r/ParentalAlienation • • Sep 25 '23

10 TRUE Things Alienated Kids Won’t Admit..... (from a child survivor’s POV)

248 Upvotes

I’m an adult child of parental alienation (29, f). I figured everything out last year... after being alienated from my dad for twenty years. As I'm sure you can imagine, it has been a painful, confusing, and heart-breaking process since learning the truth. At the same time, however, the truth has allowed me to begin to heal and become the person I've always wanted to be.

I created The Anti-Alienation Project to speak out about this form of abuse. I thought I’d share the link to my most recent video because I’m hopeful some targeted parents might find it helpful :)

10 TRUE Things Alienated Kids Won’t Tell You:

https://youtu.be/4O_rh4sSZto?si=knfa_9VDqAf2hpJZ


r/ParentalAlienation • • Jul 03 '24

Parents Who Have Successfully Fought Parent Alienation Syndrome

40 Upvotes

Introduction:

Nothing stirs up passions more than the controversy generated when parents are at war over the custody of a child. A controversy is an issue where evidence on both sides can make a compelling case. It is never black and white, but when people have their emotions aroused, an issue can quickly turn into two polar opposites. Fear takes over reason, incomplete facts become evidence, and court calendars become jammed with repeat visits to a judge to try to bring sanity to what is unlikely to ever be sane. On top of this, social movements promoting one side over another clamor for justice. Politicians are lobbied to pass laws to bring order to chaos. Gender wars are fueled, and lives are destroyed.

My exposure to custody wars came from the mothers and fathers attending my Breakthrough Parenting classes at The Parent Connection, Inc., an agency I founded in Los Angeles in 1983. Many of these parents were litigating over child custody. Most said that they wanted to settle the case, but none of them would settle by giving up all access to their child, which seemed to be the only alternative open to them. It was disturbing to see that in many of these cases, the child was behaving outrageously, to the point of cursing their parent, kicking, spitting, and calling them "stupid," "mean" and "horrible."

What can you do when one parent is intractable and vitriolic? What can you do when the child becomes caught up in the fight and takes sides? I came to realize that this level of conflict in custody disputes was a fallout from sweeping societal changes.

What Has Changed?

In the 1960’s and through the 1970’s, feminists told fathers that they must take a more active role in raising their children. Women were going to work, going back to college and pursuing careers as never before. A shift then began as fathers became more involved in the day-to-day care of their children than was true in previous generations. While rigidity about parental roles began to fall away, the Tender Years Doctrine was still in place. This doctrine presumed that by virtue of the fact that a woman was the mother of a child, that she must be the superior parent. In the early 1970’s several states passed "no-fault" divorce laws, where anyone who wanted out of a marriage was free to leave. Some have called them the "no guilt laws." There was a proliferation of divorce that was historically unprecedented.

After the breakup of the family, many fathers wanted to continue to be involved with the care of their children. They found that they had no legal right to have custody of their children unless the mother agreed to it. Due to the lobbying efforts of James Cook, founder of the Joint Custody Association, who was caught up in this problem himself, the California Legislature successfully passed the first joint custody laws. Joint custody was widely seen as a better way of handling the evolving problem of how to share child custody. It was believed that it would lead to fewer fights over the custody of children because it was more equal. These laws helped to level the playing field for fathers. Other states also passed joint custody laws. Unfortunately, there still exist states that do not have laws supporting joint custody.

The majority of mothers and fathers welcomed joint custody. Others did not. As with any trend, there was a backlash. Child custody became a highly political, gender-specific issue. Thus, the ramping up of high-level disputes also began in the 70’s. In most states the tender years presumption (mother knows best) was replaced with the best-interests-of-the-child presumption of joint custody (the best parent is both parents). In the 1980’s courts began to increasingly ignore gender in determining child custody, which removed the automatic allocation of full custody rights to the mother, and mothers began to have less time with her children. Instead, courts looked first at how the custody could be shared, and if that wasn’t possible, judicial officers attempted to determine which parent was more interested and better able to attend to the best interest of the child. Fathers perceived that they were at a disadvantage because of a bias toward the mother having custody. Thus, in the 1980’s more fathers than ever started showing up at parenting classes to make sure that their skills were state-of-the-art. This is when these issues were first called to my attention.

Most parents are able to share custody of their children, and they work out childcare issues in an amicable way. A large number of women were relieved to have fathers share childcare. This enabled them to pursue their personal goals involving education and career. However, when there was not a friendly resolution to custody, fathers found themselves with a greater opportunity to gain joint or primary custodial status by litigating. The stakes got even higher when the legal system was used to resolve these difficult problems. In extreme cases, the alienation of a child’s affection against a targeted parent became a bizarre escalation of the intensity of the conflict.

Who Discovered Parent Alienation Syndrome (PAS)?

In association with this burgeoning child-custody litigation, forensic psychiatrist Dr. Richard A. Gardner first identified Parent Alienation Syndrome in the 1980’s. He noticed a dramatic increase in the frequency of a disorder rarely seen before, that of programming or brainwashing of a child by one parent to denigrate the other parent. However, the disorder wasn’t only brainwashing or programming by a parent, but was confounded by what he calls self-created contributions by the child in support of the alienating parent’s campaign of denigration against the targeted parent. He called this disorder parental alienation syndrome (PAS), a new term that includes the contribution to the problem made by both the parent and the child.

What is PAS?

Gardner’s definition of PAS is:

The parental alienation syndrome (PAS) is a disorder that arises primarily in the context of child-custody disputes. Its primary manifestation is the child’s campaign of denigration against a parent, a campaign that has no justification. It results from the combination of a programming (brainwashing) parent’s indoctrinations and the child’s own contributions to the vilification of the target parent.

What is the Child’s Part in PAS?

