r/PCAcademy • • Jan 16 '21

Arcana My players gave an explanation to magic that you might want to add to your caster's knowledge

923 Upvotes

So on last night's session, the characters were doing a long rest on a campfire. They start to talk, and soon the subject became magic. The fighter of the group asks the wizard and the ranger why do they say funny words when they do magic (my caster players like to actually say incantations out loud when they cast, which I totally love). The sorcerer just said "saying the spell out loud helps me focus".

But then the wizard came up with this explanation:

"Well, you see. The weave that suffuses the multiverse is somewhat sentient, maybe because of the fact that it's guarded by Mystra. Some even say that Mystra is the Weave. Every sound that exists, every word spoken, vibrates the weave on a certain way. My theory is that the weave has some sort of 'memory' that associates words and sounds with important events. And thus, we harness that memory. "

At this point the Fighter had this face of confusion, so the wizard continued:

"Alright, imagine that there is a huge plague, that is super contagious and is killing a lot of people. And let's say that everytime someone dies, someone says 'Fuck'. When they're about to die, they say fuck, when they see another person die, they say fuck. When they're at the funeral, everyone says fuck. Becausw the word 'fuck' is being used a lot in such an event of death and misery on a massive scale, the weave will asociate the word fuck with death and plague. A couple of centuries later, there may be a wizard that, while researching a new spell, discovers that the common word 'Fuck' evokes a necromatic aura on the weave. And thus, someone can cast a spell by saying Fuck. Or any other word, really."

"so I can make fire magic by saying my name if I cause a wildfire and shout my name a lot?"

"Well... Fire has been used since the dawn of history, so there are a lot of words and sounds to use that evoke fire and heat. But... I suppouse if the wildfire is big enough and enough people shout your name, then you name might become a verbal component for a wildfire spell"

"Hell yeah, let's burn some stuff after this mission"


r/PCAcademy • • Jan 07 '21

Beasts and Mounts Giant frogs are medium, thus they are eligible beasts companions for beastmaster rangers. Grung are small and therefore can ride medium creatures.

720 Upvotes

That's all. Have a good day.


r/PCAcademy • • Apr 02 '21

Table Skills Anyone ever seen an evil character done well?

623 Upvotes

Just got out of a short session, but one of our players did a fantastic evil PC, best I’ve ever seen honestly. In case it matters he was Neutral Evil - he thought solely of benefiting no one but himself. His party members were simply tools he needed to complete his goals. This meant, of course, that he had to protect his allies, earn and keep their trust, and keep them in his debt by doing things for them. He definitely didn't want to make them his enemies by stealing from them or betraying them - that would both weaken his own standing while strengthening his opponents'. It wouldn't do to let someone kill his Wizard's favorite familiar, or insult the honor of his Barbarian and get away with it: those acts would weaken his allies, and make them less effective tools. And if it meant risking it all (which translates to "risking the evil character's own life"), then so be it: those allies were his best chance at success, and he needed them. Until he didn't. But even then, just because you're done with a tool now doesn't mean you throw it away! That's just wasteful. You might need it again in the future.

Our whole party thought he was lawful Good.


r/PCAcademy • • May 24 '21

Roleplaying The #1 tip for being a good player: care about the world.

576 Upvotes

This may seem obvious, but I’ve seen a number of players, including myself, not following this maxim. If there’s a great NPC you like, make it known that you like them and make an effort to talk to them later. If you hear about a legendary weapon, investigate further. If one of your party members is from an interesting location, ask them about their home. The best thing you can do for your dm and other players is to care about the world and its characters.


r/PCAcademy • • Apr 13 '21

Roleplaying Changing your character's voice when they speak in another language

570 Upvotes

So I just did this in our game last night. My character is a kobold, and he normally speaks in a brash, childlike voice with a ton of malapropisms. Last night, however, we ran into a group of kobolds, and I spoke to then in Draconic. Because I don't think he would have an accent even speaking in his native language, I changed his voice to a soft british accent with elevated word choice. One of the other party members knows draconic, and he also changed his accent: going from a South American kind of accent to a Southern accent, since he learned it differently.

Obviously we did this for a comedic effect, but it could easily be done in a more serious means. Liam does this for Caleb in Critical Role, with him dropping his accent.

Changing your voice also just makes it clear that your character isn't speaking in Common, which helps enhance the roleplay


r/PCAcademy • • Feb 04 '21

Backstories Fey warlocks are the easiest thing to roleplay because you got your powers because the Fey “thought it would be funny.”

517 Upvotes

r/PCAcademy • • Nov 23 '20

Inspiration Some narrative inspiration for why a dnD 5e character cannot progress past level 20.

489 Upvotes

In dungeons and dragons, and high fantasy tabletop games in general, player characters gain power far beyond that of the average human or elf or orc. But such power always has a limit, which for dungeons and dragons 5th edition, is reaching level 20. Why can’t characters go beyond that? Mechanically it makes sense, a game needs to bound the power level somehow, otherwise Wizards of the Coast would have to make an infinite number of abilities for each class. And a character at level 20 is already on par with a demi-god, so going much further would risk the mechanics of the system collapsing. So mechanically level 20 makes sense, but why narratively do characters never reach level 21?

