r/PCAcademy • • Nov 10 '24

Need Advice: Concept/Roleplay The mechanics of the Scribes Wizard is perfect for my character, but I despise the flavor. What should I do?

2 Upvotes

I want to create a shifter who's trying to reject his animalistic side. He wears fine clothes, speaks in a posh voice, and always tries to resolve problems with words first. If it wasn't for his birth name of Fenrir or the fur covering half his body, he would hardly seem like a shifter at all. He is trying to distance himself from his more barbaric werewolf family.
Fenrir also exclusively uses ice magic. Besides cold damage spells, all of his other abilities manifest as creating ice/snow or manipulating cold air. If he tries to cast another type of spell, it turns to frost. This reflects his cold demeanor and is a personal challenge for him to overcome.

The mechanics of the scribe wizard are 100% spot on for what I want my character to do. I can get a wide variety of spells, but they all turn to cold spells thanks to the scribes' level 2 feature.

Problem is, I can't stand the flavor of wizards.

Every other caster can just know their spells but wizards (the most intelligent mages) constantly forget and have to look up how to use their own magic.
Other spellcasters can have cool origins for their powers like a god, a revelation from nature, a patron, or a sorcerous lineage that changes their entire being. Wizards have to be students at not-Hogwarts or spend an age on their own self-teaching in a library. And if they ever lose their spellbook, they instantly forget all their years of education and start from square 1.
The scribes subclass doubles down on being more bookish than any other type of wizard.

Wizards aren't easy to reflavor either.
The book is impossible to get rid of, especially for scribe wizards. And I can't easily explain away the ice-only thing either. Wizards are supposed to study every type of magic possible and be spell kleptomaniacs. Every explanation I can think of ends up sounding like another class.

So what should I do?
Shelve the character? Play a different class? Or somehow us this mechanically perfect, thematically terrible class anyway?


r/PCAcademy • • Dec 14 '25

Corrupting other PC's on my team.

0 Upvotes

I am playing a Lawful Evil character in my current group, while everyone else is good aligned. However, one of the other characters is making choices and taking actions that stretch the limits of what a "Good" character would do. My DM has already mentioned that their alignment may be changed if they continue these actions, but I see an opportunity. Is it possible to corrupt a PC enough to force an alignment change against a player's will? I know this is kind of a dick move, but I want to see how far I can push before they realize what I am doing.


r/PCAcademy • • Jan 19 '22

Table Skills When is it good not to heal (controversial)?

27 Upvotes

Alright so I had a moment when a friendly player's character keeps dying. The second moment he was about to fail his last death save again,, I triggered a reaction to heal him. He came back and was probably bummed out from nearly dying twice but, suddenly, I had a thought.

We like to say that its bad to make choices for the other characters: we would never tell them what actions to take. However, what if healing a dying character prevents the player from making a new BETTER character? Better in the way that it changes the game to new choices that enrich the experience?

It's not that they say "heal me" or "don't rez me" it's just a thing that happens in the heat of the moment. Rather than be an autopilot all the time, I start to think about it and felt it took a dark turn. I've been healing for a long time and I've noticed my teammates never need to deal with the consequences of their actions as long as I'm there to mop it up. They never need to learn.

I know this is a controversial take and when I asked another D&D group they said not healing dying characters was in bad faith and I'd get ejected immediately from the table but I'm unsure if they see the wisdom I am putting forth. We can't tell players how to play their characters but they basically are telling me what I must do, while I continue (in my perception) to view their limitations on these characters which I know they could do much better with like die less often or simply make a more enduring character, for the sake of their own enjoyment and development of the story of the game.

Am I evil thinking this way or is this bad?

EDIT: I realized that MANY people are biased in their characters survival which is why I look like the bad guy thinking this way. But does anyone see the wisdom of my words or is it all bias?

EDIT2: Thinking about it further, perhaps the best idea is to keep them alive to truly satisfying conclusions rather than let the prince get ganked by a critical hit before he could clear his name. However, in the same vein, how would you know who should die and who should survive? What if the prince's story just makes everything worse? I am haunted by the complexity and forced to continue despite my wondering. The alternative is to get booted for imagining this perverted controversy.


r/PCAcademy • • Aug 03 '24

Need Advice: Concept/Roleplay My character was drunk the day they were told about someone’s death. How would they react/feel once they’ve sobered up?

0 Upvotes

So our party recently lost one of the other PCs. Me and another party member weren’t around for the death, so we were told about it once the rest of the party met with us.

My PC was told while five cups deep in mead, one of which she drank a little before hearing the news. I played her to be closed off and in a daze, partially because it made sense for her character. She owed this character for protecting her the night before. It led to some nice moments when she met the player’s new character and she also got to distract herself by fighting in a colosseum, which doubled as a way to sober up. But I also roleplayed that way because I don’t know how to roleplay grief properly. I just can’t get it right.

Now my character will likely be sober the next session. Not only that, but she was tasked to do something at the memorial service. How can I do this?


r/PCAcademy • • Sep 22 '26

Share Advice: Guide/Inspiration How To Play A Druid

4 Upvotes

”Nature is neither cruel nor kind, but indifferent to all suffering.”

