So a few days ago I tried my first proper ‘channel’ swim and longest swim ever – Jersey to France. It’s about 22-23kms across but swimmers typically cover around 28km. I have been fascinated by an English Channel swim for years and only over the last year or so I have thought maybe I could make that dream come true, so this swim, which is a smaller version of the EC, was my sense check to see if an EC swim could be more than a pipedream.
For background I am a mediocre to average adult learned swimmer. My IM swim time is around 63 minutes; my 1500m pool time (short course) is 24.50; and my 100m pool PB time is 1.20. My longest swim to date before this year had been Windemere (17km) which I’ve done twice.
In training for this swim I did less than I had hoped for. In the 12 months leading up to the swim I had covered 600km, with around 200km of that open water. That’s maybe 80% of what I had hoped for. My training was heavily based on the ‘you can swim in a day what you swim in a week’ rule of thumb, with 10hrs being my target weekly swim time in the weeks leading up to my swim window (in my bigger weeks I had covered 12hrs before my taper). This summer I had also completed 3 x 6hr swims, and a back to back 10km on consecutive days. I knew that this was a minimum and that I needed everything to go right on the day for me to succeed……. and as you can see from the post title in the end I didn’t quite make it to France.
I was swim slot no. 2 in a 7 day window Friday - Friday, so I had expected to swim maybe on Saturday if the weather was good and the first swimmer got away on Friday, so I booked to arrive in Jersey on Thursday afternoon…..but I got a text from my pilot on Wednesday to say we were going to swim on the Friday morning so that was a surprise. The forecast for Friday afternoon onwards for the next 5-6 days was for high winds so this might be the only realistic window in the week. I don’t know what happened to the swimmer with slot no. 1.
I hit the water at 4.30am on Friday morning. I can’t describe the nerves as you strip down in the dark, do your final grease up, attach the light to your head and jump into the dark water. My wife was crewing for me and she took a picture as the observer helped attach the light to my goggles and to say I look nervous would be an understatement. This was a moment that had occupied my mind for the last year, and in particular for the last 2-3 months. I had dreams (nightmares) of this moment. I got to feel like a real channel swimmer as I jumped in and followed the boats floodlight to the starting beach, raise my arms, get the signal, and start.
Swimming the first hour in the dark was amazing, I loved it. I kept my focus on the little light at the front of the boat (which was on my right side) and concentrated on keeping in line with that. As I swam Venus and Jupiter were clearly visible overhead and I have some great photos of this.
My feed plan was to feed after 1 hour and then every 40 minutes after this. I alternated between High5 and custard - people get shocked when I say custard, but its easy to drink, tastes great, fills you up, and is full of calories. I took in no solids and at no time did I bonk or have a hunger knock.
I had feared that I would panic and want to get out after a short time, or would loose focus and think about how much swimming I had left to do, but I never did. I counted my feeds and concentrated on following the boat and nothing more. I can genuinely say that other than 1-2 very short periods I had no issues of mental challenge.
We were swimming on the first suitable tide so whilst being a neap tide, it was still relatively big. There was also a Force 3-4 wind and conditions at times were testy. But with the tide behind me I covered around 19km in the first 5 hours according to my wife who overheard the pilot saying this. At 5hrs in the pilot was predicting a 9hr swim.
At about 7hrs in we turned to start towards France which was about 4-5km distant. The tide had now turned and I was trying to cut across an ebb tide that was coming across me from the French coast. The wind had also started to pick up (there was a high wind warning for the afternoon). When we turned I saw the French beaches for the first time and I had a 5 minute period when I thought to myself – I’m going to do this – but I put that thought away.
Unfortunately this is where things finally went wrong. Whilst I still felt physically fine and not tired, my stroke rate had dropped a little, the increasing wind was making it hard to breath properly, and my stroke had lost a lot of its power. Between hours 7-9 I covered maybe 5kms parallel to the French coast without getting much closer – I just couldn’t break through the tide. When the boat tried to cut towards the coast I wasn’t able to keep with him. 9 hours in with the wind rising and with the ebb tide moving into its peak period the decision was made to end the swim – I was around 3.5kms from the French coast having swam around 27-28kms. To say I was gutted would be an understatement.
I won’t lie, I cried getting back onto the boat and I cried whilst hidden under my robe when back on the boat. This swim had been the primary focus of my life for the last few months. Training every weekend in the sea an hour from home, dreaming about it, thinking about it, and paying for it (these swims make ironman look cheap).
So why did I fail? Simple answer, I’m just not a good enough swimmer. A poster here (Swimeasyspeed) had mentioned to me some weeks ago that you can’ t train for a swim like this like you would for an ultra marathon or an ironman, i.e. aerobic fitness and training volume are not enough. You also need to work on your technique. This is mainly where I failed I think. I was still feeling ok after 9hrs of swimming, but my stroke had fallen apart at that stage and wasn’t powerful enough to deal with the deteriorating conditions or to cross the ebbing tide (maybe if I had swam on a smaller neap tide I could have made the beach, but then I would have had less flow behind me when swimming with the flood tide and arrived later, so who knows). I learned a huge amount from this swim, but the primary one is that if I want to do another swim like this I need a coach. I need someone to make sure my stroke is as good as it can be and that even when I get tired I retain good technique. The videos that my wife took during the swim show how both how much room for improvement there is in my stoke and how my stroke deteriorated over time, even though I didn’t feel tired.
So where is my English Channel dream? At the minute I don’t know. 9hrs of swimming has shown me that mentally I can be in a good place for a long swim, but I need to improve my technique. I plan to spend the winter working with a coach if I can find one and then see where I am. Age is against me, I’m 52 and could be 55 by the time I’m ready and get an EC slot. Maybe I should stick to the shorter swims like Fastnet and Bristol Channel for a couple of years to build experience and confidence.
For this of you who have read all of this, well done.
TL/DR – I failed after 9hrs of swimming still 3km from France.