r/Pauper • • Mar 05 '25

Salty, Hot Take about Artifact Lands

0 Upvotes

People who are in favor of banning the MH2 bridges should also be in favor of unbanning Hymn to Tourach because, at the very least, there should be severe penalties for decks that do basically nothing until Turn 3.


r/Pauper • • Feb 06 '23

OTHER I've created "Snapcaster Mage" in Pauper. Do you guys think it could be playable in our beloved format?

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/Pauper • • 2d ago

PFP We need to admit to ourselves that zeta (and affinity) was a mistake

0 Upvotes

Rant warning

This esper affinity deck is the most infuriating deck I've had the misfortune of playing against since broodscale, which at least killed you fast and you were done. The fact that this deck gets to have 1 mana instant speed unconditional exile based removal, 1 mana draw 2, 0 mana 4/4, 1 mana discard 2/1 flyer, 2 mana flying deathtouch cantrip 1/1, AND gets to run dust to dust side is disgusting. It feels AWFUL to play against unless you're post side and can land a dust to dust or vandalblast when it matters, and then even then the affinity deck can rebuild with its absurd mana efficiency.

It feels utterly demoralizing to have the literal best effects in the format at 0-1 mana in a deck that can utilize all of them and have access to some of the best sideboard colors. No creatures (not even in graveyard), no cards in hand, they have a million cards, and a constant board presence, it's absurd. Every game against it doesn't feel like pauper.

I'm someone who's been playing the format for a good while and had never really had an opinion on affinity or the artifact lands and whatnot. Hell, zeta even powered up my pet brew deck to make it pretty viable, plus it leans on refurbished familiar quite heavily. But this has gotten absurd, I'd argue that dispatch, strix, and refurbished familiar need to go... or the untapped artifact lands do. We can't keep having affinity pop up every other set because we're still clinging on to those insane enablers in the MANABASE. I don't care that it'd make my pet deck of 3 years borderline unplayable, it's what's needed.

I know I'll definitely get pushback on this since affinity is the most divisive topic in the format, but I don't care. The play experience is so abysmal and is ruining the format for me. I love this format, it was my first magic format, my primary one, and my favorite, I've poured so many hours into playing it and working on deckbuilding, so it kills me to hate it so much right now.

Edit: yes I know the deck isn't taking over the meta or having insane win rates, but this was meant as a broader critique of the cards where esper affinity happens to abuse a lot of. Additionally, even if a deck isn't entirely dominant, the cards in that deck spread across the whole format (as with zeta and affinity) is something that isn't taken into account with specific deck win rates, PLUS the feel of playing against the cards. High tide wasn't dominant but it sure as hell wasn't fun to play against.

Also I'm not taking a stance on the decision to legalize or not zeta (that's a whole other thing), I'm saying these cards from zeta are making the format worse and it's a mistake to have them in the format.


r/Pauper • • Sep 01 '26

CARD DISC. Mystery Booster Commander Edition is also Secret Lair/Convention Exclusive so the PFP needs to also not make any downshifted commons illegal if they want to be consistent.

6 Upvotes

Declaring Secret Lair products not being intended to affect Pauper legality does not make sense when WOTC has Mystery Booster Commander Edition in the pipeline which whether you like it or not is also a Chaos Vault exclusive product not unlike the Zeta set. I understand that Zeta will be available in much lower volumes but the MBC set will also sell out instantly and not have wide availability in LGSs and online retail especially for people residing outside of the US.

What I'm asking the PFP to do is either work with the contacts who design and plan Chaos Vault releases and put a stop to introducing conflicting common reprints not "intended" for Pauper legality or simply make the commons rightfully legal. As a new player in the format half of the excitement for when new sets release is checking for downshifts and new printings that expand the card pool, and I think it's great that a new powerful set is downshifting some cards that otherwise would not have been legal. It is fun to experiment with new cards, and being an eternal format I think it's very important to not arbitrarily restrict card legality like the PFP is trying to do.


r/Pauper • • Oct 08 '23

CARD DISC. Green downshift

Post image
0 Upvotes

It would be great if they downshifted this card, don't you think?"


r/Pauper • • Feb 02 '26

SPIKE Pauper Metagame Update (2 feb)

Post image
0 Upvotes

Pauper monthly meta report after weekend events.

source: magic4everbots.com


r/Pauper • • Jun 22 '26

VIDEO/STREAM Why Hawkeye Combo Is Perfectly Fine For Pauper!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

Just as the title says - would love to hear some counterpoints if I'm missing anything!


r/Pauper • • Aug 12 '17

ONLINE Those of you who bring T1 decks into the Just for Fun room, why do you do it?

