r/PhilosophyExchange • • Sep 30 '21

Essay The Obligations Authorities have to Traditions

21 Upvotes

I think the contemporary Western world has revealed a need to reflect upon and articulate in what way people in positions of authority are obligated to carry on the traditions that have been handed down to them, and don’t have a simple right to change them, despite their authority.

In exploring this question myself, I’ve found two thinkers to be rather useful: the ancient Chinese philosopher Confucius, and the modern English author G. K. Chesterton.

I think the fundamental reason modern authorities are so iconoclastic when it comes to traditions is because they do not recognize that their own authority is itself handed down to them in a lineage. The illusion that authority originates otherwise comes mostly from the incoherent liberal “consent of the governed” and the liberal obsession with written constitutions, as if they were the tradition itself, or the root of them.

The right way of thinking about authority is not as something that is given from the people being governed to the people governing, or from a piece of paper, but as a responsibility being passed down from previous authorities. Historically, positions of authority tend to be established when a person or group of people take up responsibility for others and a good common to them, establish some order that handles protecting that good and distributing it to others, and pass on that legacy onto others who continue to carry the established order out. To put it another way, positions of authority are the empty chairs of the ones who found them, and subsequent authority’s root their authority in how they carry on the spirit of the founder. The founder is the one who led the people, and now his successors are those who manage what he started.

And so, this means that the people in positions of authority don’t have the freedom to just contradict the very traditions that give them the legitimacy to rule that they have. In fact, they are obligated to keep them, and the burden is on them to justify any change in that tradition, and, the only way to actually fulfill that burden is to appeal to a deeper part of that tradition, or another, more authoritative tradition. The only reason we can contradict a tradition is in following an even more traditional tradition. And the deepest and most authoritative part of any tradition is the very purpose for which it was established.

It would be presumptuous and arrogant then on any authority’s part to contradict any tradition he is custodian over, unless he first understands for what purpose or end it was established, and has himself personally reached that very end for which the old tradition was established.

In other words, an authority needs to grasp the reason, the good, the tradition was established for before he tears it down, as Chesterton puts it, and he must have already obtained that good the tradition arose for if he wishes to have the minimum wisdom and knowledge necessary to establish a better tradition, or as Confucius puts it,

”Let a man who is ignorant be fond of using his own judgment; let a man without rank be fond of assuming a directing power to himself; let a man who is living in the present age go back to the ways of antiquity; on the persons of all who act thus calamities will be sure to come.”

”To no one but the Son of Heaven does it belong to order ceremonies, to fix the measures, and to determine the written characters. Now over the kingdom, carriages have all wheels, of the-same size; all writing is with the same characters; and for conduct there are the same rules. One may occupy the throne, but if he have not the proper virtue, he may not dare to make ceremonies or music. One may have the virtue, but if he do not occupy the throne, he may not presume to make ceremonies or music.”


r/PhilosophyExchange • • Sep 29 '21

Meta What is r/PhilosophyExchange?

19 Upvotes

Welcome

r/PhilosophyExchange is a place to discuss the nature of our existence and how we should operate in the world. We encourage intellectual, meaningful conversations on topics such as:

  • Morality

  • Aesthetics

  • Religion

  • The ideal state

  • Economic systems

  • And knowledge itself

Users from all backgrounds are welcome to participate. Posts may include questions, discussion prompts, casual thoughts, essays, and debates on a wide range of topics. We incline everyone to follow site-wide rules and engage respectfully with an open mind.

Thank you


r/PhilosophyExchange • • Oct 08 '21

Essay Thoughts on Conservative Leftism?

11 Upvotes

Conservative Leftism is an umbrella term for ideologies that are variably left-wing on economic issues, but variably conservative on social issues. Conservative leftists generally say capitalism (or corporatocracy) profits from moral issues within society, therefore to truly protect traditional values, neoliberal economics must be rejected. They oppose intersectionality, seeing it as "identity politics", and more often than not are nationalist.

Conservative leftist ideologies range from varieties of Christian Democracy to National Bolshevism (the word "Nazbol" is frequently used as an insult for leftists who reject intersectionality or conservatives less in bed with laissez-faire economics).

Famous conservative leftists include:

Gregor Strasser

Muammar Gaddafi

Joseph Stalin

William Jennings Bryan

Benjamin Disraeli

MLK Jr.

Alexander Dugin

George Galloway

Getúlio Vargas

Angela Nagle

The Polish Law and Justice Party

Stupidpol (to a certain extent)

Huey Long


r/PhilosophyExchange • • Oct 02 '21

Discussion Agrarianism Versus Urbanism

11 Upvotes

Cultural division that falls on geographic lines is nothing new, but the extent to which the culture of a region varies from rural to urban has never seemed more potent today.

