r/Parahumans • u/Malicious_Smasher • Oct 19 '25
Worm Spoilers [All] In defense of coil: law one of the 48 laws of power. Spoiler
Yes, Coil is an "evil" villain who kidnaps children and drugs them. Yes, he unleashed Echida onto the city of Brockton Bay in a final gesture of petty spite. And yes, our epic protagonist kills him to defend her friends.
But let's put all that morality aside, put ourselves in the shoes of an amoral supervillain, and focus only on how he went about achieving his goals. Which ultimately may have entailed helping Cauldron stop Scion or turning Brockton Bay into a safe bastion from his rampage, but we won't get into whether those ends justified his means.
This is a series of threads that will be analyzing Worm through the lens of Robert Greene's book The 48 Laws of Power. However, I may have gone off in a completely different tangent about why Coil was right to betray Taylor and why he should've been even more ruthless in dealing with the Undersiders who were a thorn in his side.
Rule 1
"Always make those above you feel comfortably superior. In your desire to please or impress them, do not go too far in displaying your talents or you might accomplish the opposite and inspire fear and insecurity. Make your masters appear more brilliant than they are, and you will attain the heights of power."
In this first chapter, Robert Green illustrates this principle with an example of how Finance Minister Nicolas Fouquet went above and beyond in throwing a lavish party to impress the king with his taste and connections. A message intended as a gesture to show Foquet's value to the king was interpreted as a boastful display of his superior influence. Thus, Foquet was imprisoned for the rest of his days on a bogus charge. Now, does that sound like anyone in Worm?
Taylors quest to prove herself to be "more valuable" than Dihan was a fool's errand from the very start because Taylor was a neophyte to the world of supervillains who had a poor grasp of both her place in coil's organization and coil's values and priorities, mainly control Coil can control Dihana more easily because she is a drug addicted 12 year old. likewise as we see in cannon even the PRT struggles to control Taylor as she repeats her pattern of amassing a "cult" who will stand with her against their superiors.
Let's say, for the sake of the argument, that Taylor, before Coil's betrayal, hypothetically was more powerful and useful than Dihana. For the sake of the coil's broader goals, I believe this is not the case since Coil craved more power than what he could obtain in Brockton Bay. And Taylor, while exceptionally effective as a regional warlord, could be replaced with another villain, albeit one who might be less effective or more expensive. Dihana could be useful to coil through his rise in the prt and building his criminal empire across the world, while Taylor could only be useful in Brockton Bay. (Robert Green goes into this further in law 11 with an example of how great mercenaries can be replaced, but great artists like Michelangelo cannot)
But for the sake of argument, put ourselves in the shoes of Taylor, who didn't know about coils' larger plan. And that, from her limited pool of information, she correctly assumed she could become more valuable. Yet even this premise was a mistake.
Taylor's role in Coil's organization was to advance Coil's agenda, not hers. When Taylor mustered up the temerity to request coil-free Diahna, she was attempting to dictate the coil's agenda. If this megalomaniacal super villain agreed and compiled with taylors request, later down the line he might have to simularly avoid implementing other plans that this stuborn teenage upstart might find morally objectional and by then she will have amassed even more influence and power within his orginzation allowing her to make bigger demands and having the consqeinces of not following those demands be more dire. Making coil's power less effective if he's already starting both of his days from a postion of diminished exctuvie power.
If Coil was honest and said releasing Dihana is not part of his plan. Then Taylor may have fomented discontent within the undersiders, used her amassed influence to sabotage Coil's plans, and he would've lost the use of a valuable asset he needed during a period of crisis. But by killing Taylor, he keeps her around when he needs her and disposes of her once she becomes a threat.
Coil's mistake was not from betraying Taylor. It was either his broader strategy of over-reliance on unloyal mercenaries from whom he remained overly distant or the fact that he didn't liquidate the undersiders who were fanatically loyal to Taylor. Coil attempted to destroy Taylor's reputation, which was a massive threat to him, through an imposter. But Lisa would have obviously seen through it, and even Rachel intuitively sensed something was off about "Taylor".
But if he had put off the confrontation with Taylor long enough, maybe made up some lie about how he needed Dihana for one more week, it would buy him enough time to establish himself as PRT director. He could kill three birds with one stone by achieving his original goal of "stopping the villains" to show how effective he would be as PRT director. But this time he would be doing it for real instead of performing a kafabe. (This also supports my point that once Coil has secured Brockton Bay, he no longer needs the undersiders, since leaving the stage of Brockton Bay was always part of his plan.) Secondly, he would be getting rid of a sub-faction that had outlived its usefulness and would eventually become a threat to him. And last but not least, he could kidnap and drug Lisa and keep her as another "pet," giving him another valuable information tool.
Now I imagine this would've been no easy task. But the undersiders are not invincible, the story would be rather boring if that were the case. Yes they've come out on top of almost every threat thrown at them. I could argue this is plot armor, but I will instead argue that the undersiders have often endured these crises from the endbringers to the slaughterhouse nine as a part of a coalition comprised of other heroes and villains. Even during the Alexandria fight, Tattletale had various mercenaries at her disposal, even if the only thing they did was buy time and give Taylor a vague hint. Coil with his influence in the prt, cauldron and the world of villains could come at the undersiders from all sides to isolate and decapitate them. Who would be there to save the undersiders?
Yes, Lisa was able to turn Coil's mercenaries against him in cannon, but with Coil having access to the prt's resources, he can equip his mercenaries with the tool the prt used to counter her power. I don't know what it's called, but I remember some superhero (maybe Dauntless) having something that blocked Lisa's voice. Maybe it was tinker tech from armsmaster maybe it's something eles idk. Maybe they simply used regular technology, though if that's the case, Coil likely would've utilized it had he planned to stop Lisa from the start rather than killing her as a reactionary move in response to his failed plot to kill Taylor.
With Lisa's voice silenced, she'd be unable to pull out her final trump card of the cash bonus (which she had to keep secret throughout the cannon because Coil could've figured it out in an alternative timeline), and thus Coil would've been free to turn her into his second pet.
I imagine Imp might be rather difficult to deal with, but if Coil is stabbed by Imp in one timeline, he could simply point his troops to shoot over to where he was stabbed in the second timeline. Maybe he'd have to stay inside a sealed bunker or hire a villain mercenary who counters her power.
As for Taylor, his original plan was perfectly sound,but he should've teleported her into a room that was about to instantly blow up, instead of underestimating her and doing the cliche supervillain bit of tying your enemy up to a timed death trap they can escape from.
Delaying it might ruin the element of surprise. But I imagine the timeline diverts from canon as Coil blows up Taylor, the undersiders become suspicious or attempt to avenge Taylor later, but by then Coil has amassed enough power in the prt to deal with a decapitated undersiders from both sides of the law.
Grue, regent, and bitch while powerful in their own niches, don't really warrant much explanation.
And Pariahan and Flechte, I imagine, wouldn't want to rock the boat on the undersiders' suicide mission since Doll Town will remain safe regardless. They were always an auxiliary at best and never a true part of the undersiders/ cult of taylor.
Anyway, I hope you liked this thread. Please feel free to chime in if you have any other examples of worm characters who "outshone the master" and paid the price for it.
Stay tuned for part two of "don't outshine the master," where i go into how Bonesaw makes jack Slashe seem more brilliant than he actually is