1 Upvotes

because i cant for the life of me come up with a reason why. someone asks you "want to play just for fun?" and your response is to get the spikey-est deck you can find?


r/Pauper • • Jan 24 '21

CARD DISC. Common Cause presents, the KHM Sleeper

1 Upvotes

From the same guy that told beforehand [[Fiery Cannonade]] would be the best card from its set (currently occupying the top4 overall spot for most used card in the format), he also tells you that this one is a sleeper...


r/Pauper • • Apr 04 '22

SPOILER Is this legit? A Mana Leak with Snuff Out.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Pauper • • Aug 27 '26

META An open letter to the PFP on Secret Lair

36 Upvotes

I decided to do this post because i can't express my opinion on Twitter, so why not make a post on my favorite Reddit to also get more opinions on the topic?

 

Of course the Topic is the new Secret Lair that contains quite a few downgrade as common, I want to analyze all the cards here and explain my view on them.

 

A big premises, this is my personal opinion, I'm part of the LPI board, so this need to be clarified, it's not a statement from LPI and my colleagues may have different opinion from mine, but I know many players in our 140+ leagues have an opinion similar to mine and I encourage everyone to express their in a polite manner, we are not here to flame or insult anyone (except Garden players).

 

I will analyze the downshifted cards one by one, if some new get's spoiled i will add them.

 

Serra Angel

[[Serra Angel]]

A card that's a symbol of Magic history, I think it can be integrated in pauper quite easly, it's not OP and maybe it will be played in some deck, it's nice to give her a new home.

 

Sengir Vampire

[[Sengir Vampire]]

Another big flier like the Angel, but another card that will probably see not much play.

 

Narcomoeba

[[Narcomoeba]]

An obviously very strong card, i think we all agree in a Pre-Ban since Pauper have no way to manage a spy that combo on turn 1 or 2.

 

Dispatch

[[Dispatch]]

A lot of people asked for Swords to Plowshares in the past, since white it's missing good exile removal. We can now finally have a nerfed version that is even more in-flavor for Pauper, an artifact driven format. This will be really nice to play alongside the Inspectors generating Clue token.

 

Cut Down

[[Cut Down]]

A nice black removal, will probably see play in Gardens or some more control oriented black decks, i think the format can easly accept it since we already have cast down and snuff out.

 

Price of Progress

[[Price of Progress]]

Another card that can be pre-banned, it's too strong for the format given the high number of non basic lands we play and the low cost of execution.

 

Baleful Strix

[[Baleful Strix]]

The card that started all this discussion online, as Gavin said a really loved card in the past, it would be nice to give him a home in Pauper. The format power level is high, this card can synergize with a lot of decks, it can be tested, maybe put it already on a watch list, but i think it doesn't deserve a pre-ban.

 

Given these explanation i want to say that maybe Pauper needs this little shake up, the format is stale because Modern Horizon/Commander sets have warped it, and now that no new sets of these kind are expected the format is not receiving many new cards.

Probably it's not worth to change the Format definition, but instead work on the format balance and ban only the problematic cards. Of course we don't know the future, I will also be mad if a new common card is printed only in a Secret Lair, but that risk maybe can be avoided in other ways, for example with Wizard teams actually talking to each other, because the clear indication from this story is that they don't.

 

We are quite far away from Paupergeddon or other major tournament, i think we have plenty of time to test these cards and ban them if needed avoiding any risk of ruining the experience to anyone, please PFP let us play even if for only a few months.

 

Thanks PFP for you're hard work, I've met a few of you and you all are really nice people (I'm not saing this to convince you :D )


r/Pauper • • Oct 26 '23

META If at the next B&R you hear that 4 cards will get banned — one card from Mono Red, Affinity, Caw Gates, & Terror each — which cards would you guess that would be?

0 Upvotes

r/Pauper • • Feb 14 '22

How do you feel about a cycle of these lands to fix Pauper's mana base problem? Would be too powerful for the format?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Pauper • • Oct 31 '20

OTHER Should Wotc ban all monarch cards?

0 Upvotes

With commander legends bringing all of these new monarch cards into the format and the fact that trim is still not banned I fear that monarch is just to good for the format and like conspiracies in legacy or vintage could and/or should wotc just ban all monarch cards. Please give your thoughts down below


r/Pauper • • Jun 18 '24

Foils are officially worthless for tournament players.

