r/Patents • u/FirefighterEmpty8498 • Sep 07 '24
Why Making Patents Expensive Undermines Our National Security: A Case-in-Point
If you had an idea which you thought could contribute to our national security, change the nature of warfare, or could perhaps make you wealthy, what would you do? Most likely, the first thing you'd do is investigate the possibility of obtaining a patent. Anyone who has actually gone through this process could tell you that this is not as simple as one might imagine.
The U.S. Government should want for inventors to be able to obtain patent protection as effortlessly as possible. It should want this because the Invention Secrecy Act of 1951 and the International Traffic in Arms Regulations absolutely depend upon an assumption that inventors will run out and obtain a patent, thereby unintentionally notifying the government of potentially defense-applicable inventions.
It was my experience upon promulgating my first invention that I could not afford to patent my concept. Nonetheless, I knew that it could change the world. I decided to share that idea; a concept for a new type of prism which later became part of multiple missile defense systems; online and anonymously. I did this without taking any steps to protect my work and it's a decision which I will never regret. To my surprise, no one tracked me down to ask me to keep the idea under wraps. No "men in black" came out of the shadows to offer me a research job. In that particular case, we got lucky. That particular technology found its way only to the U.S. and a single ally.
I've published 390 papers (and counting) concerning physics, many of which would be considered to be inventions if submitted for patent protection. The trouble is that from a legal perspective, those ideas are not inventions at all until they are patented and even once patented, only the titular inventor (differing from the true inventor in most cases) can be subjected to the codicils of the Invention Secrecy Act.
Amongst these additional inventions were concepts for enhancing the security of computer systems and even a method for transmitting a private key securely, thus overcoming the Alice and Bob Paradox. The ability to do this means that the National Security Agency, for example, would be unable to decipher communications sent using that protocol. In the wrong hands, such information could seriously harm our national security and yet no one has intervened to prevent its dissemination. This is true of at least one quarter of my papers, which are in the public domain and are available here: https://archive.org/details/Collection_of_Ideas_DARPA_Didnt_Want/ Many have already been adopted by researchers in multiple countries. These are the most recent 186. An additional 204 papers are hidden somewhere on the Internet and I will make these additional papers available at a time of my choosing. Many of those original 204 are referenced in the later work and are, frankly, already circulating amongst the parties which need to be aware of them.
In my quest to gain recognition for my ideas, I contacted every university with a physics program in the United States and after having no success, contacted all of those in Europe. Some universities quietly confided that they were reluctant to even look at such ideas for fear of lawsuits and I was even told by one university that they would only conduct research in exchange for substantial grants. Without university credentials and without a patent, it was unlikely that I was going to get noticed.
In February of this year, I unexpectedly received a response from one of the hundreds of universities to which I sent my work. A representative from that university told me that my papers were being disseminated amongst the staff of the university and that I was getting noticed. It was thrilling. The only caveat was that the university which finally responded to my offers was the Saint Petersburg State University.
After thinking about it for a while, I decided that I wasn't surprised that my own country ignored my ideas while one of our adversaries lent an open ear. Two other institutions in Russia; one of which exclusively deals in secret military research; additionally responded to my offers just months later, bringing the total number of Russian entities developing my work to three and the total number of U.S. entities developing them to exactly zero. In most cases, I never even got to submit my work to the American institutions. As such, it is quite possible that Russia has gained more advantage from my life's work than has my own country. Ironically, this was made possible by the very Internet which DARPA developed in order to give our own country an advantage. Russia is now sitting on some truly remarkable new technology and it is because of me. No one has attempted to prevent me from doing this and no one has held me accountable for doing so.
Had patents been more accessible, none of the events I have described would have transpired. There is a solution to this problem and it is threefold: 1.) Suspend the requirement that patent attorneys be utilized in order to prepare patent submissions. 2.) End credentialist policies in the public and private research sector which set forth requirements that researchers must hold degrees. 3.) Make university education entirely gratis for those who have demonstrated both the aptitude and interest necessary to perform work in research.



