r/Permaculture • • Aug 30 '23

Is permaculture just a colonial version of indigenous gardening? Change my mind. Or let me change yours.

0 Upvotes

I've been very into permaculture for a long time, converted my tiny urban lawn into a legit food forest, with 50+ (native!) species, about half of which are edible or medicinal. The main thing I've learned is that life begets life: the more plants I grow, the more abundance of all the plants I have, and the more bugs and birds I support. I have always stuck with natives (about 95%), as I see the deep value in supporting our existing native species, which can largely only be done with native plants.

But recently, I've come to see permaculture as a kind of colonialism--it uses a kind of indigenous way of planting, but without much of the actual indigenous knowledge of place and ecosystem. Instead, it's (mostly white, so far as I can tell) people bringing in plants from all over the world, and when someone points out that they're maybe not the best plants to bring in, the permaculturist just shrugs and says, oh, it's already screwed anyway. I'm in the midwest and this area supported literally millions of people, pre-Euro contact. The book, Iwigara, by Enrique Salmon, helped me realize just how many of the natives I'm already growing are actually edible and medicinal, but that knowledge has just been hidden from the main view for so long. Rather than focusing on plants that do well in my climate, without regard to their origin or local value, why can't we shift permaculture into a native-plant based system? As the foraging movement and the Tallamy/backyard movement demonstrate, we could really do all of these things and support the systems that have evolved in the exact place that we live, rather than a hodgepodge that largely continues to benefit only humans. I get that we're changing the climate/ecology (duh) of every place on this planet. But there are very much still species literally everywhere that could benefit from our planting native plants that feed both us and the wildlife that deserve to live, and whose ecosystems may not ever return to their "pure" state, but we could just do a whole lot better.


r/Permaculture • • Feb 19 '24

Looking for leftist anticapitalist online communities geared towards gardening/farming.

2 Upvotes

Does anyone know where I can connect with other leftist/anticapitalist online that are into farming/Permaculture? Disclaimer: I am not looking to discuss or explain these principles to anyone here.


r/Permaculture • • Jan 15 '21

Here a great video showing the opposing side to oyster farming, an unnatural totally not permaculture practice. I saw some oyster farming post on here last week that had zip all to do with permaculture.

65 Upvotes

r/Permaculture • • Dec 30 '23

This is what grocery stores should be relaxed with.

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/Permaculture • • Apr 20 '26

I tested an Electroculture setup at college, these are the initial results after the first month

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

First 3 bed pictures are the control, 2nd set is of the electrified bed, Observations:

More uniform growth across the bed and more weeds, indicates higher seed germination.

Slightly more vibrant green color.

An extra shoot on the onion bulbs is more common compared to control.

Significantly larger potato and strawberry leaf's that snuck in.

Electrified bed bulbs are slightly elevated in the soil, could indicate larger root growth.

The apparatus is based on the guidelines given in the Electroculture book by Justin Christofleau: Copper tube with steel wiring at the top and connected to a steel bolt with magnets on it pointing magnetic south

Leading from the bolt is a steel wire down to a steel wire mesh under the soil, which is then connected to steel wire leading to a grounded iron spike in the Earth, magnets placed on the wire at the entry and exit points of the bed.

According to Christofleau it takes 6 years for the soil to fully acclimate to the apparatus and the subtle currents, for now I'll just be monitoring the growth over the coming months.


r/Permaculture • • Jun 17 '12

Very excited about permaculture (x-post from AdviceAnimals)

Thumbnail
qkme.me
0 Upvotes

r/Permaculture • • Aug 06 '22

Can someone help me identify this plant?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Permaculture • • Nov 10 '23

Permaculture GPT : AI-Powered Permaculture: Instant Expertise in Your Hands!

23 Upvotes

https://chat.openai.com/g/g-y8BV6typ7-permaculture-gpt

Hay Permies

I built a GPT powered assistant and its awesome to bounce permaculture ideas off. (You will need a chatgpt plus account to use it for now. but if you do its free to use )

Here is how it describes itself

Permaculture GPT, your AI-driven guide designed to enhance your permaculture journey.

  • Tailored Solutions: Get specific, customized advice for your unique permaculture challenges. From small urban gardens to large-scale regenerative agriculture, Permaculture GPT adapts to your needs.

  • Expert Knowledge at Your Fingertips: Drawing from a wide range of permaculture expertise, I provide insights and recommendations that align with permaculture principles and ethics.

  • Real-World Applications: Whether you're experimenting with companion planting, natural building, or water harvesting systems, get practical steps and innovative strategies that work in real life.

  • Accessible 24/7: Got a permaculture question at 2 AM? I'm here round the clock to assist you with immediate, actionable advice.

  • Community-Driven Learning: Engage in discussions, share your experiences, and learn from a collective pool of knowledge and insights from permaculture practitioners worldwide.

