r/Objectivism • • Aug 08 '12

"[Rand] committed package-dealing when forming her definition of anarchy. Her definition replaced the meaning of anarchy with an illegitimate anti-concept..."

http://www.strike-the-root.com/91/burdzinski/burdzinski1.html
0 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

3

u/Iconochasm Aug 08 '12

Perhaps if the author of that piece could be bothered to attempt to deal with the political arguments, they might figure out where they got Rand wrong. The descriptions of anarchy from Objectivists given are not axioms or definitions, they are conclusions.

4

u/TheAethereal Aug 08 '12

The descriptions of anarchy from Objectivists given are not axioms or definitions, they are conclusions

Exactly. The foundations of Objectivism are solid. But there are some poor conclusions. That is why I consider myself an Objectivist, even though I don't believe in the state.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '12

[deleted]

3

u/TheAethereal Aug 08 '12

I don't really care what I call it, but yeah, I'll subscribe.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '12

[deleted]

3

u/Iconochasm Aug 08 '12

The author uses phrases from Rand and Peikoff to show what is purported to be the Objectivist conception of anarchy, but the author confuses disparagements based off previous chains of reasoning for fundamental definitions.

3

u/Krackor Aug 08 '12

The conclusions that Rand and Peikoff wrote about were not purported to be peripheral characteristics of some types of anarchy. They were purported to be characteristics necessarily derived from anarchy's fundamental characteristics. Rand and Peikoff did not say "well these particular anarchies had characteristics of chaos and lawlessness". They said "anarchy creates chaos and lawlessness", with fundamental necessity implied.

As such, it's totally fair to say that "absence of order" is part of the Objectivist definition of anarchy. It may not be a complete definition (and I would disagree with how the author phrases his argument here), but it's certainly purported to be part of the definition.

2

u/TheAethereal Aug 08 '12

They said "anarchy creates chaos and lawlessness", with fundamental necessity implied.

Is "chaos" bad? And of course there is lawlessness - that's what anarchy is.

The real question is "does it necessarily produce violence?" I don't see how anybody could say it does. Certainly on a small scale it doesn't. Two or three people living in seclusion don't require government. At what point, then, does government become necessary, and how do we know?

3

u/Krackor Aug 08 '12

Anarchy is not an absence of rules (lawlessness). It's an absence of rulers.

4

u/TheAethereal Aug 08 '12

I've never understood Rand's argument for statism. Though I haven't looked at in for a couple of years, I seem to recall it is the same argument that is given for almost every other government function.

Basically, we can't get rid of a criminal justice system because everything would devolve into violent chaos. But I can make the following arguments with the same logic.

We can't get rid of social security or medicare because all the elderly would die..

We can't have private banks because it would throw our financial system into chaos.

The internet must be under government control or it will be chaotic and unusable.

What is the difference between those arguments and Rand's argument for the state?

3

u/Randbot Aug 08 '12

Devil's advocate.

Markets are distorted by force, so you can't have a market in force such as a private defense agency.

5

u/TheAethereal Aug 08 '12

There are private defense agencies everywhere. You cause a ruckus in the mall, they'll escort you out. They work pretty well.

But "defense" isn't really the issue. A complete justice system is. There aren't private courts. What would a private justice system look like? I suspect it would look something like insurance. Stefan Molyneux has some interesting ideas on what he calls DROs which is interesting.

Also, the idea that private security might end up infringing on liberty so we should institute a government with the legal authority to infringe on liberty seems...strange.

3

u/Randbot Aug 08 '12

I love Stef and know all of his arguments inside and out. I just have a mental block on myself that prevents me from taking the leap to anarchism. It's hard for me to play out in my head what would happen if two DROs had a major disagreement over something.

5

u/TheAethereal Aug 08 '12

I'm with you. This stuff gets incredibly complicated. I can't possibly imagine what a stateless society would look like in this day and age. Anybody who says they can is lying. And it certainly wouldn't work perfectly, but then neither would Rand's system, and our current system certainly doesn't.

3

u/Krackor Aug 08 '12

It wouldn't be much different from what would happen if two governments or two states had a major disagreement over something.