r/Ontology • u/mossytreebeard • Oct 01 '18
r/Ontology • u/willb1898 • May 24 '22
Is Science Alone Enough? - The Metaphysics behind Physics
Hi all, I talked with Ard Louis, Professor of Theoretical Physics at Oxford, around the metaphysical assumptions underlying Physics and Science in general, and the room for faith and beauty in the fields of abstract thought. Apparently there are more people who identify as in the Sciences than in the Arts at academic institutions and that sparked this conversation which I really enjoyed, hope you do too!
r/Ontology • u/LazertheRedditer • Dec 20 '21
Does nothing exist?
Im not 100% sure if this is an ontological argument, but this is a problem that has bugged me for some time now. The word "nothing" according to dictionary definition means "absence of things". Things are objects that exist, so if those composites are absent, how can it exist?
I recently learned of simples, and as far as I have been able to understand, simples are the elements of the universe, the fabric of existence. They determine what exists, but there's a catch: they can't determine what doesn't. The only way they can determine what doesn't exist is if they themselves are non-existent, which is impossible.
The term "nothing" is used in the English language to describe the absence of any specific thing, and the fact that this word requires context takes away from the original meaning intended for it, which is "absence of things". You could see an empty box and say "there's nothing in it", but that would not be true. The box has billions of atoms and quadrillions of fundamental subatomic particles. There are also molecules like oxygen, dust, etc. The fact that there is no thing of value in the box large enough to be considered a thing, does it really mean that there is "nothing" in the box?
Suppose we remove everything that makes the inside of the box a thing: molecules, atoms, subatomic particles, their strings, virtual particles, even concepts that the inside of the box follows, such as the laws of physics and time. Put that in your box and tell me: would there now be NO THING in the box (remember, as long as it is considered a "thing", it has to be absent in order to keep its status as nothing)? Sadly, no. The fact that we describe "nothing" as if it were a thing, materializes nothing into a thing, and creates a paradox. Nothing can't exist, because the universe (whether quantum or external) simply has too many "things" to leave room for nothing.
A friend of mine mentioned that dark matter and dark energy themselves are the existing condensations of nothing. I thought "well, how can this be? Dark matter and dark energy are things, if it takes up space and there is more than 0 of it, it's obviously a thing. This contradicts the meaning of 'nothing', and this creates another paradox". Ultimately, our language and perception of reality, and the laws we assigned it don't allow for nothing exist, so personally, I don't believe the concept of nothing can exist.
r/Ontology • u/willb1898 • Feb 17 '22
The Ontology of Quantum Physics
Hi all, I've started a new YouTube series on the ontology and physical basis of Quantum Mechanics with Episode 1 on Wave-Particle Duality and the Single Slit experiment, would love your feedback!
Episode 2 covers the Double Slit experiment with observation (my favourite experiment of all time!) Hope it's of interest.
r/Ontology • u/C-O-N-A-T-U-S • Jan 26 '22
Are the concepts 'entity' and 'existence in a world' definable?
Recently, due to boredom and the strong feeling that everything I think is about concepts that I could not really define or about concepts derived from others that I could not really define, I began to develop (as I could) the axiomatics underlying my thinking to feel more confident about my conclusions by having my thoughts more systematized. The purpose of this exercise is not so much the logical system itself but rather the process –since it clarifies and structures my ideas–.
Well, the fact is that I was thinking of basing it on 3 types of propositions: undefined concepts (e.g. the concepts in question), defined concepts (e.g. the concept of world) and axioms (e.g. Leibniz's principle of identity of indiscernibles). Of course, since I want to avoid any cyclicity, I will have to base the logical system on this triad of propositions –undefined concepts are unavoidable by the Münchhausen trilemma–. The thing is that I have provisionally left the concepts 'entity' and 'existence in a world' as undefined.
About 'entity': I know that it can be defined as that which is, but one could also say that 'being' can be defined as the sufficient and necessary property common to all entities. In that sense, I consider ‘entity’ and ‘being’ to be explanatorily equivalent. In fact, I have provisionally opted for the former because it was more practical for the other concept. The only thing that I have decided about this concept is that I will formally denote the set of all entities as Ens (from the Latin ens).
About 'existence in a world': I first considered defining it as the ability of an entity to interact with other entities in the given world. But then I realized that from this followed two big issues: (1) on the one hand it seemed to me more of a characterization –which really presupposes non-immediate characteristics of the concept in question– than a definition and (2) on the other hand it is to some extent cyclical because, to know if the other entities are in the world, it must be previously known the existence of at least one of these in the said world. So I decided to temporarily leave it as undefined. The only thing that I have decided is that I will formally denote the assertion “an entity x exists in another entity y” with the notation x◊y as if it were a mathematical relationship between entities. Then I defined the concept 'world' as every entity Ω∈Ens such that ∃x∈Ens: x◊Ω.
Hence, the question arises: are the concepts 'entity' and 'existence in a world' definable? That is, are there some concepts more fundamental than these that allow their definability? Thanks for reading.
r/Ontology • u/[deleted] • Apr 12 '22
Any one noticed the kinship between Spinoza’s theology and Nieche’s eternal return?
Someone must notice it.Both monothetic constructer.
r/Ontology • u/willb1898 • Feb 15 '22
Plato's Cave & Appearance vs Reality
Hi all,
I made a video on my take on Plato's Cave and the lessons we can learn from it. I don't stick to Plato's conclusion from the fable but look at it in terms of how what we perceive with our sense impressions is necessarily divorced from the reality which gives rise to our sense perceptions. Hope it's of interest x
r/Ontology • u/Tmill233 • Dec 17 '21
I think therefore I am.