-Richard Dawkins-


I’ve heard the stories of players who chose to play a Druid. Their might, their toughness, the multitude of things that they can do with ease. Combining all those elements of power and even be able to provide protective support. It sounds like one powerhouse of a class. And for some, they think that there are stereotypes such as a tree-hugging vegan hippie. For whichever reason you want to play one and feel like you’re having some trouble with it, this is for you.

On a more personal note, I have been a DM for many years and my own advice is if you are a beginner and you’re intimidated by the rules or have trouble making choices, then playing a spellcaster might be more trouble than what it’s worth. If you still want to play a spellcaster despite all that, then I don’t recommend the Druid. Not that there is anything wrong with the class, it’s just that not only does it take a lot of spell choices and spell management, it also takes wild shape management in some editions. All of these choices, new rules, and vague definitions can be overwhelming to new players and cause a lot of time on searching and frustration. Yet, hopefully with this I can ease all that and enable any ambitious new player to hold the reins and get the scope of it all.

Creation

The Druid’s connection to nature needs to be strong so I recommend a 16 or higher to Wisdom. Yet, nature can be tough and isn’t automatically friendly towards her, that’s what Strength could be useful for. Healthy food, the great outdoors, and proper self-care could result in a strong Constitution score. Or for the ones who wish to be swift and nimble Dexterity would count. A Druid could help out with knowing the difference between something natural, arcane, or corrupted, Intelligence will help out with that if you find that important. And a Druid is an ambassador of nature and will have to commune with both nature and civilization, so Charisma would matter for your consideration.

When choosing your equipment you need to be sure if you want to go melee or ranged. Going melee requires some high investment of armor and health, if you don’t have that, take a ranged weapon or spell. A quirk of the Druid is that they are only allowed to carry leather and wood for combat. This could be because, in druidism, it is believed that metal would scare away helpful spirits. Yet, a sickle is allowed as mistletoe (the most sacred herb) is usually cut with a golden sickle during sacred rituals. For some extra flair, think about if your Druid wears hides or certain colors of cloth or leather and from what kind of wood their weapons are made of. More details about this can be found in the Player’s Handbook of your edition and if not, you can find some guidance in the rest of the post.

When you are done with your Druid, I want you to decide on a native biome where your Druid hails from. Be it a dank swamp, dry desert, icy tundra, or perhaps a mountain range, it will create a basis to start from for any theme you want to go for with your Druid be that wood types, animal shapes, or spell themes.

Spells/Animal Forms

Note I am not going to dictate, judge, or recommend specific spells or powers to you. Each edition has different spells with different effects and with the current edition, more new spells will keep coming. Any judgment on spells is irrelevant in my eyes, as some are situational or subjective to the player in effectiveness. I’ll give basic tips and broad outlines, the rest is up to you.

Druidic spells are about nature but that’s a given, isn’t it? To be precise, they’re about the elements, life, and creatures. It’s a varied mix of powers and effects so I suggest looking for a level 0 spell that deals damage or something that supports weapon combat. For any other spell of that level or higher, I suggest to start off with at least one spell that supports the group, a spell that helps with travel in the wilds, and a spell that matches the general environment. The last part requires some thought as certain spells can be difficult to explain. Summoning plants from the ground while in a frozen tundra might prove difficult, creating mist in a dry desert will look suspicious, and an earthquake can’t happen closely while completely aloft in the air. I’m not saying you should avoid these kinds of spells completely, it’s just that if you are certain that you are in a barren environment for most of the campaign that you might have trouble with spontaneously growing plants. Yet, if you still want to pick these spells for thematic reasons, you can. More about that is explained here and in the Combat section.

The ability to transform into Beasts is one part of the Druid’s complexity that can get confusing and overwhelming. So for those who have trouble with this I’ve made a plan to keep things in scope and manageable. First, recall the native biome that I suggested to note in the Creation section, this will form the fundamentals. Next, it’s safe to assume that any real-life animal is automatically a mundane beast, anything that deviates from that could be a different kind of creature. So from the biome, research and note at least one of each of the following creatures that would live there:

  • A minuscule creature such as an insect, arachnid, or invertebrate.

  • A tiny creature that might eat this minuscule creature such as a rodent, reptile, or amphibian.

  • A small or larger creature that might prey on that creature such as a feline, canine, or bear.

  • A creature that can fly.

  • A creature that can swim.

It’s okay if it’s not all connected or if you want to note vegetarian animals, it’s more about the sizes, abilities, and being prepared with a basic list of forms that you can assume your Druid knows. If your edition or biome comes with certain restrictions, note the closest animal possible from the list and look for new animals in the area if your Druid enters a different biome (or a city). Have empathy with your DM when it comes to these forms. He won’t have a neat easy-to-find list at the ready or allow the statistics of a Dragon just because you consider it to be a beast. Ask for these listed beasts before the game and keep these statistics for yourself just as you would with spells. You can do this if you have the ability to summon animals as well. It will be a timesaver for sure.

More about Beasts here.

Combat

As the Druid used to be a Cleric subclass back in AD&D, they fight somewhat similarly. If you are made to go toe-to-toe with creatures, go for it. Use spells to keep yourself tough enough to take hits if you have to. If you’re not up for that, keep yourself at a comfortable range for ranged weapons or spells. If the opponent seems tough, look for alternative ways of damaging it. Keep in mind what the group needs and support them for it however you can. And if the area allows it, use that one area-appropriate spell mentioned in the Spell section to turn the tides.

