r/Patents • • Sep 07 '24

Why Making Patents Expensive Undermines Our National Security: A Case-in-Point

0 Upvotes

If you had an idea which you thought could contribute to our national security, change the nature of warfare, or could perhaps make you wealthy, what would you do? Most likely, the first thing you'd do is investigate the possibility of obtaining a patent. Anyone who has actually gone through this process could tell you that this is not as simple as one might imagine.

The U.S. Government should want for inventors to be able to obtain patent protection as effortlessly as possible. It should want this because the Invention Secrecy Act of 1951 and the International Traffic in Arms Regulations absolutely depend upon an assumption that inventors will run out and obtain a patent, thereby unintentionally notifying the government of potentially defense-applicable inventions.

It was my experience upon promulgating my first invention that I could not afford to patent my concept. Nonetheless, I knew that it could change the world. I decided to share that idea; a concept for a new type of prism which later became part of multiple missile defense systems; online and anonymously. I did this without taking any steps to protect my work and it's a decision which I will never regret. To my surprise, no one tracked me down to ask me to keep the idea under wraps. No "men in black" came out of the shadows to offer me a research job. In that particular case, we got lucky. That particular technology found its way only to the U.S. and a single ally.

I've published 390 papers (and counting) concerning physics, many of which would be considered to be inventions if submitted for patent protection. The trouble is that from a legal perspective, those ideas are not inventions at all until they are patented and even once patented, only the titular inventor (differing from the true inventor in most cases) can be subjected to the codicils of the Invention Secrecy Act.

Amongst these additional inventions were concepts for enhancing the security of computer systems and even a method for transmitting a private key securely, thus overcoming the Alice and Bob Paradox. The ability to do this means that the National Security Agency, for example, would be unable to decipher communications sent using that protocol. In the wrong hands, such information could seriously harm our national security and yet no one has intervened to prevent its dissemination. This is true of at least one quarter of my papers, which are in the public domain and are available here: https://archive.org/details/Collection_of_Ideas_DARPA_Didnt_Want/ Many have already been adopted by researchers in multiple countries. These are the most recent 186. An additional 204 papers are hidden somewhere on the Internet and I will make these additional papers available at a time of my choosing. Many of those original 204 are referenced in the later work and are, frankly, already circulating amongst the parties which need to be aware of them.

In my quest to gain recognition for my ideas, I contacted every university with a physics program in the United States and after having no success, contacted all of those in Europe. Some universities quietly confided that they were reluctant to even look at such ideas for fear of lawsuits and I was even told by one university that they would only conduct research in exchange for substantial grants. Without university credentials and without a patent, it was unlikely that I was going to get noticed.

In February of this year, I unexpectedly received a response from one of the hundreds of universities to which I sent my work. A representative from that university told me that my papers were being disseminated amongst the staff of the university and that I was getting noticed. It was thrilling. The only caveat was that the university which finally responded to my offers was the Saint Petersburg State University.

After thinking about it for a while, I decided that I wasn't surprised that my own country ignored my ideas while one of our adversaries lent an open ear. Two other institutions in Russia; one of which exclusively deals in secret military research; additionally responded to my offers just months later, bringing the total number of Russian entities developing my work to three and the total number of U.S. entities developing them to exactly zero. In most cases, I never even got to submit my work to the American institutions. As such, it is quite possible that Russia has gained more advantage from my life's work than has my own country. Ironically, this was made possible by the very Internet which DARPA developed in order to give our own country an advantage. Russia is now sitting on some truly remarkable new technology and it is because of me. No one has attempted to prevent me from doing this and no one has held me accountable for doing so.

Had patents been more accessible, none of the events I have described would have transpired. There is a solution to this problem and it is threefold: 1.) Suspend the requirement that patent attorneys be utilized in order to prepare patent submissions. 2.) End credentialist policies in the public and private research sector which set forth requirements that researchers must hold degrees. 3.) Make university education entirely gratis for those who have demonstrated both the aptitude and interest necessary to perform work in research.


r/Patents • • Nov 20 '25

USA Urgent: The Patent Office Is About To Make Bad Patents Untouchable www.eff.org

0 Upvotes

As the title says, the Patent Office is about to make a bad change to the rules. See the EFF's take:

https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2025/11/patent-office-about-make-bad-patents-untouchable

They are going to make the change on Dec 2, so people need to make comments before then.


r/Patents • • Mar 22 '23

Why are there so many ESL patent examiners?

0 Upvotes

How did the USPTO end up with so many examiners that seem to not be native English speakers? It seems to be a much larger ratio than in other government jobs


r/Patents • • Apr 11 '24

r/patentexaminer mods removing posts with reason "makes the agency look bad"

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/Patents • • Nov 10 '23

Has anyone tried hiring an overseas lawyer from let's say a third world country to get you a US patent as a way to save money? If so, how did it go?

