r/OCPDPerfectionism • • Aug 18 '26

ADHD and OCPD

15 Upvotes

ADHD is one of the common co-morbid conditions for people with OCPD.

The OCPD Iceberg (my opinion)

How other people may view someone with untreated OCPD

1.      always judging others

2.      rigid, aloof

3.      lack of empathy, disinterested in relationships

4.      obsessed with work

5.      egotistical

Characteristics of people with OCPD that may not be visible

1.      always judging oneself harshly (guilt complex)

2.      traumatized, hypervigilant, fearful, ashamed, anxious, depressed

3.      strong duty to serve others that feels overwhelming, scared of vulnerability and intimacy

4.      imposter syndrome

5.      insecure, self-esteem contingent on achievement

Research on Personality Disorders and ADHD

- In a study of adults seeking treatment for ADHD symptoms, the prevalence of Personality Disorders was as high as 25%. The most frequent PDs were avoidant (21.7%) and borderline (18.3%). ("Severity Of Childhood Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder--A Risk Factor For Personality Disorders In Adult Life?," Journal of Personality Disorders)

- “Studies find that individuals with ADHD are generally at higher risk of development of any of the personality disorders, including OCPD. A 2017 study found in a sample of 439 undergraduate college students that four personality disorders were significant predictors of ADHD, one of which was OCPD. Clinical experience has shown that patients with ADHD may develop highly perfectionistic standards and rules in reaction to their executive functioning deficits. The harsh and negative messaging that they received over the years has made them obsess about doing things ‘the right way.’ “ ("A Multi-method Examination of the Links Between ADHD and Personality Disorder," Journal of Personality Disorders)

- “One particularly intriguing finding from the present study was the robust, positive relationship between OCPD and various markers of ADHD. Although both OCPD and ADHD might be said to struggle with cognitive flexibility, an executive function, they also seem quite dissimilar in other ways. Thus, it was surprising that OCPD obtained the largest correlations with the history of an ADHD diagnosis" compared to other personality disorders.

The authors theorize that the participants’ OCPD may have contributed to their scholastic achievement and served as an adaptive response to ADHD. They note that studies indicate “OCPD is the only one of the PDs that is more prevalent among college students and college graduates than the general population." (Smith & Samuel (in press).pdf.)

Some people believe that their OCPD developed to compensate for their brains feeling out of control because of ADHD.

BOOK

Friendship Skills for Neurodivergent Adults

SUPPORT GROUPS

Peer Support Groups

Meet Other ADD Adults For Support And Inspiration

Peer Support Group for Adults with Autism and ADHD

PODCASTS

ADHD Experts Podcast    

The ADHD reWired Podcast

Taking Control: The ADHD Podcast

Distraction with Dr. Ned Hallowell

VIDEOS

Perfectionism and ADHD  

Overcome Perfectionism | ADHD Tips That Work 

Perfectionism and ADHD: Making ‘Good Enough’ Work for You

How To Make Yourself Do Stuff When You're Paralyzed With Overwhelm

ARTICLES

ADHD Symptoms That Can Be a Sign of a Personality Disorder: Part 1, Part 2

Excerpts From Procrastination: Why You Do It, What to Do About It Now (2008)

SUBREDDIT POSTS

How Does A Combo Of OCPD & ADHD Present Itself?

Anyone Else Feel Like They Built OCPD On Top Of Pure Chaos?

People Say ADHDers Can’t Be Perfectionists or High-Achievers, But ADHD + OCPD Proves Otherwise

What difficulties do you experience because of co-morbid OCPD and ADHD?


r/OCPDPerfectionism • • Jan 30 '26

offering resource/support Letting Go Of Critical Thoughts About Other People

15 Upvotes

In The CBT Workbook For Perfectionism (2019), Sharon Martin asserts that harsh self-criticism is not an effective way to motivate ourselves to do better. Martin writes, “The same is true when we criticize others; it tends to be demotivating and doesn’t encourage people to listen to us or live up to our expectations. Criticism often leaves people feeling ashamed, angry, or afraid rather than motivated.” (164)

“When we expect perfection from others and are intolerant of mistakes, we can damage our relationships. Nagging, criticizing, and focusing on what our loved ones are doing wrong erodes connection and open communication…" (162)

BELIEFS ASSOCIATED WITH CRITICIZING OTHERS

Martin gives examples of perfectionistic beliefs (which may be unconscious) that contribute to a habit of criticizing others (166):

- There’s no excuse for mistakes.

- My way is the right way to do things.

- People always let me down. I can’t count on anyone.

- If you want something done right, you have to do it yourself.

- If you don’t listen to me, it means you don’t care about me.

- If you don’t follow through or complete a task, it’s because you didn’t really try.

- If I don't enforce some standards, this whole place will fall apart.

- People who make mistakes are careless, lazy, or inconsiderate.

- If I don't correct people, they will never learn.

QUESTIONING BELIEFS ABOUT OTHERS

Martin helps her clients challenge their critical thoughts about others, let go of their unrealistic expectations, and communicate more effectively (166-67). They develop a habit of asking themselves:

- Am I taking their behavior as a personal insult?

- Am I assuming the worst?

- Am I jumping to conclusions?

- Am I overreacting or being harsh?

- Is there more than one right way to do this?

- Can I see things from the other person’s point of view?

