r/Osten_Ard • • Nov 29 '18

Green Angel Tower Understanding the final confrontation in To Green Angel Tower [Spoilers MST]

21 Upvotes

So, I just finished To Green Angel Tower, and it was great! I really loved the series. It's a bummer there don't seem to be more active places to talk about it, especially with its at once very obvious and complicated relationship with A Song of Ice and Fire. If there are other enthusiasts out there, I'd love to talk about it!

The first thing that comes to mind is the final confrontation in the tower. I'm not 100% sure I knew exactly what happened. I had the feeling of it being a tiny bit disappointing - an overly simple solution to a really complex and desperate problem. But I also wonder if, reading into it, there is more to it than what there seems to be, because for as simple as it was, it was still really complicated.

Also if he goes into it and recontextualizes what happened in The Witchwood Crown or somesuch, please let me know, but I guess don't spoil that yet? Maybe?

Anyway, here's my sense for what happened. Correct me if I'm wrong:

  • Ineluki and Utuk'ku have been using the Breathing Harp in Stormspike - a Master Witness - to access the Dream Road and the general realm of mind and spirit beyond the material world.

  • They have been using this to spread visions, prophesies, and false promises to convince the living to help complete the ritual to bring back Ineluki. Utuk'ku has been planning this and laying groundwork for hundreds or thousands of years.

  • Pyrates is suckered in by a promise to be first among mortals and have heretofore untold knowledge. (AND HE GETS A ONE-LINER WORTH OF COMMANDO INSTEAD)

  • Miriamele thinks Elias has been suckered in by promises that he will be reunited with his dead wife, but Elias actually seems to be more interested in power and immortality than his daughter thinks he is.

  • The swords themselves have to be suckered in and would not just participate willingly. So the plan involves having each sword be discovered by a man who is well-suited to wield it, and who is wielding it at least an imitation of its devoted purpose.

    • Thorn is a sword of imperial glory. It goes with Simon because he fights a dragon with it and the sword wants to fight a dragon. Then Thorn goes with Caramis because it is an imperial sword of Nabban and wants to be held in battle by the rightful Imperator of Nabban who is also a great knight.

    • Bright-Nail is a sword of righteousness, specifically for Aedonites (Christians). It refuses to go with Elias and burns him, presumably because he is godless and not righteous. It goes with blind Guthwulf, presumably because Guthwulf is a Usires/Christ figure who is suffering in the underworld looking to be reborn, and he uses it in the Christ re-enactment to free Simon from his crucifixion the Wheel - he dies and Simon is resurrected. Bright-Nail is down with all of this, and it's down with Simon carrying it to save the world in righteousness.

    • Sorrow is a sword of grief and loss. It goes with Elias because Elias is crushed by the death of his wife and what he sees as the betrayal and implied infidelity of his brother. Elias's sense of loss, betrayal and abandonment is similar to Ineluki's, and Elias is looking to achieve what Ineluki wants, so Sorrow is down with that.

  • Team good-guys has to be convinced to go get the two remaining swords and bring them to Green Angel Tower for the ritual. So the mad prophet Nisse has been influenced through the Master Witness, and perhaps through the time travel aspect of the ritual, or just by the horrendous presence of Ineluki as a malevolent spirit, to write down a prophesy in the past that the heroes read in the present.

  • Part of the ritual involves building the five "houses" to coincide with the arrival of the Conqueror's Star - this is just classic astrological stuff. As the "houses" are built, the members of the Red Hand materialize into the world.

  • The Fire Dancers exist for three reasons:

  • The way the Art works, religious faith is able to ward against various sorts of magical things, and priests of Aedon and the High King of Osten Ard as a religious figure have been warding important places for a long time to prevent the Sithi from using them generally, which in turn, unbeknownst to them, has been preventing Utuk'ku from doing stuff. So the Fire Dancers need to attack and destroy the religious faith of Aedonites in order to create psychospiritual room for other sorts of realities to emerge in the material realm.

