All my experience with this game has been miserable. It's mechanics can be summed up to 'save or die', to the point I must think we must be doing something incorrectly because there is no way this game is so highly praised when it is essentially unplayable.
Picture this. Yesterday we started a GPC 5.2 game. There is three of us, ALL specced for combat. We go into our very first battle at Mearcred Creek. The GM rolls of the Tome of Battle BEGINNER table to see what we fight: Blue cloacks, elite shield men, veteran warriors. Enemies with 20+ combat skills.
IN OUR VERY FIRST BATTLE.
We all die, of course. Matter of fact, we redo the battle three times before we manage to barely win and all of us are so grievously wounded it will take years for us to heal.
This feels like a Dark Souls videogame where you don't come back to life when you die.
Are we doing something wrong? Is there a book or an errata to fix this extremely Player-hostile mechanic? Or has the man who wrote this book never played his own game and the only way to progress is to savescum your way to victory? At this point I am basically begging that there must be something, ANYTHING that we are doing wrong
EDIT: some may say "character die, don't get attached'. Yeah, I'd like to be able to fucking PLAY my character first though.
This game tells you to have fun and not minmax and then actively punishes you if you don't optimise