Martin helps her clients develop assertive communication skills. “Trying to reduce our criticism of others doesn’t mean we can’t ask for what we need…” (171). She offers this advice: “Use I statements. Avoid generalities such as always or never. Focus on present behaviors. Use a calm tone. Demonstrate respect and cooperation rather than superiority and control.” (172)

JUDGMENTAL TENDNECIES

In Too Perfect (1992), Allan Mallinger asks, “What about your tendency to be overly troubled by the flaws and frailties of others, or by their errors? This habit is extremely harmful to your relationships and your mood, but it is also very amenable to change. As with any habit, the key to change lies in increasing your awareness. A habit survives by being sneaky—an automatic part of you that you don’t even notice…

"Turn your pickiness against itself; be as critical as you like of this fault…catch yourself as often as possible thinking judgmental thoughts. Notice how unpleasant the feeling is—the disappointment, resentment, or disgust you are experiencing. Even the momentary self-righteous boost to your own self-esteem is hollow and painful. Acknowledge that your assessment might be accurate…then notice [the harsh judgment has] few redeeming qualities.“ (61)

Judgmental tendencies can contribute to a habit of trying to control other people. The notion that all people with OCPD exhibit controlling behavior towards others is a myth. A study of 43 people with OCPD found that 10 had verbal aggression and other-oriented perfectionism; 33 were “people pleasers” with self-oriented perfectionism. Exposing The Myths About OCPD has information about this study.

Research has shown that the impact of nonverbal behavior (e.g. tone of voice, facial expression, body language) has a far greater impact on social interactions than the content of what we say. It is not possible to 'hide' extreme judgmental tendencies.

I’m tired of hearing that I think I’m better than everyone, tips for changing?

Carl Jung said the thing you hate most in others is living rent free inside you. He was right.

BLAME VS. RESPONSIBILITY

Some people panic when they are diagnosed with OCPD or start to suspect OCPD, thinking they were "wrong" about everything that happened in their life.

In I’m Working On It In Therapy (2015), Gary Trosclair states, “Blame, whether it’s directed toward ourselves or others, usually has the tone of finding fault, the goal of doling out punishment, and a focus on the past. Responsibility…is more about understanding our role in situations in order to think or behave differently as we move forward into the future.” (95-6)

“I would suggest that you view the field of responsibility as a spectrum with those things you cannot control and therefore shouldn’t take responsibility for on one and, and those things that you can clearly control and therefore should take responsibility for on the other end. In the middle is a gray area—things you can’t immediately control, but with intention and commitment can eventually change…With time, intention, and practice, we can disengage from unhealthy ways of living….One component of this gray area is the feelings of others. We need to be aware of how our actions impact others, without taking full responsibility for their mood. Again, there is a spectrum here.” (99-100)

“When curiosity and self-acceptance are in place, you’re in a position to impartially sort out where to take responsibility and where to let go of it so that you can move ahead. The appropriate acceptance of responsibility and…refusal of it are essential to….healing and growth…Taking too much responsibility can lead to depression and anxiety, but not taking enough leads to interpersonal problems and disempowerment.” (95)    

INTENTION VS. IMPACT

A big part of managing OCPD is improving self-awareness: giving feedback to yourself, and being open to feedback from others. I found it very helpful to keep in mind that my intentions when communicating with someone might be very different than the impact on the other person.

In The Healthy Compulsive (2020), Gary Trosclair explains that “People may perceive your determination to make things better differently from the way you intend it. Even if you don’t apply your personal standards to other people, they may assume you do, and feel that you’re always looking down your nose at them. This could easily be the case if you aren’t very uncommunicative. What may feel to you like well-intended efforts to help may be experienced by others as mean-spirited criticism, control, or hostility.” (122)

APOLOGIES

People who suspect OCPD or receive a diagnosis often realize that they need to make amends for their past behavior.

From We Should Get Together: The Secret to Cultivating Better Friendships (2019), Kat Vellos:

“The best apologies are ones in which the apologizer focuses on the impact on their actions and resists the urge to frame their message around their intentions, regardless of how harmless they were. Remember that an apology should be focused on the person who has been hurt, not the one who did the hurting.

"If you hurt your friend, what actually matters is their pain, not the preservation of your reputation as a good person. Apologize, reflect, ensure that you understand the other person fully, and empathize…don’t say “I’m sorry if you felt ___” or even ‘I’m sorry you feel that way.” These are not apologies, they’re deflections of responsibility. Start with the truth, and end on your intention to do better.” (216)

MY EXPERIENCE

I found the following strategies helpful in reducing my judgmental thoughts about other people:

- Improving my self-acceptance and letting go of harsh self-criticism

- Increasing my awareness of my cognitive distortions

- Increasing my awareness of my trauma history being triggered, rather than thinking that current situations were 'making me' upset. In reality, someone else in my place would not be upset or have a smaller reaction.

- Realizing that I may feel upset with someone because they are reminding me of aspects of myself that I dislike.

- Having curiosity about judgmental thoughts. They reveal more about me than the other person. Emotions give us important information about our needs.

- Using "that's one way of doing it" as a mantra when feeling judgmental about my co-workers (when their approaches to work are different than mine). In the beginning, I would think the phrase in a sarcastic tone. Later, I used a neutral tone.

- Using ‘everyone you meet is fighting a battle you know nothing about’ as a mantra. When I worked on my trauma symptoms and OCPD, I became more attuned to signs that others’ mental health needs. My untreated OCPD was very good at making me feel apart from everyone. Now I remember that everyone is doing the best with the knowledge and skills they have, and I can relate to other people much more easily.

My judgmental tendencies were part of the 'over thinking'/ruminating characteristic of OCPD. So exhausting. Letting go of them releases a huge burden, and gave me more energy to work on my mental health.

RESOURCES

Thanks for the Feedback: The Science and Art of Receiving Feedback Well (2015), Douglas Stone, Sheila Heen

Every year, Oren Sofer, an experienced meditation teacher and author, offers a free 6-week course on mindful communication. His website is orenjaysofer.com. You do not need to attend the live sessions. Everyone who registers receives recordings of the sessions. I found the course helpful.