The idea of “I think, therefore I am” is interesting. What is thought? If you cease to think, are you no longer? Are memories required for thought? If you can no longer think, and have no memories of thinking, did you ever really have exist? If nothingness is where I came from, and it’s where I’m going, am I always nothing?
r/Ontology • u/rhyparographe • Mar 16 '21
Are you here because of an interest in formal ontology, philosophical ontology, or both?
r/Ontology • u/PhilosophyTO • Apr 26 '22
Time and the Reality of "Now" - May 1, 2022, an online discussion, free and open to everyone
self.philosophyeventsr/Ontology • u/Ablative12-7 • Jan 18 '22
Rene Guenon.
All that exists,
in whatever mode this may be,
necessarily participates in universal principles,
and nothing exists
except by participation in these principles,
which are the eternal
and which are the immutable essences contained
in the permanent actuality of the divine intellect.
Consequently,
it can be said that all things,
however contingent they may be in themselves,
express or represent these principles
in their own way and according to their own order of existence,
for otherwise they would be purely and simply nothingness.
Thus, from one order to another order,
all things are linked together and they correspond,
to come together in total and in universal harmony,
for harmony
is nothing other than the reflection of principle unity
in the manifested world;
and it is this correspondence
that is the veritable basis of symbolism.
r/Ontology • u/DanGabriel • Mar 16 '19
When creating a taxonomy, the “category” field makes me crazy. Am I right?
I don’t know if this is the right place for this, but I’m going to give it a shot. I work in information technology. When working with colleagues throughout my career to describe entities with metadata, I regularly find that someone has created a “category” field. This drives me crazy because the label “category” does nothing to explain what what kind of information should be used to differentiate the entities. “Color” is a category. “Vendor” is a category. “Category” is not a category, and I think it is lazy to use it as such.
Firstly, am I right? Secondly, is there a way to explain my issue in more formal ontological terms?
r/Ontology • u/_eudaim0nia • Feb 05 '22
Philosophy Discussion Discord Server for Academics, students, autodidacts, and general learners
I would like to invite you to a philosophy discord server. For teachers, students, and autodidacts.
The purpose of this discord chat is dedicated to the engagement of philosophical discourse and the exploration of ideas in the history of philosophy. Our main goal is to become more knowledgeable about historical thinkers and ideas from every philosophical domain through interpersonal dialogues. We are not a debate server. Argument is a method used by philosophy, but this isn’t to be confused with debate. The latter is competitive in nature, whereas the former is a cooperative endeavor. Philosophy is a group project that aims to determine what is true, and this server is a place for this activity. Here is the invite https://discord.gg/NyesZ6e5cp
Invite link is hopefully permanent, so you won't have to worry whether the link is working if you're reading this sometime in the future.
See you all there!
r/Ontology • u/willb1898 • Jan 15 '22
Is Time an Illusion? - Entropy & Time’s Arrow
r/Ontology • u/Ablative12-7 • Dec 05 '21
Rene Guenon quote.
When I read this I am transported as by a poem. I am affected and enhanced. I claim here that this is a very great poem.
Where ontology proceeds into poetry - it begins to obtain itself.
''If we define Being in the universal sense as the principle of manifestation, and at the same time as comprising in itself the totality of possibilities of all manifestation, we must say that Being is not infinite because it does not coincide with total Possibility; and all the more so because Being, as the principle of manifestation, although it does indeed comprise all the possibilities of manifestation, does so only insofar as they are actually manifested. Outside of Being, therefore, are all the rest, that is all the possibilities of non-manifestation, as well as the possibilities of manifestation themselves insofar as they are in the unmanifested state; and included among these is Being itself, which cannot belong to manifestation since it is the principle thereof, and in consequence is itself unmanifested. For want of any other term, we are obliged to designate all that is thus outside and beyond Being as "Non-Being", but for us this negative term is in no way synonym for 'nothingness'.'' - Rene Guenon.
r/Ontology • u/darrenjyc • Oct 24 '21
Object-Oriented Ontology: A New Theory of Everything (2018) by Graham Harman — an online reading + discussion group starting Sunday, October 31, free and open to all
r/Ontology • u/[deleted] • Mar 05 '21
I am looking for a further discussion of this thesis, could someone help me? Btw, i found this thesis in "the basic problems of phenomenology" by Heidegger.
r/Ontology • u/JoeyC75 • Feb 09 '21
ONT Circulating Supply
Hi Everyone
I am new to Ontology and very interested in the project and the ONT coin
I have been trying to figure out how is the circulating supply determined for ONT
Could anyone please help me understand how is this calculated and how it works?
Is it visible somewhere online?
Thank you for your help :)
r/Ontology • u/[deleted] • Jun 17 '20
Anyone have an idea for a thesis topic regarding Kant's Critique of Pure Reason?
I just had a text course on Kant's Critique of Pure Reason. We have to write a 3000 word paper on it. We are free to choose the topic/thesis in whatever way we want, as long as it uses the text as its main focus.
Any ideas on what I could write about regarding Critique of Pure Reason?
Example of idea: Which of Kant's terms overlap the most in meaning, and why are they still necessary to use? (I find that some of his terms seem almost identical, I could investigate which ones they are, and why Kant still uses terms that are only slightly distinct in meaning)
Any ideas, small or big, would be very welcome!
r/Ontology • u/jomafro • Feb 20 '19
Best podcasts for ontology?
What are the best podcasts for ontology?