In this context, we weigh in on agrarianism versus urbanism.

In my eyes, a prosperous and complete nation needs both elements. Cities of beauty and grandeur to serve as hubs of commerce, industry, and the arts. Vast pastoral lands to cultivate agriculture and raise new life. A country like the United States could have been a perfect example if not for rampant consumerism and suburban sprawl.

What do you think?

What is the ideal rural-to-urban ratio? What steps could be taken to improve existing rural and urban areas?


r/PhilosophyExchange • • Oct 08 '21

Essay George Bataille - Heterogeneous Expenditure

10 Upvotes

This post is a short introduction to the political thought of Georges Bataille, one of the most interesting and provocative thinkers of the 20th century.

Bataille’s most well known works include Theory of Religion and The Accursed Share, but I want to provide my interpretation of two of Bataille’s early political essays which were written in the 1930’s: The Notion of Expenditure, and The Psychological Structure of Fascism. Both can be found in pdf form with a Google search, or you can also find both, alongside other essays from Bataille’s early period, in Visions of Excess, edited by Allan Stoekl.

These essays are a good entry point to Bataille’s political thought, not just because of their shorter length, but also because of their more traditional sociological approach. Bataille would go on to expand upon these ideas and reiterate them in different forms, but he would never fundamentally abandon them. If you choose to continue to read Bataille, you can always trace his more abstract ideas in his more poetic writings back to the social and political implications of this earlier work.

In these essays, Bataille (under the influence of Durkheim) describes an inside and an outside for society: an inner homogeneity of stable meanings established by science, rationality, and the economic values of utility, productivity, accumulation and conservation; and an outer heterogeneity of everything that cannot be assimilated inside the homogeneous system. While the homogeneous side of society is clearly structured by the capitalist mode of production and the values of the bourgeois class, heterogeneity is a much more slippery concept, as its very nature evades the stability of definition. Bataille tells us: “Heterogeneous reality is that of a force or shock.” In other words, heterogeneity is anything that is capable of jarring us out of our business-as-usual existence in capitalist society, not by imposing an alternative stable meaning which is antithetical to capitalism, but through an immanent experience which exceeds the stable confines of meaning itself.

This heterogeneous reality is further split into two forms which Bataille calls “impure” and “imperative”. Examples of the “impure” include trash, waste, excrement, the impoverished masses, criminals, violence, madness, perverse eroticism; basically anything that carries an affective charge of revulsion and is expelled from the system.

Conversely, the “imperative” form is the idealism placed outside and above homogeneous society, and includes abstract values such as the sacred, the sublime, beauty, grace, honor, duty and glory. The meaning in these principles always exceeds our definitions for them, and what is primary is the affective attraction to these principles in society and the way that they justify an authority over society. The end purpose of society is often posed in the idealistic terms of upholding or manifesting such principles.

In a profound inversion of previous traditions of political economics, Bataille posits the heterogeneous dimension of society as the true driver of economic relations. Stoekl, commenting on The Notion of Expenditure, puts it this way:

Production in Bataille’s view is clearly subordinate and posterior to destruction: people create in order to expend, and if they retain things they have produced, it is only to allow themselves to continue living, thus destroying.

For Bataille, economics is not an entirely rational system that belongs entirely to the homogeneous realm of society; rather, economics is driven by the heterogeneous desire for “limitless loss.” Bourgeois society is beholden to this desire for loss, but this desire is also obscured through the atomization of liberalism: for bourgeois society, heterogeneous desire belongs to the individual, not to society. Despite this failure to fully recognize the existence of humanity’s heterogeneous urges, there are still outlets to be found in forms of “non-productive expenditure”, such as drinking, gambling, prostitution, sports, art and theater, etc. It is also to be found in more traditional forms such as religious sacrifice or asceticism.

The problem is that such acceptable forms of heterogeneity are exclusionary rather than social; the bourgeoisie has the means for non-productive expenditure on a different scale than the proletariat, and they use this power to expel the proletariat from the imperative heterogenous realm. One clear example of this is the concept of the ostentatious luxury of the jewel; the immediate characteristics of the jewel are secondary to the fact that so few are able to afford the waste of resources that they represent. For the bourgeoisie, flaunting the jewel is a means of expressing imperative heterogeneity while expelling the proletariat as impure heterogeneity - the act of spending on the jewel is also a social expenditure, i.e. the objectification and expenditure of the humanity of the proletariat itself.