I want to give you some inspiration on how to handle that and discuss your characters end point with your DM. This may never come up for your characters specifically (rip scheduling a long term game), but it can also explain why the heroes that came before you are not solving the problems you run into. And maybe your DM will even let you make some these old adventures for you to find in the campaign! Before I start, aging is of course a reason for all heroes to someday stop fighting. But since elves can live hundreds of years, and war forged indefinitely, these heroes could be walking around for a long long time before their age gets the best of them and I think there are more interesting reasons for adventures to stop…well adventuring. So without further ado, let’s jump into reasoning for each class.

BARBARIANS

Barbarians are martial warriors, that draw their power from rage. This is noted as a “primal ferocity” in the players handbook, in which a barbarian erupts into a state of intense violence to survive what which would kill others and land blows with excruciating force. A barbarian will burst into this state of rage dozens if not hundreds of times throughout their adventuring career. With each instance only ending if the barbarian has no more enemies to cut down, or wounds to whether. A barbarian’s rage could come from many places but is always fed by a cycle of violence and death. But what if they become numb to this cycle? They may burst into rage, only to find they feel nothing for those they slay, and no pain when a new line of red is drawn from them, for it sits in a sea of scares. And soon thereafter, the rage never starts in the first place. They let their emotions flow out for so long, so intensely, that all that is left is calm. They are finally free of the rage that clung to their heart for years.

This is the end I envision for Barbarians. Not one of slaughter and death, but of calm and self-reflection. Some would return to their tribe of origin, doing the simple tasks of a simple life and finding comfort and fulfillment in them. Maybe their past will one day come for them to continue the cycle of violence they abided by for so long ago. Maybe a young group of adventures will find them alone in a remote mountain home, seeking the answers to questions that were buried with the old one’s rage. No matter what, this barbarian cannot bring themselves to the ferocity they once felt. Instead they build and cherish a life centered on fostering growth, where in the past they caused destruction.

BARDS

For bards, I see them having two possible ends when they reach the height of their power, They either go the way of the Rockstar, where they live fast and die young, or become so astounding that the heavens above take notice. First the Rockstar. As you may know, substance abuse is a big topic of discussion in the entertainment community of the real world, and the fantasy world probably has much more powerful and dangerous drugs to choose from. Perhaps it is not a simple overdose after a life of substance abuse that does in the Rockstar bard, but a cocktail of potions that makes them forever in a gaseous form or reduces them to the size of a flea. No matter what, the bard went a step too far in the chase for an ever more difficult to reach high.

If a world-famous bard is not the type to party with dangers levels of intoxication, instead their legendary performances could charm the very gods. After one truly beautiful performance, an angel may arrive to take the bard to Mount Celestia, so that they may enrapture the gods just as they did the denizens of the material plane. If rejected, the gods that follow law may abide by the bard’s decision, others may not. Demons and devils may soon hunt the bard across the planes, for Asmodeus wants a minstrel for his demonic court. Either willing or unwilling, the bard will come to live in the outer planes, far from the troubles of the material plane.

CLERIC

Speaking of the outer planes, that is where a powerful cleric will end up, as they ascend beyond mortality. To receive an ever-increasing wealth of divine power, a cleric must exemplify some tenant of the god they worship. As they are granted power, and show they are worthy of it, they exemplify that tenant or set of tenants so much that they become a living saint. With this rise to sainthood, they must travel to their god’s domain and serve them there, for a saint has much work to do and faithful to shepherd. The cleric will be able to provide mortals of the material plane blessings or boons, but they will be given over a long time and over a vast array of people. Thus it will seem in any moment on the material plane to be of little consequence.

DRUID

Druids will have a similar ascension as to clerics, but instead of ascending into the domain of a god to bless the faithful, a druid will ascend into a force of nature, forever more protecting their domain on the material plane. Druids are in tune with nature, that is how they learn to become beasts to protect themselves and cast spells which provide for others. The more powerful the druid, the more powerful the beast they can become to protect the natural world. Until one day, the druid becomes powerful enough to transcend melding into simple beasts, and instead becomes a force of nature. Perhaps they will become a great tree, whose roots sink deep and feel the forest for miles, searching for threats and animals in need. A tree with branches and burrows to hide the young as they grow and thrash any who would harm the forest. A guardian that has become one with that which they protect. And a guide for those lost in its woods.

FIGHTER

A fighter will be ravaged by time much more easily than most of the other classes. For it takes intense physical training and martial discipline to reach the peak of fighting capabilities. Maybe there is a limit that cannot be passed for such things. For youth lacks experience, and age lacks vigor. However even a fighter years from losing their youthful edge may find themselves with shifting priorities. Instead of facing an enemy as one, a world renown fighter can become a teacher and a leader, so they may face that same enemy as one of ten thousand. Rising to generalship means a focus on battle strategy and communication. The fighter will still find themselves drawing their sword, but far more often they are training others and learning to lead. As they sharpen their strategic vision, they’re sword dulls.