When you are out of spells or they don’t seem that effective, transforming into a beast would make an effective alternative if you are able. This means that you will be in melee and taking hits. The effectiveness of your form depends on how well you understand it. It’s not about just standing and hitting. When being a wolf, use tactics as how a wolf would do it. When being a bear, imagine protecting a bear cub by using your size. When being a hawk, use your mobility to fly by and harry the opponent. When being a jellyfish, be aware that you’re not fast but you do sting. All living beings do what they do best and they have the capability and mentality to do it. Study it before committing to the form and you will be an effective set of muscles.

Roleplay

Nowhere in the old texts does it say that Druids were priests, yet they acted as such and more. Teachers, ambassadors, judges, philosophers, or healers, in any way you slice it, they had high-ranking status. As for how they are portrayed now, they are supporters of nature’s balance. Attempting to keep away from the tumults of civilization and looking for ways to purify the world. This is why the Druid had to be Neutral in older editions. Trees aren’t good and predators aren’t evil, they’re just doing what they’re intended to do. It’s a Druid’s job to keep it that way.

So in whichever way you want to go with your Druid, looking for ways to focus on their wisdom might work. Wisdom is the sense of experience and truthful conclusions of life. In D&D it’s mostly about introspection, empathy, calmness, focus, connection, or faith. If you’re struggling with finding ways to portray such a mentality, I’ve placed some similar words to help you out: sagacious, learned, informed, enlightened, sensible, prudent, discerning, judicious, perceptive, insightful, clear-sighted, percipient, perspicacious, owlish, well advised, well judged, expedient, far-sighted, sound, sane, long-headed, argute.

Wisdom comes with all factors of life, both pain and pleasure, and the ability to learn from it. It comes with the ages and maturity, and for some, it comes (too) early. The pitfall for sounding wise is the attempt to sound vague, all-knowing, or speak in tongues that in the end make no sense. This can come off as foolish rather than wise. I suggest playing someone who remains calm in heated moments, understands that there are hardships and celebrations in life, and tries to remain level-headed about plans and situations.

Most Druids are part of a druidic grove, a group of fellow Druids that share the same values of nature. All druids within this grove learn a language that they share. Use this to keep in contact with them. It will make sure that your Druid’s values are covered within the area. They might be able to help you out when you need them. Just don’t expect them to save your hide all the time.

Exploration

Most of the Druid’s abilities can help with exploration in the wilds. Anything that has to do with survival or staying alive during long treks can be covered with spells. Some allow speaking with natural creatures so that you can get some information about the area. This doesn’t mean that animals are automatically your friends, know everything you want to know, or are actually social or smart, they’re just animals. This counts doubly so for plants, they tend to stay in one place so they don’t experience much.

An expert Druid is willing to look into disbalances of nature. Especially when it comes to impure areas. Take it to yourself to discern if a fire is natural or magical, water is poisoned, tree growth has been accelerated, or if the earth has become infertile. You can do this with skill checks or otherwise if you have to. This way you can glean for hints as to what might be going on from a small to a larger scale.

Plenty of animals are good at tracking, climbing, digging, flying, or prowling at night. Take your transformations into consideration as well.

Alternatives

Druid, (Celtic: “Knowing [or Finding] the Oak Tree”), member of the learned class among the ancient Celts. They seem to have frequented oak forests and acted as priests, teachers, and judges. The earliest known records of the Druids come from the 3rd century BCE.

Caesar [also] recorded that the Druids abstained from warfare and paid no tribute. Attracted by those privileges, many joined the order voluntarily or were sent by their families. They studied ancient verse, natural philosophy, astronomy, and the lore of the gods, some spending as much as 20 years in training. The Druids’ principal doctrine was that the soul was immortal and passed at death from one person into another.

-Encyclopedia Britannica-


As priests of nature, Druids tend to be healers and keepers of balance. If you see Druids as passive vegetarians who hug trees, then let me shake you awake:

The Druids offered human sacrifices for those who were gravely sick or in danger of death in battle. Huge wickerwork images were filled with living men and then burned; although the Druids preferred to sacrifice criminals, they would choose innocent victims if necessary.

-Encyclopedia Britannica-

This part may not be true. The Romans wrote everything from their point of view and thus there is plenty of room for misconstruction and bias. They might have supported the vates in such rituals but may not did it themselves. Druidism is not so much about tending flowers or petting animals, it’s about respecting the awesome powers of nature by letting it be and understanding what nature needs. They see nature as a spiritual force of power, close to shamanism, and that the sun, moon, and powers that be are the sources of life.

Fun fact, druids were color-coded. The Arch-druid wore gold robes, ordinary druids would wear white and act like priests, the Sacrificers wore red and partook in battle, the blue robes ones were artistic and acted closely to bards, and the new druids wore brown or black.

