We've been using OBR 1 for over a year, and some of my players started using the die roller a while ago. They loved it, and more switched until almost everyone was using it, even though they always had the option of using their own dice. We've been playing together for over 30 years, so trust isn't an issue, but was fun to finally see each others' rolls again, and I could finally roll in the open as GM.
I love most of the features in OBR2, so this week for our game I made the switch to try it out. We mostly liked it a lot. Our complaints were:
A) There is no longer an option of changing the color of a token border; something we did a lot to mark various conditions. It wasn't that big of a deal, because I started using some condition attachments to tokens that were more clear anyway. It's a little slower, but we didn't mind working around it in exchange for the much improved rulers and initiative tracker, and general smoothness.
And B) We hated the roller. Boy is it clunky, even though it looks better.
In OBR 1, click=roll. You can change a color if you want. If you do, it stays that way. 1 click.
In OBR 2, because we were using the initiative tracker (which everyone liked and made my life much easier), and the dice tray is on the same bar, it takes 4 clicks to roll one die, since you can't have the tracker and the tray open at the same time. It was way too slow for me to make my rolls on as DM, since I need to make so many, so I switched back to using my own dice after an hour in game.
In OBR 2, Open tray -> select color (which you need to do for every roll, even though you can't roll 2 different colors at the same time anyway, which would be great for DMs to roll different creatures at the same time) ->click to add a die -> click to roll. That's 4 clicks to roll a D20. And yes, I know it only takes 1 click if you need to reroll the same dice a second time, but for damage you need to select damage dice and click to roll them, and then click 3 more times to get the D20 back.
It's bad enough that they convinced me to switch back to OBR1 for our next game, even though they liked the other features. We swap games between 3 DMs, and I don't think either of the other 2 DMs are going to switch to OBR2 after trying it, even though they'd talked about it.
We overall love OBR2. Is there any way to make the die roller less obnoxious?