Gardner notes that the PAS is more than brainwashing or programming, because the child has to actually participate in the denigrating of the alienated parent. This is done in primarily the following eight ways:

  1. The child denigrates the alienated parent with foul language and severe oppositional behavior.

  2. The child offers weak, absurd, or frivolous reasons for his or her anger.

  3. The child is sure of him or herself and doesn’t demonstrate ambivalence, i.e. love and hate for the alienated parent, only hate.

  4. The child exhorts that he or she alone came up with ideas of denigration. The "independent-thinker" phenomenon is where the child asserts that no one told him to do this.

  5. The child supports and feels a need to protect the alienating parent.

  6. The child does not demonstrate guilt over cruelty towards the alienated parent.

  7. The child uses borrowed scenarios, or vividly describes situations that he or she could not have experienced.

  8. Animosity is spread to also include the friends and/or extended family of the alienated parent.

In severe cases of parent alienation, the child is utterly brainwashed against the alienated parent. The alienator can truthfully say that the child doesn’t want to spend any time with the other parent, even though he or she has told the child that he has to, it is a court order, etc. The alienator typically responds, "There isn’t anything that I can do about it. I’m not telling the child that he can’t see you."

Parent Alienation (PA) and PAS are Different

Parent alienation (PA) describes those situations where the child is justified in desiring to alienate himself from a parent, as circumstances where neglect or abuse is present, including molestation or abandonment.

Dr. Doug Darnall in his book Divorce Casualties: Protecting Your Children from Parental Alienation, describes three categories of PAS. The mild category he calls the naïve alienators. They are ignorant of what they are doing and are willing to be educated and to change. The moderate category is the active alienators. When they are triggered, they lose control of appropriate boundaries. They go ballistic. When they calm down, they don’t want to admit that they were out of control. The severe category are the obsessed alienators. They operate from a delusional system where every cell of their body is committed to destroying the other parent’s relationship with the child. In the latter case, Darnall notes that we don’t have an effective protocol for treating an obsessed alienator other than removing the child from his or her influence.

An important point is that in PAS there is no true parental abuse and/or neglect on the part of the alienated parent. If this were the case, the child’s animosity would be justified. Also, it is not PAS if the child still has a positive relationship with the parent, even though the other parent is attempting to alienate the child from him or her.

Which Gender is Most Likely to Initiate PAS?

Gardner’s statistics showed that the majority of PAS occurrences were initiated by mothers. Mothers have traditionally had primary custody of children (in this century), and have usually spent more time with the children. In order for a campaign of alienation to occur, one parent needs to have considerable time with the child.

However, I’ve seen some dramatic cases where the father was the alienator. In one case, the father had no control over his obsession to speak badly about the mother. Numerous professionals told him, including the mother, that he could share custody if he was willing to follow the rules. He didn’t have the self-control to do this. When he lost custody because of his aberrant behavior, he became a cause celèbre in the father’s rights movement and took his campaign into national circles. No one would know from hearing him speak about his situation that there was serious pathology going on (PAS) or how hard many professionals worked to stabilize it.

Moreover, in cultures where women traditionally have no tangible rights, the alienation by the father can be very severe. I’ve met divorcing women who had been prevented from learning how to make a living to support themselves. At the time of separation all access to financial resources was denied and the children removed from her care. These women reported severe alienation of affection. It makes one grateful to have laws that protect human rights and enforce a better way of resolving conflict than a winner-take-all approach.

How Common is PA and PAS?

When parents first separate there is often parent alienation. For example, due to the anxiety of the mother, she is likely to implicitly impart to a child that he or she is not safe with the father. She might say "Call me as soon as you get there to let me know you are okay." "If you get scared, you call me right away. Okay?" "I’ll come get you if you want to come home." Usually this level of alienation dies down after the separating couple get used to changes brought on by the separation and move on with their lives.

However, in rare cases, the anxiety doesn’t calm down, it escalates. PAS parents are psychologically fragile. When things are going their way, they can hold themselves together. However, when they are threatened, they can become fiercely entrenched in preserving what they see as rightfully theirs. Only a small percentage end up in this level of conflict.

Why Do PAS Parents Act Like They Do?

I believe that PAS parents have become stuck in the first stage of child development, where survival skills are learned. To them, having total control over their child is a life and death matter. Because they don’t understand how to please other people, any effort to do so always has strings attached. They don’t give; they only know how to take. They don’t play by the rules and are not likely to obey a court order.

Descriptions that are commonly used to describe severe cases of PAS are that the alienating parent is unable to "individuate" (a psychological term used when the person is unable to see the child as a separate human being from him or herself). The parent is narcissistic (self-centered) and enmeshed with the child (overly involved). Furthermore, these parents presume that they have a special entitlement to whatever they want. They think that there are rules in life, but only for other people, not for them.

A person with these characteristics, they may be called a sociopath, a person who has no moral conscience. This means that they are unable to have empathy or compassion for others. Sociopaths are unable to see a situation from another person’s point of view, especially their child’s point-of-view. They don’t distinguish the way others do between telling the truth and lying.

In spite of admonitions from judges and mental health professionals to stop alienating, they can’t. The prognosis for severely alienating parents is poor. It is unlikely that they will ever "get it." It is also unlikely that they will ever stop trying to perpetuate the alienation. It is a gut-wrenching survival issue to them.

How Does the Child Get Involved in PAS?

At birth, children are totally reliant on a parent, usually the mother, for having all of their needs met. It is part of normal child development to be enmeshed with their primary caregiver, and very young children do not have a separate identity from this caregiver. One of the mother’s roles is to help the child develop as a separate person. Therefore, infancy and childhood become a series of tasks of learning how to become independent. Such as, learning to put oneself back to sleep, eat, toilet train and care for one’s hygiene. Instead of promoting this independence, the alienating parent encourages continued dependence. The parent may insist on sleeping with the child, feeding the child ("It’s easier if I do it"), and taking care of these rites of passage longer than normal child development calls for. This "spoiling" may not feel right to the child, but he or she does not have enough ego strength to do anything about it.