For Bataille, the Marxist class revolution is really a reversal of this social expenditure, such that the proletariat violently spends the bourgeoisie in an outburst of violence; and unlike most other Marxists of his time, Bataille believed this expenditure would not result in a new ideal mode of production replacing that of capitalism. Once the proletariat indulges in the violent expenditure of the bourgeoisie, that heterogeneous energy has been spent and there will be no social effervescence left to establish a new homogeneous order of any fundamental difference from the bourgeois order.

In contrast to bourgeois society and its class struggles, Bataille describes that of primitive societies via the concept of potlatch, which is a form of gift economy found in North American indigenous groups where the loss of wealth forms social obligation and power. In a potlatch, leaders compete to see how much accumulated wealth they can give away or even outright destroy, and those that dispose of the most wealth come away with the most prestige. Under this social model, wealth is never accumulated or stockpiled, nor is the power associated with the loss of wealth ever stable. There is always another potlatch on the horizon, always another opportunity for losses to mount and power to shift. For Bataille, this alternative model allows us to imagine a society which openly embraces its heterogeneity, rather than atomizing it to the level of the individual, hiding it within a private life of avarice, or expelling it with notions of guilt and shame. Rather than waiting for suppressed heterogeneous energy to burst into revolution and warfare, such eruptions are ritualized and become the principle of society.

The idea that humanity needs loss - more specifically, needs social participation in loss - offers a powerful analysis of human history, particularly of the pre-WWII period in which Bataille was writing. Witnessing the bourgeois democratic state beset on both ends by Marxism and fascism, Bataille sagely predicted that violence would be the inevitable climax, and that it would not result in the vindication of any revolutionary idealism. The point of revolution was never to realize the liberation of the working class, nor was it to realize the ultimate domination of the nation-state for the fascists; rather, revolution and war was a violent expenditure of pent up heterogeneous energy that bourgeois society had failed to release. Once this energy was released, no new idealization emerged, and instead the homogeneity of the liberal democratic state and bourgeois society reasserted itself. This narrative seems to vindicate Bataille’s contention that the need for loss, around which the primitive societies of potlatch were once formed, still exists in modern society. The economic triggers for WWII were not so much about scarcity, but a positive need for expenditure that was denied, causing the disintegration of homogeneous society.

A return to the social model of potlatch is difficult to imagine. It seems to be an unstable, ecstatic delirium in which humanity loses themselves in cycles of accumulation and catastrophic loss. The question that arises is whether the model of potlatch really offers an alternative to the catastrophes of modern history, or whether it even should. Bataille poses this question himself:

“...it is difficult to know to what extent the community is but the favorable occasion for a festival and a sacrifice, or to what extent the festival and the sacrifice bear witness to the community.”

Allan Stoekl also comments on this fundamental problem:

“It would seem that either direction would lead to an impasse. The valuing of community or society over the radicality of experience itself would, in the end, result in a vision of an ultimate homogeneous social structure that uses sacrifice or festivals; such a community could not be seen as different in kind from a bourgeois and finally even a Marxist society erected on the principles of classical utility (that is, on the denial of expenditure without return). This at least would be the necessary point of view of the “acephalic” position. On the other hand, the sheer negativity of the individual or the elite Acephalic group, seen for a moment from the point of view of the larger community, can only be a nihilistic emptiness that, headless or not, elevates itself as an absolute and therefore leads at best to simple individual death or wandering, and at worst to extremely sinister political configurations (regimes of the right are only too happy, as is well known, to make use of previously unharnessed violence).”

(A quick note for context: the “acephalic position” and “Acephalic group” refers to a short-lived political society started by Bataille prior to the outbreak of WWII. Acephalic basically means “headless” and refers to the idea that society should not be led by rational idealism, but instead by socialized desires for loss, specifically taking the form of sacrificial rituals and erotic orgies.)

To put Bataille “to use” by reimagining society is both difficult and dangerous. To imagine a society built around “safety valve” outlets for heterogeneous energy is really no different than describing what we have now: a consumer society in which money buys interesting forms of waste, while exclusion from consumption results in eruptions of warfare, terrorism, and other forms of violent expenditure. To embrace this heterogeneous energy in its totality, without subsuming it to the stable use-values of capitalist society, sounds frighteningly close to the pure imperative heterogeneity that Bataille saw being harnessed by the fascist movements of the 1930’s.

Can heterogeneity be something that homogeneous society can control and direct? Can our need for loss be grasped as our social purpose without becoming indistinguishable from the catastrophe that we fear?

Thanks for reading, I’m here if you would like to discuss.


r/PhilosophyExchange • • Oct 01 '21

Discussion Friday Discussion Prompt #1

10 Upvotes

Which fictional society most accurately represents your ideal society?


r/PhilosophyExchange • • Apr 26 '22

Discussion Do you find the works of Saint Aquinas to help guide your philosophy?

