r/Pathfinder_RPG • u/[deleted] • Jul 07 '15
[META] This sub has a severe problem with toxicity
To start, I'm very angry and disgusted with this sub, but I am going to temper that so that I can keep this discussion calm and rational, because I know yelling and calling names never helps anything.
I think the best way to describe this problem isn't to describe it at all, but rather to just let you look yourself. Go ahead right now and click the "Controversial" tab for this subreddit and tell me what your thoughts are. Because this is what my thoughts are:
This subreddit has a major problem downvoting for no reason. And not just "well I don't really like this" or "I don't think this belongs here", but actively going through and downvoting EVERYTHING an OP posts, no matter what it is.
Here is one example. The entire post is downvoted to the negatives, and when OP tried to respond they got downvoted too. Alright, maybe the community just really hates homebrew, even when the OP still can be helped...
The same happened here in this post as well. Neither of those needed to be downvoted to the negatives, and the comments that each OP made in either of those really had no reason to be downvoted.
Why? All this does is drive away people. Actually, no, it does more than that. When you downvote something, you're stopping others from seeing it. Others who may have had something useful to contribute.
By far the best example though is at the top of controversial right now. This post with the crowdfunding request. EVERYTHING the OP posted got shunted down in the negatives. I can't quite tell what the post overall is sitting at but it's low enough in the negatives that it's got to be at least -10.
We are NOT a huge subreddit. A -10 means a post gets thrown to the 3rd or 4th page of this subreddit.
Can anyone explain this to me? Like, I can understand people not liking someone asking for money on here (actually, pause... no I can't. It's a subreddit dedicated to a BUSINESS PRODUCT that constantly has people selling new books, third-party publishers posting new stuff for sale, dice makers and figurine manufacturers and TONS of other people trying to sell you things all the time.
Someone tries to run a study over this game that we are all here to love... wait, scratch that, not just A study, but one of the ONLY positive studies I've ever seen relating to an RPG. Do you not realize most academic studies over RPGs have been "Does playing DnD cause people to break from reality? Are RPGs harmful for children? What sort of longterm damage does roleplay cause?" So what if someone wants money for that? That sounds like an awesome cause to try to recruit money for. If you don't want to give someone money, at least freakin' don't hide it so nobody else who would've given doesn't see it. For a site that claims to be so academic and LOVES peer-reviewed science, it sure doesn't seem like it.)
But if you don't like something an OP posts, and it's not breaking any rules, why downvote it so hard? Take a look at the crowdfunding post. People were clearly interested in it, at least some people were. There were a bunch of people asking questions. Yet EVERYTHING the OP posted got downvoted into the negatives so far that they're automatically hidden for my settings at least.
ALL THIS DOES IS ALIENATE OUR MEMBERS. Even if YOU don't like something, when you and 15 other people downvote it, you're not doing anything but lowering the chances of someone who does want to see it from seeing it. When a post gets 5 downvotes in the first hour, it's shunted so far off the front page that the only people who will see it are people sorting by New, or someone clicking 4 or 5 or 6 pages deep... Or like the 3 comments at the bottom of this post that were just chiming in like everyone else, buried with their -2's and -3's. The worst part is that's not even a huge downvote. "Hey can anyone share this thing?" "Sure here I'll share my thing" DOWNVOTED. I'm seeing 79 users here right now, and yet 1/10th of that number can't look at the negatively-voted posts and say "Hey maybe I should at least upvote this back up to +1"?
And when someone comes here with a rules question or rules dispute, oh my god they better be damn sure they have read every single thing that has ever been published about the matter or god forgive them. How many times do you see someone say "Oh hey THIS is they way I think this rule is to be interpreted" and then someone else says "actually no check this post from XYZ"... only for the first commenter to be sitting at -25 or more because they dared to have offered the wrong answer. I'm not saying you have to upvote everything, or even to upvote a wrong answer to +50 or something, but when you downvote it that hard that fast you're just discouraging any sort of community building.
When you use the downvote button as an "I disagree" button, and when others don't upvote the heavily downvoted comments to fix this, you make this a hostile, toxic community.
We should be supporting ALL things Pathfinder. We should be helpful to EVERYONE who comes here, even if you disagree with them (ESPECIALLY if you disagree with them since it's so easy to just ignore and let other people deal with it. You don't have to LOVE every single post that's here and try to downvote to oblivion everything you don't love.)
People say the default subreddits are shit, but the niche subreddits are where you find the quality stuff. Not here. Not in this subreddit. This subreddit is toxic, and it was the only real reason I stayed around reddit. I love Pathfinder, I love reading interesting things about Pathfinder, I love having people to bounce ideas off about Pathfinder. And I hate the way this subreddit treats their own members and fans.
Maybe Voat will be better. Maybe this subreddit will clean up its act. Mods, you can probably help that by removing the downvote arrow entirely (because honestly on this sub, what NEEDS to be downvoted? If its so bad that it should be downvoted, it probably breaks a rule and needs to be just deleted anyways). Maybe one day this will be a less toxic place. And I might check back in on it then. But I can't stand what this place is anymore and I'm deleting my reddit account.
Thanks for good times, those of you who were helpful and friendly over the years.