For when you don't want to be a typical Druid, you could always try to theme yourself as one of the following spiritual/nature practitioners:

  • Animal Whisperer

  • Animist

  • Astronomer

  • Benandantanist

  • Curanderos

  • Folk healer

  • Gradobranitelj

  • Halayt (Soulcatcher)

  • Itako

  • Judge

  • Kahuna

  • M’wanga (Firespeaker)

  • Medicine man/woman

  • Meteorologist

  • Neuroanthropologist

  • Oblačar

  • Pagan

  • Plastic shaman

  • Seiðr practitioner

  • Shaman

  • Tlamatini

  • Tree Doctor

  • Ulogo

  • Uranina

  • Völva

  • Wiccan

  • Witch Doctor

  • Yaskomo

  • Zduhać

As a bonus, because Druids believed in the cycles of the world, I’ll add some druidic circles as well.

  • Cosmic cycles

  • Currents

  • Fertility

  • Grief

  • Growth and decay

  • Homeostasis

  • Life and death

  • Lunar cycles

  • Night and day

  • Seasons

  • Sleep and awakening

  • Travel

  • Weather

Inspiration

  • A Bug’s Life (1998)

  • A Land Before Time (1988) (And the sequels I guess)

  • A Troll in Central Park (1994)

  • African Cats (2011)

  • Allanon the druid in Shannara Chronicles

  • Animal spirits

  • Animal zoos

  • Animals of Farthing Wood

  • Animorphs books

  • Antz (1998)

  • Babe (1995)

  • Bambi (1942)

  • Bambi 2 (2006)

  • Bears (2014)

  • Bedlow and Whiteleaf Crosses

  • Beorn from The Hobbit (2012)

  • Biomes

  • Born in China (2016)

  • Boudica (2003)

  • Brother Bear (2003)

  • Brother Bear 2 (2006)

  • Brother Bear 3 (2019)

  • Bullaun

  • Cats (1980)

  • Cerne Abbas Giant

  • Chalk hill figures

  • Circles and cycles

  • Climates

  • Clootie Well

  • Coco the gorilla

  • David the Gnome and David the Judge by Riet Poortvliet

  • Dinosaur (2000)

  • Druid Peak (2014)

  • Druids of the Claw and Feather from Warcraft 3

  • Duma (2005)

  • Earth (2007)

  • Earth Song by Micheal Jackson

  • Feri tradition

  • Ferngully (1992)

  • Ferngully 2 (1998)

  • Flipper series

  • Free Willy (1993)

  • Free Willy cartoon series

  • Garm Wars: The Last Druid (2014)

  • Genesis (2004)

  • Getafix the druid from Asterix and Obelix

  • Global warming

  • Golden sickles

  • Grass, fire, water, electric, flying, rock, bug, ground, and ice type Pokémon

  • Green Stories

  • Harmonizing

  • Heilung

  • Homeward Bound (1993)

  • Horned masks

  • Huna

  • Hunebeds

  • Ice Age (2002)

  • Ice Age 2: The Meltdown (2006)

  • Ice Age 3: Dawn of the Dinosaurs (2009)

  • Ice Age 4: Continental Drift (2012)

  • Ice Age 5: Collision Course (2016)

  • Ice Age 6: Boiling Point (2027)

  • Imbas

  • Jacques Cousteau’s Voyage to the Edge of the World (1977)

  • Jungle Book (1942, 1967, 2016)

  • Jungle Book 2 (2003)

  • Jungle Book: Origins (2018)

  • Kemetism

  • Kimba the White Lion (1965)

  • Koyaanisqatsi (1982)

  • Leafy crowns

  • Legend of Zelda Twilight Princess

  • Les Saisons (2015)

  • Leylines

  • Life of Pi (2012)

  • Long Man of Wilmongton

  • Love Thy Nature (2014)

  • Madagascar (2005)

  • Madagascar 2 (2008)

  • Madagascar 3 (2012)

  • Menhirs

  • Microcosmos (1996)

  • Mistletoe

  • Monkey Kingdom (2015)

  • Mr. Ed series

  • Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind (1984)

  • Neo-druids

  • Océans (2009)

  • Pliny the Elder

  • Pow-wow

  • Purification

  • Ratatouille (2007)

  • Rio (2011)

  • Sacred trees

  • Samhain, Yule, Imbolc, Ostara, Beltane, Litha, Lughnasa, and Mabon

  • Shamanism

  • Shillelagh fights

  • Shillelaghs

  • Skippy the Bush Kangaroo series

  • Spirit spouses

  • Spirit: The Stallion of the Cimarron (2002)

  • Squirrel Girl from The Tick

  • Stone circles

  • Stonehenge

  • Talismans

  • The 11th Hour (2007)

  • The Cascajal block

  • The Georgia Guidestones

  • The Great Deku Tree from Zelda games

  • The hanging gardens of Babylon

  • The Lion King (1994, 2004, 2019)

  • The Lorax (1972, 2012)

  • The number three

  • The Red Horse Vale

  • The Second Jungle Book (1997)

  • The Voyage of Time (2016)

  • The White Horse in Westbury, Wiltshire

  • The Wicker Man by Iron Maiden

  • The Wickerman (1973, 2006)

  • Turkic

  • Vercingétorix (2001)

  • Warlock: Armegeddon (1993)

  • Watership Down (1978, 2018)

  • Whale songs

  • Why penguins never get eaten by polar bears

  • Wicker men

  • Widget series

  • William Blake

  • Wings of Life (2011)

  • Winston Churchill

  • Zootopia (2016)

Classes

The List of Olem


r/PCAcademy • • May 27 '25

Need Advice: Out-of-Character/Table I'm in a lv 30 campaign and my DM keeps buffing the wizards and nerfing me (the paladin). I have talked and don't know how to get him to see my side

5 Upvotes

So here's the rundown: the power scaling of the extra buffs we get (what makes this lv 30) is basically my DM will randomly reward us with mythos points (Free ASIs or at higher cost feats, spell slots, or even +1 prof).