MONK

Monks, much like fighters gain power from honing their body. Unlike fighters they also hone their spirit to harness the ki that flows through them and all living things. A monk’s greatest weapon to hone themselves is mediation. But mediation is a calm slow process and it can take centuries for one to truly understand the full extent of their body and spirit. Especially as both continually change. To achieve full understanding of one’s self and become enlightened, a monk’s best option is to use astral projection to meditate within the astral plane and its sea of nothing. For there in the infinite nothing, all one has is the self. And in the Astral plane, a thousand years is but a day in the material plane, allowing for deep and lengthy meditation. The body left behind craves not for food or rest or air, suspended as the monk floats beyond themselves. Thus, every crease of the skin, every drop of blood in the veins, and every single cell of the body can be known and felt. As can every aspect of the spirit. This meditation can be salvation, or ruin. For in the astral plane lies dreadnoughts, beings before time made to consume those that walk the plane between planes. A monk deep in meditation may never see the beast push through the infinite gray void towards them. If the monster severs their silver cord, the monk’s spirit splits from their body and they die. If consumed by a dreadnought, its donjon will be the monk’s prison until death.

If a monk avoids such a gruesome fate, then they can reach true enlightenment and understand the connection they have to the world, the planes, the universe, everything. When they return to their body, wherever that may be, it dissipates, for a body is of no use to them now. Instead they spread their ki into all beings, be they, plant or animal, devil or demon, god or man, and blanket the universe with a small shard of themselves. The ki of a single body is miniscule on the cosmic scale but spread throughout all of space and the rest of time, it alters the rhythm of the universe and the shape of the future forever.

PALADIN

A paladin’s focus on the self is different than a monk’s. For it is only half of the whole. “A paladin’s power comes as much from a commitment to justice itself as it does from a god.” The end to a paladin should follow these words, for good or for ill. A paladin’s commitments may come to symbolize the tenants of the god they follow. And when their power is unmatched on the material plane, they are beckoned by their god to enter the domain of the divine and become a warrior angel, fighting forever more against the demons and devils that cause so much injustice throughout the planes. Perhaps a cleric, in a time of need, will call out to their god and this paladin will be their answer. A holy warrior, clad in light, come to defend the tenets they upheld in life. Or perhaps a paladin falls from grace, as is so easy to do for others, and breaks their oath. This is a difficult thing for a paladin do, since a paladin’s oath is tied to the deepest held beliefs they have. To break such an oath requires immense stress, trauma, or deception. No matter the cause, a paladin that does not hold firm to their oath is but a normal soldier, and that is all they will by from then on.

The final possibility for a paladin is that they no longer need to uphold their oath, for the oath has been completed. Vengeance has been done, the darkness has been dispatched, the world is finally at peace. No matter the cause, the paladin’s success releases them of their power, for they need it no longer. In the next time of need, let another don the mantle of courage and become a holy knight. This paladin shall rest. And when their final days come, they will look back and know, they triumphed over the forces of evil.

RANGER

Rangers may not be so lucky. They must protect against an endless horde of monsters causing destruction in the material plane and the planes beyond. For every beast killed as it rampages through a village, for every monstrosity put down before it can consume another victim, for every demon banished from the realms of men, another will take its place. Yet a ranger lives on fighting against this inevitable truth if only to delay it another day. That inevitable truth will lead to a ranger’s inevitable end. Whether the monsters wear down a ranger, or if time does, it does not matter. Eventually they’ll lie dead in the place they tried to protect, as monsters roam past. Striking into civilization or tearing through the forests, until another ranger rises to slay them.

ROGUE

Just as the ranger fell to the endless horde of monsters, the rogue shall fall to the endless cruelty of their fellow man. A rogue learns early to steal, cheat, and kill. Whether to simply survive a helpless situation or claw their ways to the top is irrelevant, they will always incur a debt from such things. A debt that can only be paid in blood. A rogue at the top of a criminal organization will find themselves a target for rival factions and the ambitious among their own ranks. An assassin rogue may tie up all the loose ends for a mission, only to find themselves as the last end needing tying. Even those that escape such life traps will have their past sneak up on them one day, just as they have so easily snuck up on others a hundred times before. The world of a rogue is dog-eat-dog, and some day they will be devoured.

SORCERER

A sorcerer is much more likely to be devoured by their own power than an outside threat. Though depending on the source of their power, this may be welcomed. Divine, Draconic, and Storm sorcerers allow their mortal forms to be consumed, for it leads them to assume another, more powerful state of being. Those of a divine soul may become a demigod and even a true god with enough time, ascending above the troubles of mortals. A draconic bloodline sorcerer fully unleashes the power within their veins and transforms into a dragon. With this transformation comes immense power, but also ego and an intoxication with one’s own nobility. Sorcerer’s of the storm become the heart of their own never-ending tempest of rain and lightning. They float above the land as all storms do, detached from what is below but affecting it nonetheless.

Sorcerers of Wild Magics and Shadow Magics are not so willing to give in to their power. A wild magic sorcerer is forever on the precipice of annihilation, be it of their enemies, their allies, or themselves. Without meaning, they may tear open the spaces between the planes, flooding the material world with what lies beyond. Or erupt in an inferno, engulfing the city streets around them. For fear of these outcomes, they may be hunted, by man and god alike. Or they may resolve themselves to never use their magics again, for fear they will become the destruction they once protected the world from. Shadow magic sorcerers on the other hand, may limit their use of magics to stem the tide of darkness growing within them. Each spell they cast pulls from the dark energy of the Shadowfell, which in turn allows that energy to cling tighter to the sorcerer. In the darkest night, shadows may creep into the very heart of such a sorcerer, turning it pale black and lifeless. This fate may be halted if such a sorcerer spends their days in the Feywilds, a place filled with energy in direct opposition to the shadows in their heart. But there they must remain forever, least the shadows crawl any deeper.