A PAS mother can’t imagine that the father is capable of planning the child’s time while in his care. Therefore, she arranges several things for the child to do while at the father’s house. One of the most common ways of doing this is to sign the child up for on-going lessons without permission from the father. The parent may even decree whom the child can and cannot see, particularly specific members of the child’s extended family on the father’s side. The mother desperately wants control over the time when the child isn’t with her. One of the most unusual situations that I ran into was the father who picked up his sons at 9:00 a.m. on a Saturday for the weekend. He discovered that his very excited boys had their hearts set on going to Disneyland for the day, when this idea had never crossed his mind.

One theory about why a mother will act this way is that when a father takes his share of joint custody is that it is like asking her to give away part of her body. One mother said, "He is going to remove my right arm and take it for the weekend." It feels like the mother has lost a profound part of who she is as a person. She feels fractured, pulled apart.

Why is PAS a Double Bind for the Child?

When children spend time with the father, and enjoy it, they are put into a double bind. Clearly, they cannot tell the mother that dad treats them well or that they had fun together. They want to bond with the father, but don’t dare. They figure out on which side the bread is buttered (who has the power), and their survival needs tug at them. Therefore, children will tell the mother about everything they didn’t enjoy about time spent with the father, which will add to her belief that they don’t like to be with him. These children feel that they must protect the mother. The same is true when the alienator is the father. The child will avoid expressing their affectionate feelings for the mother to him.

Family Volatility

Families with PAS are volatile families. The father may have indeed spanked a child, or lashed out at the mother physically or emotionally. An isolated incidence can turn into a holocaust. One father spanked his rebellious child and ended up in jail on child abuse charges, followed by a six-week trial to determine his guilt. The jury returned with a not guilty verdict in 20 minutes. The verdict didn’t end it as far as the mother was concerned, however.

The alienating parent’s hatred can have no bounds. The severest form will bring out every horrible allegation known, including claims of domestic violence, stalking and the sexual molestation of the child. Many fathers say that there have been repeated calls to the Department of Family and Child Services alleging child abuse and neglect. In most cases the investigators report that they found nothing wrong. However, the PAS parent feels that these reports are not fabrications, but are very, very real. She can describe the horror of what happened in great detail. Regardless of the actual truth, in her mind, it did happen. Most of the alienated fathers I work with are continually befuddled by the mother’s lying. "How can she lie like that?" They don’t realize that these lies are not based on rational thinking. Alienating parents are incapable of understanding the difference between what is true and what they want to be true. A vital part of fighting PAS is to understand the severity of the psychological disturbance that is the source of it.

Intergenerational Patterns

What makes this problem very complicated is that PAS is often intergenerational in dysfunctional families. Almost always the alienator has people within the family who support the alienation. It might be the mother, father or grandparent who encourages fighting. These supporters are likely to assist the alienating parent financially and actually provide massive amounts of money to fund litigation. This is further proof to the PAS parent that he or she is justified in what he or she is doing.

When the Child is Placed in the Role of the Parent’s Therapist

Alienation advances when the alienating parent uses the child as a personal therapist. The child is told about every miserable experience and negative feeling about the alienated parent with great specificity. The child, who is already enmeshed with the parent because his or her identity is still undefined, easily absorbs the parent’s negativity. They become aligned with this parent and feel that they need to be the protector of the alienating parent.

What Happens to the Child When it is Impossible to Stop PAS?

Obviously, without anyone to stop the alienation from progressing, the child will become estranged from the alienated parent. The relationship with this parent will eventually be severed. It is doubtful that, without psychological intervention as the child grows, he or she will ever understand what happened. The child’s primary role model will be the maladaptive, dysfunctional parent. He or she will not have the benefit of growing up with the most well-adjusted parent and all that this parent could contribute to enrich the child’s life. Many of these children experience serious psychiatric problems.

Will they ever grow up and realize what happened to them? Without someone who can recognize the syndrome and counsel them about it, it isn’t likely that these children will ever figure it out. However, there have been exceptions where the child and the alienated parent have been successfully reunited later in life.

How Can Good Intentions Backfire?

Those people who are typically called upon to handle such difficult situations, such as the police, social workers, attorneys or psychologists assume that what the frightened mother is saying is true. These things DO happen. There are men who are seriously disturbed, violent, out of control sexually, and who stalk. There are men who are rightfully feared. The mother is very convincing in her desperation and vivid in her descriptions. The clincher is that the alienated child collaborates with the mother by saying, "Yes, I am afraid of my father." "Yes, my father did touch me down there." "Yes, he does beat me." What would you do if you were faced with having to decide how to protect a child in such a situation?

Therapists

Therapists with master’s degrees are unlikely to realize the severity and depth of the problem, because they are not trained in this level of pathology. In fact, they may unwittingly side with the alienating parent and even testify or produce evidence in court that the child is afraid of the father. This can be a serious stumbling block in getting an accurate diagnosis. Indeed, it can tip the scale into the alienating parent’s agenda and do real damage.

Our courts, social services and mental health workers are all committed to stopping child abuse and neglect when they see it occurring. However, in PAS the most dramatic and the loudest complaint ends up being acted upon before there is an investigation as to the accuracy of the allegation. This allows the alienating parent considerable time to proceed with the alienation. By the time all of the evaluations are in place and the case is heard by the court, considerable damage has been done to the child. It is an irony that the very people we turn to for help in such a difficult situation can often be those who most contribute to allowing the on-going abuse and neglect of the child to continue.

What Can Be Done about the Problem?

First, it takes a sophisticated mental health professional to be able to identify that PAS is occurring. Most forensic evaluators such as psychiatrists and clinical psychologists at the Ph.D. level have studied the disorder and are able to recognize it. Forensic evaluators diagnose PAS by having the parents take a battery of psychological tests, doing a detailed case history and by observation. They make recommendations as to what to do. Once the evaluator has written a report of the family and made recommendations, nothing will happen to resolve the crisis without court intervention.