In this game he added "blood magic" which is basically you can upcast for free (still expending the base slot) at the cost of some hitdice worth of damage. This also expands the size of AOE spells and works with rubberbanding healing (as long as you aren't killed outright). So basically the wizards can use cone of cold at 9th lv every turn over and over while getting healing worded back up.

I am a paladin and I went for the stupid busted periapt of wound closure + remarkable recovery. This was understandably shut down.

But then he introduced lycanthropy and made a system where on taking damage you must make a charisma save or transform and fall under DM control. As a paladin I was fine with this, until when I rolled and added +19 (+7 prof +6 charisma), he said that aura of protection didn't apply to charisma saving throws. I ask him why and he says it's just cause he rules it that way. Tells me to stop complaining since Charisma saves don't show up almost ever. I ask him why he needs to nerf it if it's really not that big a deal. He says his ruling is final and he doesn't want to hear anymore on it. Don't know why, but whatever. They don't come up too often so I'm not too worried. Annoyed, but not worried.

Then today I told him I was gonna switch my find greater steed mount to one with flyby cause in our last battle I got screwed over by sentinel ignoring my mount's disengage and ended up getting punished hard (300 hp in one turn hard). He then said all the melee enemies (we are fighting giants) from here on out will have sentinel and some will be able to apply multiattack to opportunity attack. And then he banned flyby on mounts. Keep in mind, I grabbed mounted combatant for the mobility six months ago. I have been planning on this for literally a year.

I started complaining about this and he said the he didn't want to hear it since I was already the most powerful and could do 300 dmg in one turn (I did that one time on a fully stacked crit). Obviously I'm a paladin and that is not sustainable damage. Keep in mind the bosses have 1500 hp and the final fight is gonna have 3. I WILL run out of slots. We also have a character where he gave them infinite lv 1 spell slots who is a paladin 2/bladesinger X with 30 AC and uses tenser's transformation then just smites every hit. I have +3 plate (21 AC) and it's super tough for me to survive even one turn next to the big guys cause they have +22 to hit and save DCs of 30.

Like, having some mobility on the battlefield is good,, but it's not like the mount is invincible. One cast of blight or another AOE and it dies. I tried to argue it but he just kept saying that he can't let me be invincible and untouchable and the best damage dealer (cause we are about to get capstone stuff and he thinks conquest paladin 20 resistance is gonna break the game). Like Idk. I'm strong. Stronger than a lot of my fellow players in offense (not in defense though good lord). But I just feel like this should work. I don't understand.

Please help me. How do I make him understand?

Full transcript: https://imgur.com/a/AYmskJb


r/PCAcademy • • Nov 23 '25

DM/Players: Stop making 'perfect' heroes. What is the BEST mechanical flaw (Feat/Ability) that drives your character's internal story?

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I spend a lot of time thinking about character arcs (for the TTRPG journal I write), and I realized the best heroes aren't defined by their highest score, but by their biggest mechanical/narrative hurdle.

I'm talking about a specific flaw—a low Wisdom score, a crippling Feat choice, or a bad Racial Trait—that defines their personality, creates in-game conflict, and forces them to grow.

Here are a couple of examples of what I mean:

  • The Arc: A Paladin with a high Charisma but a low Wisdom score. They speak with absolute conviction and inspire followers, but they are easily manipulated by charismatic villains, leading to devastating moral choices.

  • The Arc: A Rogue who chose the Slightly Built racial feat (or similar homebrew negative) to get a bonus. The flaw is they have disadvantage on grapples/shoves, driving them to find non-physical, sneaky ways to solve every problem, even when a direct fight is easier.

Your Turn: What mechanical flaw did you build into your character that created the BEST roleplaying opportunities in your campaign?

P.S. We aren't talking about "flaws" like being reckless. We're talking about the numbers on the sheet forcing the story!


r/PCAcademy • • Oct 29 '24

Need Advice: Build/Mechanics Is the Healer Feat worse?

1 Upvotes

I was looking at the revised healer origin feat and the 2014 Healer feat, and I can't help but think it's nerfed. I mean, while essentially the same and rerolling Nat 1s is nice, the fact that it doesn't bring back a downed ally and is directly tied to the player's Hit Dice kinda feels counterintuitive to the "Battle Medic" title it gives itself.

I mean sure, 1d6 might not mean much to a Barbarian, but the fact that it wasn't tied to the Hit Dice meant that the medic was always useful so long as they had a use out of the kit left.

But given I am not the wisest player out there, and my ADHD often leads me to misinterpretations, am wondering if I missed something.... Is that the case here?


r/PCAcademy • • May 28 '25

Need Advice: Build/Mechanics Would a character keeping a journal gain a buff to history checks?