How has habitual criticism of others affected your life?


r/OCPDPerfectionism • • Feb 28 '26

offering resource/support Cognitive Flexibility: 'Two Things Can Be True' Concept

Thumbnail
gallery
13 Upvotes

One of the focuses of Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT) is improving cognitive flexibility by reconciling apparently contradictory views.

Working with a therapist helped me accept situations like:

-This task is important. It is not urgent.

-This person is not able to help me with ___. This person cares about me.

-This isn’t done perfectly. It’s good enough.

-I have many responsibilities. I have the right to take a break. 

-I’m a good employee. I make mistakes.

-I am very proud of myself for ___. Most people would find it easy to do this.

-My OCPD allowed me to survive my childhood. I need to let it go ('dialing' down the intensity of the traits) to be happy as an adult.

It’s helpful to habitually use ‘and’ to connect two seemingly opposed ideas, instead of 'but.'

Example: I’m a good person (spouse, friend, employee), and I have OCPD.

This statement is quite different: I’m a good person, but I have OCPD. Having OCPD does not negate the statement that I'm a good person.

My parents’ behavior hurt me a lot, and they never intended to hurt me.

This statement is very different: My parents’ behavior hurt me a lot, but they never intended to hurt me. This statement invalidates the impact of my parents’ hurtful behavior.


r/OCPDPerfectionism • • Sep 27 '25

offering resource/support OCPD is Treatable, Exposing Myths

13 Upvotes

People with OCPD can significantly improve their mental health. 

In an interview, Dr. Anthony Pinto, the leading specialist, stated, “OCPD should not be dismissed as an unchangeable personality condition. I have found consistently in my work that it is treatable…" The website of his clinic states that his standard treatment protocol for his clients with OCPD "typically lasts 6 months…In unique cases, therapy on a weekly basis may be continued for up to one year.

Gary Trosclair stated, “More so than those of most other personality disorders, the symptoms of OCPD can diminish over time...one good thing about being driven is that you have the inner resources and determination necessary for change.”

In Treatment Of The Obsessive Personality (1985), Leon Salzman writes, “The treatment of obsessionals, while difficult, is often very successful. It results in a freer, less restricted, and less rigid individual who is no longer tied to ‘shoulds’...” (521)

The website of the American Psychiatry Association states, “Without treatment, personality disorders can be long-lasting.”

Finding Mental Health Providers With PD Experience has information about 20 studies about therapy outcomes for clinical perfectionism and OCPD.

A case study: PintoOCPDtreatmentchapter.pdf | PDF Host. After four months, the client with OCPD and APD no longer met diagnostic criteria for OCPD. I describe my recovery in OCPD, Depression, and Suicidality & Coping Strategies For Perfectionism. Another member's post about recovery: How I “Cured” My OCPD.

“Remission or recovery from meeting full criteria for a personality disorder appears to be a function of the duration of treatment, in addition to the specific diagnosis or severity and other factors. Four studies suggested that a mean of 52% of patients, given one to two treatment sessions per week, experienced remission after about 1.3 years of treatment…Dropout from treatment varies from approximately 10% to 30% depending on treatment length.” Chapter 1. Empirical Studies of Psychotherapy for Personality Disorders

People with OCPD are the most diverse PD population.

In an interview with Chris Williamson, Paul Hewitt stated that **“**each person's perfectionism is entirely unique.” He has worked as a therapist and researcher specializing in perfectionism for 40 years.

People with the same PD diagnoses are not carbon copies of each other. If they were, low diagnosis wouldn't be an issue. One member shared that he was diagnosed with OCPD by his seventh therapist.

Some people with OCPD tend to be verbally aggressive and controlling. Others are anxious and prone to people pleasing. This post has more information: Anxious and Controlling Subtypes. Some people with OCPD have self-oriented perfectionism; another basic type is other-oriented perfectionism. Types of Perfectionism

In Perfectionism in Childhood and Adolescence (2022), Gordon Flett and Paul Hewitt, the leading researchers on perfectionism, state, “There is substantial heterogeneity among perfectionists” (131).

In an interview on the 10% Happier YouTube channel, Dr. Ellen Hendriksen describes her perfectionistic clients by referring to their diversity: “If you line up a hundred different people, you will see a hundred different phenotypes of perfectionism.

Many people with OCPD seek professional help. 

“Studies show that individuals with OCPD...[are] three times more likely to receive individual psychotherapy than patients with major depressive disorder. (“Treatment Utilization by Patients with Personality Disorders,” Bender, et al., 2001).

OCPD is not the same as Narcissistic PD.

Research indicates that about 16% of people with OCPD have NPD. This means that about 84% of people with OCPD do not have NPD. Is OCPD similar to Narcissistic Personality Disorder?

Lack of empathy is not a symptom of OCPD. 

Empathy is not referred to in the diagnostic criteria. OCPD and the other cluster C PDs are driven by fear and anxiety, not malice. In The Healthy Compulsive (2020), Gary Trosclair states, “Unless there are other serious mental health issues involved, no compulsive wants to hurt others” (170-71).

Dr. Todd Grande discusses a study: Empathy with All 10 Personality Disorders | Cognitive vs. Affective Empathy. OCPD is not one of the few PDs that are characterized by lack of empathy.

I agree with this member's comment: “When ppl attribute abuse to a personality disorder they remove all responsibility from the abuser and place it on the disorder, which absolutely throws everyone with that disorder under the bus.”

OCD is not more severe than OCPD.

Dr. Anthony Pinto, the leading OCPD specialist, reports that studies indicate that people with OCD and OCPD report similar quality of life and impairment in psychosocial functioning.

Personality disorders are treatable.