WARLOCK

Warlocks have the opposite problem of sorcerers, for their own power may not devour them, but that which gifts those powers, their patron, just might. Each time a patron gives a warlock power, there is a chance the warlock has become powerful enough to oppose their patron. Perhaps giving out such power is worth the risk, for the warlock is close to completing some goal of the patron. If the patron cannot stand a warlock retaining these gifts, then they will come to conflict, for a warlock will not want to relinquish that which they have gained. This will only end with either the warlock or their patron destroyed. If the warlock survives the conflict, they can take up the mantel of patron, and give to others what they once yearned for. As this power is given, they will know it could mean their end if given too freely.

WIZARD

The downfall of a wizard is similar to that of a warlock, as it requires them gaining the power, they sought for so long. With their endless study of the arcane, wizards hope to reach spells that the mind is too mortal to contain. For these magics are only fit for gods to wield. A wizard or sorcerer at the height of their power can bend reality to their wishes, imprison the greatest evils for millennia, and rain hellfire for miles. Sorcerers avoid the dangers of containing such magic by either becoming something beyond mortal or succumbing to their powers before it can affect them. Wizards have no such respite and their mind can only hold for so long. Eventually the mind buckles under the strain of holding such immense magical glyphs, incantations, and energy. As it does, a wizard’s most prized possession, their mind, becomes the prison in which they cannot escape. Recent memories become a haze of forgotten shapes and faces. Conversations held moments ago disappear like mist. The process cannot be stopped, even if all spells are forgotten. The mind has been cracked and it will flow out. As memories fade and the world becomes a land of mysteries, the mind spurts, gasping for thought. And from these gasps come some of the magic held deepest and longest. Balls of fire erupt without word, magical barriers are erected with mundane gestures, and darts of magical energy strike friend and foe at random. The danger such a wizard possesses to nearby civilization will cause harsh measures to be taken. If a wizard afflicted by arcane dementia survives the assassins and blood thirsty mobs, they only have a life of deteriorating mental function left ahead. This is what makes so many powerful wizards seek out lichdom. Not only does becoming a lich give them a reprieve from death, but also ensures they can wield their immense arcane power for centuries instead of years.

CONCLUSION

With that, every class of hero is limited for a reason. Some are limited by their focus shifting away from themselves to leading those that have gathered around them. And with this there is always the chance of betrayal ending life prematurely. Others will find themselves consumed by the power they once wielded for so long, a raging inferno that can no longer be contained. Yet others still will be consumed by their power in such a way as to be reborn. But this new form will care little for the wants and needs of the mortal that came before. Perhaps the best off are those heroes that simply stop fighting. Instead they live into old age following mundane patterns to carry out mundane tasks and finding comfort in them. No matter the hero and their end, they will be remembered. For one cannot become legendary without first becoming a legend.

Hope this gives you some character inspiration!


r/PCAcademy • • Aug 05 '20

Guide A couple of simple things one can do to enhance their RP at the table

474 Upvotes

Good morning everyone,

a good half of you will already do all these. This is the "low hanging fruit" stuff of RPing at the table that everyone can always do, but still make a massive difference between those who do and don't.

Reaction Shots

The DM describes something happening to your character and then gives the floor over to you for your reaction.

For example: "The orc grabs the person next to you, raise them to the air and then throw them to the ground while letting of a scream filled with bloodlust. Your turn. How do you react?"

The difference between these two answers is massive:

A) "I use my Hammer to immediately attack him."

B) "I jump back, shocked, mumble something like "you damn beast" and then use my hammer to attack him."

A simple shout, a description of your characters face, a look to the other characters, a brief moment of what is your character thinking or what emotion comes over them. Having that before the mechanical description of your next action is worth gold on a table.

And everyone taking these extra seconds comes off as way more energetic and enganged on the table - even if both may be equally engaged in the game. Especially useful in combat, but anytime during the game when something big, scary, exciting or just unexpected happens it is well worth the few seconds to describe your characters immediate reaction.

Have a Ritual

This is something I look for when I read the backstories of others. What DMs often ask is "You all wake up after a good nights sleep, what are you doing? What is your morning ritual?"

Most tables I have seen, about half the players had an answer to that question. But it is one thing your character does out of their own volition, in full view of the rest and with the option of sharing that.

But it doesn't just have to be a morning ritual. Maybe there is a specific thing you do every time you come into a new town, or when meeting new people, or when faces with an unclean kitchen.

Any thing you regularly engage with, something that is routine for your character and can be relied upon. Something that deeply impacts your character when their routine is interrupted. Something your character has an unreasonably strong opinion about.

There are several characters I have played with where I don't remember their names, their classes, the time they crit some boss, but I absolutely do remember their morning ritual and the time they had no tobacco left.

How do you introduce yourself?

What is your characters answer to "Who are you?"

