Need advice on best next step in the nightmare situation of buyback/repayment. My situation:
I applied for buyback in July 2025, still waiting for a response and agreement letter. I have 14 remaining payments before reaching 120. Meanwhile, my SAVE forbearance will end next week, so I signed up for the RAP repayment plan. I really just want to be done with my loans. And I’ve already waited 16 months now for buyback, and it could be many more months or years of waiting. So my plan was to start RAP repayments, and then if buyback comes through, great, I’ll pay the rest through buyback. But my main concern was how was I going to ensure that my RAP repayments got certified through qualifying employment, since it states on the website that “in order to be eligible for buyback, there can be no plans to certify additional employment, and a buyback agreement will be voided if a PSLF form is submitted after the buyback agreement is sent.” Those statements got me thinking- if I start RAP and pay something like 3 months, and then buyback comes through (before annual employment certification), will those 3 months be lost because they weren’t certified? So I contacted FSA, PSLF department today and found out some things from a representative:
- Buyback will be voided only if I submit PSLF employer certification after buyback agreement has been sent to me.
- When I receive the buyback agreement, I’ll be required to make the payments for the 14 months, even if I paid under the RAP plan, which is why servicers will issue out refunds for overpayments.
- Once buyback is processed, any overpayments will be refunded to me. Even if those payments have not yet been certified.
- If I choose to stop payments through a general forbearance, it will not affect my pending buyback request.
Does anyone have any real world experience that can back up these statements? Do refunds actually happen? Do you truly have to pay the lump sum that is sent in the buyback agreement- you can’t just buyback the months you need at this point in time?
This situation is incredibly stressful. Any help is appreciated. In my mind, I have two decisions- 1) apply for another forbearance and wait for buyback to come through or 2) start making RAP repayments and hope I get a refund at some point (which seems incredibly hopeful and realistically improbable). Any other paths that I'm missing?
Also another important piece- my SAVE payments were $168 a month, so I’m guessing the buyback will be $168 x 14= $2,352. RAP payments will be $420 a month, so $420 x 14= $5,880.
Thank you!