r/Pathfinder_RPG • • Jul 07 '15

[META] This sub has a severe problem with toxicity

0 Upvotes

To start, I'm very angry and disgusted with this sub, but I am going to temper that so that I can keep this discussion calm and rational, because I know yelling and calling names never helps anything.

I think the best way to describe this problem isn't to describe it at all, but rather to just let you look yourself. Go ahead right now and click the "Controversial" tab for this subreddit and tell me what your thoughts are. Because this is what my thoughts are:

This subreddit has a major problem downvoting for no reason. And not just "well I don't really like this" or "I don't think this belongs here", but actively going through and downvoting EVERYTHING an OP posts, no matter what it is.

Here is one example. The entire post is downvoted to the negatives, and when OP tried to respond they got downvoted too. Alright, maybe the community just really hates homebrew, even when the OP still can be helped...

The same happened here in this post as well. Neither of those needed to be downvoted to the negatives, and the comments that each OP made in either of those really had no reason to be downvoted.

Why? All this does is drive away people. Actually, no, it does more than that. When you downvote something, you're stopping others from seeing it. Others who may have had something useful to contribute.

By far the best example though is at the top of controversial right now. This post with the crowdfunding request. EVERYTHING the OP posted got shunted down in the negatives. I can't quite tell what the post overall is sitting at but it's low enough in the negatives that it's got to be at least -10.

We are NOT a huge subreddit. A -10 means a post gets thrown to the 3rd or 4th page of this subreddit.

Can anyone explain this to me? Like, I can understand people not liking someone asking for money on here (actually, pause... no I can't. It's a subreddit dedicated to a BUSINESS PRODUCT that constantly has people selling new books, third-party publishers posting new stuff for sale, dice makers and figurine manufacturers and TONS of other people trying to sell you things all the time.

Someone tries to run a study over this game that we are all here to love... wait, scratch that, not just A study, but one of the ONLY positive studies I've ever seen relating to an RPG. Do you not realize most academic studies over RPGs have been "Does playing DnD cause people to break from reality? Are RPGs harmful for children? What sort of longterm damage does roleplay cause?" So what if someone wants money for that? That sounds like an awesome cause to try to recruit money for. If you don't want to give someone money, at least freakin' don't hide it so nobody else who would've given doesn't see it. For a site that claims to be so academic and LOVES peer-reviewed science, it sure doesn't seem like it.)

But if you don't like something an OP posts, and it's not breaking any rules, why downvote it so hard? Take a look at the crowdfunding post. People were clearly interested in it, at least some people were. There were a bunch of people asking questions. Yet EVERYTHING the OP posted got downvoted into the negatives so far that they're automatically hidden for my settings at least.

ALL THIS DOES IS ALIENATE OUR MEMBERS. Even if YOU don't like something, when you and 15 other people downvote it, you're not doing anything but lowering the chances of someone who does want to see it from seeing it. When a post gets 5 downvotes in the first hour, it's shunted so far off the front page that the only people who will see it are people sorting by New, or someone clicking 4 or 5 or 6 pages deep... Or like the 3 comments at the bottom of this post that were just chiming in like everyone else, buried with their -2's and -3's. The worst part is that's not even a huge downvote. "Hey can anyone share this thing?" "Sure here I'll share my thing" DOWNVOTED. I'm seeing 79 users here right now, and yet 1/10th of that number can't look at the negatively-voted posts and say "Hey maybe I should at least upvote this back up to +1"?

And when someone comes here with a rules question or rules dispute, oh my god they better be damn sure they have read every single thing that has ever been published about the matter or god forgive them. How many times do you see someone say "Oh hey THIS is they way I think this rule is to be interpreted" and then someone else says "actually no check this post from XYZ"... only for the first commenter to be sitting at -25 or more because they dared to have offered the wrong answer. I'm not saying you have to upvote everything, or even to upvote a wrong answer to +50 or something, but when you downvote it that hard that fast you're just discouraging any sort of community building.

When you use the downvote button as an "I disagree" button, and when others don't upvote the heavily downvoted comments to fix this, you make this a hostile, toxic community.

We should be supporting ALL things Pathfinder. We should be helpful to EVERYONE who comes here, even if you disagree with them (ESPECIALLY if you disagree with them since it's so easy to just ignore and let other people deal with it. You don't have to LOVE every single post that's here and try to downvote to oblivion everything you don't love.)

People say the default subreddits are shit, but the niche subreddits are where you find the quality stuff. Not here. Not in this subreddit. This subreddit is toxic, and it was the only real reason I stayed around reddit. I love Pathfinder, I love reading interesting things about Pathfinder, I love having people to bounce ideas off about Pathfinder. And I hate the way this subreddit treats their own members and fans.

Maybe Voat will be better. Maybe this subreddit will clean up its act. Mods, you can probably help that by removing the downvote arrow entirely (because honestly on this sub, what NEEDS to be downvoted? If its so bad that it should be downvoted, it probably breaks a rule and needs to be just deleted anyways). Maybe one day this will be a less toxic place. And I might check back in on it then. But I can't stand what this place is anymore and I'm deleting my reddit account.

Thanks for good times, those of you who were helpful and friendly over the years.


r/Pathfinder_RPG • • May 23 '24

1E Player GMs - Why do you still run Pathfinder 1e?

0 Upvotes

When the game is praised the only thing you ever see people talk about is "character options" and "customization" and "builds". It is almost a robotic response (though a genuine one). Sure, it makes sense that certain players enjoy that.