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyExchange • • Oct 08 '21

Question Do I really need to be ethical to be right?

9 Upvotes

I don't mean every unethical action is right, but just because something is ethical, it doesn't mean it is right, or wrong.

The real right or wrong is for the greater good, that spends the smallest ammount of people and money.

Convince me wrong or try to make me feel I'm right, just discuss 👍🏻


r/PhilosophyExchange • • Oct 01 '21

In your opinion what should be the governing philosophy of the West?

9 Upvotes

By the west, I mean Western Europe, the Balkan’s, and the Americas. In your opinion, what should the philosophy of the western governments be, and how would your philosophy positively effect the people of the west and possibly negatively effect them?


r/PhilosophyExchange • • Jun 29 '22

Essay The lack of an ideological mythology to support economic liberalism, coupled with the decline of religion, is why has caused capitalism to be disdained by so many millennials and zoomers.

8 Upvotes

Many older people, especially older conservatives, have a hard time understanding what has caused even conservative members of younger generations to become disillusioned with liberal capitalism. They propose that younger generations are lazier, don’t have a work ethic, expect handouts, are coddled, etc.

The real answer is far more saddening. The reality is, both reactionary and revolutionary politics have a mythology that serves as justification for why you should want to participate in the system. Be it a communist talking about “Proletarian Culture and Morality” or a fascist talking about “National Rejuvenation”, or an Integralist talking about “vocation”, the message is this:

you have a role to play in something great. You are important in the great epoch of history.

Liberal capitalism has no mythology. Why should you be excited to work for and participate in liberal capitalism? Because it contributes to the economy. Why should I want to contribute to the economy? Because if no one does the economy won’t work. That’s it.

People are dissatisfied with capitalism because capitalism offers them no purpose, no morality, no reason to live, just a cruel, unadulterated, pragmatism.

But if this has always been true, then why is this dissatisfaction recent? Because of the Protestant Work Ethic.

PWE is a futile attempt to explain why someone would want to live under a system that offers them nothing to live for. God has given you opportunity to work, and so you should. Screw vocation, screw the beatitudes. You’re value comes from the work you put in.

It’s bad theology. But until the dawn of the internet people outside of academic settings had no way of knowing this. So they went along with it. But when religion began to decline, the Work Ethic provided by the dominant one did as well.

Without the Protestant Work Ethic, it becomes much harder to be enthusiastic about working bad jobs for bad pay. And people are refusing to do so. We had this coming. And when it comes to the death of this Work Ethic, and capitalism along with it, I have no intention of mourning.


r/PhilosophyExchange • • Apr 26 '22

Essay Why I Reject Modernism

8 Upvotes

Before we start, let me define modernism in these terms:

Modernism is the way of thinking that has roots in renaissance thought, reaching it's highest state of development during the scientific revolution and culminating in the later half of the 20th century.

In the broadest sense, modernism espouses a purely material worldview in which humanity is on a constant journey towards enlightenment and progress. Random matter evolved into simple organisms which later evolved into primates which later evolved into primitive man. It is then certain that, as primitive man evolved into modern man, modern man will surely evolve into a new cosmopolitan form of man freed from the shackles of his own humanity. This line thinking stands opposed to virtually all of the human knowledge that preceded it: the world of Tradition.

From the Peruvian highlands of aboriginal America to the deserts of Arabia, from the writings of Confucius to a quiet monastery in the earliest age of Christendom, man has always known the true nature of existence. Consciousness did not ascend from matter, it has descended from God. Man is to honor their mothers and fathers, revere their ancestors who watch over them, and worship God, the Absolute, the creator. Sacrifice is a sacred virtue; whether that manifest itself in the human sacrifice of primitive cultures, personal sacrifices to observe the word of God, or God's sacrifice to us in the form of Christ on earth.

Modernism holds the perennial wisdom of our ancestors in contempt, and indeed, holds existence itself in contempt. A modernist looks back upon a thousand generations and sees nothing but horror and barbarism. To a modernist, the entirety of our human existence could be summed up as nothing more than a perpetual dark age before a utopia yet to come. As such, we are to eliminate the ways of old. Wars of religion were fought so we must all be secular humanists. Biology separates man from woman so we must redefine what it means to be either and both. Cultures and nations have divided people for centuries, so we must all shed our identities rooted in the organic in favor of mass-produced identities as global consumers. All of this is to say, modernism is fundamentally anti-human. Instead of recognizing the limits of human nature and establishing an order that uplifts the spirit to greatness and goodness, modernism attempts to mold humanity into something it never was and never will be.

Today I make the argument that our entire understanding of existence is depraved, nonsensical, and opposed to everything innately true.