  • The rituals requires a great deal of human sacrifice, and the Fire Dancers round up people to ritualistically kill them.

  • War and chaos in general (including the ghants, the kelpie, the fire dancers, the war in Rimmersgard, Josua's war, all of it) will prevent the good guys from recognizing they are being played and do the one thing that would actually pose a threat to Utuk'ku, which is to talk to the Tinukeda'ya (either the Dwarrows or the Niskies) The Tinukeda'ya would be able to figure out what the plan is and stop it, as they understand the Words of Making and Unmaking, and humanity does not.

  • <INSERT DISCUSSION OF THE ASSASSINATION ATTEMPT ON CAMARIS THAT KILLS GELOE, WHICH IS A WHOLE OTHER TOPIC>

  • So, once the Houses start to get set up in earnest, the psychospiritual space in the Dream Road and beyond gets really polluted with tons of evil, and people who are sensitive to it are assaulted by it pretty much all the time. Once the various folks have the swords and we're close to the end game, they feel an inexorable pull to attend the ritual, even if they know it is bad.

  • In the final stroke before the ritual, Utuk'ku defeats Jiriki and Friends and the power of the First Hokage at the pool in the basement, which gives them the power of that Master Witness and gets things going.

Okay, so, to get to the actual ritual:

  • Elias has been prepared as a vessel for Ineluki without his knowledge - Pyrates has been taking dragon bones from the Dragonbone Chair and boiling them into a potion, telling Elias it will heal him, but really it is gradually changing his physiology into a sort of demonic, infernal Sithi, fit for Ineluki's possession. Dragon's blood appears to have transformative powers and attune people to the psychospiritual world.

  • Pyrates is also planning to double-cross Ineluki and has planned to use the Words of Changing at the last minute to bind Ineluki to his will.

  • The three dudes with the three swords stand in their little circle and touch blades, and the ritual releases the pent-up energy of the Words of Making, which is a sort of counterbalancing tension to reality's tendency to revert to the mean even when influenced by the Art.

  • The idea is for the energy of the swords to be released by Words of Unmaking, and they kind of snap like rubber bands, creating a bubble of unreality and sending Green Angel Tower back in time to a time before it was warded against the return of Ineluki by the Aedonite priests.

  • This all happens. Nobody does anything to stop it. The swords release their energy, Elias becomes possesed by Ineluki, and Pyrates springs the trap to seize control of Ineluki.

At this point, things get a little confusing, but my sense is a few things happen in succession.

  1. While coming into the material world, Ineluki becomes vulnerable because he enters a mortal body.

  2. Pyrates's attempt to control Ineluki fails, and Elias-Ineluki kills him by boiling his face with his hand.

  3. Simon comes to understand Ineluki, and lets go of his hate for him, which weakens the ritual in some way and turns Bright-Nail to dust.

  4. Miriamele, released from magical constraints by the death of Pyrates, puts on her backwards baseball cap, turns her bow and arrow sideways and shoots Elias-Ineluki gangster-style with Jiriki's White Arrow.

  5. The white arrow has an arrowhead made out of a psychospiritually active material (it's said to be similar to the witnesses, and the mirror are said to be scales of the wurm or whatever, so maybe it has a dragonscale-tipped point, which is a sort of psychic resonator designed to summon help in a time of need? Maybe?). The arrow critically injured Elias-Ineluki both physically and spiritually, killing him.

  6. This then causes "everything to be okay" in a rather straightforward and friendly cascasde. The tower collapses and Cadrach has to offer his noble sacrifice. The ward is released and the tower goes back to normal time. The Red Hand and the other houses... go away? Utuk'ku and the few remaining Norns go home to feel sorry about themselves for losing again.

  7. And then we go to the denouement with the kingdom and the marriage and all that.

Okay, so, did I get it? Is this what happens? Or am I missing something here?

I do have a few questions about all this:

- What's the deal with the Sithi and Unbeing? There seems to be a sense that what Utuk'ku really wants is an end to the material universe so she doesn't have to be alive anymore, but nobody outlives her. I was kind of surprised that Ineluki's plan seemed to be to resurrect himself, rather than to destroy all of existence. Or am I reading that wrong?

