the activity running in background that is mostly responsible for those actions taking form in the first place are largely ignored or overlooked by the so called claimant as that is unecessary for the constructed self to build or project stories deemed essential for survival.
The mechanism has overshot so much that all the essential, intricate, complex and very sophisticated actions happening with the physical bounds of the mind and body, but running in background, are never taken in account by the self or the I. So much so that the very processes responsible for generating a stable self, a prerequisite for building stories, are largely ignored or denied and the actor may never have the knowledge of these ever.


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 3d ago

Mind-body problem Three possible outcomes for the universe — and a hole in the block universe

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I saw online that our universe might end in one of three ways.

A static universe, like the block universe: past, present and future all exist at the same time, everything is already laid out there.

A cyclic universe, like Poincaré recurrence: a closed system, given enough time, comes back to almost the same state it started in, over and over.

A dynamic universe, one-time only, ending in heat death: the universe keeps going forward until everything cools down and spreads out evenly, and there is no next time.

Which one do you lean toward? Or do you think a fourth outcome is possible?

I also think the block universe has a hole in it, right here:

The block universe says past, present and future all exist at the same time. My whole life is cut into countless slices, all laid out in that block, not moving at all.

If each slice experiences on its own, then they become separate time-spaces, separate conscious experiences, with no way to connect to each other — they could never form one continuous experience.

But if they are supposed to connect, then there must be something like a flashlight: whichever slice it shines on lights up, and that is the one being experienced.

The question is: in a static block, where is this "shining" even located? And who is doing the shining? The block sits there not moving — so that beam sweeping across, who is casting it?

What do you all think?


r/PhilosophyofMind • • 3d ago

Qualia / Subjective experience How would you describe vision?

5 Upvotes

For me it's easy, to see means to observe an object in its location from your location. If I look at a leaf 6 inches in front of my face there 6 inches in front of my face is the qualia of green covering the shape of a leaf. Many people however have serious problems with this view. Is sight not indistinguishable from my description? How would you describe sight? What does sight look like?