Furthermore, the modernist conception of existence is strange and esoteric in the scheme of history.

To say that humanity has evolved from primordial goo and will naturally progress into a race of globalized, completely impartial formless figures of man? That is simply ridiculous. Yet, nearly every man today consciously or subconsciously accepts that assumption on its face. If a man is hanging off a cliff and you hand him a rope, and he mistakes that rope for a snake, his actions from that point on could be completely rational for his perceived situation. He will still fall to his death. Such is the nature of false presuppositions.

We are living through the lowest point in human development.

We have forgotten what was plainly evident to every normal man in every normal time.

The truth which has always been known to man has been abstracted and perverted beyond the point of parody.

The truth now only exists through fragments of something mostly lost to time. These are our myths, traditions, religions, and cultures.


r/PhilosophyExchange • • Oct 02 '21

Essay The Purpose of Government and the Liberal (classical, modern, libertarian) Error

Thumbnail self.catholic_solidarity
8 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyExchange • • Oct 01 '21

Question What are the concrete goals of having a religious State?

8 Upvotes

I am a Christian Democrat, specifically in the vein of Christian Democracy practiced by Maritain (what I would call “classical” or “orthodox” Christian Democracy).

I understand that many further to the right of myself would agree with myself that the aim of law is to direct people to virtue, but disagree over the means and particular concrete instance of what this looks like. I don’t think I would disagree that government must consider the values, virtue and character of people in the process of governing, nor that the state should make efforts to install within the citizenry virtuous attributes like fraternal love, ascetic moderation and God fearing faith.

What I would push back against is my perceived assumption that the way in which these just aims are pursued are through the imposition of a philosophical minimum, the throwing aside of fundamental human rights like freedom of thought, conscience and religion and the making of the state into an organization that enforces morality in rather direct and concrete ways, such as imposing criminal penalties for certain sins.

Of course, I may be totally off the the mark here.

So what are the concrete ways in which you envision the State pursuing the aforementioned just aims? Is it through the imposition of philosophical minimums (ie a state church)? The criminal penalties for certain sins (ie prostitution or drug use)? Something else entirely?

Curious on everyone’s thoughts.


r/PhilosophyExchange • • Oct 01 '21

The most important thing for humans to do IMO

8 Upvotes

In the future general AIs will exist, and human consciousnesses (as well as other consciousnesses which would be described as people since they will be just as intelligent as us and will also have emotions and desires and the ability to argue for their own rights as people) will be software running on computers. These software people would be immortal since they could just copy their data onto backup computers and when the computer they’re currently running on dies they’d just start running on a different one. They could also experience time at a much faster rate than us, i.e., one second in real time could feel to them like a day in real time does to us. If you doubt any of this then I guess that’s a different discussion but none of that is really uncertain IMO.

Now here’s the problem: let's say that someone runs a program that tortures these software people to a degree unimaginable to modern humans, and shoots the computer running these peoples’ consciousnesses being tortured off into space at near the speed of light. If no one knows about this then those people could just end up being horribly tortured for what seems like literally 100s of trillions of years to them. That would be so bad that it would make the holocaust look like turning a library book in overdue in terms of moral badness. So basically for anyone that has any power over whether or not/ how often this sort of situation is expected to occur in the future, it would be more important to stop this kind of thing from happening than anything else that person could do. It wouldn’t even be just a little bit more important, it would be vastly more important - even if your individual contribution to the expected value of the amount of times this occurs is really small - than literally anything else in terms of moral responsibility, just cause of how incredibly bad that situation would be.

Like let's say that you had an opportunity to make this slightly less likely to happen, but you didn’t act on that since you were busy dealing with some other (probably more immediate) problem. If it does happen then, how on earth could you justify your decision to the people that ended up being horrifically tortured way beyond our comprehension for what was to them 100s of gazillions of years? IMO you can’t really.

You might be thinking, why would anyone do this though? Well imagine a super intelligent general AI (#1) that is at odds with another super intelligent general AI (#2) off in some other solar system. #1 knows that it can’t just directly defeat #2 cause it’s not powerful enough, but it knows that it wasn’t programmed to care about the suffering of human-like consciousnesses as much as #2 was programmed to care about that. So it tells #2, “if you don’t do what I want, I’ll start up this computer running this torture program and launch it away from you so fast that by the time you’re able to catch up to it it will already have been running for a long time”. #2 might think #1 is bluffing, so #1 rigs up some sort of system outside of its own control that will automatically activate this launch if it detects that #2 doesn’t meet #1’s demands. In this scenario, neither #1 nor #2 wants this torture to happen, but #1 thinks that the risk of #2 not giving into its demands is low enough to warrant the risk (since #2 cares about this sort of stuff more than #1 does). It’d sort of be like a hostage situation I guess. But if one time #1 miscalculates or something, then the computer could be launched and the horrible situation occurs. So this is a scenario in which this sort of thing could happen even if none of the actors involved are trying to do it just out of pure evilness or something. I’ve thought of plenty of other scenarios where non-evil general AIs could end up causing this to happen, so I don’t really think it’s something that can be dismissed just by saying that they probably won’t be evil enough to even want to do that.