0 Upvotes

I am making a halfling kensei monk from a nomadic tribe of story gatherers. As part of his background, I was thinking of having him keep a journal of the party's adventures and sought out to budget that in his starting equipment. However, the only feasible option I could find was the item "book" from the 2024 PHB. As per the description:

If you consult an accurate nonfiction Book about its topic, you gain a +5 bonus to Intelligence (Arcana, History, Nature, or Religion) checks you make about that topic.

Now, typically I think of this item as an encyclopedia type book, but if the topic of the non-fiction book happens to be your own adventures (the arcane runes you find, the feats you achieve, the discoveries you make, and the divine truth you uncover), does that mean you'll gain +5 bonus to Intelligence checks regarding your own memories?

At first I thought it was a silly question because of course a player wouldn't have to roll an inteligence check to remeber the shopkeeper's name, but then I thought of why the character might... for instance, a history check might reveal that the shopkeep was balding, or that the arcane runes are mirrored... or you might even realize that the noble is subtley changing the details about a supposed invasion your party stopped... the book actually becomes a great tool for the DM to drop hints that bad rolls might otherwise miss.

So am I correct in my analysis?


r/PCAcademy • • Mar 17 '26

Complaining player !!

0 Upvotes

Looking for advice. I have a player who switched out characters 60 % of the way through. He's now complaining he hasn't received any items and his character feels left out. I homebrew with inspiration from linear campaigns. I have tried to include all the characters backgrounds and finish up their stories tying them into the main plot. I'm not mad, just a little surprised because essentially he changed my final story for his original character and now he feels left out. I intend to end his story with a heroic moment, but this has caused me to rethink my agreement to allow him to change out characters. Kinda ruined the plot and I haven't altered the campaign to include him, well enough apparently. Any advice ? As I try to navigate the final part of the adventure so everyone is happy.


r/PCAcademy • • Apr 29 '24

Need Advice: Concept/Roleplay How would I create a waitress turned office assistant?

0 Upvotes

Our campaign consist of a squad of detectives solving cases within an urban fantasy universe is, we're one session away from completing a character arc at Level 19. After that, we'll be doing side quests as lower-level character (Levels 5-6) in the same universe to break away from the intense games.

I discussed with our DM about retiring my lower level character because her goal was accomplished (she was a Tabaxi Monk shopkeeper whose employees went missing during a coffee crisis that turned the citizens into caffiene-addicter zombies who were lured into the under dark, and she managed to save a few of them). Our DM said to let it rip with characters who could be additions to the universe.

I personally wanted to play a simple character, a former waitress who was one of those brainwashed citizens and is now struggling to readjust to her life. She then leaves her restaurant gig for an office position at the detective agency for a quieter environment to regain her bearings, and from there I'll let the session events determine her story and growth (of course).

For once, I want to drop the tragedy and complex backstories and play something...simple RP-wise. I will say I don't have a class to choose; she's an office assistant with restaurant experience, so feats would be Chef, Healer, Observant, or Skilled with a Guild Merchant background. We'd also be Level 5. She'd also fight with improvised weapons, office supplies, paper, and personal weapons.


r/PCAcademy • • Aug 03 '24

Need Advice: Build/Mechanics Monk Lich

0 Upvotes

So I recently watched a video from a YouTube channel called Pointy Hat where he made The Soul Incarnate, a way for a monk to become a lich as well as a creature stat and to become a monk Lich you have to do an extremely dangerous ritual where you cultivate a plant what when used to make tea dries the body from the inside out which the monk slowly drinks more of each weak until you completely replace any other food/drink intake with it then you place yourself in a wooden box mostly underground to meditate with your last cup of tea with other people watching over the box as you pull on a string attached to a bell to know when your dead and as you meditate you must figure out how to balance your ki to make a self sustaining loop where your mummified body doesn't need any sort of outside energy or sustenance so that when you die and those looking over the box opens it your soul and ki becomes an incorporeal creature with your mummified body being your phylactery that you can possess if someone tries to destroy it. I want to know what benefits you think being this type of Lich would be.


r/PCAcademy • • Feb 10 '26

Need Advice: Concept/Roleplay Please tell me that a goliath and a halfling can have a baby....

5 Upvotes

I am utterly amused by this character concept and, technically, I believe I can make it work but I wanted to know if you (as a DM) would allow this shenanigan at the table:

According to the new half-species rules, as I remember them, your character's apperance can favour either parent or a combination of the two, but your stats can only favour one parent. Now typically there's not much going on here, but the character I have in mind is a mercy monk whose halfling in apperance, but goliath in traits. Aka a 2' tall ~~ankle biter~~ body builder whose got a powerful build, 45ft of movement at lvl 3, the ability to teleport, and the ability to become large at will.

I find this extra funny when you consider them carrying the opposite back to safety: a female goliath wizard with halfling traits like halfling nimbleness. [Something like this.](https://youtu.be/f25TH8IW38c?si=Wq4-4QIAR4dLSo8u&t=16m55s)

So I ask you, dear DMs, is my concept too silly for your table?


r/PCAcademy • • Nov 04 '23

Need Advice: Concept/Roleplay SO HOW BOUT THIS SPOOKY CHARACTER IDEA

0 Upvotes

A dhampir who was born on a blood moon on October 31st and on that day there was a odd occurrence of the shadowfell being closest to the material plain it ever was and especially closest to where he was born so all I need is a class for it to be spookiest


r/PCAcademy • • Jul 28 '26

Need Advice: Out-of-Character/Table Should I change my class?