In the classic text Becoming (1955), Gordon Alport stated, “Personality is less a finished product than a transitive process. While it has stable features, it is at the same time continually undergoing change” (p. 19)

Neuroplasticity is the ability of the brain to form and reorganize synaptic connections in response to learning or experience or following an injury. Neuroplasticity Explained (3 min. video)

Gary Trosclair explains, “Over the last 25 years the concept of neuroplasticity has emerged as one of the guiding principles of psychological science. Previously understood as a potential that ends with childhood, we now know that the capacity to change the brain endures well into adulthood. And that experience actually leads to measurable changes in the brain and subsequent changes in behavior."

Marsha Linehan, the therapist who created Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT)--the 'gold standard' treatment for BPD and chronic suicidality--overcame BPD and suicidality herself.

Mental illness is as common as brown eyes. Mental health recovery is also common. 


r/OCPDPerfectionism • • 15d ago

“Name It To Tame It”: Fueling Mental Health Recovery By Finding Your Feelings, Part 1

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

I suppressed my feelings for decades before receiving treatment for OCPD and trauma. I had no idea that I had a problem because my abusers and sister suppressed their feelings too. The unspoken rule in my childhood home was to silence feelings and focus on achievement. I joke that I'm a recovering thinkaholic. I started to work on increasing awareness of my feelings by paying attention to my body sensations (e.g. breathing, tension). Keeping an audio journal helps with maintaining my progress.

From Running On Empty: Overcome Your Childhood Emotional Neglect (2019), Jonice Webb, Chritine Musello:

Understanding The Purpose and Value of Your Emotions (pgs. 120-22)

“Neuroscientists have studied extensively the evolutionary development of the human brain. For humans, the ability to feel emotion evolved millions of years before the ability to think. Human emotions originate in the limbic system, which is buried deep below the cerebral cortex, the section of the brain where thought originates. In this way, our feelings are a more basic part of who we are than our thoughts…Our emotions cannot be erased, and will not be denied, any more than we can erase or deny our hunger or thirst.”

“For every emotion, there is a purpose. Emotions are incredibly useful tools to help us adapt, survive, and thrive. People who were emotionally neglected were trained to try to erase, deny, push underground…this invaluable built-in feedback system. Because they are not listening to their emotions, they are operating at a disadvantage from the rest of us. Pushing away this vital source of information makes you vulnerable...” (122)

“Sometimes...emotions feel like a burden…[but] emotion is necessary for survival. Emotions tell us when we are in danger, when to run, when to fight and what is worth fighting for. Emotions are our body’s way of communicating with us and driving us to do things.”

EmotionFunction
disgusttells us to avoid something
feartells us to escape/self-preservation  
angerpushes us to fight back/self-protection
lovedrives us to care for spouse, children, others  
passiondrives us to procreate, create and invent
hurtpushes us to correct a situation
sadnesstells us we are losing something important
compassionpushes us to help others

DON'T BLAME THE MESSENGER

In the video "The Myth of Perfect Regulation," Heidi Priebe suggests that viewers ask themselves, “Do I know how to listen to my emotions as messengers even when they are telling me something I don't want to hear?”

I discovered that my feelings provide valuable information about my needs and circumstances. I no longer view uncomfortable feelings as problems. Instead, I view them as indicating issues that need to be addressed. If I fully experience them (instead of overthinking), I’m more likely to make healthy decisions.

Two things can be true: I don’t want this feeling. It’s telling me something important. Experiencing uncomfortable feelings isn’t a problem; the situations provoking uncomfortable feelings may be problematic.

BENEFITS OF LABELING FEELINGS

Studies indicate that habitually labeling feelings has a positive impact on mental health. Dr. Dan Siegel created the phrase 'name it to tame it' to refer to how labeling feelings promotes emotional regulation. Neuroimaging studies show that labeling emotions reduces activity in the amygdala, resulting in a calming effect.

In Atlas of the Heart (2021), Brene Brown explains, “Language is our portal to meaning-making, connection, healing, learning, and self-awareness. Gaining access to the right words can open up entire universes. When we don’t have the language to talk about what we’re experiencing, our ability to make sense of what’s happening and share it with others is severely limited. Without accurate language, we struggle to get the help we need, we don’t always regulate or manage our emotions and experiences in a way that allows us to move through them productively, and our self-awareness is diminished.” (xxi)

BEING PRESENT WITH FEELINGS

In The Healthy Compulsive (2020), Gary Trosclair states, “Avoiding feelings…cuts you off from a source of direction and wisdom. Each of these feelings can serve as a warning sign that something is out of balance.” (65)

“To move toward the healthier end of the compulsive spectrum, you will need to stop avoiding emotions with busy-ness and instead allow them to flow into consciousness. Once you’re aware of what you’re feeling, you can decide how to respond to it. If you don’t, you’ll be driven by forces you aren’t aware of...

"While it is true for everyone that avoiding feelings can make the feelings more disturbing, people who suffer from OCPD are particularly prone to a cycle of negative emotions…if they don’t slow down to deal with them…People who are driven have energy and a capacity for intense work that give them a way to avoid their feelings that’s socially sanctioned and rewarded. Avoiding emotions may seem beneficial at first, but over time it can lead to a rut of anger, disappointment, and cynicism.

"But what does it mean to listen to feelings? It means to allow the feeling to rise into consciousness long enough to really experience it, to understand what’s bothering you, to develop the capacity to tolerate the feeling, and to see if there is anything to learn from it…For most compulsives, this will need to be deliberate; you’re likely to rush into doing rather than feeling, and consequently you miss both disturbing and positive feelings.” (59-60)

WORRY VS. ANXIETY

People sometimes worry in order to reduce their anxiety. Worrying distracts them from distressing mental images, and physical sensations caused by anxiety.