But those running the games, especially those with experience in AD&D 1/2, OD&D and other fantasy RPGs that are less burdensome on the DM/GM, what is it about running PF1e (or even 3e or 3.5), that keeps you coming back despite the long, dense monster stat blocks that need cross referencing, the unending conditional modifiers that can convolute combat and everything else that makes the game more difficult to run at higher levels, especially if you want to run a more freeform/sandbox game with less prep. Heck, monsters built exactly like PCs? That was exciting to me in the early 2000's and it made sense, but I'm starting to realize I use less and less of the options that this design made available as I get older.

Disclaimer: I am only playing devils advocate, and myself mostly run a 3.5/3e mix, still mostly enjoy it and have my reasons. But I've been questioning those reasons after many years and am putting this out there to see where others are coming from.

EDIT: Lots of PF2e and 5e responses and comparisons, I have no interest in those games. My interests are specifically in 3.x, AD&D 2e and a few other D&D adjacent fantasy games. So no need to justify PF1e vs PF2e or 5th edition. I'm with you there.


r/Pathfinder_RPG • • Feb 20 '25 Bravo This

Other The two different audiences of Paizo NSFW

34 Upvotes

I feel that my opinion on second edition is a lot like Sarah Z’s opinion on the Mean Girls musical. It’s good it got rid of some of the racist and sexist crap but it also appeared to softened the edges a bit two much.

Yes with second edition they did try to get rid of the shitty racist stuff but also went a bit too far when it came to trying to soften any potential edges. Beliving that villains doing problematic things makes something problematic.

It reminds me of what Sarah Z said in her Mean Girls the musical video.

They did change some of the shitty parts but also got rid of the bite.

1D4chan of all places has a pretty good analysis on it

Contradictory Tone One weird thing about Golarion is that, when Paizo was starting out, they decided to market themselves not only as the "true heirs to 3.5", but also as "the mature D&D company" - touching upon subject matter that the bigger, more public WotC couldn't or wouldn't dare.

Initially, as part of their blatant pulp-styled setting, that meant they went for a much more grimdark tone to their world. In a manner closer to D&D's Sword & Sorcery ancestors, the world of Golarion is really fucked up; ogres are depraved, sadistic, inbred cannibals right out of a hillbilly slasher film, one of the main evil deities promotes miscarriage, mutation and bestiality, another main evil deity is the goddess of lust, cannibalism, and necrophilia, body horror runs rampant, slavery is legal in many major countries, one country is basically Nazi Germany controlled by devils, the Gods of Good can be (and usually are) deeply morally flawed...

But then, somewhere along the lines, they realized there was another audience also looking for "mature" D&D content: the social progressives crowd, who wanted a D&D world that more overtly tackled political matters. So, Paizo decided to fill their world with things to appeal to them. Ethnic minority pride? Well, how about the fact that not!Africa is the oldest, most unbroken seat of human civilization on the planet, was never conquered by any other human nation, and is even one of the original founders of magic amongst humanity. Sexual minority representation? Homosexuals and transgender people are everywhere amongst the NPCs and the game's iconic characters.

Now, this is not exactly a happy marriage. The progressive fanbase tends to look down on the pulp fanbase with sneers of disgust; witness the controversy over Erastil for one of the earliest examples of this. In return, the pulp fanbase scorns the progressives as gutless and wanting to "hugbox" the setting, until it becomes as bland and PC as they find D&D itself. Unfortunately for the pulp fans, it seems the progressive fanbase may have won; 2e has "moved on" with Golarion such as good-aligned goblins joining mainstream society, open rebellion in Cheliax, slavery is not only no longer around but not allowed to be written about, and a reforming Grand Lord on the throne of Taldor which may put some pretty major nails in Paizo's coffin, given that the pulp fanbase was the original foundation for their setting's success.

At the same time, there were plenty of voices even before the PC elements were introduced arguing that the "mature" content was just edgy for edge's sake, so who knows what the general public wants? And it's not as if having racial diversity somehow inherently exists on a competing end of the spectrum from grimdark.

That is, until 2023 when Paizo released their new "Remastered" OGL-less books. In addition to removing alignment, law/chaos damage, and other 3.5e holdovers, the creators have declared that not only will they never be mentioning Drow again, but that in fact any mentions in prior books about Drow were just shit made up by a lying Pathfinder Lodge member and any Drow you may have allegedly met in prior adventures (such as Second Darkness or Abomination Vaults) were in fact disguised lizard people. Needless to say, this has resulted in massive amounts of skub and is in competition for the lamest-ass media retcon since Rise of Skywalker or Warcraft: Shadowlands.

But, strangely enough, there's good reasons to move on from the Drow from a business perspective - copyrightable ones. With Pathfinder firmly moving away from being a D&D clone with the Remaster to its own license, ditching aspects like Chromatic dragons and drow and trying to establish their own brand and mark on fantasy isn't a terrible idea.

Ultimately, like much of 2e, it's coasting on playing the "Well, 5e is worse!" card, not unlike 1e before it. At least Paizo's generally done a good job breaking even banking on Wizards to pump out massive unforced errors... Click to expand... It seems that Pathfinder cultivated two different fan bases one of mostly white thirty and up fantasy tabletop fans and the other side the newer audience of TTRPG that came with Critical Role. That is more diverse and associated with Tumblr who where attracted to queer themes but are as whole not into more dark and gritty fantasy and transgressive themes.

Not saying that the "classic TT Gaming sphere" never included minorities and women. But broad audiences.