Let me know what you think.

https://chat.openai.com/g/g-y8BV6typ7-permaculture-gpt

Hopefully it will be free for everyone soon


r/Permaculture • • Jul 13 '21

Right?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Permaculture • • Aug 18 '24

discussion Mining the cities to build sustainable communities around the world

Post image
0 Upvotes

I’ve been thinking about building an online community that owns several digital businesses that gather money from the cities to buy land and build eco-communities around the world that will eventually need 0 money to sustain themselves.

Am I crazy or do you think this is possible?


r/Permaculture • • Nov 06 '20

CMV: “Permaculture” is mostly white people rebranding indigenous farming techniques acting like they discovered it

7 Upvotes

All of the techniques I’ve seen have been used for centuries, but there are people acting like they just discovered these techniques and they are somehow revolutionary.

The only time I’ve ever seen anyone make a profit with a “permaculture farm” is when they have a YouTube channel or they sell classes. 99% of the time it isn’t actually profitable or scaleable.


r/Permaculture • • Aug 09 '18

Do you consider social justice to be an important part of permaculture?

0 Upvotes

I have been thinking lately about social justice issues and how they relate to permaculture.

I think the permaculture ethic "fair share" needs to be considered more. We need to find ways to help minorities gain access to land since they have been systematically denied it through redlining and other racist tactics.

I also think it would be in the best interest of society to apply the permaculture philosophy of valuing diversity to people as well as plants. As a lesbian, I see again and again that "my kind" seem to be more adaptable to certain conditions. When there is a gap in society and a need for someone to fill it, lesbians often step up. This has often played out to the advantage of society when there has been a shortage of men. Lesbians step up to fill the gaps. That's what nature does, and is, and I for one wish more people valued that diversity in people.

What are your thoughts?


r/Permaculture • • Apr 25 '22

discussion Anyone here consider themselves a permaculturist and a free market capitalist?

4 Upvotes

I feel like permaculture, as opposed to many other segments of environmentally aware communities, feels more embracing of freedom and the public choice. Just curious if there are any other self identifying free marketers in the group.

Edit: I feel like I’m getting ratioed hard here but I am enjoying the feedback and learning a lot. Thanks!


r/Permaculture • • Feb 15 '17

Paul Wheaton: Increasing the Velocity of Permaculture

Thumbnail
youtu.be
4 Upvotes

r/Permaculture • • Dec 17 '25

general question Has Anyone Tried Growing a Pawpaw Tree Before?

0 Upvotes

We planted a pawpaw tree last Spring and it died. I was talking to a local farmer who had about 15 in his fencerow, and he said to never plant them in warmer weather; plant them in the winter season, and they'll live.

He has fruits on them in late summer, and he lets me collect them. I am trying to figure out why this native species won't transplant well in a cool early Spring.

I am going to give it another try, planting one now that it's winter.

Does anyone have tips on their success?


r/Permaculture • • Jul 09 '18

Bury Kitchen Scraps Directly in Garden

Thumbnail
youtube.com
4 Upvotes

r/Permaculture • • Jan 01 '20

Thought you guys might appreciate my sentiment. Ive recently found myself being vilified for growing my own food- including meat.

Thumbnail
imgur.com
36 Upvotes

r/Permaculture • • Mar 25 '24

Paid a land too much, I need a bit of emotional support from permaculture friends

1 Upvotes

Hi, me and my family bought a land a year ago. This land is 3.3 hectares and we bought it too quickly. I am not sure why we wanted to buy that so quickly and why we were rushing. Actually I know why, one of us was putting pressure because thought that we had to do everything quickly. SO we followed and got carried away with it.

We paid 180k with taxes for 3.3 hectares, now we also wanted to build on top of it and that's going to cost even more money. It seemed like the cost was because we had the possibility to build which is not too common, also the rules says that with 3.3 hectares we would be able to build houses for everyone and we wanted to be all close together. It's also 10 mins from the seaside, so it looked appealing.

It's true that we could use some room for b&b and get some money back, but still...

Also many people around us now they are telling we overpaid that but looking at website it's always these kind of prices.... I am not sure why these people say our price was crazy when the websites don't say those prices they state.

I feel so emotionally sad we did this invstment. I love the land we bought and I want to do a permaculture project but that felt like a huge waste of money. I know in other countries you would buy much more land with that.....


r/Permaculture • • May 18 '24

Permaculture just feel like a oversized garden in farm land.

0 Upvotes

If every farmer started using permaculture won't there be food crisis?


r/Permaculture • • Aug 24 '22

How collapse-aware is the international permaculture community?