- What happened to the Red Hand and all the other Houses?

- What was the deal with the First Tree and why didn't Utuk'ku kill all the Sithi?

- Did Ineluki really just die because he was shot?

- Did this seem like an 80s fantasy movie climax to anybody else? Complete with lightning effects and stop motion animated monsters?

- Simon seems to at least take some credit for having accomplished something constructive through all these adventures that helped out and won the day. Why does he think this? It seems like at the end of the day, he barely does anything, and most of what he did ended up just making things worse (and it's arguable that the real ending/triumph in the story that brings everything full circle isn't the death of Ineluki, but his reunion with Rachel the Dragon anyway). He seems correct to believe that Miriamele deserves the credit, but even that seems like dumb luck based on how screwed everybody was. Is this a case where Simon starts to begin to believe the lie that he was a hero, in the same way Prester John did?

Thanks for reading!


r/Osten_Ard • • Aug 13 '19

ALL Memory S&T Almost exactly how I imagine Geloe’s house.

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/Osten_Ard • • Jan 22 '20

ALL Memory S&T The Lasting Legacy of Tad Williams’ Memory, Sorrow, and Thorn (Barnes and Noble, 2017)

Thumbnail
barnesandnoble.com
16 Upvotes

r/Osten_Ard • • Jan 12 '20

Art King Elias

Post image
16 Upvotes

r/Osten_Ard • • Mar 04 '20

Art Simon Snowlock Spoiler

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/Osten_Ard • • Jul 22 '19

We need more Osten Ard hot garbage!

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/Osten_Ard • • Feb 01 '20

Changes and a new sub

13 Upvotes

There's a brand new sub for Tad's work over at /r/TadWilliams

Discussion won't be limited to Osten Ard, but will cover any and all of Tad's work.

It really is brand new so there isn't much in it. It'd be fantastic if you could join me there and help the place to grow.

If anybody has any idea about css and styling a community, and would like to help, please get in touch.

The reason? - Simple, I'm a mod here and this isn't my sub so it's a bit tricky to do too much. So I've started another one.

Thanks.


r/Osten_Ard • • Apr 11 '20

Sub for all Tad's work over at /r/TadWilliams

12 Upvotes

There's a brand new sub where discussion isn't limited to Osten Ard, but covers any and all of Tad's work, over at /r/TadWilliams .

"Now come please. Come and join us. Up the corridor you have a room full of friends. Some of them you don’t even know yet!"


r/Osten_Ard • • Jan 01 '20

Happy New Year 2020

12 Upvotes

May the year bring you health and happiness, and Tad's new book.


r/Osten_Ard • • Jan 08 '20

What about a tv series for MST?

11 Upvotes

There's been GoT and there's been His Dark Materials.

What would you think of a tv series of Memory, Sorrow and Thorn trilogy?

Who would you like to take the starring roles?


r/Osten_Ard • • Jun 07 '19

Osten Ard community

11 Upvotes

I'm just about to finish To Green Angel Tower and have been looking around for resources on the series. I can't seem to find a comprehensive wiki or an active community. Does anyone know where to find such?


r/Osten_Ard • • Jan 25 '20

Witchwood Crown Notes for "The Witchwood Crown"

Thumbnail
duskbeforethedawn.net
10 Upvotes

r/Osten_Ard • • Dec 27 '19

Tad Talks Tad Williams talks about world-building

10 Upvotes

A Fantasy Literature article in which Tad talks and offers advice to writers about building fantasy worlds.

[Research and then write] Lots of science and history. But don’t just make it dry and ordinary. If you’re working in our field, you’re creating the fantastical — things should sometimes be both more horrible and more wonderful than on our plain old vanilla everyday world. People who grew up on Tolkien didn’t just love Moria, and the Nazgul, they also wanted to visit (or even move to) Lothlorien and Rivendell. Yes, you want to build a solid foundation, a rational base that makes the reader feel, “Yeah, this could exist”, but you also want to give the reader a reason to remember your world long beyond the time they can remember all the ins and outs of the plot

Some of the comments beneath the article are quite interesting too.

