r/PaidSocialLearning • u/zohaahmed1 • Apr 17 '25
We spent $10K on Reddit ads last month. Here’s what worked and what didn’t
Reddit ads can feel confusing. Sometimes they work, sometimes they flop. But after testing them for a B2B cybersecurity client, we figured out what actually makes a difference.
Here’s what we learned:
1. Targeting is key.
Most people go straight for r/cybersecurity. That’s fine, but don’t stop there. Smaller subreddits like r/netsec worked better for us.
Here’s how we find good ones: Search “cybersecurity reviews Reddit” on Google. Look at the posts on the first two pages. Click into them and check which subreddit they were posted in.
Some subreddits won’t show up in Reddit’s ad platform unless they have a few thousand members. But this method helps you find real communities where your audience is talking.
2. Avoid dynamic expansion.
This feature sounds good in theory. It tries to get you cheaper clicks by showing your ad to more people.
But in our tests, it didn’t work. It sent traffic from random subreddits that didn’t match our audience. We got cheaper clicks, but they weren’t qualified.
We always turn this off now.
3. Webinars is the key to success.
At first, we got around 3 to 5 leads a month. Each one cost about $250. Not bad.
But once we started offering a free webinar, the quality of leads got way better. People who signed up were more engaged and more likely to become real customers.
If you're running B2B Reddit ads, webinars are a great way to give value first and earn trust.
4. Start small and scale slow
Reddit isn’t like Meta or Google. It’s better to spend $20–$50 a day on a tight test first. Start with just 1–2 subreddits and 3 ad variations. See what’s clicking. Then slowly scale your budget or test new angles.
Go after high-intent sub-reddits where you know your customer persona will be. Like I mentioned before, smaller sub-reddits may be the better route than going after bigger ones in the start.
Trying to do too much at once doesn't help.
Proof:

That's just a few things I could think of. Let me know if you have any questions.