It leads to weird clashes like one of the early adventures having the BBEG be stated in the interduction to be conceived when an Archdevil possessed his father and then raped his mother and now when I saw someone on the Pathfinder 2E subreddit discuss "SA Vibes"

On another note I despise the term "SA" it's abbreviating a term that's already used as a cleaner up less harsh version of Rape and it's so vague that it can refer to non consensual groping to full on penetration of gentaila with a knife.

It reminds me of Hazbin Hotel and how a subset of the internet hates Viziepop for daring to have shows set in Hell have edgy jokes.


r/Pathfinder_RPG • • Jul 25 '22

1E Player Hot Take: high point buys in Pathfinder 1E are not needed, or even necessarily a good thing

0 Upvotes

(I am speaking specifically of First Edition, as I know the maths is a lot tighter in 2e)

I hear a lot of claims that the 15 (standard) and even 20 (high fantasy) point buys are too low for playing Pathfinder. I've even heard people (who for some reason, think that they know better than Paizo) claim that 25 (EPIC FANTASY) is too low.

I fundamentally disagree with this, for a few reasons, which I will go over.

I think 15 is a perfectly reasonable sweet spot for most campaigns, with 20 being better for very intense campaigns where players are expected to face an extreme challenge, and are (within the scope of the story itself) exceptional far beyond a normal adventurer, with 10 point buy being better for campaigns which go in the opposite direction.

Reason 1: world building and coherence:

As I have elaborated upon in a previous post, a point buy of 15 already makes each player a pretty exceptional person, with a point buy of 10 "merely" being heroic. Your adventurer is the class valedictorian and the village football (or Golarion equivalent) team captain. You are one of the biggest fishes in the pond. Most people you have met in your life are going to be weaker than you in at least one respect (survivorship bias means that Constitution will rarely be a low score in adults, but anything else is fair game).

That's already somewhat tricky to write around, but not impossible. Bilbo Baggins was perhaps exceptionally charismatic, braver than most hobbits, but he was recognizable as an ordinary person. By contrast, when we get to point buys of 25+, we cannot be Bilbo Baggins. We can't write our backstories as Bilbo Baggins's. We aren't mostly normal people who either longed for adventure, or found ourselves thrust into it.

No, we're Clark Kent. We're superbeings who grew up amongst comparative insects. Really THINK about what a +25 Point buy for, say, a human Magus would mean. If you want to bring both int and strength up to 16 (with your racial +1 going into one of them), you're as strong as Halfthor Bjornson and as clever as Einstein. How do you write that backstory? Think how much that constrains you in writing your backstory! You aren't a normal person, you're an anomaly.

And that's if you aren't doing some wild minmax where you jack some scores up to 20 and reduce others to 5. My first Ever Pathfinder character was written as a weird mutant specifically to justify how odd his scores were (it was a game with a custom 30 point buy).

It simply becomes very hard to RP as a character who is THAT FAR BEYOND the average person.

It can make sense in some campaigns, but if 25 or higher is the norm, it becomes a lot harder.

Reason 2: Trivialising ASIs

Every character, every creature, from the lowliest commoner to the most formidable adventurer, receives a +1 to the ability score of his or her choice every fourth level.

This (over the maximum possible lifespan of the character, 1-20) is less than the difference between standard and epic point buys. Getting an extra point is just inherently less exciting when it's so trivial next to what you are starting with. Instead of representing a significant growth in your abilities, it becomes... trivial.

For the same reason, high point buys make the age-related stat changes less meaningful. Normally, in 1E, as creatures age, their Strength, Dexterity, and Constitution decline, but their Intelligence, Wisdom, and Charisma rise to compensate. This is interesting, and does a good job at showing the difference between how young and old adventurers might operate.

With a really high point-buy? It doesn't matter. Age has little to no impact, the veteran spy is not substantially wiser than the hotheaded young assassin he chases, and the brash criminal has no meaningful advantage in physical agility.

Reason 3: it ISNT a necessity for characters who play tactically

2E gets a lot of praise for emphasising the teamwork elements of its system. Flanking, aid another, various circumstance and status boosts... the thing is, 1E has them too! It arguably has MORE of them!

in 1E, you can get a +1 for attacking in melee from an elevated position, a +2 from flanking (+4 with the right feats), and a +4 for attacking a prone target (technically a debuff to the target's AC). That's way more than 2E would permit! With clever tactics and planning, a party can set up a massive advantage for rolls.

So why doesn't 1E have this reputation of being a great game for tactics and teamwork? I think it's largely because so many people play with higher point buys that it doesn't matter, combined with rolls being binary yes/no situations. You either hit or you don't, going beyond the AC/DC rarely (excepting edge cases like demoralize checks) provides an advantage.

As a result, many characters just focus on their full attack, hitting as many times as possible. They don't reposition to higher ground, or coordinate with allies, or work to mitigate enemy defences... because they don't need to, they can just work out which rolls they'll need the most, and jack up the associated stats.

How often, in your games, do you aid another member of your party's attacks, or their armour class? I rarely do it myself, unless; A: I am playing a specialised character who gets very big bonuses doing it, or B: I am in a low point-buy game, and it's worth spending my action on.

If we assume that the system was built around a 15 point buy as standard, then no wonder these options are rarely used, a lot of people are playing with the equivalent boosts built right into their characters from the get-go, without the designer's intent!

The same is true of spellcasting.

By design, a spell needs 10+the spell's level in the associated stat to be cast.

Even a full-range spellcaster such as a Sorcerer or Wizard, should be just fine with 19 in his or her casting stat, and that only becomes necessary at 17th pr 18th level! This relates to the ASI point from earlier.