The alienated parent has to take the report to a judge who must then be convinced that the child is being alienated and that it is not in the child’s best interest to stay in that environment. It is rare that judges have any degree of mental health training. They most often learn about PAS from the bench. It usually takes several trips to court to point out how badly a child is being treated before a judge is willing to act.

How Are PAS Cases Resolved Legally?

Judges are inevitably conservative in their orders. Even when the evidence is overwhelming that the alienation is occurring, the court order may still end up saying, "the parents are to make joint decisions about the child’s welfare," when this may be impossible to do. This is further evidence that the judge doesn’t understand the magnitude of the problem. The judge in one of the most severe PAS cases I worked on was from the old school. He was tired of having the litigants continue to appear before him. One day he said, "Why don’t the two of you go out in the hallway and kiss and make up." This is an example of how frustrating these cases are for judges. Indeed, these are the hardest cases to decide.

It usually takes a dramatic situation where court orders are broken to force the court to change primary custody. Often it is only a matter of time before alienating parents become desperate and their unstable mental health gets the better of them. People in an official position start to recognize the alienating parent as being out of line, and become supportive of the targeted parent.

In one case, the 9 and 4-year-old daughters were abducted and presumed to be on their way to Australia through an underground group that hides women who are victims of domestic violence, often of a sexual nature and where the father is stalking. The girls were missing for 3 months and found in another county where they were waiting for final arrangements to be made before their departure. When the police broke into the house at 3:00 a.m., they found the girls sleeping with their mother. They had been given boy’s names, clothes, haircuts and their hair was dyed. They were not allowed contact with anyone outside of their hiding place, not even to go to school. The oldest had strep throat and the youngest was seriously withdrawn.

In another case, the mother could no longer convince the social workers, the police or the Court about her allegations. She was known to be unstable because she had cried wolf too many times. She abducted her daughter to Utah. She told officials there that the courts where she lived were protecting a proven child molester. The press was called. After she was interviewed; there was a virtual feeding frenzy as the father’s photograph and the story was on all the local news networks. A big part of the problem was that the seven-year-old girl, said "Yes" when asked if her father had molested her. Even though this had already been disproven by forensic evaluators, she was still confused.

Can the Alienation Be Reversed?

As children get older, the alienation can be reversed with proper psychological care. However, it won’t work if the alienating parent is not contained. In the last case described above the mother was given severely limited visiting rights. She had remarried and had a new child, however, she still regularly calls the police to report the father for abuse. Presently, the daughter resides with her father, receives weekly therapy and hates the police. She gradually understands how disturbed her mother is.

In the former case, where the mother was kidnapping the children to Australia she now sees them two hours a month at the Department of Children’s Services with a social worker present to monitor everything she says and does. The girls have also been in extensive therapy and are doing well.

Since this is among the most severe kinds of abuse of a child’s emotions, there will be scars and lost opportunities for normal development. The child is at risk of growing up and being an alienator also, since the alienating parent has been the primary role model.

What is the Best Way to Deal with PAS?

The parents who were successful in getting primary custody of their children in a PAS situation were those who:

  1. Completed a comprehensive parenting course, such as Breakthrough Parenting, and who stuck around until they rated excellent in the knowledge, skills and methods taught there. Thus, their parenting skills became superior.

  2. Were even tempered, logical and kept their emotions under control. They never retaliated. A person who reacts in anger is proving the alienator’s point that he or she is unstable.

  3. Thought of giving up, but never did. No matter how awful the harassment got, they worried about leaving their children in that environment. They were driven to continue trying to get the court to understand the seriousness of the issues and to change primary custody to them.

  4. Were willing and able to go to the financial expense of seeing it through.

  5. Got legal representation from a skilled family lawyer who had experience with parent alienation syndrome. The parent became good at understanding how the courts work and understood the law as it applied to their case. They often ended up as pro-per (representing themselves) because of excessive expenses.

  6. Had a case where a forensic evaluator made a strong statement about the alienation and recommended changing legal and primary custody to the alienated parent. Some parents had to go back to the evaluator to demonstrate that his or her earlier recommendations were not working.

  7. Persevered in demonstrating that they were rational, reasonable, and had the best interest of the child at heart. They provided the court with an appropriate parenting plan that showed that the child would be well taken care of in their care.

  8. Even though they and their children were being victimized, they understood the nature of the problem and focused more on what to do about it. Alienated parents who got caught up in how terrible it all is and spent time judging the situation, went under emotionally. Thus, the successful ones didn’t live a victim’s life. They were proactive in seeking constructive action. They avoided adding to the problem.

  9. One father expressed it like this: "I don’t know how to make it better with the mother, but I do know how to make it worse." He was one of the more successful parents I met in fighting the PAS problem because he stayed in the role of the peacekeeper.

  10. Kept a diary or journal of key events, describing what happened and when. They documented the alienation with evidence that was admissible in court.

  11. Always called or showed up to pick up their children, even if they knew that the children wouldn’t be there. This was often very painful, but then they could document that they had tried, when the alienator alleged that this parent had no interest in the child.

  12. Focused on enjoying their children’s company and never talked to their children about their case. They always took the high road and never talked badly about the other parent to their children. They absolutely never showed a child any court orders or other sensitive documents. They didn’t let the children overhear inappropriate conversations on the telephone.

  13. Didn’t violate court orders. They paid their child support on time and proved that they could live within the letter of the law.