Now to the main point I guess, which is that I think humans alive today CAN influence the probability of this thing ever happening in the future. Once the first general AIs are developed (which I don’t think will happen anytime too soon, but it probably will happen sometime in the next 2000 years or so I’d guess), they could probably easily use their superior intelligence to become far more powerful than all humans, so our window to influence their system of ethics and stuff like that is probably pretty short and not all that far off in the future. Since humans living today are going to be the ones passing down culture and beliefs and stuff to the humans who have this opportunity, we are able to influence (albeit only to a rather small degree) the (expected value of) the future general AIs’ values and ethics. Since this will determine the likelihood of the aforementioned bad scenario occurring, we then have a moral obligation to do everything in our power to reduce the likelihood of this bad scenario occurring in the future.

So basically if one wants to live a virtuous life, if you’re aware of this issue then the way to do that is to do everything you can to reduce the likelihood of this happening as much as possible, and the effect you have there will dominate everything else you do in terms of how morally good of a life you lived.

I know not everyone will agree with this (especially given how condensed the argument here is), but it is genuinely what I believe and I consider it sort of like my own personal religion (except entirely based on reason and not faith). I haven’t touched upon what exactly I think a 21st century human could do to influence this in a positive way, but I have some ideas. At the very least, making sure that religious conceptions of the justness of a hell-like punishment aren’t passed down too far in the future is a start. Also making sure that human culture isn’t going to consider software people not deserving of the same rights as people whose consciousness is running on fleshy biological computers (our brains).

Any thoughts? If I haven’t convinced you that this is an important thing to focus on, why not? Is there anything that you think could convince you of this? If you are convinced, do you have any suggestions about what 21st century humans could do to (in expectation) lower the probability of this happening in the future?


r/PhilosophyExchange • • Nov 11 '21

Essay Mass Democracy

Thumbnail self.christiandemocrat
7 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyExchange • • Oct 02 '21

Question What is the difference between epistocracy and noocracy?

7 Upvotes

I've been hearing these terms, but, I'm not sure what the difference is? A source says that epistocracy is rule of the educated, whereas noocracy is the rule of the intelligent. So, what's the difference? Educated and intelligent are pretty much the same.

Thank you!


r/PhilosophyExchange • • Dec 03 '21

Essay The Nuclear Family is not Enough to Support Civilization

Thumbnail reddit.com
6 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyExchange • • Oct 01 '21

Discussion Antilia is a phantom island in the Mid-Atlantic appearing in maps from c.1424-1587 equated with the Savage Islands, Madeira and according to its lore a Latinophone Romanized Catholic theocratic empire. It could become an authentic imperial micronation/model/new country project. What do you think?

Thumbnail
self.monarchism
6 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyExchange • • May 07 '22

How Freedom Became Slavery (Own Essay)

Thumbnail
forheavenssake46778317.wordpress.com
5 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyExchange • • Nov 22 '21

Discussion Canadian Nationalism?

5 Upvotes

I was thinking, though, in what sense can Canada be considered a nation except in the liberal “civic nation” conception, which is obviously not the conception we have in mind?

Is Canada a nation in the sense that we possess a unique cultural identity? What about shared history/lineage?

Furthermore, a local area often has a unique shared history, lineage and culture in the same way a nation does, for instance.

So in what sense can culturally disparate places like the Canada, where it seems that someone in Nova Scotia has nothing in common from someone in Alberta is somehow part of the same nation? Does Canada really have the characteristics of a nation in the sense of a shared history, lineage and culture? Or only in the liberal sense of the civic nation?


r/PhilosophyExchange • • Oct 21 '21

Thoughts on Vaccine Mandates Societal Impact?

5 Upvotes

This is a thought that I've been working out over the past few days in light of many heavy handed mandatory vaccine requirements in various countries and workplaces. I'lll try to break this up into sections to organize it.

The Previous Attitudes Towards Health & Vaccines

It seems to me that many people from older generations (Boomers, etc.) have a very high view of doctors and people who work in hospitals or healthcare. In fact, at least in my experience, emergency rooms and clinics often get overloaded with people coming in with minor health conditions like head colds etc. Many people really do have this attitude that they should go to a doctor for every common or minor condition that causes them discomfort.