0 Upvotes

Right now, I’m playing two DnD campaigns with some friends of mine. One I’m DM, one another player is DM. I’m playing a circle of the sea Druid who is very chipper and easy going. I love her so much, but I'm just not enjoying the mechanics of playing a druid in combat for some reason. I can’t pinpoint why, because I’ve loved playing almost every other class except for fighter. Since the campaign is very much tied to the gods and each player has one, I was thinking of maybe asking my DM is I could slowly switch to a fathomless warlock later on with my patron being my god. A cleric would make more sense for my character, but one of the players is really weird about characters being similar (She even got upset when I first made my character), even though her character that is a chipper cleric is in the campaign that I run. I do like playing warlocks, but I don’t want to ask now because we’ve only done 4 sessions even if they were long. Also, we had a couple sessions before but they got scrapped because a player quit and the DM was very new to DM’ing. In those sessions, I had a different character, but I had accidentally made her too hard to play because she was a very deep character and I’m not that good at roleplaying. That character was in fact a warlock, so I do feel bad. What should I do?

Edit: I’ve talked to my DM a bit and looked over my spells, and I’ve decided that it was because A. Somehow my weapons all got deleted from my inventory on DnD beyond? I don’t know how that happened but we went back and added them and now my character is much more versatile B. I think something was wrong with my app in general because it was showing the spells I would’ve had at like level three instead of six. So long story short story, my fault!


r/PCAcademy • • Oct 17 '23

Need Advice: Out-of-Character/Table I just have to say something about yuan it

0 Upvotes

I love them very much like they would be my favourite race but there is a couple of things that really TICK me off about them 1 they are almost always referred to as emotionless creatures that just kill and are evil 2 my yuan ti character after spending a whole campaign with his party members showing just how nice he is and how not to judge a book by it’s cover after the campaign the entire party set out on another quest without him saying he’s a dangerous creature so I wasn’t in their next level 11 - 20 campaign and the dm wasn’t on my side either the npc that was fawning over my character the entire campaign declined his request to go on a date after he just saved her entire home town and family so I left that group And finally 3 whenever I show a concept of a friendly yuan ti character to a friend of mine he always says that’s not what the book says they are evil creatures so I have to convince him with my backstory that there’s a reason to it So with all of that being said I say STOP THE YUAN TI HATE THEY DONT DESERVE IT AND WE NEED TO SPREAD THE WORD THAT NOBODY SHOULD BE MADE TO FEEL BAD ABOUT WANTING TO BE A FRIENDLY SNAKE PERSON


r/PCAcademy • • Jun 22 '25

Need Advice: Build/Mechanics How can I create an oathbreaker paladin in D&D Beyond?

0 Upvotes

Hello, As the question states above, I want to create an oathbreaker paladin in D&D beyond.

From what I gathered, I should be abke to do this, but the option does not show up when I select a sub class.

To be certain, I have checked the following things:

  1. I have the 2014 rules enabled;

  2. I have acces to the players and DM's guide;

  3. I have synched my account to the content I have access to.

I have tried this both on an excisting and new character, but neither allows me to create an oathbreaker.

Is there anything I'm missing?


r/PCAcademy • • May 02 '26

Need Advice: Build/Mechanics Would it be OP to make a medium sized fairy?

0 Upvotes

I've come across this idea a few times now... not to make the race medium sized, but to make your specific character medium sized. Be it that their mother was an elf, an abnormality, or whatnot, the fact is that you're a medium (4-7 ft) creature and thus do not feel like you fit within your own community.

More specifically, the idea that has me entranced is that your village/community has always been kind, welcoming, and accommodating, but the one who feels out of place has always been you. You've always worried that you're just bothering others and that they'd be better off without the giant thorn of the village, so you set out on your own but always yearn for the warmth you left behind.

However, I am concerned that this would be more complicated than giving a human dwarfism since the fairy has the ability to cast Enlarge on itself. On the other hand, the duegar is a medium creature who can do the same. So I would like to ask DMs what their take on the matter would be? Would this request be broken or not?


r/PCAcademy • • Nov 30 '24

Need Advice: Concept/Roleplay How do i play a Lawful Evil child character?

0 Upvotes

I have a barbarian that has the mentality of a toddler, and misinterprets battle and other situations into simple childhood games and problems. His rages were bursts of excitement, and he didn't notice he was hurting his enemies. His motivation was to help people and make up for the things (and people) he broke.

He was Chaotic Good originally, but I ended up drawing the Balance card from The Deck of Many things.

Now, this character isn't very crafty. He has a 10 in Intelligence, and a 13 in Wisdom. Other than temper tantrums, I'm not sure what kind of "Lawful Evil" things I can do.

What kinds of things would a lawful evil child do? Are there any examples in media of Lawful Evil children?


r/PCAcademy • • May 15 '25

Need Advice: Concept/Roleplay Is randomizing your subclass a pain for DMs?

0 Upvotes

I had a character idea that I thought would add a bit of fun organized chaos to a table, hopefully without any drawbacks. But never having been a DM, I thought it might be best to check before even suggesting to play it...