  14. Were truly decent, principled people. It was obvious that they loved their children.

PAS cases are the most difficult to figure out, even for professionals in the field of divorce. Once the syndrome is discovered, it is even harder to figure out what to do about it. It is important to be connected and supported by compassionate people while going through such a difficult time.

http://www.fact.on.ca/Info/pas/major98.htm


r/ParentalAlienation • • 5h ago

I actually don’t know how I’m supposed to feel this level of pain anymore

9 Upvotes

I think I have hit an exhaustion wall.
I am so hurt.
Physically I feel like I could throw up.
Mentally, I am so sad, I miss my daughter.

The guardian ad litem cleared me as safe.
Has called out the other party for their behavior, even used the word alienation.

And still suggested such little time for me.

I am so fucking heart broken.

How the hell does this happen. My whole world is upside down. I cannot handle the grief I am carrying and the grief and anger of my family around me- who are justified, but so angry this has happened to my child and me.

I just need words of encouragement from someone who is in my position, not people who are watching from the outside.


r/ParentalAlienation • • 6h ago

Today is my birthday

10 Upvotes

I have gotten no texts or calls from either of my middle schoolers. I haven’t seen one of them in 7 months and the other one stopped coming to my extremely limited placement time about 2 months ago. In fact, today is one of my placement days. But, since neither come and the GAL says she doesn’t know what else to do, I suffer.

Nine months ago, before I moved out of the house, I was carrying them to bed and we would laugh at the hilarity of me trying to carry them, cradle style, up two flights of stairs. Then i would toss them on their beds. That was the nature of our relationships. Incredibly close, affectionate, and involved. Every bedtime, every school conference, coached every team.

Now? Crickets. Because I made the worst mistake a man could make. I divorced a narcissist who flat out told me “why do you get to decide to divorce me?”. She has made me out to be the bad guy, blamed me for everything, and then went to court and called me “mentally unstable”. That’s right. The oldest trick in the book. No evidence at all. No calls to police. No child services. Nothing. She even said in an email, “I’m begging you to forgive me.” None of it mattered. She exposed the biggest flaw in the system. If you get the kids on your side by exploiting their pain and becoming the victim, it doesn’t even matter what kind of parent the other person is. You will win.

So, if you’re sadistic and don’t care about the long term mental health of your children, you will probably get full time placement and full child support. I couldn’t imagine doing that to kids.


r/ParentalAlienation • • 8h ago

Is there any point?

3 Upvotes

At the moment i vacillate on thinking that i might be able to beat the parental alienation knowing that its coming, at other times I think i may as well have her to him and be done with it because its futile. Are there any parents here who are in contact with thier child who is being alienated? Does anyone feel like they are managing to give their child the skills they need to see through this?


r/ParentalAlienation • • 10h ago

Has anyone had experience with "The Parental Alienation Grief Program (PAGP)"?

4 Upvotes

Interested if anyone has had experience with "The Parental Alienation Grief Program (PAGP)". I can't seem to find any reviews online or if its worth it. Did it help anyone?


r/ParentalAlienation • • 4h ago

Is your parenting plan enforceable?

Thumbnail
tiktok.com
1 Upvotes

A lot of parents will be making this phone call for the first time this year. Have you had to make this call? What was it like for you when you found out how things really are?


r/ParentalAlienation • • 11h ago

Custody Hearing Approaching

3 Upvotes

Quick Summary. My ex & I share custody of a 10 year old child. He moved from our original state when she was only 2 years old and has not returned since. Our child spends breaks and weekends with him in our home state. Recently we agreed she would live with him temporarily in his state while I finish nursing school. The agreement was for her to stay one year. Everything was fine until it wasn't. About a month in from our daughter living there he flipped the script on me. He now controls when she can and can't talk to me. Will not allow me to see her when they visit our hometown and ignores all my messages and calls. With the holidays approaching I'm so worried I won't be able to see her. I almost feel like just driving to where they live, getting her out of school and just bringing her back home. I really don't want to create any traumas for my child so I just stay quiet about everything. I recently went to my home states family court to file a parenting time/custody hearing. We have court next month. I'm wondering will the judge order him to just return the child because of all his immature, unnecessary behaviors? anyone have any experience with this? I feel like he is trying to alienate me from our daughter and it's working. When I talk to her sometimes she seems irritated and upset with me. I really don't know what to think...


r/ParentalAlienation • • 9h ago

THE FATHER WHO WASN'T DEAD The Story of Edward Lee Thornton

2 Upvotes

Hello ma'am, 

THE FATHER WHO WASN'T DEAD

The Story of Edward Lee Thornton and the Family He Left Behind.

A Father Lost, A Truth Hidden!!!!

My name was Laura Lee Thornton and I was only three years old when my father, Edward Lee Thornton, walked away from the family he had helped create.

My little brother, Brian, was just ten months old. Mymother, Rose Marie Whitten  Thornton, was left behind to raise two small children without the man who was supposed to stand beside her, love her, and help her build a life for their family.

At three years old, I was too young to understand what abandonment meant. I didn't understand why a father would leave his little girl or why a baby brother would have to grow up without knowing the comfort of having his daddy around.

I didn't understand the questions that would follow us through the years. I didn't understand the hurt my mother must have carried, or the strength it must have taken for her to keep going while raising two children on her own.

What I would eventually learn was something far more difficult to comprehend.

My father hadn't simply left.

He had gone to extraordinary lengths to make us believe he was dead.

Imagine growing up believing that your father was gone from this world, not because he had chosen another life somewhere else, but because you believed there was no possibility of ever seeing him again.

There is a particular kind of grief that comes with losing someone you never really had the opportunity to know. You grow up with an empty space where memories should be. You wonder what his voice sounded like, what he would have been like as you grew older, and whether he ever thought about the children he left behind.

For years, that was the reality of our family.

My mother, Rose, had to carry on. She had two children depending on her. I was three, and my brother was still a baby. Whatever explanation had been given, whatever circumstances surrounded my father's disappearance, the result was the same: we were left without him.

But the truth has a way of finding its way home, even after years of silence.