Vaccines are a boon of modern medicine. We are taught that they were the cure for major illnesses like polio. It's basically been ingrained in us since we were kids that they are safe and effective, virtually no one gets hurt from them, and there is something wrong with people who don't take vaccines. Naturally, if a doctor tells us to take a vaccine, we will comply. We don't want to be seen as a conspiracy theorist or a crazy person, after all.

A great example of this is from a conversation I had with someone a few months ago before the vaccines for COVID came out. When the topic of vaccines came up the other person made the comment that "I've never looked into the arguments against vaccines but the people who think that way are crazy." I thought to myself, isn't this how most people think? Why do we think someone is crazy when we haven't even listened to their ideas?

The Current State

Clearly, many people have taken the vaccine. Certainly everyone who is on the liberal political spectrum believe in it and rushed out to get them as soon as they could so they could virtue signal about it on social media and dating apps. Even many people on the right side of the political spectrum would have gotten the shots. Indeed, most people got the shot without thinking about it.

However, it seems that not enough people have taken the vaccine and so our governments have determined that harsh measures must be imposed. These largely include putting people's employment at risk for not getting vaccinated but many countries have strict vaccine passport systems that in some case prevent even online shopping for the unvaccinated. However, there are still many places that are permissive with exemptions or allow regular antigen testing as an alternative to getting fired (at least for now).

I could see healthcare having strict policies like this since other vaccines have been a requirement in the past. Though getting those vaccines would have been more of a free choice since they would have had to have them before starting their careers.

In any case, there are additional factors to consider:

  • Vaccine Passports are common in many countries.

  • The severity of the policies vary. In some countries you can't enter a grocery store to buy food. I've heard in New Zeeland some supermarkets won't let you order food online without showing proof.

  • Governments are becoming much more strict and doing things that are effectively shunning groups from society. In the Dominican Republic you can't take public transportation or take money out of a bank.

  • The people who don't want to take the vaccine are not as large in number (it seems) as those who have already taken it. This varies from country to country.

  • Harsh vaccine policies seem to be prevalent in countries with the highest vaccination rates.

In short, people are being coerced to varying degrees that they must take the vaccine or be shunned from society. You can argue whether that is their choice or not, but the result is the same.

The Future

During the past two or three months, things have gotten a lot more political. In Canada, Justine Trudeau mandated vaccines for everyone in the Federal Public Service. Joe Biden did something similar in the US. As mentioned above, it seems nations are getting more strict as we approach the new year. People have and will continue to be fired for not getting the vaccine.

Regardless of the assumption that most people get vaccines because they trust them to be safe and effective, there seems to be a not so insignificant number of people who don't buy the narrative and won't take the vaccine even if it means loosing their jobs. Among these people are many thousands of healthcare workers who should be more educated about vaccines than any other group of people. The number of people not taking vaccines is growing, and I suspect some are looking into vaccines in general and becoming skeptical of those as well.

There are probably many ways this could change society. But what I'm thinking about mostly is the fact that we don't seem to value personal autonomy anymore and don't have a problem with shunning someone from society. The forced nature of policies are probably pushing some people to a position of resistance where they many have taken the vaccine in time with less severe measures.

I randomly watched an episode of Star Trek Voyager a few days ago where the plot was an encounter with a race that exterminated another group because they refused to embrace modern technology and ways of living.

Even if we think that people are putting others health at risk for not taking the vaccine, why are we not allowing options such as regular rapid testing to accommodate simply based on respect for personal choice?

Also, how will this impact how people view doctors?

Left leaning people will likely trust doctors even more.

Conservatives, even if they got the vaccine, may be less trusting given the overreach of government mandates and vaccine passports.

But I think there will be an even larger group who will be increasingly skeptical of modern medicine given the lack of respect they appear to have for personal autonomy and choice.

Another thought: based on who will be fired for not getting vaccines, this could be seen as a form of "systemic discrimination" against people with more conservative views, since they will almost always be the ones opposed to the vaccine, vaccine passports, or mandatory vaccine policies.

In any case, I think we are headed to a increasingly fractured society. How it shapes up and how big those fractures turn out to be are anyone's guess.


r/PhilosophyExchange • • Jun 10 '23

Discussion The quasi-religious nature of philosophy as a way of life

4 Upvotes

I'm a believer in a school of thought known as "Philosophy as a Way of Life". This school dictates that philosophy has a quasi-religious quality about it. The key difference between religion and philosophy as ways of life is twofold.