A wizard gets 3rd level spellcasting (requiring an intelligence of 13) at level 5, AFTER the first ASI. This means that the wizard could easily start the game with 12 Intelligence, still much more intelligent than most people, about at the level of the average electrical engineer. They absolutely do not need astounding, once-in-a-generation, borderline-superhuman IQs at the start of the game!

"Guy who is substantially smarter than most people, but not so smart that people would want to study his brain after death" is a perfectly good backstory for a wizard!

This wizard would, however,m have to select his or her spells more carefully, tailoring them to the weaker saves of the enemy he or she expected to face that day, instead of being able to use his or her favourite spells, brute-forcing the saving throws with stat-inflated DCs. This is how Wizards tend to be described in most of the fiction which inspired D20 gaming, like the Jack Vance novels! The lower stat buy is actually CLOSER to the core concept of the stories!

Conclusion:

There are absolutely some cases where a higher point buy makes sense, and some tables where it's more fun. However, I hope I've shown that it certainly isn't needed for the system to work, and it really shouldn't be considered the default way to play the game.


r/Pathfinder_RPG • • Jan 13 '25

1E Player Voicing a different ethnicity, OK or not?

29 Upvotes

So I am having an argument with a player, I literally have no idea if I am right or wrong on this.

I played Pathfinder Kingmaker on PC and loved Ekundayo the Ranger who was a person of colour, great NPC and great voice. I am playing Pathfinder as a player and my Character is called...Ekundayo! I created him as a homage to my favourite character but created my own backstory to fit our game. I am an escaped slave (captured at 14) from the Mwangi Expanse who became a street urchin in Sandpoint before being arrested and rather than going to prison I became a Black Arrow... Yes I am playing Rise of the Runelords and this character joins at the appropriate Black Arrow juncture (Spoilers as free as possible)

Now, Ekundayo learnt Common at 15 when he escaped so would talk, like Ekundayo in the PC game, with an accent of Mwangi Expanse which as a gaming group we agree sounds like Nigerian or Angolan. Is it wrong for me to voice him being a white guy? One of my players says it is and I have been asked to revert to my posh east London/ mildly Mancunian accent but to me that completely changes the character. "Nah mate, I was captured in the Mwangi Expanse innit" I think I am voicing a character, much like my DM/GM does when different races are encountered and am not doing a comedy voice, I am literally doing a cross between Nigerian and English. I have a muse for this too with a work colleague who is from Nigeria and mixes her accent with Mancunian and also says she can't see an issue.

Thoughts and advice please.

UPDATE: So after reading the comments I decided to discuss it with someone very wise, my 10 year old daughter. She gave this sage advice: If you do it and make her unhappy thats not very nice of you.

Yep. At the end of the day it is a game and I have a lot of fun playing it with my friends so if one of them is unhappy with something I'm doing then I'll stop. Simples. Ekundayo is now Angus and is a Scot. I get do do a voice and she gets to complain how bad I sound but doesn't feel uncomfortable. Win WIn.


r/Pathfinder_RPG • • May 12 '22

Other Anyone bothered by Ghlaunder being referred to as male?

4 Upvotes

I know complaining about incorrect sexual dimorphism to a dark god in a Fantasy world is pretty pedantic. but i’m that pedantic.

in real life only female mosquitos drink blood. the males just drink nectar. and i know Ghlaunder isn’t actually a mosquito but they appear as one.

so why can’t they be gendered as female?


r/Pathfinder_RPG • • Mar 24 '23

1E Player What are your favorite 'Bedroom' spells? NSFW

0 Upvotes

I realize this might be a raunchy question, but I was curious to hear everyone's opinion on some fun, funny, or creative uses for spells in the bedroom. Here is a small list that I have compiled so far:

Unseen Servant - You'd be surprised by how much fun you can have with a '2 strength', invisible, and mindless servant.

Haste - Casting this on yourself (and not your partner) can literally give you the speed of a jackhammer.

Waves of Ecstasy - instant satisfaction, and targets multiple partners too. Works best if you encourage your partners not to resist and fail their saves.

Invisibility - its basically like a fancy blindfold, and definitely useful for teasing and surprising your partner.

Fly - You can have sex while floating in mid-air! Just think of all the crazy positions you can enjoy.

Enlarge Person - Indulge in your 'Lady Dimitrescu' fetish, or just enjoy the...ahem...size bonus.

Reduce Person - For people who enjoy the 'short stacks'.

Secure Shelter - Conjure forth your love shack.

Conjure Carriage - Conjure forth the shag-wagon.

Bountiful Banquet - Nothing sets the mood like good food and lots of booze.

And of course almost any 'polymorph' effect is great for adding variety to the bedroom as well, but what do you guys think? Got any other cool spells to suggest?


r/Pathfinder_RPG • • Feb 26 '13

Well I found out where NOT to buy miniatures from, Paizo, I want to support you but 30+ days for 4 miniatures...

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/Pathfinder_RPG • • Apr 16 '20

Other [META] There's not always a right answer, and it's never the most important thing

4 Upvotes

I am sick and tired of trying to help new players on this subreddit only for people to insult me for my interpretation of the rules. I have spent the better part of a decade memorizing thousands of feats, spells, rulings, changes in those rulings, and builds - it is rare for me to find a rule I've never seen before. That does not mean I am even close to fully understanding the game - in fact, I readily admit to when I've missed something on a regular basis, and can be convinced to change my interpretation in the presence of such evidence. The fact that it happens, is in fact, part of the beauty of the game. Unfortunately, the way people respond to this has ruined my experience in this subreddit completely.