If this sounds basic, it is. But nonetheless I see a lot of players who's best response is "I'm Jeff." (Or whatever their name is) The mayor of the town you just saved doesn't ask for just your name, he wants to hear a 1-sentence self-description. And it absolutely jumpstarts the following conversation with any NPCs. I can be as simple as "humble servant of the people" or "famous duelist in the port-city". People love titles. They don't even have to be real.

It wouldn't be cool if the protagonist just says "I'm just Geralt. Normal Guy." instead of "Don't you know this is the Witcher, Geralt of Riva?"

Openly and loudly discuss what you want to find in that treasure room

A) It increases the chances that something like it may be in there.

B) Opening the last door to the vault is surprisingly suspenseful, if the party had a hearty discussion about their desires and wishes. And without this, it often just comes down to "Oh look. Here is some treasure. Guess I'll have a look." and even good loot somehow becomes a letdown.

Pre-Murder Death Threats

Engaging in a smack talk between your character and the enemy is fun. Many western Climaxes are basically built on those. See this for example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lyuwBW9lNa8

It is the wonderful middle ground between a villain monologue and voice-less faceless heroes immediately rolling initiative upon seeing an enemy. Do this especially for the BBEG and its lieutenants, they deserve it. You can do it before initiative, but it is also welcome during. Too many players do not use their free speak action, even for just smack talk, and instead become silent robots during a fight.

As I said, these are tiny tiny things everyone can do without much trouble. Many already do. But they absolutely have a huge impact on the table and everyone who finds themselves not doing any of this should try it out.

You don't need a grandiose backstory. Or be a super amazing public speaker. Or have the best ideas. Simply take 5 seconds at the beginning of your turn to be impressed about what just happened. It works.


r/PCAcademy • • Jun 01 '21

Classes and Archetypes UPDATE: My DM told me he uses four hour short rests after I’d built a Warlock. Is my Warlock kinda fucked?

429 Upvotes

After a lot of good advice/suggestions (and some people who are weirdly aggressive about DM’s having home rules (like, seriously, who hurt you?)), I talked with my DM and he acknowledged I had no idea how the resting would work ahead of time and it would have affected how my build ended up if I had.

He’s letting me switch out my Warlock levels for Sorcerer ones so now I’m playing a Sorcerer 7/Paladin 1 build. Some of the Sorcerer options are pretty close to the character stuff I’d been working with before, so it’s a very easy transition from a story perspective while allowing me more utility in combat. Pretty excited to try a class I’ve never played with before and should be fun to actually have the spell slots to burn going forward.

Moral of the story: talk to your DM. There’s usually a way to work around stuff like this.

Side note, y’all who jumped immediately on the “he’s a bad DM” train need to stop assuming so much. Dude is a great DM who forgot to let me know about a home rule. There are worse sins out there.


r/PCAcademy • • May 04 '21

Roleplaying Am I weird for wanting to RP a Berserker Barbarian as a “simple, honest farmer” wielding a log-splitting axe?

418 Upvotes

“I got to get some extra cash. Half our herd died to frost last year, and a barn typically costs a two years wage, etc etc.”


r/PCAcademy • • Jul 29 '21

Table Skills Am I wrong to feel bad that the DM introduced another character with the same abilities as me, but stronger?

415 Upvotes

So I've been playing in a campaign set in a homebrew world for the last 5 months, and we at are level 5 currently. The party has been pretty balanced, class and race wise, with me being the only wizard/full arcane caster in the party. We have a druid but he is up front a lot and doesn't use his magic or wildshape much, the others are up front and don't do much magic. Now during this campaign, a lot of the other characters have gotten very powerful magical items (ones that as a DM myself I would consider very overpowered for a low level PC), but my wizard hasn't gotten any. So I've been feeling pretty underpowered already. In steps a new player*, bringing the party total to 6 PCs, and he's playing an artificer/wizard multiclass (I think, the player won't actually say what race or class he is, even though I asked several times), wearing heavy armor and able to cast the same spells as me but he has higher stats and is much more powerful than me, already having magical items, both from his artificer class and ones that he has (again the player won't really say, so I'm going by things he used in combat). To add insult to injury, the very first combat, on the first turn, he cast a web spell that hit my familiar, which pissed my character off. The player (out of character) starts trying to convince me its fine, but I told him that it wasn't fine but that we should move on with the game as I didn't want to bog things down.

Am I wrong to feel obsolete here? I also feel like this secret character stuff is really obnoxious and I should know at least out of character what someone is playing. I'm considering leaving the campaign over it and am going to talk to my DM, but I wanted to know if I was out of line here, or if others would feel crappy about this situation?

*note that I was not asked if its ok if this new guy plays a wizard or anything, as a mostly DM, I would always ask my players if someone playing the same class or role as another player was ok

Update: Talked with the DM and I'm moving on. Back to being a forever DM I suppose. I definitely learned some lessons I am going to use to improve my DMing and making sure players are having fun.

For those wondering I finally learned that the mystery character is, and of course its this crazy min maxed build, custom lineage - artificer 1/wizard 4, I didn't ask the feat, but must be heavily armored (unless its the magic items, I was on my way out so I didn't get every detail.)


r/PCAcademy • • Nov 08 '20

Tools and Resources Use the "16 Personalities" test to RP your characters better

411 Upvotes

Go to: https://www.16personalities.com/free-personality-test

Answer the questions as your character would and you'll have a fairly comprehensive guide for how your character will act in certain situations and how they handle relationships.


r/PCAcademy • • Jan 25 '21

Arcana Can I use Speak with Plants to speak to salad and threaten/instill fear in it as I prepare to eat it?