In How To Be Enough (2024), Dr. Ellen Hendriksen explains that “worry and rumination are cognitive methods of engaging with emotion that keep us in an abstract, intellectual, verbal headspace in an attempt to control and avoid the physiological activation of anxiety. Worry and rumination might feel bad…[but] anxiety feels worse.” (226)

RESOURCES

Videos on Worry

Videos on Overthinking

How to Stop Ruminating and Overcome Social Anxiety

“Name It To Tame It”: Fueling Mental Health Recovery By Finding Your Feelings, Part 2

How has OCPD impacted your ability to identify and manage your feelings?


r/OCPDPerfectionism • • Aug 18 '26

Highly Recommended YouTube Channel About OCPD

11 Upvotes

Molly Shea has been sharing videos about her experience with OCPD for six years. She has a YouTube channel called You Seem Normal.

Molly's channel has reached 1,000 subscribers. You can help people find her videos by subscribing to her channel, commenting, and giving her videos a thumbs up.

It takes a lot of courage to speak openly about mental health, especially about personality disorders. I love Molly's positive attitude, her openness, and her insights. In a recent episode, Molly said, "Even when perfection is attainable, it’s unsustainable."


r/OCPDPerfectionism • • Aug 16 '26

OCPD and Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD): Similarities and Differences

11 Upvotes

Excerpts from Obsessive Compulsive Personality Disorder vs Autism from neurodivergentinsights.com, created by Dr. Megan Neff, a psychologist who has ASD, ADHD and OCPD tendencies. She co-hosts Divergent Conversations | A Neurodivergent Podcast.

Studies have found that up to 40% of people with OCPD also have Autism Spectrum Disorders.

DISTINCT AUTISTIC TRAITS

§  Sensory Diversity: Individuals with autism often experience intense sensory perceptions, ranging from hypersensitivity, where sensations are overwhelming, to hyposensitivity, where they are understated. A key aspect is interoception, the awareness of internal body sensations...

§  Autistic Brain Style: The Autistic mind typically employs a bottom-up processing style, focusing on details before the whole. This concrete thinking is often paired with monotropism, an intense focus on specific interests...

§  Distinct Autistic Communication Patterns: Autistic communication is usually direct, concrete, and straightforward. Autistic people often prefer meaningful discussions over small talk...

§  Neurological Distinctiveness: Autism is a distinct neurotype from birth, characterized by a sensitive nervous system and unique ways of processing, experiencing, and interacting with the world.

DISTINCT OCPD TRAITS

§  Pathological Perfectionism: Unlike mere attention to detail, pathological perfectionism in OCPD involves an overwhelming need for orderliness and perfection. This trait can significantly impact task completion, leading to personal suffering due to a loss of flexibility and efficiency.

§  Persistent Productivity: Individuals with OCPD often feel a compelling need to be constantly productive. They may struggle to relax or engage in activities they perceive as “non-productive."

§  Core Defense Mechanism: The development of OCPD is often a defense mechanism against deep fears of imperfection and losing control. This complex psychological process serves as a shield against intense feelings of shame, driving individuals towards a relentless pursuit of perfection. The defense mechanisms in OCPD are typically “ego-syntonic,” meaning they align with the individual's self-perception, making them challenging to recognize as problematic...the behaviors feel integral to the person's identity...

SIMILAR ISSUES ON THE SURFACE, DIFFERENT MOTIVATIONS

OCPD Task Paralysis, Procrastination and Indecision

§  Fear of Making the Wrong Choice: The dread of error in OCPD is tied to potential guilt or shame. This anxiety leads to a hesitation in decision-making, as the goal is a perfect, error-free choice.

§  Perfectionism and Shame: At the core of OCPD is the fear of making a mistake and facing the associated shame. This leads to a delay in decision-making as a protective mechanism against the turmoil of imperfection.

Autism Task Paralysis, Procrastination, and Indecision

§  Executive Functioning Challenges: This involves complexities in decision-making, stemming from difficulties in planning and organizing tasks. Individuals may struggle to know where to start, which can significantly impede task initiation and progression.

§  Autistic Inertia: This term describes the difficulties that Autistic individuals often face in initiating new tasks. It goes beyond simple procrastination; it is linked to the challenges in shifting focus or transitioning between activities...

§  Autistic Catatonia: In addition to inertia, some individuals may experience Autistic catatonia, which involves motor shutdowns. This condition can significantly impact the ability to start new tasks, as it often leads to periods where the individual becomes immobile or unresponsive to external stimuli.

§  Motor Movement Difficulties: ...These difficulties can manifest as clumsiness or uncoordinated motor skills, further complicating the process of initiating and engaging in new tasks. These motor challenges can be mistaken for reluctance or hesitation, but they are actually neurological in nature.

§  Demand Avoidance: A distinct feature of autism is a resistance to external demands, which differs significantly from general avoidance. This resistance is not about defiance; rather, it is deeply rooted in the need for self-directed control. Autistic individuals may experience a fight-or-flight reaction to situations where they perceive a loss of autonomy or face overwhelming sensory input and energy demands...

OCPD Preoccupation with Details, Rules, and Organization

§  Fear of Failure and Need for Control: Individuals with OCPD often have an intense focus on details, driven by anxiety about imperfection and a desire to exert control over their environment.

§  Perfectionism: This drive for perfection, a way to fend off feelings of shame, manifests in a strict adherence to order, rules, and details. Additionally, the sense of incompleteness when things are left disordered can be distressing for those with OCPD.

Autism Preoccupation with Details, Rules, and Organization

§  Cognitive Style and Special Interests: For Autistic individuals, attention to details is often part of our inherent cognitive style and is usually connected to our intense interests.

