Hello! Ever since Edelman was making the "Should he be in the Hall?" rounds on ESPN, I think some of us Patriots fans have been doing something really wild. It seems at least twice a month I'm in comment sections seeing talk about Edelman being superior somehow to Welker. This is an absurd comparison, and it's unfair to make towards Jules. People are making these arguments because they want to mask that they "like" Julian more. That's fine. You can like him more, but you can't factually say he was a better receiver nor can you factually say he contributed more to the Patriots success.
Now - let me state my case here. Wes Welker contributed more to the Patriots, and more to FOOTBALL as a whole than Julian Edelman has. Wes Welker is also a better receiver than Julian Edelman, and it's not close.
The reason I say Wes has contributed more to the Patriots and is a better receiver is for the same reason. Yards. Receptions. Touchdowns. Playoff stats.
What is the job of a receiver? 1. Get open. 2. Catch the ball. 3. Get yards and score points.
**Welker: Reg season:**672 Receptions, 7,459 Yards, 37tds Playoffs: 69 Receptions, 686 Yards, 4tds Edelman: Reg Season: 620 Receptions, 6,822 Yards, 36tds Playoffs: 118 Receptions, 1442 Yards, 5tds
Looks pretty close, stat wise for them right? Where Edelman really gets the edge is in the playoffs. Here's the thing.... Wes Welker's stats are over a 6 year period. Edelman's stats are over an 11 year period. So on a game-per-game basis, Welker contributed more to the Patriots than Edelman did. Contribution meaning balls caught, yards gained, points scored. Welker played in 4 playoff runs with the Pats. Edelman played in 9 playoff runs. If Welker played in more than double the seasons as Julian did, his stats would likely be better.
What is not the job of a receiver? Winning playoff games or Superbowls.
The prevailing argument here is that Julian Edelman is a "better Patriot" or a better player because he helped win/won more Superbowls. This is an argument you would not make, and an argument that has NEVER been made, for ANY Wideout ever. No one is saying "Randy Moss, Megatron, and Julio Jones aren't as good as Julian Edelman. They never won a Superbowl." Why? Because everyone understands it's not their job to do that. Quarterbacks? Sure. That's all good. Not wideouts. Not any other position.
But Edelman made clutch catches!
Yes, he did make some clutch catches. so did Wes Welker his entire career. Every 3rd down felt like a foregone conclusion when Wes Welker was on the field. Edelman also led the league in dropped passes from 2018 til he retired. Edelman drops a lot of passes. Welker has dropped a lot of passes. It happens. They're smaller guys with smaller hands. David Tyree made a clutch catch, no one is singing his praises for the hall of fame. Sometimes you get lucky with them, sometimes you don't (and we all know, as Pats fans, we often don't get lucky with them.)
I'll wrap this up with another note. Wes Welker revolutionized the slot receiver role. He was the most proficient, most productive, most dominant player to ever play that role. He was part of TWO of the greatest offenses to ever touch turf. No other player has been able to replicate that success.
There is no comparison. Julian was a great player. We've had great players (Deion Branch, Troy Brown) at the receiver position during our championship runs. It's ok to like a certain player more. It's cool to say "I'd still put Julian Edelman on my team over Welker." You're allowed to like one player over another for any reason you choose, but when it comes to "Who was better." Wes Welker earned that respect.
TLDR; Jules isn't Wes. Stop comparing