r/Permaculture • u/permelculturist • Aug 30 '23
Is permaculture just a colonial version of indigenous gardening? Change my mind. Or let me change yours.
I've been very into permaculture for a long time, converted my tiny urban lawn into a legit food forest, with 50+ (native!) species, about half of which are edible or medicinal. The main thing I've learned is that life begets life: the more plants I grow, the more abundance of all the plants I have, and the more bugs and birds I support. I have always stuck with natives (about 95%), as I see the deep value in supporting our existing native species, which can largely only be done with native plants.
But recently, I've come to see permaculture as a kind of colonialism--it uses a kind of indigenous way of planting, but without much of the actual indigenous knowledge of place and ecosystem. Instead, it's (mostly white, so far as I can tell) people bringing in plants from all over the world, and when someone points out that they're maybe not the best plants to bring in, the permaculturist just shrugs and says, oh, it's already screwed anyway. I'm in the midwest and this area supported literally millions of people, pre-Euro contact. The book, Iwigara, by Enrique Salmon, helped me realize just how many of the natives I'm already growing are actually edible and medicinal, but that knowledge has just been hidden from the main view for so long. Rather than focusing on plants that do well in my climate, without regard to their origin or local value, why can't we shift permaculture into a native-plant based system? As the foraging movement and the Tallamy/backyard movement demonstrate, we could really do all of these things and support the systems that have evolved in the exact place that we live, rather than a hodgepodge that largely continues to benefit only humans. I get that we're changing the climate/ecology (duh) of every place on this planet. But there are very much still species literally everywhere that could benefit from our planting native plants that feed both us and the wildlife that deserve to live, and whose ecosystems may not ever return to their "pure" state, but we could just do a whole lot better.
