r/Objectivism • • Jan 15 '21

cool

Post image
160 Upvotes

45 comments sorted by

16

u/8stack Jan 15 '21

Can anyone tell me what is general public perception on Atlas Shrugged, Ayn Rand and Objectivism right now in US.

I live in Belarus, we’re now having a darkest time of communistic dictatorship in at least last 10 years. So I actually need to remember myself ideas of Rand to keep my sanity some days.

There are not a lot of people who knows who she are here or what a book or philosophy about. But I wonder how it is in US. The country that built on the very same ideas but executes it in modern days in completely different ways.

16

u/TheSniteBros Jan 15 '21

You would be disappointed. The youth and young adults (18-30) have all been indoctrinated with far-left propaganda since they were in 1st-grade. The freedom beacon that was my great nation of America seems to be dying. As Lincoln said, “no nation could every take a drink from the Ohio river... if the US is to fall we must be the author and finisher of it.” and while that is rather sad I do have SOME hope. I think that over the next 2 years with Biden, Pelosi, and Schumer all at the helm of America, many in Gen-Z will hopefully realize that moving towards a socialistic economy is not advantageous. I think the USA is headed for the darkest time since 1860, however, out of those dark times will hopefully come greatness. Whatever happens, happens. Too many young people in America forget of a time of hardship or pain and from this comes weakness. I think either people will change their ways or they will be forced to in the long run.

6

u/SapphireSammi Jan 15 '21

You’d be surprised how many Gen Z kids are right wing. They’ve grown up online, so they know not to say anything that will impact future job prospects.

It’s my generation (millennials) that really have no fucking idea how good they have it.

3

u/TheSniteBros Jan 15 '21 edited Jan 16 '21

I am Gen-Z and trust me, we are not as right wing as everyone thinks. Millennials are worse though so you are right about that. Most of my close friends (who voted for the first time this year) are Bernie supporters or confused GOP voters who don’t really know anything about history or politics. The worst part is they have a sense of “I am right because I know so” despite not being able to factually back it up. I tend to try and steer clear of the intense debates with them because it isn’t worth it. As someone who is in college I am more encouraged as many of the students from the middle of the country have rejected both parties but it is still not great. Again, we haven’t had a real war for 3 generations and that means it is likely nobody remembers or could fathom what it is like to have Jap bombers attacking you or your brother. It is quite sad actually.

1

u/letshavea_discussion Jan 30 '21

The notion that you need a war to craft character in people is a bit cynical maybe. What can't we progress without wars? Are we saying that dire circumstances are necessary for greatness?

1

u/TheSniteBros Jan 31 '21

Personally I think without mass conflict the nation cannot unite for a single cause. The reason Rome, British Empire and the USA were so great was, unfortunately, due to wars. I am a libertarian and do not like foreign wars but it seems that the only thing the citizens of a nation can ALWAYS agree on is evils. Hitler, Stalin, Osama, etc. were all reasons we went to war and it worked. While I was not alive when 9/11 happened I do know (from my older relatives) that 9/12 was one of the greatest days in US history. The nation healed, came together, everyone holding an American flag and we fought against the evils of terrorism. Of course it got way out of hand and now we have an endless war in the middle east but I see that as a fault of government wanting the MIC to grow. Point is, as bad as you may think it is for young men like me to die, it seems almost necessary in order to keep the nation united. Unless you have an alternative I see no other option.

1

u/joemart20 Feb 25 '21

Very well said

1

u/lurkerofthelockers Mar 24 '21

I mean I kinda see what you mean, but I can’t but think of 1984

War is peace Freedom is Slavery Ignorance is strength

2

u/TheSniteBros Mar 25 '21

More like... Strong men create good times, good times create weak men, weak men create hard times, hard times create strong men. Rinse and repeat.

-5

u/8stack Jan 15 '21

I mean, I get it, capitalism is great, but some stuff is better managed with socialism. It’s absolutely inhumanly when people can’t afford medical treatment because of money barrier.

There is a great Scandinavian social-democracy model that seems working great for people and doesn’t impact business.

I’m not very efficient with my English to properly explain my thoughts, but I firmly believe that it’s bad that we have strong perception of capitalism good/ socialism bad, and can’t just imagine that there might be a model where it’s both working together where it’s better. People just too obsessed with black/white perception of this terms trying to oppose them always.

I also don’t think that Rand was a capitalism in a way it’s done in America. If it was a fair market, where business competes on equal conditions it should always be best for end customer, but we all know that it isn’t a thing. And that mess up with some spheres that actually put people in a danger with a basic needs.

5

u/TheSniteBros Jan 15 '21

If you like Ayn Rand I would recommend you look up Milton Friedman. He explains how pretty much every “fault” with capitalism is really a fault with government. If medical care (a commodity) was free market it would be infinitely better then in a socialist market. Their are certain things government must supply and those are called public goods. All commodities should be free market no matter the commodity. Monopolies, Oligopolies, and Corporatism are all failures of government. I dare you to find any one of those that sustained itself for a decent period of time without government intervention or slave labor (it is impossible to do).

-2

u/8stack Jan 15 '21

Yeah, I agree with your point. But what more realistic? Create absolutely non corrupt government who manage everything properly, and not corrupt business environment, or just use other approach to managing some spheres like medical care.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '21

[deleted]

0

u/8stack Jan 15 '21

Amazing idea, why it’s not a reality?

0

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '21

[deleted]

1

u/8stack Jan 15 '21

Are there people who are represent pure capitalism and call for lowering government impact right now in US politics?

3

u/stansfield123 Jan 15 '21 edited Jan 15 '21

I mean, I get it, capitalism is great, but some stuff is better managed with socialism. It’s absolutely inhumanly when people can’t afford medical treatment because of money barrier.

There is a great Scandinavian social-democracy model that seems working great for people and doesn’t impact business.

Why do people always bring up Scandinavia as a model for socialism? Scandinavian countries are some of the LEAST socialist in the world. The Heritage Foundation assigns an economic freedom index to countries every year, based on the size of the government, how open the market is, how easy or difficult it is to conform to regulations, and how well property rights and contracts are enforced.

Scandinavian countries are consistently ranked in the 10% most free countries in the world, economically. Denmark and Iceland have more economic freedom than the US, Sweden about the same, and Norway slightly less.

Good examples of countries with little economic freedom are Venezuela, North Korea, etc. If you want to know the kind of health care socialism provides people with, ask someone from Venezuela about it.

North Korea is pure socialism. Venezuela is close to pure socialism. China and India are about an equal mix of socialism and capitalism. Western Europe, North America, Australia, Japan are also a mix of socialism and capitalism, but it's 80% to 90% capitalism and 10% to 20% socialism. Denmark, in particular, is closer to 90% capitalism.

1

u/8stack Jan 15 '21

Thats why people bring up Scandinavia. Americans see Social-Democracy as Socialism and give far-right people 5 minutes and they will start calling everybody who even mentioned it communists. Yet somehow Sweden have more economic freedom than US as you mentioned. Only thing I tried to say is that some spheres are better when managed in social-oriented approach, and not as a free market. At least based on real world examples.

When I say "better" I mean general population of a country, not economy, not super rich or medical corporation, sure it worse for them, but there are things that can't be sacrificed for GDP just from moral standpoint.

2

u/stansfield123 Jan 15 '21 edited Jan 15 '21

Only thing I tried to say is that some spheres are better when managed in social-oriented approach, and not as a free market.

Capitalism IS a social-oriented approach: it gives people the power to form ANY social relationships they wish.

That's the whole point of it: it allows people to co-exist peacefully in a society. It's the only system that does that, in fact. And it doesn't prescribe how they interact. It can be through trade, competition, charity, or even a voluntary, socialist style welfare association (though that would be a huge mistake to enter into, if it's a large group of people).

The reason why Scandinavia is a nice place is because of how capitalistic they are. If they were 100% capitalistic, they would be an even greater place.

And no, no one would be left to die of preventable diseases. Capitalism doesn't erect any "barriers" that stop people from helping each other. If Scandinavians wanted to help each other in a fully capitalist system, they could. And they WOULD want to do that. I've been to Sweden many times and there's no doubt in my mind that that's true.

2

u/stansfield123 Jan 15 '21

far-right people

"Far-right" primarily means Nazis. Nazi is short for National Socialist. National Socialists are socialists. Nazi Germany was a welfare state.

That's one of the many reasons why US libertarians (who ARE NOT far-right, in fact they don't fit in the one dimensional right-left paradigm, period) oppose socialized healthcare. They fear that it will give the US government the same power over the population that the Nazis had.

Incidentally, the Nazis ended up using the National Socialist People's Welfare agency (NSV) as the umbrella agency for both universal healthcare and the concentration camps. The reason is obvious: in a welfare state, people depend on the welfare agency for their survival...so that's the agency no one will dare question.

1

u/8stack Jan 15 '21

Great info, thanks a lot!

2

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '21 edited Jan 15 '21

There is a great Scandinavian social-democracy model that seems working great for people and doesn’t impact business.

You can't have welfare with open borders. Wait for it. Apart from that welfare only works in Scandinavia because they already have a productive culture.

And about the healthcare issue in the US, you have to go deeper. Words like inhumane are used to appeal to emotion. This is a rational problem, not a an emotional one.

