r/OrthodoxChristianity • u/MabKaterberiansky • Jun 19 '25
Sexuality I, a Christian, don't agree with many Orthodox Christian ideals NSFW
Hey everyone, I (30F) feel the need to share this. Maybe in the hopes of finding someone in the same boat. If you want to scorn me, save your words; I have enough scorn from my fellow Christians in the church where I was baptized. I fast as much as I can, and I pray almost daily.
Context: I grew up in Serbia, where Orthodoxy is a cultural part of our identity. So, I grew up with it, but I didn't really accept it until the age of 27, when I decided to get baptized. I have always been interested in religion ever since a young age and even wanted to go to Bogoslovski Facultet (faculty here for future priests and Sunday school teachers) to become a teacher, so I'd have access to explore other religions through our Orthodox lens. However, being put off this path by a teacher, I just remained in my profession. However, my path strayed into the occult, which I found interesting but ultimately not intimate enough with what I've felt within since I was a child.
Anyway, for the past 3 years I have been trying to my abilities to read the words of church fathers and align myself with Christian ideals, but I find myself fundamentally disagreeing with most of what I hear.
I don't agree with the position of the woman. I find that most of the time, women are called to submit, be quiet, and uphold the man, more than men are called to protect and provide. Personally, I think women are too good at submitting and being quiet that they don't need more advice on how to do that. Even if the husband is bad, the church fathers call on them to forgiveness and moving on, which can create a toxic or even dangerous environment for the woman, where she suffers in silence. I respect St Paisios; however, I don't agree with his and many others' stance on working women. Many of them are quick to scorn working mothers, but don't extend the scorn to men who don't put in enough effort to have their wives be SAHMs. Also, I don't think the world works like that anymore. One income can rarely sustain one household. Also, spousal financial abuse is a real thing; many women are forced to stay in abusive relationships because they spent their lives in the home, so they don't have the working experience or education to go out and earn more than minimum wage. I think nowadays, submitting to a man is super risky, there's a shortage of men you can safely rely on (meaning: he won't leave you after you gave birth to two kids, he won't abuse you financially/mentally/physically if you're the 'weaker' partner aka less money, no family to protect you etc). I'd never, in my good conscience, say to a woman to submit to a man. I'd always advise her to do what's best in her interest, because it's her responsibility to do so, rather than a random man you've met two years ago.
Yeah it would be ideal if we lived in a world that supports the propagation of a family unit where the husband works and the wife takes care of the house/kids, and there are deep consequences for abuse and a support network for the abused. However, reality is a far cry from that, and it's just an unreachable ideal. I hate to see women suffer and church fathers congratulating them for it. I want to see them happy and thriving. Not suffering and being told that's where they're supposed to be.
Lastly, I cannot and I will not ever scorn the LGBT people; many of my loved ones belong to this community, and I will never judge them for it. I've known more straight Christian people who deserve the judgment more than they.
EDIT: take a look at this video if you have time, I cannot agree with it more https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZMnF32GlWss&ab_channel=BreakingDownPatriarchy
TL;DR:
30F Orthodox Christian from Serbia, baptized at 27, struggles with traditional church teachings—especially around women's roles and working mothers. Feels the advice to submit and suffer in silence can be dangerous and outdated, especially given modern realities like financial abuse and lack of reliable partners and support systems. Believes women should prioritize their own well-being. Also rejects judgment of LGBT people, defending them against religious scorn. Seeks others who feel similarly conflicted within the faith.