Somewhere along the way, we discovered something that changed the story we had been told.

Eddie Lee Thornton was alive.

He was living in Arizona, Sun City Arizona.

The father we had believed was dead was still walking this earth. He had continued living his life, even marrying another person named Angel Thornton while the family he left behind lived with a very different understanding of what had happened.

That discovery brings questions that are difficult to put into words.

Why?

Why would a father allow his children to believe he was dead? Why would he allow a little girl and a ten-month-old baby to grow up without knowing the truth? What could possibly make someone go to such lengths to disappear from the lives of his own children?

And perhaps the hardest question of all: Did he ever think about us?

Years later, another painful chapter would unfold when his mother, Wyllie Thornton, passed away. I made several attempts to have a relationship with her but I was told my family—my mother's family—was beneath hers. My great-grandmother, Lilly Lathbury raised my mother and she was a hardworking, God-fearing woman. My mother's side of the family didn't come from wealth, but it did come from love and hard work and belief in our Lord and Saviour. Then when we read her obituary, information about her grandchildren was listed, but our names were nowhere to be found.

We weren't even acknowledged as her grandchildren.

We have often wondered if that's because Eddie didn't want his current wife to know he had children.

It was another reminder of how easily a family can be erased from the pages of its own history. We were Edward Lee Thornton's children. We were Wyllie Thornton's grandchildren. That relationship did not disappear simply because someone chose not to acknowledge it.

We existed. We had names. We had a mother who raised us. We had a story that deserved to be told.

This is that story.

It is not simply a story about a father who left. It is about a little girl who grew up without him, a baby brother who never had the chance to know him, a mother who was left to raise her children, and a family that eventually discovered that the truth was very different from what they had believed.

A father's absence can shape a child's entire life.

But sometimes, discovering the truth about that absence can change everything you thought you knew.

We were never the ones who disappeared. We were the children he left behind.


r/ParentalAlienation • • 6h ago

My Journey Through Parental Alienation: The Pain, The Evidence, and The Fight to Get My Children Back

1 Upvotes

There are very few pains in life that compare to being slowly pushed out of your own children's lives while you are still alive, still loving them, and still fighting to be their parent.

Going through parental alienation was one of the darkest and most emotionally exhausting experiences of my life. I experienced heartbreak in ways I never imagined possible. Watching my relationship with my children change, seeing them become distant, hearing them repeat hurtful things that I knew did not come from their own experiences, and feeling like a stranger to the very children I had loved and cared for was devastating.

The hardest part was not knowing what to do. I would reach out, try to communicate, arrange visits, and make every effort to maintain that bond, only to face rejection, hostility, accusations, or obstacles. There were moments I questioned myself. I cried privately, struggled with anxiety, lost sleep, and wondered whether my children would ever understand how much I loved them.

On top of the emotional abuse, I had to deal with a former partner who used manipulation, intimidation, and controlling behaviour to undermine me as a parent. It felt as though every attempt I made to be involved in my children's lives was turned into another reason to paint me as the problem.

But eventually, I realised something important: I could not afford to let my emotions be the only thing speaking for me. I needed evidence.

I started documenting everything.

Every denied visit, every unanswered message, every threat, every incident of intimidation, every attempt to interfere with communication, and every situation where the children were put in the middle of adult conflict. I saved text messages, emails, call records, relevant correspondence, and kept a detailed timeline of events. I also gathered independent evidence that helped establish the pattern of behaviour.

I stopped relying on verbal promises and started keeping everything in writing. I made sure my own communication remained calm, respectful, and focused on the children's wellbeing, even when I was being provoked.

It wasn't easy. Revisiting painful messages and incidents sometimes reopened wounds I was desperately trying to heal. But I understood that if I wanted the truth to be recognised, I needed to present facts, not just emotions.

Eventually, that documentation became a crucial part of my legal case.

The evidence helped demonstrate a pattern of controlling and abusive behaviour, the interference with my parental relationship, and the ways in which the other parent had been undermining my role in the children's lives. It also helped challenge the image they had tried to create of me.

After everything I had endured, I finally achieved a custody outcome that allowed me to rebuild my relationship with my children and protect their wellbeing.

I won't pretend that winning in court erased the pain. It didn't. The emotional scars, lost time, and memories of being separated from my children cannot simply disappear. But it gave me something I had fought so hard for: the opportunity to be present in my children's lives again.

To every parent currently experiencing parental alienation, please hear me: don't give up, and don't underestimate the power of documentation.

Keep records. Save messages. Record dates and incidents. Keep communication in writing wherever possible. Follow court orders, remain composed, and avoid reacting in ways that could be used against you. Seek professional and legal support, and make sure your evidence is organised, factual, and relevant.

Don't manufacture evidence, exaggerate incidents, or use your children as witnesses in your conflict. Let the facts speak for themselves.

Most importantly, don't allow someone else's narrative to define who you are as a parent.

Parental alienation can be incredibly difficult to challenge, but you are not necessarily powerless. Evidence can make a real difference, and courts can recognise harmful patterns of behaviour when they are properly established and supported.

I am sharing my story because too many parents suffer silently, believing there is no way out. There is hope. There are legal avenues. And with the right evidence, professional guidance, patience, and persistence, it is possible to achieve a better outcome.

You don't have to fight with anger. Fight with facts. Document everything. Protect your children. Never stop acting in their best interests.

One day, the truth deserves to be heard. And your children deserve the opportunity to have a healthy relationship with both parents, free from manipulation, fear, and emotional pressure.


r/ParentalAlienation • • 8h ago

Narcissistic mom trying to sue me over "grandparent rights"

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/ParentalAlienation • • 8h ago

Filing next week. NYC. Contested. Need all the heads up.