Post image
10 Upvotes

This is one day after cracking my second MH3 pack. Stop printing foils if this is what we have to deal with.


r/Pauper • • Jun 12 '18

FUD Stop saying "Pauper is not a defined format"

3 Upvotes

Pauper is what you can play on MTGO with its card pool and its own banlist. Whatever you play that is not in accordance to this is not Pauper. "Why i cannot play this card if it is a common?" Because Pauper is not the format of all commons.


r/Pauper • • Aug 07 '24

Arbor Elf?

2 Upvotes

I’ve been playing Gruul Ponza in the last few weeks and mostly found myself disappointed by the Arbor Elf. While the effect looks really strong when used on an enchanted forest, it is never useful when needed because the effect is not useable when played but on the next turn On turn 1 you almost always prefer [[Wild Growth]] or [[Utopia Sprawl]] On turn 2, if you played an aura on turn one, you prefer [[stone rain]] or [[thermokarst]] On turn 3, you prefer [[Mwonvuli Acid-Moss]] or [[Writhing Chrysalis]] On turn 4, you prefer any other land destruction card or a cascade creature if the ramp allows it Anything after turn 5 is not really relevant, mana should not be a problem a that point.

I decided to cut 2 [[Arbor Elf]] to add 2 [[Stone Rain]], what do you think about it? Is it wrong ? Is it OK but with something else than [[Stone Rain]]? Here is my list:

https://www.moxfield.com/decks/sFX3e6KuuEWBtIXPJu_MKw

Thanks


r/Pauper • • Sep 21 '26

VIDEO/STREAM 5 Reality Fracture Commons for YOUR Pauper Decks

Thumbnail
youtu.be
9 Upvotes

r/Pauper • • Dec 25 '18

so... bans?

4 Upvotes

i know that this is a very original thread, but i have just looked at the last tournament results on goldfish, i have also look at the % of meta of certain decks, right now "blue black delver" is 18% of the meta, there are other two "delver" decks at around 8% and there is also "inside out" at around 4%. 30% of the meta has to do with blue, last tournament, 7 of the 10 most played spells are blue, and the red one is pyroblast.

something has to happen people, i dont like bans, but this is becoming drake season again and i think that nobody likes that too.

now, lets assume that we have to ban something, something blue, the first thing that comes to mind is gush, probably a good call, others say to ban delver, since all the decks have delver on the name, is also probably a good option, but i am going to present you with a third option, an option for all of you to consider, since is a card that i dont see mentioned almost never as the problem, but i think that is the main issue here. that card is augur of bolas.

augur is simply too good, is an early drop that draws a card and stops early damage from faster decks. but not only that, is algo a geat top deck, all of these decks run 30 instant and sorceries, with augur you see 3 cards, there is almost 100% to see a spell there, and there is a good chance to see 2 or even 3 if you are lucky, you are not only drawing a card, you are usually drawing the one you need the most from 2 or 3 cards, plus a 1/3, all for two mana. that 1/3 can even finish the game if left alone. if for some bad luck you dont see 1 spell, is still great, since you are bottoming all those lands, delver is a deck that can clearly play on two lands and augur stops you from flooding. of course, you can also lose one of your creatures here, but you are more certain to draw into spells like preordain and the like that are also going to dig for those creatures later. also, augur has an etb effect, that makes him not a good target for opponents bounce removal, and also is a great bounce target for you, cards like delver can be stopped this way while cards like augur actually want to be back on hand.

there is simply not weakness from an augur, at best you can break even with it if you can kill him for 2 mana without losing a card from your hand in the process.

im my opinion it should be banned first, when that card entered the meta is when delver started this climb to the top of the meta, before that is was still a good deck, but things like stompy could race it and there was a balance that is now clearly broken, i am only going to ask something from all of the people reading this post. in the future, just look at augur when it enters play and try to imagine that game without it. just do that and you will soon see how absurdly good that card is in the shadows


r/Pauper • • Jun 21 '26

META The current state of pauper

Post image
0 Upvotes

It feels like for a long time Pauper has been considered to be in a “good” place. In my opinion the format has become a bit less diverse and all of the top decks are either hardcore aggro decks or midrange slop, mostly artifact / artifact bridges based. Combo hasn’t played a large part in the format (maybe that will change with the new bow seeker combo) mainly because every time there is a good combo deck in the format it gets banned because players aren’t ready to adapt. As for control, it’s almost nonexistent aside from skred/ ephemerate decks.

White feels like the worst Color by a mile, with only two decks in the top 15 of the meta, I think it’s because it doesn’t get good card advantage spells, but that has been the case forever, I don’t really know if it’s ever not been the worst because I’m still kinda new. (played for around two years) I would like to see some more strong white commons getting printed.