385 Upvotes

Just curious.


r/PCAcademy • • Dec 26 '20

Tools and Resources When using Fantasy name generator, use the WoW version to get more heroic names

374 Upvotes

This example is orc specific

Sample from the normal one

Thurunur

Kulaz

Tharumak

Hogurth

Mugodark

Gromaburk

sample from the wow version

Trinoth Vengesong

Umdach Wickedkill

Mikanzirg Dualchest

Drahltath Frostspirit

Arorn Cravenpack

Sotzarzor Foremane


r/PCAcademy • • Jul 03 '21

Backstories Does a "Black Knight" Folk Hero make sense?

373 Upvotes
  • Serf saves Lord's Son from death by boar.

  • Serf requests knighthood.

  • Serf is lured into the woods and is hunted by the Lord, his Son, and the Captain of the Guard. Seeing how they were "robbed" of a proper hunt and "humiliated" by other Lords.

  • Serf is left impaled against a tree, presumed dead.

  • Years later the news of the murder is somehow leaked to the lands and rumors of the Serf's survival are whispered.

  • The Lord returns to the clearing, only to find no sign of the spear nor the Serf. Coincidently, there is also a spear-wielding Bandit who is targeting the Lord's caravans.

  • The coin from such robberies ends up in the hands of the Lord's serfs. The Bandit swears that they will target the caravans until the Lord, his Son, and the Captian are brought to justice. Either through the law of the land or by their hand.

(Still debating if the Black Knight should be the Serf or someone else.)


r/PCAcademy • • Apr 23 '21

Backstories Is “running away from an arranged marriage” a good backstory for a Noble character?

371 Upvotes

r/PCAcademy • • Aug 22 '20

Table Skills Character Died and DM keeps saying the next session will be the one my new character will be introduced

358 Upvotes

Last month my character died in a group I have had about 20 sessions with. I immediately sat down and got to work on my next character and sent it to the Dm to get him into the story. The Dm at first said that the character would likely be introduced at the end of the next session. The next session rolls around and DM says it will likely be near the start of the next session. That session came and went. Now it looks like my character will show up for part of the next session according to the DM.

This would not be too concerning to me, but I asked the DM shortly after my character died if I could control an NPC or a guest character of sorts and the DM said no because it would not make sense for another player to show up at this point in the story. Shortly before the next session, the DM brings in another player to "balance the party" and left me nothing to do. I'm relatively new to DND how should I address these concerns to the DM.


r/PCAcademy • • Apr 07 '21

Roleplaying When caring about each other is the party's central goal

352 Upvotes

My current D&D party is made of four characters who genuinely care about each other and the community they live in, and that's been the entire impetus behind pretty much all our decisions. No worrying about if you can trust the other PCs, no fighting over loot/spoils, no underhanded shenanigans to one-up each other, no dark hidden backstories that the other players can't know until it messes up the party's plans. Each PC gives the others the benefit of the doubt, and goes out of their way/makes personal sacrifices to ensure the wellbeing of their loved ones.

Just a scientist (transmutation wizard), his lab partner (artificer, but it's all biological themed), his niece (college of glamour bard with blood magic), and his sentient robot bodyguard (divine soul sorcerer). It's the most wholesome, refreshing D&D I've ever played. For example, we've so far gone on quests to...

-calm down the berserker rampaging through town (turns out he was trying to free someone who was kidnapped, who we then helped return home to his husband)

-set up the community garden (and hold a party afterwards!)

-watch the bard's first show at the theater (the cops shut it down when things got too out of hand, but it is what it is)

-escort the bard to her demonic boss so she can get some upward mobility in her circus (this got a bit out of hand when we got unwittingly sold some shrooms)

-cure the bard who accidentally poisoned herself to impress her demonic boss (Okay I'm noticing a pattern here... I admit, I play the bard)

-Help the warforged learn more about his own creation

We've have a grand total of 2 combat encounters, and only cause the party can't sneak for shit. It's super refreshing and relaxing, and I suggest trying out something similar if you can get your party on board!


r/PCAcademy • • May 27 '21

Roleplaying Learned something about evil PCs

340 Upvotes

Not a DM but I did learn something from another DM who did not ban evil characters. He was running out of the abyss and at first I question his motives for allowing his (the DM’s) friend to bring in an evil PC. The PC was chaotic evil no less, but he was played quite well.

A chaotic evil human fighter with a huge hatred for drow, this PC was prone to murdering them at any chance he got. He was vengeful and enjoyed killing drow whenever he could get away with it. However, this PC was smart about it. He knew Sarith (the prisoner drow) was too useful to kill immediately due to navigation skills. He wasn’t going out of his way to look for drow to slaughter, but he didn’t hesitate to do so if nobody was watching, even if he got nothing but his bloodthirst from it.

It wasn’t until the very end of the campaign when this character revealed his true colors. He wanted to unleash the demon fight in Menzoberranzan, in its slave pens. He knew the demon lords would completely ruin the slaves and because the drow rely so heavily on them, it would be their downfall. Multiple slaves died just so he could destroy the drow city and nobody suspected the PC had it in him.