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/ParentalAlienation • • 8h ago

​Looking for pro bono / low-cost family law resources in Lafourche Parish (Lockport) to enforce a standing NY custody order

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

I’m a father going through a high-conflict divorce and custody battle, and I’m looking for guidance on finding free or low-cost legal representation in or around Lockport, Louisiana (Lafourche Parish) who can help me enforce standing court orders out of New York.

​To give some background: my wife and I have been together for 12 years (married for 10) and have three kids—two girls and a boy. Neither of us is perfect, and I’ve always owned up to my mistakes, but infidelity is a hard line for me due to a personal tragedy I experienced growing up. Despite that, she cheated multiple times over the years. I stayed and forgave her for the sake of our kids because being a present father has always been my #1 priority.

​Eventually, she went down to Louisiana, had another affair, and when I insisted she come back to New York so we could address our marriage, our kids, and separating our lives properly, she returned and filed false paperwork against me.

​Due to ineffective counsel on my end, my case in New York was badly mishandled:

​My attorney failed to submit clear, documented evidence and sworn depositions that contradicted her claims.

​The judge improperly led her during testimony, and my lawyer didn’t object or use her contradictions to protect my parental rights.

​I was pressured into a settlement I explicitly told my attorney I didn’t want—one she is now using as a weapon against me—forcing me to jump through hoops despite her having zero evidence.

​I am currently filing grievances with the bar association and judicial review, and I’m having to file motions pro se (on my own) in New York while trying to learn the law as I go.

​Where things stand now:

​She has taken our three children to Lockport, Louisiana, and completely cut off my court-ordered phone calls and visitation. The last time I was allowed to speak to my kids was October 8th or 9th.

​Local police in Louisiana told me they cannot enforce our standing New York custody/visitation agreement unless a Louisiana judge formally recognizes it.

​Her new partner is actively trying to alienate me from my kids, even telling me he stole my wife and that my kids will soon be calling him "dad."

​I know her exact address in Lockport, but I am staying completely away and handling this strictly through the courts so I don't jeopardize my future with my children.

​My biggest concern right now is jurisdiction:

I know she can't legally establish custody jurisdiction in Louisiana until the kids have been there for 6 months, especially with an active NY order in place. However, I’m worried she is going to try to file for divorce there behind my back and use a default judgment or procedural loophole to claim jurisdictional rights—forcing me into an endless, expensive battle between Louisiana and New York courts just to see my babies.

​I have documented proof of everything, and I’ve been an involved, everyday dad since the day my kids were born. I am desperate to protect my rights and get my court-ordered contact restored, and I cannot afford a massive retainer right now.

​Does anyone know of legal aid organizations, pro bono programs, or family law attorneys in or around Lafourche Parish who handle interstate custody/UCCJEA enforcement and might be willing to take on a case like this—or point me in the right direction for getting my NY order registered there? Any advice or local resources would mean the world to me.


r/ParentalAlienation • • 1d ago

Im done. Its over

15 Upvotes

Hi all, time for me to admit it is over.

I’m losing my kids this week. The whole case has been clearly rigged from start.

A judge who won’t look at evidence of maternal influence, who won’t look at the past and 4 years of violation

A psychologist who says alienation occurred, yet writes prevention in the report

Don.A lawyer who is a former colleague of the judge

A frankly corrupt quashing of my exes conviction for defying contact (which we got in August after 7 months) - which was so egregious the national head of appeals fast tracked it. As victims we were not informed of, and received the verdict during the trial.

I’m now being offered one 10 min call fortnightly, and 4 hrs in public with no third parties including wife or kids. I’m not a danger, not a risk, and police checked and cleared in 8 countries

Help me make sense of this…because it’s destroying me inside now


r/ParentalAlienation • • 1d ago

From alienated child POV part 2

25 Upvotes

Motivation: Adult Children of Parental Alienation - Dr. Amy J. L. Baker

Hello lovely parents,

I hope you're all doing well. I understand that this journey can be incredibly difficult. Some of you have endured parental alienation for decades, while others are only beginning to experience it.

I've written in this forum before, and I hope to continue sharing insights from the perspective of an alienated adult child. I recently read a chapter from Dr. Amy J. L. Baker's Adult Children of Parental Alienation, and I thought some of its findings might be helpful.

Having looked at the accounts of adult children, a few recurring themes stood out:

1. The targeted parent should have fought harder for the relationship.

This was perhaps one of the most consistent themes. Many adult children felt that their targeted parents gave up too easily, particularly when they eventually stopped calling, writing, sending cards or making other attempts to maintain contact.

Interestingly, this remained true even among children who had explicitly rejected the targeted parent. They might have insisted they wanted nothing to do with them, yet still felt hurt when the parent eventually respected that decision and walked away.

For many, it was experienced as abandonment rather than respect for their wishes.

2. The independent thinker phenomenon.

One particularly interesting aspect of parental alienation is what is sometimes described as the independent thinker phenomenon. The child insists that their rejection is entirely their own decision, that nobody has influenced them, and that they have independently arrived at their conclusions about the targeted parent.

Sometimes, the child becomes a more convincing advocate for the alienating parent's position than the alienating parent themselves.

They may provide an elaborate list of grievances, justify the alienating parent's behaviour, dismiss attempts to challenge the narrative and insist that their feelings are entirely their own.

3. Countering the alienating parent's narrative is incredibly difficult.

Many adult children acknowledged that there was probably very little their targeted parents could have done to completely counter the alienation.

The alienating parent often employed several tactics, including denigration, interference with communication, and portraying the targeted parent as someone who did not love or care about the child.

Even honest mistakes by the targeted parent could be amplified and used as further evidence to reinforce the existing narrative.

Consequently, the child was making what they believed to be an independent decision, without necessarily understanding how their perceptions had been shaped.

4. Guilt and the eventual reconsideration of past behaviour.

Some adult children expressed feelings of guilt when they eventually reconsidered how they had treated their targeted parent.