The article ends with a question:

How about you? What makes you want to jump into the world of a story and stay there for a good long while?

I just like to escape into another world that I can almost relate to but is so very different from my own. I like to immerse myself into that world with all it's good and bad things and experience it through the characters own eyes, and feel their emotions as the story progresses.

Tad does this by the bucket-load.


r/Osten_Ard • • Dec 26 '19

First book

10 Upvotes

So, I've just picked up the first book, via Audible. I had a free credit to use, so thought it was worth investing. I'm still ploughing through the 6th Outlander book, so won't start just yet, but am looking forward to getting hooked :-D


r/Osten_Ard • • Feb 10 '20

Ayaminu (Last King trilogy spoilers) Spoiler

9 Upvotes

Don't read this if you haven't read Heart of What Was Lost, Witchwood Crown, and Empire of Grass.

So, after appearing significantly in Heart of What Was Lost as a sort of guide and mentor with a mysterious goal of her own, the Sithi named Ayaminu reappears near the end of Empire of Grass. She's not mentioned at all in Witchwood Crown or previously in this book, as far as I know, so it's a small appearance. I made this thread to get people thinking: what role will she play, and does she have more than good intentions?

My own thoughts are that she's likely a villain - not a full on cackling power for power's sake villain, but a more morally gray one.

If you consider her a villain and that the goal she has is what she says in HOWWL - to see the Sithi and Norn reunited, just like they always were before Utuk'ku - then a whole lot of smaller questions start to make sense.

How did someone (human OR Norn) reach and kill Tanahaya's master? How did the human attackers know all about these old Sithi hunting paths in the Sithi forest, let alone their tactics? Why are some Sithi being left alive but with their mirrors taken, like Tanahaya?

The attacks by the humans on Sithi are another matter. They're basically false flag attacks, meant to rally this new group, the Pure (who basically behave and are described like Fascist Sithi...they literally think they're of a different race than the other Sithi, wear pins, and horde knowledge.) Specifically, we're told they started AT The Pure's city of Chikaza and spread outward.

Speaking of the humans, we know Hugh and the Hern have seemingly turned on everyone for the Norns. But what if they're not working for the Norns?

When Aelin interrogates the men who imprisoned them, he says exactly what we know is going on but the man replies by saying he doesn't know what's going on and implying they didn't turn on anyone but Erkynland. So, what if a Sithi like Ayaminu showed up, spoke to Hugh of their people's old bond, and asked him to help them by taking out her enemies and letting the Norns pass through his lands in exchange for getting Erkynland?

At a guess, Ayaminu is allied with Akhenabi and has been since HOWWL. Raising the dead outside the mountain was probably part of a scheme to either smuggle her in or smuggle something out. My own thoughts: it's the documents from the Queen's own archive that someone tried to destroy.

There's also smaller hints. The Norns from the hidden bases that no one, even the Prince-Templar high up next to Utuk'ku, knows of...the hidden bases set up like Ayaminu's hidden base and a stone's throw from it. The attack on the Pure by "Queen's Hand" who are not showing their faces (note Tanahaya's lengthy interior thoughts about how SOMETHING is happening here and she needs to figure it out as author sign posting that we need to pay attention) and seem to come from nowhere with zero warning.

Note also how the Ayaminu scene occurs out of chronological order by a significant amount of days/weeks: it happens near the end of the book, but should be occurring back Part 2: Autumn's Chill, mere hours after Naglimund falls. Ayaminu is located a stone's throw from the Pure, but no one in the city knows about the massive war party of Norns or the "other" mortals who showed up despite days/weeks of forewarning.


r/Osten_Ard • • Jan 27 '20

Books similar to Tad's Osten Ard stories?

