I'm posting this here since this topic is readily dismissed on Pantheon's forums, yet I feel it's deserving of more discussion and that the implications of multi-boxing are not being taken seriously by some of VR's staff. The reason this needs to be addressed is because there are a prominent amount of people on Pantheon's forums that have stated an intention to multi-box on launch, regardless of the final form of Pantheon's combat design.
To get this out of the way now, because it's been brought up in every discussion about multi-boxing that I've seen, I want to make it clear that I am not talking about botting. I am specifically talking about the practice of multi-boxing. For the sake of this post, I'll define multi-boxing as the practice of one player manually controlling multiple characters simultaneously (sometimes with the assistance of in-game functionality, like /follow).
Some may be curious why people have an issue with multi-boxing, especially in regards to Pantheon which is drawing a lot of inspiration from EQ where multi-boxing is quite popular. The fact is that multi-boxing is popular in EQ due to a few things: 1) The incredibly weak minimum requirements to run EQ, you could probably get it running on an actual potato if you tried, 2) combat design, and 3) dwindling population and a desire for players to circumvent the work required to put together full groups.
Despite its popularity in EQ I still believe that in itself multi-boxing is inherently opposed to the true spirit of what we should hope for in an MMO like Pantheon.
Part of the draw of Pantheon is the supposed return to a time where players were forced to work through the effort of finding people to group with, to immerse themselves in these social interactions, and to do away with things like dungeon finders. By doing so, players were ultimately rewarded for their efforts by being able to complete difficult group content, content which is designed around the idea that 6 individuals came together to work through it.
Someone who is multi-boxing (even just with one other character) is negating the effort that every other non-multi-boxing player has to go through in order to complete content. On top of that, they're able to either keep loot all to themselves or have a greater chance of winning loot (one of the defenses multi-boxers give is that people won't be able to tell that they're multi-boxing, which means it's likely they'll be happy to roll twice on loot in groups).
This hasn't even touched on the likelihood that some multi-boxers will be happy to slowly work their way to certain bosses or mobs that drop rare loot to camp them, denying an actual full group of players the opportunity to experience that content. It happens in every MMO where multi-boxing is a thing.
Multi-boxing shouldn't be something that's acceptable. Every player should have to exert the same effort to complete content. Someone should not be rewarded for paying extra and making that content easier without the need to go through what every other group of players has to, and that's navigating the difficulties that come along with social interactions and finding the players they want to group with. That's a part of the process of (older) MMOs that makes the time playing rewarding and what many of the people who are excited about Pantheon want: that difficulty that requires us to work together, to be social, to find people we want to play with, to create guilds with them and grow with them.
Yes, there will be times where finding certain classes or good players is difficult, but isn't that what we've been asking for? Why should someone get to skip that difficulty by paying more, and is it really any different than that person having their own personal dungeon finder?
I understand that some people don't feel this way, and that's fine. I disagree with those players. Given this, it is not unreasonable for paying customers to desire an opportunity to play the game with others who are playing the game as intended, where everyone has to put forth the same effort to complete group content.
Please, give us a server where multi-boxing isn't allowed.