In certain cases, the alienation had been so deeply entrenched that the children genuinely despised the targeted parent. Looking back, some recognised that their hostility had been heavily influenced by the alienating parent's attitudes and perceptions rather than their own direct experiences.

This is not to suggest that every alienated child eventually reaches this realisation, but it does feature in some adult children's accounts.

5. The loyalty conflict and emotional enmeshment.

Another recurring theme was the extent to which alienating parents involved their children in marital conflicts.

Some made their children confidants, discussed intimate details of their marital struggles with them, and attributed most, if not all, their problems to the targeted parent.

This creates an unhealthy emotional dependency and a loyalty conflict. The child begins to feel responsible for protecting the alienating parent, sometimes at the expense of their relationship with the other parent.

A word about expectations

I also want to be careful not to give anyone false hope.

Although some adult children eventually recognise the manipulation and reconnect with their targeted parent, currently there is no reliable, representative statistics establishing how frequently this happens.

Dr. Baker's research and other studies provide valuable accounts of adult children's experiences, but qualitative studies involving small groups cannot establish the proportion of alienated children who eventually reconsider their experiences.

It is also important to distinguish between recognising the alienation and actually pursuing reconciliation. A person can eventually understand what happened and still choose not to rebuild the relationship.

My final thoughts

One thing I found particularly interesting in Baker's chapter was that some adult children eventually discovered that their targeted parents had fought much harder than they had realised.

Some learned about court proceedings, letters and gifts that had been returned unopened, or attempts at communication that had been intercepted.

Even years later, discovering these efforts meant something to them. It helped them understand that their targeted parent had not simply abandoned them.

There is an important lesson here: Do not necessarily interpret your child's rejection as an indication that they want you out of their lives permanently.

Continue to communicate your love in appropriate, non-intrusive ways. Respect boundaries and avoid putting your child in the middle of the conflict, but where possible, leave the door open.

At the same time, recognise that you cannot control the outcome. Not every child will eventually reconsider their position, and reconciliation is never guaranteed.

Please take care of yourselves, too. Your life and wellbeing matter, regardless of whether reconciliation eventually happens.


r/ParentalAlienation • • 19h ago

Advice? potential alienation?

1 Upvotes

I share children with my ex husband (been divorced over 5 years) and we haven’t been the best co parents but we have done a good job at keeping it away from the children until recently. We have had 50/50 time since we first separated. He tried to file an emergency order for full custody at first which was promptly denied. My child under 10 told me that she expressed to her dad that she was excited to see me and he said “why are you excited to see your mom? she does nothing for you and I do everything” referring to taking them to birthday parties and the pumpkin patch. I do admit that we haven’t gone to a lot of those things recently because I have to work weekends and it’s been harder to make those things happen with our pretty much full schedules. But I have to work to provide a roof over our heads. He hasn’t had a job in over a year and a half because he quit to avoid making child support payments. His grandparents bought the home he lives in and i’m certain have been providing for him financially as well. Tonight my kids found a show they liked with a new season and we put it on, my oldest got really upset and said her dad told her she’s not allowed to watch that show at my house because he’s excited to watch it with her and promptly went to her room. After going up and talking to her she said her dad said “how would you feel if you did everything for someone and they went and watched a show they were excited about with someone who does nothing for them?” and she refused to come downstairs until the show was turned off. A couple days before this she was making comments about how her dad says they aren’t allowed to wear or bring certain items to my home because “they never come back”. Which is funny because I don’t have any of the clothes or shoes i’ve bought them but i’ve never once made a comment to them about it. During one of their sports practices once a week it falls on his days and my younger child told me that her dad said she’s not allowed to come sit by me anymore. (last time my daughter cried for me and he had to physically take her out of my arms) He comes with his mom, siblings, and both grandparents every week and they all crowd my children and follow them around if they do come by me and just stare at us the whole time they’re saying hi to me. I’m worried about the emotional damage he is causing them by making them feel like i’m a bad mom and do nothing for them. I can’t talk to him about it because he will immediately get defensive and just start making accusations towards me about all the things he thinks make me a “bad mom” I’m truly at a loss. it’s the worst feeling in the world to know that something is/will cause lifetime trauma for my children but there’s absolutely nothing I can do to prevent it


r/ParentalAlienation • • 22h ago

Change of custody and suing my ex for breaching the custody agreement

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/ParentalAlienation • • 1d ago

Has anyone successfully used Form DS-5525 to get a child’s passport without the other parent’s consent?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/ParentalAlienation • • 1d ago

LIVING GHOSTS

1 Upvotes

Song I wrote and created using Suno. About my struggle with loosing a daughter to alienation 3 years ago now.

https://suno.com/s/BLX0DSP6DGV3zFsy


r/ParentalAlienation • • 1d ago

How Does asking for parenting time in Minnesota go if other parent objects for unfounded reasons?

1 Upvotes

r/ParentalAlienation • • 1d ago

parental alienation in netherlands \ friesland

4 Upvotes

So, I have already explained my situation here. I was an emigrant in the Netherlands, had a son with a woman, and this woman acted crazy. I did not tolerate her behaviour. In summary, I cannot see or talk to my son, and I haven't been able to for two years. I have been alienated for five years.

I was really lonely in the country, and while I had to work (in a physically and mentally demanding job), this woman did not let me see my son. If I reacted to her provocations, the fault was mine.

We live in a crazy world, folks. Use condoms.

To make things worse, this woman has the support of her family and friends to gaslight and undermine me, making my livelihood a hell. They don't respect the work you have done; it's all about nationalism.

Bear in mind this woman stalked to my home a lot of times before getting pregnant.

See some of the messages I received from the mother of my son:


r/ParentalAlienation • • 1d ago

How Does asking for parenting time in Minnesota go if other parent objects for unfounded reasons?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/ParentalAlienation • • 1d ago

Thanksgiving schedule conflict HELP!

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes