I’ve been working with several named pawpaw cultivars this season — Rappahannock, Shenandoah, Potomac and Susquehanna — and one thing that’s surprised me is how differently they behave once you take them beyond eating fresh.
Rappahannock was actually my least favorite of the four for eating out of hand, but probably the most unique in flavor.
The fruit I had was intensely aromatic with a distinctly tropical, almost papaya-like character. There was also a subtle spiced complexity underneath it that I didn’t get as strongly from the other cultivars. The flesh was quite firm and starchy, and as it ripened it developed a beautiful golden-orange hue.
That papaya character was actually why I preferred Shenandoah, Potomac and Susquehanna for eating fresh. But those same qualities made me curious about what Rappahannock could do in a frozen dessert.
I originally developed this Pawpaw Lassi Gelato around Shenandoah. It produced a good gelato that was still distinctly pawpaw, but the lassi character was more restrained. When I made the same concept with Rappahannock, everything seemed to come together differently.
The base is eggless and made with cultured dahi, with a small amount of Kesar mango to round out the fruit and green cardamom for the primary spice note.Rappahannock’s naturally spiced complexity complemented the cardamom particularly well. Its tropical, papaya-like character also felt almost adjacent to the flavor profile of a lassi, so the pawpaw and cultured dairy felt more integrated rather than like two separate components. Its strong aroma also held up remarkably well through the dairy and freezing.
The Shenandoah version was still clearly pawpaw, but it tasted more like a pawpaw gelato interpreted through lassi. The Rappahannock version feels more naturally lassi-forward, while still keeping pawpaw as the dominant fruit.
That was probably the most interesting part of the experiment for me. Rappahannock was my least favorite of these cultivars to eat fresh, yet it has been my favorite for this particular application. Sometimes the characteristics that make a fruit less appealing to you out of hand are exactly what make it useful when you start building a flavor around it.
Next, I’d really like to try this recipe with Mango pawpaw and KSU-Chappell, particularly because of their more mango-forward tropical profiles, and see whether that pushes the natural connection to lassi even further. The use of these might not need the use of the little bit of kesar mango.
This is part of Umai ( Instagram @mmmumai), my small-batch gelato and sorbet brand where I also make other confectionery and condiments. I serve the DMV with weekly local pickups in DC and Maryland. This flavour was my new yearly addition to pawpaw frozen dessert pantheon. Another flavour I developed and offer is a paw paw sorbet that has a hint of passion fruit and infused with Tahitian vanilla.
For anyone else who grows or eats named pawpaw cultivars: which cultivars have surprised you once you started using them for something other than eating fresh?