1

u/8stack Jan 15 '21

You could call it whatever it won't change the fact that people may not call a doctor in emergency conditions just because they can't afford it and the possibility of such situation is inhumane.

2

u/AuAndre Jan 16 '21

Is it not inhumane to force someone to work? Why should a doctor be forced to help someone in an emergency situation? And if they are the kind of doctor to want to help someone in an emergency situation, why do they need the government to tell them they have to?

1

u/8stack Jan 16 '21

Yeah, paying private owned hospitals and insurance companies = paying doctors. Imagine that you don’t need to pay for your every step in a hospital because you already paying taxes and doctors getting paid from this taxes. Wild, isn’t it? It’s basically a country level insurance without paying a bunch of guys in the middle who want to become rich because of your health problems.

2

u/AuAndre Jan 16 '21

Where did I say paying doctors? What i said had nothing to do with the payment of doctors. That is a secondary issue. The primary is the use of force on doctors to have them perform acts which they otherwise would not. For any reason.

For example, say a doctor wants to open up a clinic doing some small procedure, procedure A, for a small community. He won't make too much doing it if he's paid by the people, but he makes enough to get by and is happy to do this procedure for these people in a personalized and relaxed environment. In the free market, this is 100% alright. If its a value like he thinks, he will survive. If it is not, then he will fail and do something different. If his boss is the government, he has to appeal to them to open the clinic, convince them that its worth setting up, convince them that he wouldn't be better suited in the bigger city hospital, where he would help more people (doing something he doesn't enjoy), convince them that he should even be doing procedure A, because Procedure B is more efficient and Procedure C (which hes always hated) needs doctors so he'd be better fit doing Procedure C. He may make a good case and be allowed to start his practice, until they decide it is no longer a good use of resources. Or he may not make a good enough case, and he will have to spend the rest of his life doing Procedure C instead.

Is that moral? Is it moral to say that the doctor has to do what will help the most people? From the utilitarian perspective, yes, but the utilitarian perspective justifies Nazis so it may not be the best. I will leave it for you to answer. Is it moral to force a doctor to do what they do not want to do? Ceteris Paribas. Nothing else considered. Is that moral?

1

u/8stack Jan 16 '21

Not true, he does not have not appeal government to open clinic. That’s mostly people who unlikely to use his service because they already paid their medical needs with taxes and can get treatment at municipal hospital for free now.

1

u/TwentyFourtySix Jan 15 '21

I can't imagine why your shithole country is a communist shithole

1

u/8stack Jan 15 '21

A bunch of old pieces of shit who were born in communism and started developing there, and stopped developing there, never used internet. Occupied government and corrupt as fuck because mentality Of old people is complete garbage here.

1

u/berpaderpderp Jan 15 '21

There is a great Scandinavian social-democracy model that seems working great for people and doesn’t impact business.

Scandinavia is way more homogeneous than the US. Their issues are different from ours. We have a wide disparity in our tax base as well. Too many "takers" and not enough "makers". As it stands, there are just too many differing opinions in the US.

Scandinavia doesnt have the diversity we do. They all have the same basic culture, diet, etc. It was the same when I was in Poland.

There isn't a one size fits all solution.

2

u/BenjiTheShort Jan 15 '21

Fuck Lukashenko!!!

2

u/8stack Jan 15 '21

Thanks a lot for a support!

2

u/BenjiTheShort Jan 15 '21

My parents are refugees from the USSR. Don’t stop fighting until these commie scumbags are gone for good!

4

u/daryl_feral Jan 15 '21

He'll be charged with sedition soon.

2

u/Bigfourth Jan 15 '21

Believe that’s a she based on hair

2

u/daryl_feral Jan 15 '21

Good eye. I assumed too much.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '21

Even if he disagrees with Biden, he still defends him in order to further his own prospects. Peak objectivism.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 19 '21

Except he serves an authoritarian empire and is paid with stolen money

1

u/[deleted] Jan 19 '21

So was Rand herself. One looks after ones own interest, no matter which empire one is in.

0

u/techstural Jan 15 '21 edited Jan 30 '21

Interesting. Just recently I was reflecting on Trump as an (unlikely) sort of John Galt character.

3

u/kraghis Jan 16 '21

Lol more like Ellsworth Toohey

1

u/techstural Jan 16 '21

Admittedly, he doesn't have quite the same sort of image. I was thinking of some perhaps subtler qualities.

3

u/letshavea_discussion Jan 30 '21

You could get a pass saying this in 2017 but nowdays, I don't think so.

1

u/techstural Jan 30 '21

Not even as an ultra-paranoid/vindictive/despotic version? lol

2

u/douglasmacarthur Jan 16 '21

🤦‍♂️