Now I’m glad he wasn’t banned from the table, it was actually fun.


r/PCAcademy • • May 06 '21

Table Skills I don't have to heart to speak with the dm and players about my breakdown

335 Upvotes

So almost two weeks ago, I had a roleplaying incident with another player. I wanted to interact more with their character, so my character followed them into the woods when they were doing private stuff. In retrospect, I should not have done that, but the character (note: not player) was furious and started to yell at me. Somewhere between that, I (note: me, the player) started having a nervous breakdown, so I skipped out of the session asap to lie in bed and kind of...go through with my emotions.

Now, the next session is about to come up, and I find my blood pressure rising at the thought of going through the aftermath, or even interacting with that character. I want to bring this up, but I am uncomfortable with oversharing my own mental health struggles (and I don't know the people that well to know if I am safe to do so). I also don't want people to feel bad since even I didn't know I wouldn't be able to handle the roleplay. I also know I do not necessarily have to share, but I'm not sure what to do? I'm a newer player, so I can't just tell an established and well-liked character to change who they are to accommodate me without good reason. I feel so stuck right now and it feels like the only option right now is to eat my feelings. What can I do?


r/PCAcademy • • Oct 20 '20

Backstories An Open Letter to Players Regarding Backstories, From a Forever DM

330 Upvotes

Players,

First of all thank you! I don't think the importance of your role at the table gets appreciated enough when people discuss tabletop roleplaying games in general. Without you, us DMs are simply writing books no one will likely read. Your characters breathe life and provide focus to our worlds. You are essential and I would like to say I appreciate you on behalf of DMs everywhere.

Backstories. Ahhh, Backstories. The first thing I'd like to do is define two really important concepts. The Backstory Hook and Backstory Elements. After that, I want to share some of the dangers of the former and the benefits of the latter.

The Backstory Hook is that event many players develop that caused a serious amount of trauma in their PC's life pre-adventuring. It is the death of family members at the hands of a cruel tyrant or bandit. It is the destruction of their home after an attack by evil forces like demons or the undead. It is the soul crushing loneliness of permanent exile. Backstory Elements are the smaller events that are born from Hooks which produce more subtle influences on a character's personality. They aren't black and white by design. Now, lets start with Backstory Hooks.

There is a common understanding that Backstory Hooks are essential to character development. They do provide motivation for how to roleplay a character and help your DM make the campaign narrative more immersive. Here is something you may not know though. The more experienced your DM is, the less they appreciate these black and white Backstory Hooks. As a DM gains confidence in their ability to craft immersive campaign plots, the less they want to lean on the obvious crutch of a Backstory Hook. By this point, an experienced DM has probably incorporated a large variety of Hooks that essentially boil down to the same theme. Revenge. Justice. Betrayal. We've seen it before. It simply doesn't interest us like it use to.

Another issue with Backstory Hooks is that they heavily influence a player's approach to a story. A character whose parents were slaughtered by bandits likely has a player that will view the entire world through that very narrow lens. Does an NPC have any hint of moral ambiguity? They probably deserve death. Moral soft ground becomes non-existent. In short, your DM has been hobbled. If they want to introduce an NPC that has important information, that NPC has to very obviously not come close to the cross-hairs that the player with the Backstory Hook is constantly looking at the campaign through. The entire story shifts into two very obvious moral camps, Good and Bad.

So, what can you do as a player to avoid the issues surrounding Backstory Hooks? Develop Backstory Elements instead! Hooks tend to be viewed as unsolved problems. An Element is something that has some resolution but a definite consequence. The consequence impacts the character's personality, motivations, or fears. In essence, Elements set a player up to approach the campaign with a forward posture rather than one that is constantly looking over its shoulder at the Hook.

Curiously, Elements can most easily be crafted by starting with a Hook and then applying some ambiguity to it. For example, lets go with the murdered parents Hook. An Element would be that the character's parents died in an accident that was unfortunately the character's fault but the character lied to everyone and now has to live with that. The player can now focus on the consequences. Has their character leaned into the lying until they have convinced themselves? Do they feel a lot of shame? Does the sight of parents with their children invoke these emotions? How does the fact that there can be no justice for their parents deaths until the character themselves have come to terms with it impact their motivations?

What do Backstory Elements provide your DM? A much more fluid way to engage your character in the campaign that doesn't depend on satisfying a single goal like justice or revenge. In the example above, a DM can have a side scene revolving around similar circumstances. A murder mystery where it is revealed that a child accidently caused the death of their parents. Now a scene develops that is very emotionally charged. From my perspective as a DM, I'm heavily invested in this scene as well because I don't even know what happens.. Do you as a player understand how powerful that is? How much joy and fun that provides your DM? When they get surprised by a scene?

A Backstory Element doesn't necessarily require the character to have done something awful either. Again, start with a Hook. A village wiped out by bandits. Go further though. The character, orphaned, was taken in by a travelling caravan merchant. This merchant became a mentor. Helped the character reconcile the emotional trauma over the course of several years. The character picked up some unique skills.