1 Upvotes

US patent lawyers seem to be pricey compared to other countries. Although it's true that US patent lawyers may have more experience with US patent law, I'm sure the third world country patent lawyers have experience with it aswell since it's usually the country that most people want to patent in.

Anyone with experience can share?


r/Patents • • Sep 03 '22

Patents are a joke

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/Patents • • May 01 '23

If I saw something in another country, can I patent it as an invention in my country?

0 Upvotes

This said product is currently not available in my country, so since nobody has filed for a patent in my country can I do it?


r/Patents • • Feb 20 '23

USA I need advice on how to make a patent easy for competitors to copy

0 Upvotes

Let me explain.

I work in cybersecurity and we have invented something that significantly reduces the likelihood of becoming a victim of a phishing attack. I would be very happy if other companies may implement this idea as well to make the internet safer for everyone.

Well, my employer doesn't think so and has instructed me to file a patent on it instead.

Unfortunately, I have to comply, but I would like to hear your tips if there are ways to make this patent easily copyable by others without infringing the patent. I was thinking about adding a few obscure details that are not really needed or something like that. Any advice?


r/Patents • • Aug 11 '24

Jurisprudence/Case Law Big Tech’s abuse of the patent system must end

0 Upvotes

r/Patents • • Dec 22 '22

How do patent attorneys research an innovation that they’ve never heard of?

0 Upvotes

I’ve asked colleagues this on many occasions, and Wikipedia is often mentioned.

Wikipedia is having its end of the year fund drive. Support it.


r/Patents • • May 18 '25

Inventor Question Highschooler Trying To Create A Patent

1 Upvotes

Hello, everyone, I came up with an idea for a product (I ain't trying to get it in the public domain), but I was wondering if anyone could help me find resources that could help me get a patent. Patents are expensive, and coming from an upper-middle-class family who said they WOULD NOT help me pay to patent anything, I was wondering if there are any resources that I can use to help get one. I know I won't qualify for the pro bono program as my family makes too much to qualify. Also, any recommendations on how to do a patent search by myself first to fully know it has not been patented, as I have looked on Google and tried using Google patents, but I just get a ton of results that have nothing to do with my idea.


r/Patents • • 27d ago

Why not go with the cheapest attorney?

0 Upvotes

I saw a comment from someone that said they wouldn’t just recommend going with the cheapest attorney. Why?

Aside from that, what criteria would you use to pick the right attorney then?


r/Patents • • Oct 23 '24

"Comprising" - Can someone help me understand this part of a claim

0 Upvotes

When an independent claim is written like this:

"I claim:

  1. A sandwich comprising:

a. two slices of bread;

b. a layer of peanut butter applied to one of said bread slices;

c. a layer of jelly applied atop said peanut butter layer;

d. a layer of marshmallow fluff applied atop said jelly layer;

e. the other of said bread slices positioned atop said marshmallow fluff layer."

"Comprising" means the invention includes but is not limited to the elements listed.

So does this mean the patent covers all possible sandwiches? What if the sandwich was made without the peanut butter and jelly - would it still be covered/protected by this claim?


r/Patents • • Apr 17 '22

Opinion | Save America’s Patent System

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
2 Upvotes

r/Patents • • May 05 '25

[Urgent] I need advice on filing a solo patent by myself and potential competitor

0 Upvotes

Hello, I am in the process of filing a solo patent by myself that will be relevant to a business I'd like to build around the intellectual property. I come from a computer science background (CS PhD) and I can write about the technical specifications of the patent in great detail, but I understand there is legal nomenclature that should be included to represent all varying 'embodiments' of the proposed system and methods.

I've gained some interest in the general concept/direction I'm going into from potential investors/clients (I shared the 'what' not the 'how') and I'd like to protect this as soon as possible. I'm thinking of first filing a provisional patent on my own to get an early filing date because there is someone who actually began threatening to steal my IP and do their own business – this is a longer story, but essentially I shared my IP with someone I wanted to work under me and they were upset when I no longer to work with them. I also have documentation of all the ideas I've shared with them, but this is still concerning as I don't know who they are in contact with or who is advising them.

I was thinking of filing solo to have an earlier filing date and avoid legal fees. I'd use ChatGPT o3 (ChatGPT plus) to help me add the legal nomenclature I'd need for a *first* provisional.

I'd like to hire a lawyer for a follow-up patent to the original patent within the next few months, but I'd like to see if filing solo in this way is feasible given that I have the technical knowledge to do this.

Please let me know and any help is appreciated on this matter! Thank you!


r/Patents • • Aug 13 '25

Practice Discussions Which country is the best when it comes to patent applications and grants?

0 Upvotes

Looking at the numbers and statistics, China is definitely leading when it comes to applications and enforced patents, and they’re also contributing the most to international patents. But I’ve also read that China’s patent quantity doesn’t always reflect quality, so I’m curious who you think produces and enforces the most quality and highly innovative patents (as of now)?


r/Patents • • Sep 07 '25

R&D engineer who made 600+ MVPs, First time applying for a patent (UK IPO), do I really need an agent, or can I go solo? I’ve attached samples of my work to demonstrate my skills, my patent ideas have not been disclosed yet.