0 Upvotes

Everybody has seen a newspaper article mentioning the collapse of civilization (or any of its sub-systems) by now. Famous thinkers and writers predict it, and entire communities, both online and in the real world, have sprung up around the topic of civilizational collapse. Just reading the news can make one feel like collapse is not too far away. Many permaculturalists I know personally have stated the impending collapse of civilization as one reason why they started the sometimes rocky road towards self-sufficiency and sustainability. Permaculture does seem like a great response to such scenario.

My question is: what do you think? Is the widespread collapse of civilization - or the collapse of systems crucial to a functioning world economy - likely? If yes, how long do we have until (excuse the prepper terminology) "shit hits the fan"?

Note: It's good to first define what we mean by "collapse" - I usually think of it as a reduction in complexity. Let's go with Jared Diamond's definition and say "collapse" means "a drastic decrease in human population size and/or political/economic/social complexity, over a considerable area, for an extended time." The collapse of global civilization would thus encompass things like the collapse of crucial supply chains of resources or goods, such as fossil fuels, chemical fertilizers, metals and plastics, etc.

316 votes, Aug 27 '22
49 By 2030
110 By 2050
42 By 2075
27 By 2100
29 After 2100
59 Never

r/Permaculture • • Dec 21 '24

Plantain the herb - a powerhouse of healing for both body and soil.

0 Upvotes

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

person enter squeal continue oatmeal violet enjoy encouraging piquant shocking


r/Permaculture • • Jun 19 '20

Why the third ethic of permaculture must be defended absolutely and without compromise

0 Upvotes

https://www.permaculturenews.org/2017/04/13/controversial-third-ethic-permaculture/

You really need to read this article, and the responses.

Permaculture only exists because our existing techno-industrial-agricultural system is unsustainable and heading rapidly towards collapse. The whole point of permaculture is to try to create something actually sustainable to replace it: that's what "permaculture" means.

Permaculture is therefore the only alternative to accepting ongoing, uncontrollable collapse - of both civilisation and population. There are no others. Either we build a sustainable human world, or we accept that the unsustainable human world will collapse. Therefore, if people try to take permaculture and turn it into something else which fundamentally isn't sustainable, they must be resisted absolutely. We cannot compromise with them, because to do so simply means we have to accept total collapse.

Permaculture isn't socialism. The goal of socialism is fairness, and in reality it means global fairness. In other words, most socialists are committed to trying to make the existing world fair(er) for all 8 billion humans. This is a worthy goal, but it is completely impossible, for a whole bunch of reasons that are so obvious that I shouldn't have to point them out. It was never going to happen even if we weren't heading for collapse, and the idea that it can happen while the global population is experiencing an involuntary reduction because we've already busted the limits to growth is totally absurd.

What we are actually heading for is a survival situation. A lot of humans will not survive. Permaculture is the absolute key for those who want to stand any chance of surviving. It's the ONLY answer. And in such a situation it is absolutely necessary that limiting the population - at every level the permaculture system applies to - is put first and foremost. It is not optional, and not negotiable.

This means accepting that we cannot save 8 billion people. If you cannot do that, personally, then that is perfectly understandable. But you are on a collision course with reality, doomed to fail. That is your right. What is NOT your right is to attempt to import this goal into permaculture, because permaculture must be based on reality. It cannot incorporate goals which are doomed to fail because they do not accept the reality of the limits to growth.

In short, people need to choose between socialism, at least on a global level, and permaculture. And if you can't accept it then you are setting up an ideological war that you must lose and will lose, because you cannot be permitted to destroy the one and only thing that stands between humanity and extinction.

Moving Forward

Instead, this controversial third ethic should act as a guiding light to help individuals examine their own resource use more carefully – looking at reducing their consumption and addressing the social challenge of sharing not only surplus, but also labour and production. Permaculture is about community, about resiliency, and about sustainability.

No, no, no, no, NO NO NO NO NO!

No, this third ethic is not "a guiding light for individuals to examine their own resource use." It is a fundmental building block of the entire system. Putting the onus on individuals, instead of fixing the systemic problem, destroys the whole project. This is not the way forwards. This is the way to ruin. This is what you get if you compromise with socialists because you lack the moral conviction and courage to defend the integrity of permaculture.


r/Permaculture • • Oct 03 '17

18 Woman Go Bare For The Love Of Indigenous Plants

Thumbnail
greenpop.org
0 Upvotes

r/Permaculture • • Aug 12 '26

pest control Best Way to Get Rid of Pill Bugs from Garden?

0 Upvotes

I know I know people say pill bugs don’t eat your plants but I’ve been watching it happen with my own eyes for weeks now. when my tomatoes just barely start to blush they get devoured by the pill bugs. I’ll pick up a tomato and see a bunch of them burrowing into the tomato and eating it but no other bug doing so. Driving me nuts losing all of my tomatoes to these guys. I want them in compost, not in my tomatoes!! I want to avoid anything synthetic in terms of pesticides. Nothing toxic.