What do you think could be Changed? Whether it’s new designs / bans.
I think if the bridges get banned the entire format will have to change and maybe that’s a good thing?

IDK I’m just kinda sick of playing midrange and aggro.


r/Pauper • • Jan 24 '25

OTHER The format feel stale to me. Am I the only one?

0 Upvotes

I was really happy about MH3 because it brought many new and strong decks to the format, giving it a breath of fresh air. Problem is, after its release the format felt stale to me as I always see the same decks being played at my locals: Jund Wildfire, Glee Combo, Mono Red and Affinity. Up until november I was fine with it, but after more than 2 months of having to play every week against the same decks I got bored to the point I don't even wanna partecipate to my locals anymore. The fact that the latest banlist didn't shake things up in any way, even by just unbanning one or two cards, didn't help either.

Don't get me wrong, I love pauper as I feel the format is one of the most skill intensive since you get to play with really basic cards and have to squeeze the most out of these simple cards in order to make good decks. But since WotC generally doesn't care about giving pauper strong new cards, focusing commons to be more limited oriented, the decks that see competitive play are almost always the same for a very long time, and I feel that, lately, this problem feels bigger than ever to me (with "ever" meaning the amount of time I've been playing this format, so around 2-3 years).

I'd really like WotC to design common around pauper playability too, just like they release new cards which are focused to be played in formats like modern and commander. I know pauper is not an official format, but there's no doubt it is a loved and played one by many players and one of the most recognized. I know pauper is not much monetizable as they're all commons, but some more support even in draft sets would be appreciated.

Honestly, I'm genuinely not having that much fun anymore playing this format, and I'm really sad about it. This doesn't want to be a rant. I just want to know if to anyone else the format is feeling stale as it is for me too. Up until some new, strong decks are brought out, I think I might take a break since I don't want to feel forced to play a format I'm not having fun with. I repeat, I love pauper, but I feels it also would benefit it to receive some love from WotC too and get some concrete support from them.


r/Pauper • • Jun 20 '20

META Mystic Sanctuary needs to be banned

6 Upvotes

Like the title says I think mystic sanctuary is just too good for the decks using them. U/B delver was already the best deck in the meta and having this land along with Deprive and Tragic Lesson it makes the decks way more consistent and gives both card advantage and temp advantage. I think the two spells that utilize it on their own are great cards and should be played still but combined with this land it just takes the fun out of Pauper. Playing MTGO is a nightmare because ¾ decks I play are Mystic Sanctuary heavy. Can someone please convince me otherwise?


r/Pauper • • Jul 30 '26

PFP Town Support Please!

Post image
1 Upvotes

Pauper is rich with archetypes built around a suite of lands:

- affinity & metalcraft decks are built around artifact lands

- tron decks are built around Urza's lands

- Poison Storm is built around depletion lands

Wouldn't it be fun to have decks built around the town subtype? It could be as simple as one good card that cares about towns. eg, nobody would play gates without [[Basilisk Gate]]. Nobody would play snow-covered lands without [[Skred]].

[[Adventurer's Inn]] *already* sees play...

Dear WotC - please provide town support at common. ☺️


r/Pauper • • Jul 25 '25

OTHER [Petition] Ban the Marvel cards from Pauper — Universes Beyond is going beyond reasonable limits

29 Upvotes

Look, I love Pauper. I’ve been playing it before sanction, before online, and currently most people are because it feels like one of the last formats where the game still resembles Magic: The Gathering, not “Spider-man vs. Spongebob featuring Gandalf Riding Optimus Prime with the Thundercats Sword.”

But this Marvel set — specifically some of the cards legal in Pauper — has completely disrupted the tone and feel of the format. For example, playing against Spider-Man in white weenie is not only immersion-breaking, it feels like a joke. And not the good kind. These cards weren’t designed with Pauper in mind, or even mtg, just profit and it shows.

There are already tons of complaints online about gameplay inconsistencies and weird cards that are the same but dont have the same name, and this just makes it worse. We’re mixing power creep with IP creep, and the format is suffering.

Pauper should remain Pauper. It’s grassroots, clean, and coherent. These Marvel cards are a blatant cash grab, and while that’s WOTC’s prerogative, we as a community should get a say in what kind of format we want.

Universes Beyond is starting to cross the line. Let’s draw it here. Ban the Marvel cards from Pauper.

Would love to hear your thoughts — and hoping we can get some visibility on this.

879 votes, Aug 01 '25
598 I also hate it
281 I like spider-man in the format