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Hi everyone I am a UK Masters graduate 2024 with a strong technical background I have built 600+ MVPs for startups and R&D engineer (Embedded systems Mechatronics Robotics) and published 10+ international journal papers But here is the thing I have never applied for a patent before in UK.
This is my first time applying through the UK IPO I have read the official gov site but I am not sure if the process is truly as straightforward as it is described or if in reality it is more complicated.
If I follow the IPO step by step process exactly will I still need an agent or agency to apply for my patents How many months takes to approve or reject a patent in real time.
Is anyone else going through this journey Maybe we could connect and move forward together Also does anyone know of any free guidance agencies or charities that support first time patent applicants.
I would love to hear what the real world of patents looks like from those with experience And of course if anyone helps me I will be more than happy to support your technical research in return


r/Patents • • Nov 27 '24

Jurisprudence/Case Law If a name is misspelled on a patent form, does it invalidate the patent?

0 Upvotes

Hi, I’m doing research into the MMR Lancet fraud case, and I had a question about patents.
for those unaware, the MMR Lancet Fraud case was a case of medical fraud that caused a health scare about the joint Measels, mumps, and rubella vaccine’s potential to cause autism. During this period, the lead researcher made a patent for an alternative vaccine, but on it, the co-inventor’s name is misspelled: instead of Hugh Fudenberg, it says Hugh Fundenberg. I was just asking if this would invalidate a patent, or if it would be ignored. Thanks!


r/Patents • • Jun 14 '21

USA How to write a provisional patent?

2 Upvotes

I am having a lot of trouble writing my US utility provisional patent. The one where you have to write the summary, brief description and all the other nonsense. Are there any cheap patent attorneys or agents or videos or software to help me with this?

I am a teenager with no prerequisite knowledge on how to write legal papers and would appreciate some help :).

Also, would getting a patent help me with my college admissions application?


r/Patents • • May 06 '25

Thinking of building a Chrome extension for one-click copying of patent descriptions and claims — worth it?

0 Upvotes

Hey folks, I’m considering creating a Chrome extension that lets users copy the description, claims, or the entire patent content from Google Patents with just one click. No more endless scrolling or manually selecting and cleaning up text.

It seems like it could save time for patent researchers, legal professionals, or anyone doing prior art searches. I’m curious though — do you think there’s a real demand for something like this? Would this solve a pain point you’ve faced while using Google Patents?

Would love to hear your thoughts or feature suggestions!


r/Patents • • Aug 16 '24

What would be your ideal Patent research software?

0 Upvotes

I am a former examiner, and I was thinking of creating a software to help research.

Is there any pain points you have at your current set up?

How do you normally search? Mine would be a combination of keywords/classifications/authors etc


r/Patents • • Aug 26 '24

Patent Visualization Software

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I just started a job as a market analyst and looking for some software that you guys think is beneficial and reliable! I have heard of companies like Patent Forecast where they offer a subscription based plan to access company information, reports, and a patent visualization radian to get bigger insights into what is happening within certain industry sectors but I'm not sure who / what company is the best to use.

Not sure if any of you have heard of this company or others that offer similar services and your thoughts on them! Looking for open and honest opinions and feedback.


r/Patents • • May 30 '24

Make Espacenet and Google Patents Better

0 Upvotes

Hi Power Users of Espacenet and Google Patents,

Sorting through hundreds of search results can be time-consuming. To simplify this process, we've created a project that provides extended summaries, identifies relevant technologies, and highlights how each patent stands out from prior art, etc. — all within the Espacenet and Google Patents search result pages.

This allows search pros to quickly grasp the essence of the search results without the hassle of navigating multiple pages. Get a deeper understanding at a glance and save valuable time.

You can learn more and try it for free at Petapator.com.

Check out a screen capture: https://imgur.com/a/petapator-com-Ugtiz2x


r/Patents • • May 31 '24

This patent I was working on got allowed, but there was no restriction requirement during prosecution? What would you do in this case?

0 Upvotes

the case got allowed but i feel like there could've been a restriction requirement on the case by the Examiner but the examiner didnt give us any restrictions at any point. The claims are pretty broad and theres a mixture of method of making the apparatus and the actual apparatus design itself. Do I just let it go?


r/Patents • • Dec 14 '24

Online courses for patents?

0 Upvotes

Are they actually useful?? I've been seeing a lot of courses online regarding patents but I've never really thought they were good :( lmk ur past experiences

Idk either way I'll be enrolling in this https://www.udemy.com/course/patent-masterclass-a-z-the-only-course-youll-ever-need/ since its free, I'll let y'all know how it is once I'm done with the course!!

Day 1: I LOVE IT, I'm almost done with the course, but it's giving me a lot of details I never knew :0 consider this course if u really need a patent but lawyers are too expensive

Day 2: (Will update soon!)