First off, it's on average like 90% irrelevant to my comment. Either most of my advice is completely untouched by the ruling, or the possible rulings have already been addressed, or both. I have lost track of how many times I've pointed out that a conversation has moved entirely beyond the realm of actually being useful to the player, and still, it persists.

Second off, this is a DM-driven game. Something doesn't even have to be possible AT ALL by RAW for it to be allowed in a game. If the RAW is even a little bit unclear, and even when it's not but it's reasonable RAI, then there is no harm in suggesting it to a DM.

So, I've started to disclaim my comments with "as always, ask your DM", but this gets totally ignored on a regular basis. There are real human beings claiming that the only thing that matters is one right RAW. Well, English is an ambiguous language. Given that Rules As Written is based on a subjective language, it is impossible to always have an objective answer. It is entirely possible and even common for a phrase let alone a paragraph to have multiple meanings. At best, FAQs can clarify these, establishing an official intent, yet even those are written by writers that, as we all know, are fallible and make frequent mistakes. So stop acting like there's only one right perspective, or even if there is, that it's the only thing that matters.

Lastly, these discussions wouldn't be so bad if they didn't turn sour a completely unacceptable majority of the time. It literally doesn’t matter how I start the conversation, or how many times I acknowledge the points of the other person, a majority of the time all I get back is “I’m right, you’re wrong, you’re stupid.” There are no concessions. There is no compromise. You're lucky if you don't get straight up insulted, or just told "you're wrong" with zero consideration of anything resembling an argument in 300 condescending words.

Now, I can admit that I have lost my cool in some of these conversations. I can't say I have no role or blame in this. But the core issue is that this subreddit seems to normalize holding being "right" over being helpful. At the same time it is unbelievable and wonderful that there's pretty much always people up to give build advice, it is unbelievable and awful that half of these people are looking to pick a fight and "win" for their own ego, not to help.


r/Pathfinder_RPG • • Aug 03 '18

2E Can we just take a moment to appreciate the effort put into representing women in RPG's in the new Pathfinder Playtest

1 Upvotes

In the new Pathfinder Playtest Rulebook, every single pronoun used to describe an undetermined person is always "her".

Talking about the GM ? It's always "her"

An undetermined character? It's "her".

From everybody in the RPG community, thank you for making that effort!


r/Pathfinder_RPG • • Sep 11 '23

2E Player Why do so many people hate alternate ancestry boosts and ban them, not letting players use them to truly express their character?

0 Upvotes

Why do so many people hate alternate ancestry boosts and ban them, not letting players use them to truly express their character?

It is baffling how many people I encounter who not only hate alternate ancestry boosts but actively ban and disallow players to use them, forcing players to play stereotypes/monoliths instead of letting them have freedom to craft the character they want to play, and forcing them to play ancestry stereotypes like uncharismatic socially awkward dwarves or dumbass uncivilized Iruxi

Not to mention some people raise issues with locked unchangable ancestry boosts with things like biological existentialism

Discord Westmarches like Broken Lands: Three Kingdoms and The Mysterious Island (run by tevelas on discord) force players to play stereotypes like socially awkward dwarves or unintelligent uncivilized iruxi

There was also This guy who was arguing against Alternate Ancestry Boosts, and when I defended it I got downvoted

Most people I’ve met in D&D like Tasha’s Custom Origin rules

So why are there so many people against AAB in PF2e? Do people really think forcing players to make monolith characters is fun?

I use the word monolith a lot because in Paizo’s post discussing alternate ability boosts, Paizo said that ancestries aren’t a monolith, hence why they made that errata


r/Pathfinder_RPG • • Feb 10 '15

Oh so it's that time of year where we have to address horrendous downvote practices again huh?

0 Upvotes

Seriously we have to do this every few months?

If it's pathfinder, don't downvote it. If you see something pathfinder getting lots of downvotes, upvote it.

I see 168 subscribers here now. Yet the "new" is filled with heavily downvoted very pathfinder related material. My own post got 6 downvote a in 30 minutes, and no upvotes. Why? There are members here. What are you guys doing? If you want a good community, upvote what belongs. Don't downvote things you disliked for no other reason.

I feel like this conversation has to come up WAY too often!


r/Pathfinder_RPG • • Jan 27 '26

1E Player New Player here, Are Spellcasters really significantly weaker in Pathfinder compared to other TTRPGs?

0 Upvotes

Me and my friend group are completely new to Pathfinder, but have played DnD 5e before.
Where in DnD a wizard could throw Firebolts for 1D10 fire damage as a cantrip my Arcanists best damaging cantrip is Acid Splash for 1D3...
I haven't found and good damaging spells for first level either.
Again the DnD comparison,
Lvl 1 evocation spell, 90ft range, 1 action.
3D8 damage of any type +1D8 per spell level above first.
And in Pathfinder I have, Corrosive Touch, A melee spell that deals 1D4 dmg?
I understand that it scales with the caster level and that at fifth level it's a first level spell that deals 5D4, but in the early game I feel it is useless to even fight and not just healbot when the Rogue dealt about 10dmg every turn.


r/Pathfinder_RPG • • Jan 01 '26

1E Player Does anyone still roll to confirm crits?

2 Upvotes

I'm just kind of curious.

I tried playing 2e but did not like the system and switched back to 1e. However, there /were/ many thinks about 2e that I liked, namely no longer having to roll to confirm crits and instead its just beating their AC by 10 or 9 depending on the weapon/feats/etc.