This type of character can be drawn into campaign narratives involving the lost. Perhaps they want to pay it forward and mentor others. Travelling with this merchant has provided them with a more cosmopolitan perspective on different cultures. They can become the glue that keeps the more extreme characters in the party together. A peace keeper.

What can I do with that as a DM? Well, a peace keeper is one of the greatest boons to a DM possible. It relieves so much stress when someone approaches the task of maintaining party cohesiveness from an in-character approach. It also provides me with the ability to do the next thing that absolutely delights DMs. We can surprise a player. Maybe the party encounters the old mentor on the road. The mentor has a problem that needs help. If the campaign is darker, maybe the party comes across evidence that the mentor wasn't as good as they were. Came upon hard times and had to make hard choices. The character now has to deal with the reality of their mentor crashing from a pillar. Or the mentor is found to have been killed. The theme of vengeance is introduced except it is on my terms as a DM. It hits the campaign like a stab in the ribs and provides immediate momentum. The theme of vengeance hasn't been hanging over the entire campaign like a whip constantly flogging it since Session One. Again, as a DM, we get to surprise you. We love that. Perhaps more than getting surprised.

So, in conclusion, I want to strongly encourage all the players out there to start kneading their Backstory Hooks into Backstory Elements. If the Hook is exceptionally brutal, find some softness. If the Hook is exceptionally innocent, find some edges. The dynamic nature of an Element will help you roleplay a far more engaging and interesting character as well as provide your DM more options to incorporate a spectrum of themes after deconstructing it and reconstituting the parts into the campaign narrative in general.

Good luck! Oh! Don't forget to discuss these Elements with your DM! They might have some interesting ideas or perspectives on how to mold an Element from a Hook.

Sincerely,

A Forever DM (By Choice)


r/PCAcademy • • Sep 24 '21

Arcana We've Been Sleeping on Mind Whip

329 Upvotes

This spell. If you're like me, you saw it in Tasha's and thought "oh, that looks pretty good", and then forget about it. I certainly haven't seen many people talking about it.

But it is good. It's better than good. It's amazing.

After playing with it, our party's wizard has quickly launched this spell into the very top ranks of our personal favourite spells. Why is it so good?

- It requires an Int save to resist. Statistically, one of best saves for a spell to have. Even very intelligent characters, such as ancient dragons or vampires, don't have proficiency in Int saves.

- On a failure, it takes away a creature's reaction and it's choice of movement, action, or bonus action. This means that after you whip it, you and every other ally can simply walk past the creature with no fear of opportunity attacks, forcing it to use movement to catch back up at them. If the creature is knocked prone, (say from a shove), it has to choose between staying prone and using it's entire turn to stand up

- It doesn't require concentration, making it a great utility spell to cast while you're concentrating on other things.

- On an upcast, it doesn't deal more damage; it gains more targets. At higher levels you can fairly consistently immobilize chunks of enemies with only an action and a 3rd/4th level slot.

I think at first it seems to compare pretty unfavourably to things like Hold Person and Tasha's Hideous Laughter, but the Intelligence save component makes this spell much more reliable than a lot of people might realize.


r/PCAcademy • • Aug 29 '21

Table Skills Am I being a bad player by always ending my turn out of danger?

328 Upvotes

We're currently mopping up the last dungeon of LMOP, planning on moving onto ROT after. This is the DM's first time, so he's going 95% by the book. My character is a very cowardly kobold sorcerer, who has learnt his lesson about line of sight after getting peppered by some arrows in a dungeon or another. Since then, my turns usually consist of getting into line of sight, shooting fire bolt/scorching ray/what have you, and ducking behind the nearest corner to end my turn. While this is in character, this makes my character pretty much untouchable (by the book means only one room encounter at a time, no patrols show up mid-encounter, and we have a sturdy frontline). Is this something generally disruptive to DMs and I should stop?


r/PCAcademy • • Apr 15 '21

Table Skills I don't want to play in my own player's campaign anymore.

326 Upvotes

So, I got the invite to join one of my uni players' new campaign. I was excited, created a lovely little character who I enjoy RPing quite a bit, and (some) of the players are fun.

However, the player/DM who runs it, just can't run a game. He is slow to talk, doesn't describe, actively tells us what the enemies didn't do and why, as well as what they do and with their reasoning, which is a big no-no IMO as it takes any tension away, as well as just not being able to make the players actually play. He waits too much for the players to tell him what they want to do, without explaining what is actually happening around them, which becomes especially tedious during combat. He asks for feedback after every session, and I don't mind giving it, but as he is a player in my campaign and I am quite afraid to make him uncomfortable, as well as the fact that he has been DMing for way longer than I have, so I don't want to step on any toes. This has been after 3 sessions, which have all been quite stale, pacing wise.

I feel like I have two options. Either I help him become an (in my opinion) better DM, especially with the flow of the game so that combat with 3 low-level enemies doesn't take 2 hours to run, or I somehow let them know I don't want to continue playing, in a respectful way, but I have no idea how to do so. I feel there isn't too much chance for option 1 to be successful as he is quite awkward, but option 2 might also be a bad option, as I don't want to unmotivate him from DMing.

Apart from all of this, the players really, really like my character. I feel bad about taking their joy away from my little Kobold sorcerer, looking for their dad, who they believe to be a blue dragon.

All in all, difficult situation, don't know what to do, help ='(