§  Special Interest Categorization: Many autistic people find comfort in cataloging and organizing data, especially related to our special interests. This behavior ties into our monotropic focus and the use of repetition as a form of self-soothing. Unlike OCPD, these activities are not primarily driven by anxiety.

§  Comfort in Predictability: Structured routines and explicit rules provide a sense of comfort in what might otherwise feel like a chaotic world.

§  Context Independence: Autistic individuals often experience what is known as “context independence” (alternatively described as “context blindness”). This means that social rules and norms are not intuitively absorbed; hence, we rely more on explicit rules and norms to navigate social situations. This reliance on explicit rules compensates for the challenges in picking up unwritten social cues.*

OCPD Workaholism

§  Driven by Control and Perfection: For individuals with OCPD, an intense work ethic often stems from a deep need for control and an aversion to making mistakes. Work becomes a crucial means of upholding high standards and managing anxiety.

§  Self-Worth Tied to Productivity: Self-esteem and productivity are often equated, leading to difficulty in relaxing and viewing non-productive time as wasteful.

Autism Workaholism 

§  Comfort in Routine and Structure: Many Autistic people immerse themselves in work or focused activities because these environments provide predictability and structure. This setting offers comfort and a sense of stability.

§  Deep Engagement in Special Interests: Engaging in work or tasks, particularly those that align with their special interests, can be deeply satisfying and captivating, providing a profound sense of engagement and fulfillment. Additionally engagement with special interests helps to block distressing emotions and stimuli and is a form of self-soothing.

OCPD Need For Predictability, Routine and Structure

§  Control and Perfectionism: In OCPD, a strong need for sameness and predictability stems from a deep-seated desire to maintain control and achieve perfection. This need is often a method to minimize the uncertainty that could lead to errors or perceived failures.

§  Anxiety Management: Adopting predictable routines is also a strategy for managing underlying anxiety. By adhering to known patterns, individuals with OCPD can alleviate feelings of stress associated with unpredictability.

§  Emotional Regulation: In OCPD, the drive for control and predictability often ties into emotional regulation. By maintaining strict routines and predictability, individuals with OCPD might feel more emotionally stable and less prone to the distress that unpredictability can bring.

Autistic Need For Predictability, Routine and Structure

§ Sensory and Cognitive Processing: For Autistic people, the reliance on routine is often linked to managing sensory sensitivities and achieving cognitive comfort. Predictable routines can help in managing sensory sensitivities, as familiar environments and activities are less likely to present overwhelming or distressing sensory input. These routines also provide cognitive comfort, helping to reduce cognitive load and make the world more navigable.

§  Autistic Inertia: Challenges with changes in routine are partly due to autistic inertia, where shifting attention or altering established routines can be inherently difficult. This is not just a preference for consistency but is deeply rooted in the way Autistic brains process information and handle transitions. Autistic inertia can make adapting to changes in routine particularly challenging, and sudden changes can be disorienting or distressing.

OCPD Dichotomous Thinking

§  For individuals with OCPD, dichotomous thinking often aligns with a perfectionist worldview. This black-and-white perspective can be a way of coping with anxiety and a need for control and predictability. 

§  This thinking style can manifest in OCPD as a rigid adherence to rules, procedures, and a strong sense of what is “right” or “wrong.” It's a way to manage the distress caused by uncertainty and maintain a sense of order and predictability.

Autistic Dichotomous Thinking

§  In contrast, for many Autistic people, dichotomous thinking can be more reflective of a cognitive processing style. It's not so much driven by anxiety or a need for control, but rather a preference for clear, unambiguous information.

§  This cognitive style might lead to challenges with understanding nuances and gray areas, especially in social situations and communication. Autistic individuals often have a precise way of interpreting language and actions, which can make it difficult to navigate situations where subtlety and indirect expressions are common.

From The Obsessive-Compulsive Personality Disorder Workbook (2026), Anthony Pinto: “Autism typically becomes evident in early childhood…whereas OCPD traits and behaviors typically emerge during adolescence and may not fully impair functioning until early adulthood. Moreover, social and communication deficits are core features of autism. While individuals with OCPD may also struggle in relationships, this is typically due to rigidity and insistence on control…rather than deficits in social understanding. In addition, individuals with autism often show restricted, repetitive patterns of behavior as well as intense, narrow interests…Although individuals with OCPD often do prefer routines and have set ways of doing things, these patterns are usually the result of a preoccupation with rules and order relating to perfectionism and personal standards, rather than a narrow interest.” (24-5)

BOOK

Friendship Skills for Neurodivergent Adults

SUPPORT GROUP

Peer Support Group for Adults with Autism and ADHD

DIAGNOSTIC CRITERIA

DSM diagnostic criteria for Autism Spectrum Disorder: INFO--DSM 5 Diagnostic Criteria.pdf

Outside the U.S., providers often use the ICD instead of the DSM: ICD-11 criteria for Autism

TREATMENT

Radically-Open Dialectical Behavior Therapy (RO-DBT) is for people with 'overcontrol disorders,' such as OCPD and Autism.

SCREENING SURVEYS

Review of ASD Screeners for Adults

OCPD Assessment Available Online

DISTINGUISHING AUTISM AND PDS

The behavior of people with ASD is most similar to the behavior of people with Schizotypal, Avoidant, Schizoid, and Obsessive Compulsive Personality Disorders.

One study found that 48% of participants with ASD met criteria for a personality disorder. Personality Disorders And Autism Spectrum Disorders: What Are The Connections?

In an interview (S2E69), Dr. Anthony Pinto, the leading OCPD specialist, talked for a few minutes about distinguishing Autism from OCPD (an hour and eleven minutes in).

VIDEOS

Is It Perfectionism?

