hi all. sorry for the delay, but here's my comparison between the two, and my previous post where u/sugarcookieaddiction also shared their experience. random stuff/tldr at bottom.
edit - a little anecdote i mentioned in the comments but posting up here for visibility
i setup my pura max next to my lr3 and was planning on spending a week or so to transition my cats, but was in a hurry so as soon as i set it up i left for an errand. literally minutes after leaving, i got a notification that one of my cats used the pura max lol.
end of edit.
design/exterior/build
whichever you like more aesthetically between the 2 will vary (i personally like the look of the pura max, and it also happens to be shorter in height compared to lr3 while being roomier on the inside), but there are a couple design features that i want to specifically talk about.
- the waste storage. the lr3 stores underneath with a carbon filtered drawer. the pura max stores in a drawer on the side that locks in and has a cover to physically seal the drawer when it's not in use. i prefer the pura max here for storage but also because it's one less thing to purchase over time (the filters)
- the pura max has a deodorizer built-in into the side, lr3 doesn't have this
- pura max comes with a 'litter mat' to put in front which is nice
- the lr3 had a rubber mat on the inside, where the pura max is plastic/polyester. i've had this for awhile now and i feel like its better with odor/smells. one of my cats would urinate at the very front of the lr3 and i feel like it just got really dirty and smelly with the rubber. this could be completely anecdotal, but thought i'd mention
- last thing i wanna mention is about the physical rotation of the machines. if you are looking straight at the lr3, it rotates horizontally, and the waste has to slide down into the chute to fall down. if you are looking at the pura max, it rotates vertically backwards and then when it is resetting it'll guide the waste into the bin. i personally feel the pura max does this better as it was not rare, but maybe occassional, for some waste in the lr3 to not make it all the way down to the chute and then fall back into the regular container. i feel part of this is because of my cat urinating at the very front, but i thankfully haven't had that issue with the pura max.
app/software/features
some things that i liked about the pura max features
- the pura max measures weight and can use that to differentiate between which cat is using the box. may not matter as much for a single cat house. it also tracks the duration that the cat spends in the box.
- in terms of auto cleaning, the lr3 can clean 3, 7, or 15 minutes after it's been used (going off memory here, so but im 90% sure it was those numbers). the pura max can go up to 1 hour and has 1 minute increments for more control.
- the pura max can also set up periodic cleaning up to 3 times a day, if you just want a few extra cycles. if the lr3 had this, it may have solved the issue i mentioned earlier about some waste clumps not getting caught.
- i think they just updated the app because there is now a 'deep clean' option in petkit to clean twice each time it cleans.
- avoid repeated cleaning if the cat enter multiple times in the pet kit app as well
- they both have a light, however, the lr3 turns the light on automatically when its dark, wish the petkit would do this
usability/ease
small section but i wanna talk about a couple point on a day to day use case. i bought the big bunch of wastebasket liners from costco to use as bags for the litter boxes. with the lr3, i was ripping the bag just a bit to make it fit into the tray nicely. with the pura max, i don't have to rip it to make it work well. i don't think this needs to be a valid point, but i think the ease of being able to put any bag into the waste bin of the pura max is nice.
another point worth noting is that the deodorizer uses batteries, so those will need to be replaced at some point.
random stuff/thoughts/tldr
i had this issue with the lr3 where it would randomly think that the bonnet was removed. it became a common occurrence, but sometimes it would be fine for awhile. even the pura max occassionally incorrectly 'detects' a pet and stops its cleaning cycle, but so far in my time i haven't found it just sitting upside or at some angle, making it unusable for my cats. i wouldn't say it happened a lot, but it did happen a few times where the lr3 was just sitting mid cycle for quite a bit of time.
the first month of the lr3 i would say it held the smell in pretty well. later on, and kinda what i alluded to earlier about the rubber, i could not get the smell out, and tried to just mask it via candles or other scents. so far, i feel the pura max has done a satisfactory job for holding in smells. i don't expect it to change too much with time since the seal is the same and nothing else really changes.
my reasoning for getting the pura max was i wanted something that had less hiccups and controlled smell better, and with the promotions wouldn't need to spend too much more after selling the lr3. if you have any questions, feel free to ask, i could be forgetting some of the experiences or considerations i've had since using this.