9 Upvotes

What would you recommend to readers that have equal depth, world and character building, to Tad's Osten Ard books?

Some good, long, reads that envelop the reader.

Traditionally I think most would suggest Lord of the Rings, so I'll get that one in first.


r/Osten_Ard • • Jun 06 '19

ALL Memory S&T What is the age rating for MST?

9 Upvotes

I want to give it to my younger sister, is there any sex or language I need to know about?


r/Osten_Ard • • Jan 31 '20

Heart of WWL Book notes: "The Heart of What Was Lost" by Tad Williams

Thumbnail
duskbeforethedawn.net
8 Upvotes

r/Osten_Ard • • Jan 04 '20

War of Flowers My first read of "The War of the Flowers"

8 Upvotes

About the book:

Theo Vilmos is a thirty-year-old lead singer in a not terribly successful rock band. Once, he had enormous, almost magical charisma, both onstage and off—but now, life has taken its toll on Theo.

Hitting an all-time low, he seeks refuge in a isolated cabin in the woods. While there, he reads an odd memoir written by a dead relative who believed he had visited the magical world of Faerie. And before Theo can disregard the account as the writings of a madman, he, too, is drawn to a place beyond his wildest dreams...a place that will be, and has always been, his destiny.


Edit: 19th Jan 2020
I've read the book and would recommend it to anybody who's looking for a standalone fantasy that they can't put down.

I've made some comments below, but please bear in mind that I'm no reviewer!


r/Osten_Ard • • Jun 20 '19

Map Where are the good maps?

8 Upvotes

I'm reading the Dragonbone Chair and, after finishing A song of Ice and Fire, I find the lack of good online maps of Osten Ard surprising. I got used to the Rich tapistery of official and fan maps of ASOIAF. It seems like we are missing a nice, detailed, high resolution map that contains the names of all the places/rivers/roads in the books.

What am I missing? Is it that the Osten Ard community is small? am I the only one who really likes to follow things on maps? Or is there an awesome map somewhere that Google is too stupid to help me find?

I realize that the books have maps, I realize that there are some maps online. But none of them seems to have comprehensive place names.


r/Osten_Ard • • May 16 '19

Empire of Grass In the middle of Empire of Grass

8 Upvotes

So there are definite parallels to the original series: Lost in the forest, same antagonists, a troll as guide/mentor. But while the elements are similar, the story itself is unique, and the further exploration of the world and cultures is so good. So so good. Definitely worth getting in to the new trilogy. I'm loving it so far.


r/Osten_Ard • • Jan 15 '20

Tad article in Vulture: "What Is Game of Thrones’ Legacy in Epic Fantasy?"

7 Upvotes

I think it's interesting to see Tad's point of view about GoT and the development of fantasy writing in general and how it's tied in with world events.

The article was published Apr. 12, 2019

https://www.vulture.com/2019/04/game-of-thrones-george-r-r-martin-legacy-epic-fantasy.html?utm_source=tw

If, after this, you like the idea of reading E.R. Eddison's The Worm Ouroboros - first published in 1922 - which comes in at over 400 pages in paperback. The Kindle version is a mere 49p for UKers, and $1:30 on the .com site.


r/Osten_Ard • • Jan 09 '20

Art Skali of Kaldskrykes. Just finished SoF, not sure if we get a description later on so this is imagination for now.

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/Osten_Ard • • Jul 10 '17

Witchwood Crown Got The Witchwood Crown!

7 Upvotes

I preordered it from amazon. Got it on the 27th. I'm a little past halfway. I'm loving it. There are definite parallels between this and the original trilogy, but it's not annoying or cheap. It's an amazing story so far. I think if you liked Memory Sorrow and Thorn, you'll love these.


r/Osten_Ard • • Jan 03 '17

Heart of WWL [No Spoilers] Time to awaken from your long slumber r/Osten_Ard. New book available today!

7 Upvotes

I just downloaded "The Heart of What Was Lost" from iBooks. I am looking forward to returning to Osten Ard. Anyone else excited?