Me and some DMs I've seen incorporated this into 1e and never have looked back, any feats that helped confirm crits now just increase damage. This also works great for PbP games where if someone scores a crit we don't have to wait a day or two for them to come back just to roll again- not to mention the anti-hype for rolling to confirm and not getting it anyway.

I'm just curious what does the community at large think of the 2e way of confirming crits.


r/Pathfinder_RPG • • May 06 '24

Other Tell me why I should try Pathfinder

1 Upvotes

Hi all,

I've been DMing 5e D&D for some 5 or 6 years now with the same consistent group. I've tinkered with other systems (mostly Powered by the Apocalypse based things, though I did play around a bit with the Witcher TTRPG) and found myself homebrewing things for 5e D&D more often then not because the game just didn't have rules for whatever niche thing my group was doing (ranging from traveling rules, to throwing grenades that create surfaces similar to those in the Divinity Series, to playing cards).

I've got one player who swears that pathfinder is the most overly complex system she's ever seen and is a nightmare to even try and hit something because you need to know 17 different ACs. And then I've got another player begging me to run the next major storyline of our multi-year campaign in pathfinder 2e instead of 5e D&D, as (according to her) it has way more versatility.

For context on the games we play, we're story and RP heavy (plenty of sessions don't see combat at all if the players are clever), but I'm always annoyed by 5e's rather lackluster social encounter and exploration mechanics. We're playing in a heavily personalized version of 5e D&D's Faerun and intend to keep in that world for a long while.

So tell me, why should I play pathfinder? I'm interested in the system, but I don't know much about it beyond what those two players I mentioned. They've both played some pathfinder, but admittedly not much. I want to hear from some experienced folks why they find the system fun, and why it works for their group (or, why it absolutely didn't work for their group).

And my second question: HOW do I get into Pathfinder? What books should I read as the DM, are there any youtubers/streamers/etc with a lot of helpful context, and what's your biggest tips for someone looking at this system for the first time?

Thanks everyone!

EDIT: I just want to thank everyone was all the incredible info they've shared! Y'all are a lovely community. I'm gonna keep picking through the comments and replying to folks as well, but holy cow this post got more attention then I figured it would.

EDIT2: those folks in the comments who said the first player was likely playing PF1E and not PF2E - thank you! She thought she'd played 2E, but when we sat down to look at a 2E sheet (under the intention of her telling me exactly what she hates about the system), we realized she had actually been playing 1E back in the day. 2E seems like a much more manageable beast for my group.


r/Pathfinder_RPG • • Aug 13 '15

IMPERFECT DICE ARE NOT AFFECTING YOUR GAMING EXPERIENCE IN ANY WAY AT ALL

10 Upvotes

There have been so many posts lately about how to test your dice, which dice are more biased than others, et cetera ad nauseum.

IT DOESN'T MATTER. AT ALL. You are not going to have any sort of different gaming experience with these different dice out there. It doesn't matter if one has a 1% bias, 2% bias, 10% bias. It doesn't matter! Unless you have a dice that lands on the same number every single time, then you're excused from this rant.

But for everyone else, stop worrying. Stop caring. It doesn't matter.

Even if you have a dice that has slightly more weight on the 1 side, or a big empty bubble right under the 20, let's really REALLY critically analyze what that would mean. It would mean that, from the exact same starting position and with the exact same force, at the exact same angle, on the exact same surface, the die would land on the same number everytime. But you're not throwing dice under those conditions so who gives a flying fuck.

Now, maybe if you throw under close conditions, same exact starting position with nearly the same force at almost the same angle, then maybe that die's tendencies might effect those rolls over a very very large number of rolls, something in the hundreds of thousands of tolls. Again though, this isn't you and it doesn't apply to your game.

Now, if you have some imperfect dice with bubbles and heavy spots, or even if two different plastics with different densities are mixed causing heavier spots in some areas (Jesus what a stupid fucking conspiracy theory...) and you're grabbing one or two or a handful, and shaking them around, dropping them on a table, putting them in a dice roller, whatever... Here's what I think you people are thinking: these biased dice, thrown in the completely random and unpredictable situations, are going to come up as 1 specific number more from those many variations of different conditions.

That's not how it works. That's not a fear that should be worried about. You're not being cheated out of more 20s because of a bubble in your dice. THE SMALL IMPERFECTIONS IN YOUR DICE ARE NOT GOING TO BE STATISTCIALLY NOTICEABLE TO YOU THE WAY YOU PLAY RPGS.

You are putting enough randomness by shaking a dice and throwing it to completely disregard whatever densities or bubbles or weighting is on the die in question. It won't matter. You're not going to have your game turn out any differently. It's still just abstract math that you have very little control over (unless you somehow perfectly control physics, angles, the force at which you throw, the exact position the die is in when you drop it, etc) and that isn't having any long term effect on your game.

Stop worrying about it. Stop trying to find perfect dice. Stop falling prey to extremely well known psychological phenomenon (holy shit you mean your brain remembers bad rolls when they were really serious a lot more than you remember bad rolls for mundane or unimportant things??)

Just play the game. The dice are fine. You're fine.


r/Pathfinder_RPG • • Oct 28 '23

Lore Atheist???

0 Upvotes

Ok so my character doesn’t praise a god, he’s seen plenty of evidence they’re real and believes in them all, but he doesn’t devote himself to one or praise one, what would that be called


r/Pathfinder_RPG • • Dec 19 '23

2E Player Are stone creatures immune to electrical attacks?