Autistic/OCD Struggle Of Perfectionism

OCPD and ASD | Behaviour Similarities | Part 1, Part 2

Perfectionism isn't Serving You | Autism Experiences

Why High Masking Autistics are Obsessed With Perfection

Autistic Memory and Attention To Detail - Are You a Perfectionist?

Autism and The Pursuit of Perfection: My EXTREME Growth Mindset

Moral Perfectionism: When Surviving as a Neurodivergent Means Never Messing Up

How to Spot Autism in High-Masking Adults and 30 Signs You're Masking Autism

RESOURCE FOR PROFESSIONALS

Assessing the Intersection of Autism and Personality Disorders


r/OCPDPerfectionism • • Jan 02 '26

offering resource/support Dysfunctional Families

10 Upvotes

Mental health providers have theorized that children in dysfunctional families tend to take on the following roles, and that these behaviors can continue into adulthood:

Other roles include the enabler and the caretaker.

BLC-Dysfunctional-Family-Roles

INSIGHTS ON ABUSED CHILDREN FROM JOHN BRADHSAW

John Bradshaw was a mental health counselor known for his PBS specials on identity, shame, and dysfunctional families. His books sold over 12 million copies. They’re available in 42 languages. Unless otherwise noted, the quotations are from his Emmy award winning series, “Homecoming” (1990).

“Children don't know what normal is. How would you know what normal parenting is? All you know is [what’s happening in your family]...All children idealize their parents.” (Episode 1)

“A child can't know they're being abused. How do you know what abuse is? Who's teaching you about life? Who's modeling life for you?...[When your parents] say ‘I'm doing this for your own good,’ why would you argue with that?” (Ep. 3)

Children blame themselves for being abused: “I had to idealize [my parents], and make them okay, and me bad. That's what children do...” (Ep. 1)

Children “need to believe their parents are okay.” If their caregivers are not okay, “what's going to happen to me?” (Ep. 2)

“When you're being abused, you're being taught power, control, shame, secrecy, fear, distrust, distance, and the numbing of emotions, [that] those are the basis of relationships. That's what you're being trained to believe, and you begin to confuse that with love.” (Ep. 2)

Abused children often suppress their feelings. “You can’t heal what you can’t feel.” (Ep. 3)

The worst part of abuse is the “inability to talk about it to anyone…to have no witnesses or allies.” (Ep. 5, The Family series)

Abusive parents teach children to deny reality. Children in healthy environments have the freedom to “to see what you see; to hear what you hear; to feel what you feel, rather than what you're supposed to feel; to think what you think, rather than what you're supposed to think; to want what you want, rather than what you're supposed to want.” (Ep. 5, The Family)

Sources: Homecoming and The Family

VIDEOS

What Are The Dysfunctional Family Roles?

Trapped in a Cycle of Burnout: The Grown-up Hero Child

Mascot Role, Golden Child Role, Scapegoat Role, Hero Role, Lost Child Role, Caretaker Role

SUPPORT GROUPS

Adult Survivors of Child Abuse

Depression and Bipolar Support Alliance

Anxiety and Depression Association of America

BOOKS

Adult Children of Emotionally Immature Parents (2015), Lindsay Gibson

Running On Empty: Overcome Your Childhood Emotional Neglect (2019), Jonice Webb

Do you relate to any of the roles of children in dysfunctional families?


r/OCPDPerfectionism • • Sep 13 '26

"It's Just An Experiment": A Method For Outsmarting OCPD and Achieving Lasting Behavior Change

9 Upvotes

This post explains what behavior experiments are: Doing Behavioral Experiments Breaks The Cycle of Maladaptive Perfectionism

People with OCPD tend to ‘put themselves on trial’ for their perceived mistakes and shortcomings. Doing behavioral experiments helped me think like a scientist not a prosecutor. I did behavioral experiments for six months to supplement therapy. I did one experiment each day for several months, and then 2-5 experiments each day. This was a very effective strategy for reducing perfectionism, rigid habits and beliefs, negative self-talk, social anxiety, extreme frugality, false sense of urgency, and compulsive organizing. After about six months, I stopped consciously thinking of experiments and naturally stepped out of my comfort zone.

My experiments involved choosing to do something that made me slightly uncomfortable for a brief period of time. Having the attitude "this is just an experiment" was a way of letting go of the habit of setting unrealistic goals and feeling ashamed when they are not met.

When I felt calm or a very low level of discomfort, I chose to do something that I knew would cause slight discomfort. I observed what happened and then moved on with my day. When observing my reaction, I felt curiosity instead of self-judgment. I thought (and sometimes said) this feels uncomfortable.

My experiments were small steps out of my comfort zone. They were so brief that the discomfort was not overwhelming. When I sensed that I would be overwhelmed if the experiment continued, I ended it.

If I had the opportunity to do an experiment, and engaged in a compulsion instead (e.g. excessive cleaning), I moved slowly when engaging in the compulsion. This increased my mindfulness and helped me stop the compulsion sooner.

Positive reinforcement was key. I received encouragement from my therapist. I remembered, ‘it's okay to feel proud of myself for doing something that may be easy for most people.’ Even one experiment a day is an accomplishment—365 per year.

I didn’t view experiments as work, rules, or 'shoulds.' I didn’t take notes or plan them in advance. I did not view experiments as forcing myself to do something. Instead I thought ‘I’m going to try this and see what happens’ and ‘I’m willing to step out of my comfort zone for a short time.’

Before I learned to manage my OCPD traits, I often felt panicky, tense, and frustrated when circumstances forced me out of my comfort zone. If someone had offered me a million dollars to change one of my habits for one day, my first thought would have been, ‘How badly do I need that money?’ I lived on autopilot. I found it distressing to break my routines even when it made perfect sense to do so (e.g. leaving my apartment messy when running late for work).

What "Experiments" Have You Done Today?

