r/PhantomFiction • u/PhantomOfZePirates • May 25 '17
It's normal for parents to leave a list of rules for the babysitter. It's normal for the list to be a little strange. What isn't normal is for the list to be as ominous as these.
It's a summer gig. I need the cash to fund my growing vinyl collection. I look out the kitchen window, forcing a big ol' award winning, greatest damn babysitter in the US of A grin and wave as Mr. and Mrs. Jones back out of the driveway. Apparently little Annie is a pretty quiet kid, likes to be left alone with her dolls to play. Works for me. That means I can chill and watch videos. Grabbing the list of rules they left on the counter, I go and plop down on the couch to give it a once over. Flipping on the television and putting my feet up, I read the list:
1.) Annie must eat all vegetables with dinner. 2.) Annie may have one cookie for dessert. 3.) Please no boys or friends in the house. 4.) Keep the basement door locked at all times.
Uh, ok.
5.) Bedtime is at 8:30. 6.) Ignore the scratching from the basement. 7.) Keep lights on at all times after 8 p.m., with the exception of Annie's room.
Wait, what?
8.) Ignore the pleading from the basement. 9.) Do not call the police. 10.) Whatever you do, don't scream.
Heart hammering in my chest, I stare down at the list. Is this Mr. and Mrs. Jones' twisted idea of humor?
"Will you play with me?" a soft voice asks from across the room.
"Jesus fuck shit," I gasp, looking up to see Annie staring at me with big doe eyes. "Uh, sorry... You scared the crap outta me," I say, getting to my feet. She just stares with those big brown eyes. "Right, we can play. But after dinner," I tell her, entering the kitchen to heat up the meal Mrs. Jones left.
I watch as Annie takes a seat at the table and quietly sets to work eating her vegetables. "So, Annie, you're like six, right?" I ask, trying to make conversation. She just ignores me while considering a piece of broccoli, before popping it into her mouth. "I remember being six, it was-" I stop when I hear a gentle scraaatch from behind me. I swallow and slowly swivel round in my chair, eyes instantly locking on the basement door. It's my imagination. It fucking has to be. I exhale and force my eyes back to Annie, who looks unperturbed. SCRAAAAAAATCH. Longer this time. With more force. It sounds like rusty knives raking down the old wood of the door. "Did you hear that?" I demand of the strange child.
Annie slides off her chair and looks at me. "I finished all of my broccoli," she smiles sweetly and takes my hand. "Now we get to play," she says, pulling me down the hall. I fight the urge to look back at the basement, even though my heart threatens to go into cardiac arrest even though I'm just 16. I watch too many damn horror movies is all.
I yawn and look down at my watch, while Annie continues to engage her dolls in some weird ass conversation about moths. "Shit, it's 9 o'clock, kiddo... Past your bedtime," I tell her, standing to tuck her in.
She looks up at me once all comfy cozy under her blankets. I move to turn on her nightlight for her, since I still sleep with one, myself. "No!" she yells, sitting up violently in bed. "Leave it off.... And don't forget to close my door," she whispers.
Jesus. Alright, then. "Ok. Nighty night, Annie..." I smile slightly, before exiting the room, making sure to turn off her light and close the door.
Once in the hall, I exhale and push my hands through my blond hair. They better fucking pay well. With a sigh, I flip off the hall light and go back into the living room. Maybe a Disney movie will calm me the hell down.
Halfway into The Fox and the Hound, I start to fade, head bobbing and everything. Until I see the pitch black shadow in the hallway. Lurking in the corner, it's tall and thin, and dark enough for me to distinguish it from the black of the hallway. "Oh, shit," I jump to my feet, suddenly wide awake as adrenaline shoots through me, making me tingle from head to toe. I'm across the room in two bounds and shove the light-switch up so the light above blares on. There's nothing there.
"Lucy. Sweet, lovely, kind Lucy.... Won't you please come play with me?" a soft, childlike voice asks... From the basement. Oh fuck no. My eyes dart to the phone in the kitchen. They said not to call the police. Maybe I just need sleep. "Luuucy, let's plaaaay," the voice giggles, high and melodious. I am gripped with vertigo as dread plunges its icy fingers into my gut. "Oh, Lucy. Why won't you let me out? You and I can be such friends. Please? Please let me out." Fuck it. I run to the kitchen and dial 911. Some maniac is clearly in the basement. I tap my foot and chew my lip while I wait. And wait. And wait. Until there's nothing but a dial tone. Beepbeepbeepbeep.
"What the actual fuck?!" I breathe, glancing toward Annie's room. All seems quiet in there, at least. Unwillingly, my eyes slide toward the basement door. The voice has gone mute and the door is wide open, revealing the hungry black maw of the frigid basement.
"Lucy," the same, sickly sweet voice purrs... From behind me. Its voice is whispering in my ear, in my heart, in the depths of my soul. "You really shouldn't have called them, sweet, precious Lucy.... Now it's too late. Look at me, Lucy."
Hesitantly, even though every inch of me begs not to, I turn. And I scream.