0 Upvotes

Hey stupid noob question here, but are stone creatures immune to electrical attacks in Pathfinder 5e? I haven't seen anything to necessarily indicate as such, but I am kind of using pokemon logic here.


r/Pathfinder_RPG • • Oct 10 '14

My player gave an amazing speech and then he made this diplomacy roll. I am a bad D20.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Pathfinder_RPG • • Nov 20 '25

1E Resources Change My Mind: I don't like elephant in the room

0 Upvotes

I was thinking about Elephant the other day, and realized I've never really heard any strong arguments for it. My natural reaction to seeing it, is that it gives half the fighter class to everyone for free, and is geared towards the "god tier at level one Chosen One/Heavily Munchkin'd" type players. Which is not my personal preference for play-styles (or players when I'm GM).

My only concessions in that direction are that I allow Precise Shot to be taken without a pre-req and to replace Point Blank Shot as a pre-req for other feats. I also always allow the Trapfinder campaign from Mummy's Mask to be taken as a general trait when not playing Mummy's Mask. These two rule changes allow ranged to be viable at level 1 (without being a human or fighter), and eliminate the need for a Rogue/Ninja at level 1.

Beyond that I feel feat progression as written by Paizo allows for the different levels to feel different. Level 5 feels stronger than level 4, level 7 feels stronger than 6. Elephant in the room makes every level up just be about BAB, saves, and magical abilities. It tries to make combat feats not matter, which in turn makes Fighter that much less relevant, because everyone can do much of what a fighter can do.

Am I missing something, or is Elephant geared to the "Chosen One" player builds? I know Elephant was all the rage for a few years, but that seems to have died down somewhat. Anyways I would like hear the best arguments from the pro-Elephant crowd, since I really haven't had this believe of mine challenged.


r/Pathfinder_RPG • • Jun 09 '24

1E Player It’s time to get racist

57 Upvotes

What’s the best race? The worst? Though I haven’t played one, Fetchlings seem to have some really cool racial traits. I hate their stat bonuses, I love STR/WIS based characters too much and charisma is my eternal dump stat, but their spell like abilities and alternate racial traits make them pretty damn cool and worthwhile for certain character concepts. Plus, the Plane of Shadow is pretty badass!

Aside from that, tieflings are probably at the top for me. Hellspawn in particular are pretty cool (hail Asmodeus), especially with the racial traits that make them a bit more monstrous in appearance.

Worst race? Though they’re mechanically robust and well fleshed out, the Skinwalker is highly disappointing to me for one small, petty thing: their aesthetics amount to some feral and animalistic features on a discernibly human frame. Of course, appearance can be decided between players and their DM, but I personally like to try and stay faithful to the source as I can before trying to ask for special text-bending.

What’s your favorite race, and what’s a race you wouldn’t touch with a ten foot pole? What are some lesser known races you like that may not be commonly available (the Rougarou, for example).


r/Pathfinder_RPG • • Dec 22 '25

1E Player What is the most Aura Farming class and Race?

4 Upvotes

What’s the coolest class and race combination you can think of? I’m trying to min-max something a bit different than raw damage or optimization, i want to min-max aura. Think characters like Piccolo or Zoro.

I personally think Swashbuckler is incredibly cool. The ability to parry enemy attacks is really badass. (Right now im at level 8 btw) How would you flavor and build such a PC?

Coolest race has to go to Gargoyles, they fly, are made of stone, and i think they are pretty easy to customize flavor vise.


r/Pathfinder_RPG • • 1d ago

1E Resources [1E] Spellbook Generator: print an in-world spellbook for your caster, with a unique magic circle for every spell

2 Upvotes

Ho, Pathfinders!

Kirran is my first Pathfinder character ever, and I think my first wizard, too (there may have been one back in my days of The Dark Eye, the big German RPG). What I definitely had there were clerics with a vademecum, a little in-world prayer book, and I've had a soft spot for rich in-world supplements ever since. On top of that, I'd like to play Kirran at LARP one day, and a LARP wizard needs a physical spellbook: one you can hold, leaf through and read a formula from.

There was one more problem: Kirran knows far more spells than a wizard usually does (close to 400). A book that size is useless if you can't find anything in it, so it had to be searchable, too. In the end I built a tool that writes the book: what the formula for fireball looks like, what you say, what your hands do, and what the previous owner scribbled in the margin.

Spellbook Generator: free, runs in your browser, nothing to install, no account. Source code on GitHub.

What it does

  • A page per spell, written in-world. For each of the ~3,000 PF1e spells the generator draws a magic circle and writes the spoken formula, the gestures, a bit of magic theory ("why does this work?"), a three-phase casting procedure and marginal notes from the book's owner. Cantrips get half a page, an nth-level spell gets n pages.

  • The circles follow rules, not random noise. Every element means something: the core seal shows the school, the knots show the spell level, the rings show range and duration, a gate marks the saving throw, hatching marks spell resistance, cornerstones show V/S/M/F. Each spell also gets an "essence profile" (Ignis, Aqua, Vis, Mens, Spatium …) that colours the circle. Click any circle and it explains itself layer by layer. Similar spells look related, and if you play long enough you'll learn to read them.

  • Prints like a real book. A5 (or A4 two-up), with a table of contents, chapters per spell level, running heads and page numbers. It can split a big book into several volumes, print single spells as scrolls (circle on the front, formula and rules on the back), and print a separate Rules Volume with the actual rules text, numbered to match, so you can lay it next to the in-world book at the table.

  • Made for big books. Search and filter your own book by name, level, school or essence, jump straight to a spell, use the clickable table of contents, bookmark a spell by its address, and split the printed book into volumes of equal thickness.