EXAMPLES OF MY EXPERIMENTS

·       Sending an email to a friend without fixing a typo.

·       Posting a comment with typos online and waiting to edit.

·       Refraining from cleaning up a small area at my workplace at the end of the day.

·       Slowly reducing the amount of time I spent working at home.

·       Waiting 10 minutes before starting to make breakfast, instead of my usual routine of making breakfast as soon as I wake up.

·       Allowing myself to tear up for a few seconds before suppressing my feelings. Eventually, I learned to cry.

·       Making a low stakes disclosure with an acquaintance. (working on guardedness)

·       Asking a store employee where an item is located. (targeting social anxiety)

·       Saying ‘good morning’ to a stranger when walking on a nature trail.

·       Engaging in small talk for a few minutes with strangers and acquaintances (e.g. Uber driver, librarian, co-worker).

·       Taking a ten minute break at work.

·       Using a different route for my daily walk.

·       Doing laundry on a different day than usual.

·       When washing my hands, scrubbing with soap for 19 seconds instead of 20.

·       Waiting 5 seconds before checking a Facebook notification, then waiting 15 seconds, 30 seconds, etc. (targeting false sense of urgency)

·       Waiting 10 minutes to check email when I get home from work instead of checking it immediately.  

·       Waiting 5 minutes to respond to an email or text, and slowly increasing wait time.

·       Buying an item without comparison shopping, starting with inexpensive items (targeting analysis paralysis, extreme frugality)

·       Arriving 10 minutes early for an appointment instead of 20 minutes.

·       Waiting a few seconds to wash my hands after picking an item off the floor.

·       Seeing a mess in my apartment and waiting a few seconds before cleaning up. (I worked up to leaving the mess overnight, leaving it for a few days, a few weeks).

·       Leaving a dirty item in my sink and going to work.

·       Going on an errand and leaving the lights on in my apartment (targeting frugality)

·        Setting a timer for 19 minutes instead of 20.

·        Doing toning exercises, lifting my right leg 10 times and my left leg 9 times.

·        Changing my to do list to Comic Sans font for a few minutes.

·        Doing a typing exercise: I worked hard to reduce my strong drive for completion. It got a little bit easier every da

·        The first compulsive organizing experiment I did was tossing a pencil on the floor for a few seconds. I did that experiment many times. Moving one item out of place slightly (turning it askew) is another good experiment.

More examples of experiments:

In the short book Mini Habits For Weight Loss, Stephen Guise describes how he finally got in shape (after 20 years of trying) by setting a goal of doing one push up each day.

Sheldon Needs Closure | The Big Bang Theory

On another episode, Sheldon talks about trying to learn how to swim from watching videos. That reminded me of how I tried to improve my mental health by reading self help books for many years; it didn't help. I learned new ways of coping by working with a therapist and doing behavior experiments.

AFFIRMATIONS

I found these affirmations helpful:

·        Pace yourself.

·        One day at a time.

·        No risk, no reward.

·        Practice makes progress.

·        Get comfortable with being uncomfortable.

·        This is not failure. It’s more data.

·        “If you can’t make a mistake, you can’t make anything.” Marva Collins

·        “Do what you can, with what you’ve got, where you are.” Teddy Roosevelt

I reminded myself that it's okay to feel proud for doing something that most people find easy.

DISCLAIMERS

Dr. Steven Phillipson, an OCD specialist, has stated that it’s best for people with OCD to only do Exposure/Response Prevention (ERP) exercises (similar to behavioral experiments) under the close supervision of a therapist.

This post is not intended as advice for people who are experiencing suicidal thoughts and/or struggling with basic self-care.

RESOURCE

When Your Comfort Zone Keeps You Stuck

Do you take small steps out of your comfort zone? Why or why not?


r/OCPDPerfectionism • • Aug 18 '26

OCD and OCPD: Similarities and Differences

9 Upvotes

CASUAL DEFINITION OF OBSESSION VS. CLINICAL DEFINITION

People casually use the term obsession to refer to persistent thoughts and desires that influence their behavior. Mental health providers define an obsession as a “recurrent and persistent thought, image, or impulse that is experienced as intrusive and inappropriate and causes significant anxiety or distress.” (230). Obsessions occur repeatedly, despite efforts to resist them.

Source: When Perfect Isn’t Good Enough (2009), Martin Antony, Richard Swinson

OCD OBSESSIONS VS. OCPD PERSEVERATIONS

The obsessions of people with OCD involve unwanted urges, images, and thoughts about danger to themselves or others that provoke anxiety. Carrying out time consuming compulsions provides temporary relief from the anxiety. Other people, and usually the person with OCD, view the obsessions and compulsions as irrational and bizarre. Common OCD obsessions and compulsions: What is Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder (OCD)? & OCD Therapists NYC

People with OCPD perseverate and hyperfocus on issues and tasks they value (e.g. work, organizing). They have a tendency to ruminate, worry, and overthink. Their compulsions are rigid habits and routines driven by moral and ethical beliefs and a strong need for order, perfection, and control over themselves, others, and/or their environment. People may receive praise for behaviors stemming from OCPD (e.g. diligence at work). The OCPD diagnostic criteria refer to "over preoccupation," not clinical obsessions.

TYPES OF OCD

Common Types of OCD

Relationship OCD Resources

Overview of Pure Obsessional OCD (no obvious compulsions)

What is Visual Tourettic OCD?, Overcoming Visual Staring OCD

DSM CRITERIA

OCD: Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder

OCPD: dsm.pdf

SCREENING SURVEYS

OCD Screener

OCPD Assessment

DIAGNOSTIC TESTS

OCD: The Yale-Brown Obsessive Compulsive Scale (Y-BOCS) is the most common assessment for OCD. