r/PEDsR • u/comicsansisunderused • Aug 21 '20
Will Eating Soy Turn Me Into A Soy Boy? NSFW
I've always been partial to soy. Comparing the macro profile of soy milk to any other kind of non-dairy and it looks pretty good - a cup of soy milk is 80 calories (compared to 150 calories in cows milk), 4 grams of carbs (compared to 12 grams), 1 gram of sugar (compared to 12 grams), 4 grams of fat (compared to 8 grams) and 7 grams of protein (compared to 8 grams). I think I recall that the micro profile of soy is also pretty favorable.
There's a good table available here comparing popular milk types and nutritional values.
Since recently turning vegetarian (but I still eat fish. And eggs. And dairy. And I'm not uptight about eating meat if I absolutely have to) my soy consumption has increased. Since I'm not on tren right now, I have no desire to grow breasts. So... should I be concerned about my soy intake? What impact does soy has on muscle protein synthesis and hormones. After all... soy boy... right?
The Data
10 resistance trained men in their early 20s participated in a randomized crossover study, where all subjects completed 3 experimental treatment conditions supplementing with 20 grams of whey protein, soy protein or placebo. Subjects taking the soy protein showed lower testosterone immediately following exercise by about a third, whereas placebo showed an increased spike in testosterone by about a third. There was no change in estradiol (e2) or SHBG. This study is interesting, to a point. But the lack of what this means long term (i.e. rates of growth) not indicative of anything long term, and especially less important to those who are using SARMs (low test) or AAS (high exogenous test). After all, the natural testosterone increase response post work-out is not relevant when no natural testosterone is being produced.
Over 12 weeks, 20 subjects were supplement with 50 grams per day of either soy concentrate, soy isolate, soy isolate and why blend, and whey blend only in combination with training. There was NO significant difference in groups for total and free testosterone, SHBG, body fat, BMI or weight. Test/Estradiol ratio increased across all groups i.e. test went up relative to estradiol. Subjects taking whey blend only did show the lowest estradiol, however the soy isolate and whey blend had the highest increase in testosterone/estradiol ratio. Every group had a non-significant increase in estradiol.
Over 6 weeks, 20 subjects ate three scones (holy shit, sign me up fam) in addition to their normal diet for 6 weeks. Scones were made of either wheat or soya flour (120mg/day of isoflavones). Total test fell from 19.3 nmol/l to 18.2 nmol/l. Nothing else really changed, other than markers of oxidative stress improved (which could help protect against prostate disease and atherosclerosis).
Studies do show that soy protein is not as effective as whey / dairy protein for muscle protein synthesis 1 2
So...? Will it make me a soy boy or not?
I did find some evidence of soy suppressing AR expression, as well as various in vitro studies showing changes to test and estradiol which are inferior to the real world trials in pretty much every instance. Measured at a specific point in time, soy does appear to impact test and estrogen. Over the longer term, these impacts are (probably) negligible when combined with:
strength training
consumption of protein from other sources
and presumable PED use
In study #2 a blend of whey and soy had the best outcome in terms of testosterone increase relative to estradiol decrease.
So What?
Taking this data and then looking at it in the context of PEDs use + a typical high protein diet that would meat (heh) the definition of 'eating clean', I'm not overly worried about my consumption of soy. Given the short term impacts to muscle protein synthesis and response after resistance training, I would not consider soy as my only source of protein, ever, and should be combined with some other source - whey, casein, pea protein etc. As it relates to increased consumption as part of my daily diet, I'm not seeing anything that convinces me to not eat soy. Besides, tofu when prepared right (baked in the oven, crispy) is delicious.
Edit: adding to the conclusion here based on comments below. Would I give it to my son, or any kid? No. Their is no doubt that soy does have a hormone impact which for someone in development or otherwise dependent on natural hormone production could have a large impact (See studies above). My level of concern is such that I'm not going to stop my son eating edamame at the local asian restaurants now and then, but at the same time I'm not giving him cups of soy milk to drink on the daily. I have little to no concern for degenerates such as ourselves, often on TRT or otherwise messing with our hormones in far more drastic ways. Opinion subject to change based on evidence (of course).