  • Daily preparation. Fill in your slots, prepare spells from your book, tick them off as you cast, "new day" after resting. Each game day gets an in-world date, and there's a log with stats (most-cast spells, "often prepared, rarely cast").

  • More than wizards. Paladins and clerics get a breviary with generated stained-glass windows per spell. Wizards can also get an apprentice's primer, Primer of Circles, that teaches the system of circles lesson by lesson. Devout characters get a Vademecum (a little prayer book of their church) and a devotion journal.

  • Everyday spells. About 70 tiny, hyper-specific, harmless tricks in the spirit of Frieren: Pancake Flip, Sock Match, Just One Ice Cube, Hot Soup, Cool Bowl, that kind of thing. Each is built on an existing low-level spell so it stays within the rules (house rules, clearly marked).

  • English and German. Interface, in-world texts and rules can each be switched separately. The circles are identical in both languages.

The fun part: making it yours

Out of the box the book is written by a neutral, nameless wizard. But everything personal is read from a character profile: who wrote the book, where they learned their spells, which deity they serve, which calendar they use, what they think about their own magic. Spoken formulas can even switch language depending on where a spell was learned. In my character's book, the spells he picked up in the Worldwound are spoken in a different tongue than those from his years in Absalom.

You don't have to write that profile by hand. Give an AI the example profile and a description of your character (ancestry, class, deity, backstory, campaign, tone of voice) and ask it to fill it in. The guide has a ready-made prompt. Kirran, by the way, is an android exploiter wizard in his third life. His notes come from three hands: his first life (a gruff old abjurer), his second (a sickly woman who knew she would forget and wrote everything down for her successor) and him, relearning it all and commenting on both.

📄 Sneak preview: a few pages from his books (PDF) with margin notes in all three hands (German version, which also has pages from his Vademecum of Nethys). And a guide with screenshots, including how to write your own profile with an AI.

Credits, where credit is due

A word on AI: I built this with an AI coding agent, but not by one prompt 5 minute vibe coding. I worked spec-driven (OpenSpec, the specs are in the repo) for 40 hours writing 29 A4 pages of prompts and reviewing results: every feature started as a written proposal with requirements and scenarios, which I reviewed and corrected before any code was written, and a headless-browser test suite checks layout and UI on every change. The circle system, the essence theory, the house rules and the design decisions are mine; the agent did the typing and much of the drafting. To be honest about the texts: I've read and approved the Vademecum in full, but I haven't fully reviewed the generated magic theory in the spellbook yet. If something reads odd, tell me.

It's a hobby project, so expect rough edges (the English in-world texts are newer than the German ones). Bug reports, ideas and "my sorcerer's book should look like X" are very welcome, here or as GitHub issues.

Until we meet on Golarion! 🔮

Spellbook Generator uses trademarks and/or copyrights owned by Paizo Inc., used under Paizo's Community Use Policy (paizo.com/licenses/communityuse). We are expressly prohibited from charging you to use or access this content. Spellbook Generator is not published, endorsed, or specifically approved by Paizo. For more information about Paizo Inc. and Paizo products, visit paizo.com.


r/Pathfinder_RPG • • Jan 31 '24

1E Player Why are magic items so... bleh?

1 Upvotes

I was looking through the lists of Pathfinder magic items, and noticed a couple things.

One, a lot of magic items add in a minor Deflection bonus to AC, or a minor conditional Resistance bonus to saving throws, even though any player able to get those items is likely going to be able to have a Cloak or Ring with those bonuses anyway.

Two, a lot of items that don't do that are just bonuses to different skills or some less-than-helpful spells once per day. Sometimes an ability with a really bad saving throw to resist it. By the time you can afford 14,000 GP for something not essential, nothing important is going to fail a DC 13 Will Save. Random peasants have a pretty good chance to succeed, even.

Three, a lot of items that WOULD be pretty cool are way overpriced. A Halo of Menace sounds pretty cool, an area debuff that stops when someone hits you. That could be used for casters who don't want to get hit anyway, to allow you to passively help out your allies... But it's 84,000 GP for -2 to hit and AC as a Mind Affecting... effect. A Falcon Crown gives you an... ok ranged option a few times per day, you sacrifice a spell slot for 1d4 damage per level of the slot, decent for if you REALLY need to hit something and just don't have any offensive spells left... if it didn't cost 42,000 GP.

This isn't a problem carried over from D&D 3.5, either. You'd have items that cost 1,400 GP that let you teleport 10 feet a couple times per day, a Ring for 5,000 GP that let you place a 10 ft Wall of Force for a couple rounds to do things like block charges or reinforcements, some boots for 1,400 GP that let you attack someone Charging you like you'd Readied an Action if you're holding a 2-handed weapon... 3.5 has plenty of unique Magic Item Effects, enough so that you could fill out all your Magic Item Slots with low cost equipment and still have a pretty good toolkit, compared to Pathfinder's "+2 to a certain use of a skill" or "+2 Resistance against Poison, +2 Enhancement Bonus to Dex, and +1 Armor Bonus to AC" that doesn't stack with any of your existing equipment.

What I want to know is why Paizo decided to make Magic Items so much less... fun, for lack of a better term. It could just be that 3.5 already had those items so there wasn't a point, but 3.5 also already had many things that they ported over to Pathfinder. It might be a game balance thing, but they also let Sacred Geometry into one of the books and that's stronger than most of these items.

I get why they made many decisions that they did, like making Prestige Classes not anywhere close to as needed as they'd been, but this one just confuses me.