The first is the necessity in the belief of a deity vs the ontological principles. All religions require a belief in a deity as their original principles, whereas a philosophy requires the belief in an ontological principle, which may be a god or gods, but is not necessarily. For example, the Stoic Way of Life requires the fundamental belief that the universe and how we ought to conduct ourself is understandable through reason. In antiquity, this meant the belief in the universe as a living being, unfolding according to reason, which we could use a fragment of to understand it. In more modern times, this means understanding the fundamental principles of our universe, such as mathematics, physics, and also human-specific domains such as neuroscience and psychology. Essentially, a religion requires adherence to a set of rules allegedly emmanating from a deity or set of deities who are the supreme authority on morality with very little room for change, whereas a philosophy as a way of life might have some core beliefs in how we should conduct ourselves, set upon an ontological grounding, but it is more about investigating to understand the world and how we should behave*,* than a claim to knowledge about how to understand the world and how we should behave.

In this way, Neoplatonism is a little more religious, than say, Stoicism, although I would argue where it is prevented from being a religion is in the fact that ideas like The One and the Nous, the Henads etc. are all more conceptual and abstract than they are literal. This allows the possibility for deviation and growth in the philosophy, as the "canon" is a little more loose than the Christian "canon". Neoplatonism has the same advantage of the ancient Greek myths (given it was a product of this time), as well as ancient Egyptian and Babylonian stories, in that it was always meant as a conceptual framework for trying to understand the world, rather than a doctrinal set of rules dictated by an allegedly, omni-benevolent, omniscient and omnipotent being.

The second is the way in which they are accessible to the average person. I would say that this is probably the more obvious distinction between a philosophy as a way of life and a religion as a way of life. Religions are more accessible to the average person, as they rely on tradition to maintain their thought across time. They have doctrines that are passed down from generation to generation through traditions and rites with little deviation. Because the purpose of religion is to unite people, it provides structure to communities, which is why people who subscribe to them are often socially and politically conservative. These doctrines are often presented in a way that are simple and easy to understand, hence allegories and the fact that many of the stories in say, the Bible, come off as very simple, despite being full of philosophical brilliance. However, this runs the risk of these doctrines becoming dogma.

Philosophies, on the other hand do not seek to unite people and often seek to explain things in a logically consistent, rational way, often failing to tap into the human spirit in the way a religion does, or a great story like Lord of the Rings, Harry Potter, or Star Wars can. These are all ancient stories, told over and over in different times and places, but still equally resonant. However, the purpose of philosophy is to investigate the world and, if it's possible, gain wisdom. This often requires a great deal of learning and intensive, reflective thought, which is daunting or uninteresting to many people, thereby alienating them from philosophy's complexities and pushing them to religion's simplicities.

This said, I do not believe that these things are mutually exclusive. I believe that all religions are undergirted by a rich and deep philosophy which is equally as complex as other schools of philosophy. It is only that these religions have found ways in which to represent their philosophical concepts simply that gives them the social advantage over schools of philosophy.

The quasi-religious quality of philosophy as a way of life is where I believe these two concepts (philosophy and religion) can merge. Philosophies that are direct relations to the Socratic turn in philosophy often portray philosophy in this light, due to the Socratic turn's focus on aesthetics, ethics and political philosophy. The best two examples of this (in my opinion), are Stoicism and Neoplatonism.

Stoicism's focus on simplicity is part of what I believe has caused its modern resurgence and its popularity in antiquity. Its devotion to principle, specifically virtue, is a quasi-religious quality that was able to be explained in terms that the average person can understand and often gives very practical lessons for how to think, behave and feel that touch the human spirit.

Neoplatonism's nature in particular allows it to blur the line between religion and philosophy in a way very few other philosophies do, as it often includes things like prayer and theurgy, as well as a devotion to polytheistic gods. This allows the Neoplatonist framework to tell stories of the Greek Gods and Heroes to explain its perspective and unite the people, and then use philosophy to unpack that story for those who are a little more skeptical.

Neoplatonism's nature allows you to fit many religions (or even no religion) into its framework. I believe that's because of its quasi-religious nature, which prevents it from becoming dogmatic in the way that traditional religions often do.

Anyway, just thought I'd put this thought out there and see what people think.


r/PhilosophyExchange • • Oct 08 '21

Media Final version of the map of Southeast Magellanica. Here decipted as a phantom continent, M/Terra Australis is both such and my planned micronation on Pacific islands equated w/the phantom continent, an ethnoculturally Anglo-Dutch-Fin-Swe traditionalist Puritan confederate Christian commonwealth

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyExchange • • Oct 03 '21

Discussion Do you agree with the statement: “Oppression by corporations is more of a concern than oppression by governments.”

Thumbnail self.christiandemocrat
4 Upvotes