According to lore, Eladrin are the subspecies of elves closest to their pantheon, offering them the ability to change between 4 aspects of themselves marked by the seasons. In my adaptation, these changes are far more chaotic and pronounced: like with split personality, each season would have their own name, personalty, fears, and even subclass. The stats, feats, and ASI won't change, but the Summer Eladrin might be a hot headed Ascendant Dragon Monk, the Fall Eladrin could be a Drunken Master, Winter would then be a Warrior of Shadows, and Spring's a Warrior of Elements. And at the end of a long rest, the player would have to roll a d4 to see which side comes out.

Yes, it would be a bit more for the player to handle, but would this random subclass feature make encounter balancing harder on the DM?


r/PCAcademy • • Jan 16 '23

Inspiration I created a new character through ChatGPT (AI) and was super impressed! These are my results...

21 Upvotes

I was inspired by a post I saw a couple months ago on one of the other D&D subreddits. That post was a DM using ChatGPT to world build (including the specific D&D adventure, backstory, plot hooks, twists, how the PCs came together, etc.) I immediately thought this would be really cool to use for PCs as well. It took me a minute to sit down and try it, but as soon as I started I was blown away. I included two imgur threads of my two slightly different attempts. I apologize for how long they are (especially the first one), but I wanted to give you the full experience and comment on certain things I found really impressive. The individual images should have captions where I share my thoughts on why I asked certain things or my thought process.

BM Fighter with a Dip in Tempest Cleric. This was my first experience with ChatGPT, so things were a bit all over the place in the order I was asking things. Mostly just focused on RP elements (backstory, traits, allies, etc.)

(This is the art I use for this fighter, just for reference.)

Storm Sorcerer. With this character I had nothing except art inspiration. I wanted to see how well it would handle the technical aspects of a character (ability scores, spells, etc.)

(this is the image I was describing as the initial prompt)


r/PCAcademy • • Dec 05 '24

Need Advice: Concept/Roleplay Help me build on this list of phrases a bard would say while high

0 Upvotes

I am planning on making an eloquence bard or whispers bard (haven't decided yet) and possibly multiclassing it.

The important part is that I need helping expanding my repertoire of phrases I'd say when I expend my bardic. Die to use bardic inspiration or vicious mockery/ unsettling word/ psychic blades.

I really want to tailor the phrases to things one would expect to hear from someone high in the game and not make references to real life. The point is to build verisimilitude to the lore of the world I am playing in.

To help give an example I have provided a list of a few I have come up with or seen online myself.

I think it would be fantastic if we could add to this list and so others in the future can utilise this list for their own used in similar scenarios to roleplay a similar character.

Inspiration phrases:

If a wizard casts clone and kills it. Is that suicide or murder?

Swords are just like words... you gotta swing them to kill and ... fuck, I'm high.

If money is the root of all Evil, why do they ask for it in all the temples?

Scientifically, it's so fucked up that humans drink the milk of other animals. Like you don't see Owlbears sucking on a goat for milk. So fucked up.

(To Barbarian) You know how we are told to swallow or anger? Well if Anger is bad, then that means you are swalling bad things. You should just let it out, it's good for you.

Do you think the gods are Tulpa?

If two wizards cast detect thoughts on each other, whose mind are they reading?

Maybe Halflings just all have a normal amount of luck, it just gets condensed because they’re so small.

You ever wonder if there are tall dwarves that blend in with humans?

You may think you’re brave, but remember: the original half giants needed two parents. Why do you think modern Goliaths are so durable and crazy, huh? Huh?!

Like, are dragon colors racist? Look, I’m just saying-

Could a Lizardfolk Cleric cast Purify Food And Drink on an injured teammate?

I was having a wonderful thought about these Realms where… oh, I seem to have Forgotten it.

Does a hydra think communally, or do the heads have arguments?

If magic made me a hydra, could I bring my friends, or would it all be me?

For someone who has it in their name, a cleric does very little paperwork or other clerical duties

Are magical parents the best because they can cast Comprehend Languages and understand their children, or are they the worse because the children realise their parents aren't listening to them?

If I used Tongues, I wonder if I could make even (party member) understand basic logic.

Who the heck thought to use bat poop to make a magic fireball? (or in fact, any set of material components)

I mean, really, what's the difference between a cleric and a warlock? Marketing?


r/PCAcademy • • Jan 30 '25

Is it alright in a role play...

0 Upvotes

Is it alright on a role play that it's all just acting and less talking?


r/PCAcademy • • Jan 01 '26

Need Advice: Build/Mechanics Is there a way to give monk levels to a mount?

3 Upvotes

Odd little question, but I've noticed that there isn't much mechanical advantages for a monk to have a mount. Sure, carrying capacity is a thing, but eventually I feel like going on foot would be the better and faster choice.

One solution I keep falling back on is to give the mount (currently thinking of a farmer with a trained mule companion, but also inspired by dogs doing yoga) monk levels with the lore that they both trained together every day. I'm not really thinking of making the mount an active part of the party like a rangers animal companion, but more of applying it as flavouring that offers a bit of mechanical advantage to the party.

For instance, the fact that the mount is trained could offer an explanation as to why your wagon is always safe (which is already typically hand waved by the DM anyways), and the increased speed could shave off the party's travel time.

Am I way off the mark?