I am Gen Z. Yes, the generation that is often criticised by older generations for being immature, rebellious and disrespectful. Yet, we often believe that we are not simply rebellious; we are progressive.
Yes, perhaps we are progressive in some ways. But, in many other ways, we hold the same conservative attitudes that we criticise in older generations. If we believe that we are progressive, shouldn't we also be willing to criticise the things we have faith in? Refusing to question our own beliefs is not progress; it is a defensive mechanism.
Consider religion. Some of us reject religion because we believe its claims lack empirical evidence, while others embrace it without critically examining why they believe in it. But I wonder whether both reactions are sometimes driven less by reason and more by group identity. Some Gen Z atheists may reject religion simply as an act of rebellion, rather than through a genuine examination of its claims. Similarly, some religious Gen Z individuals may call themselves progressive while refusing to question their own religious assumptions.
Some of us may be more rebellious than previous generations, and perhaps that is a good thing. But rebellion can also lead us into the same political worship and group loyalty that we criticise in older generations. Have we ever considered the phenomenon behind this behaviour—the tendency to divide ourselves into "us" and "them", often without examining the empirical or epistemological foundations of our beliefs? In simpler terms, this may be tribalism: a tendency to favour our own group and defend its beliefs without sufficient evidence.
We can observe this tendency in religious gatherings, political rallies, concerts and communities formed around caste, colour, nationality and ethnicity. People can become intensely emotionally connected when they find themselves surrounded by others who share the same identity. There is nothing inherently wrong with belonging or sharing an identity. But when that identity prevents us from questioning our own group, it becomes a barrier to independent thought.
There are many directions we could explore through this subject. But perhaps two important questions deserve our attention: What can actually help us develop a progressive mindset, rather than simply adopting new beliefs and defending them with the same old unquestioning loyalty? And why is groupism dangerous—not only for our nation and the world, but also for us as individuals, particularly for our intellectual and personal autonomy?
At both the individual and societal levels, tribalism or groupism becomes dangerous when it makes certain beliefs impossible to challenge. Bhagat Singh explores a similar problem in his essay Why I Am an Atheist. He describes how a person who questions a faith inherited from their ancestors, or challenges the very existence of an almighty God, may be labelled an apostate or a renegade. He further considers the situation in which a person's arguments are too strong to be refuted and their spirit too strong to be intimidated by threats of misfortune.
An apostate, in this context, is someone who abandons or renounces a religious faith. The important question is what happens to such a person after they challenge the beliefs of their community. They may face rejection, hostility or isolation. The fear of being treated as an outsider can discourage people from expressing their doubts, even when those doubts are reasonable. This creates a society in which people may learn to protect inherited beliefs rather than examine them. Throughout history, the suppression of dissent has also threatened thinkers and ideas that challenge established institutions.
In the same essay, Bhagat Singh presents his understanding of a progressive individual. He argues that anyone who stands for progress must criticise, disbelieve and challenge the elements of inherited faith. Every aspect of an established belief must be examined through reason. If, after careful examination, an individual arrives at a particular theory or philosophy, that belief can be welcomed. However, their reasoning may still be mistaken, misleading or fallacious. What matters is their willingness to accept correction because reason remains the guiding principle of their life. He warns that blind faith can dull the mind and make an individual reactionary.
This idea raises an important question: Is being progressive really that easy? I don't think so. It requires intellectual effort, continuous questioning and the willingness to abandon even those beliefs that we personally value. One of the biggest problems with reactionary thinking is the assumption that the knowledge or beliefs we have inherited or developed are permanent and beyond correction.
This brings me to the philosopher of science Karl Popper and his principle of falsifiability. According to Popper, for a theory to qualify as scientific, it must be possible to test it in a way that could potentially prove it wrong. Consider the example of white swans. Observing a million white swans cannot conclusively establish that all swans are white. But discovering even one black swan disproves that universal claim.
This illustrates an important limitation of induction: collecting supporting observations does not necessarily prove a universal conclusion. Popper's philosophy encourages us to expose our ideas to serious criticism rather than merely collecting evidence that supports what we already believe.
I believe this principle offers an important lesson for anyone who wants to develop a progressive mindset. We should not treat our conclusions as permanent truths simply because they are supported by our traditions, communities or personal experiences. We must remain open to criticism, evidence and correction. Progress requires more than accepting new ideas; it requires accepting that our own ideas can be wrong.
But does scientific thinking alone make someone progressive? Certainly not. Scientific thinking is only one part of progressiveness. Being progressive is a much broader responsibility that involves questioning social inequalities, respecting individual freedom, developing ethical values and recognising our responsibility towards the natural world. Intellectual progress, social progress and environmental responsibility cannot be treated as entirely separate goals. If we want our nation and humanity to progress, we must also reconsider how we treat the planet and the other forms of life with which we share it.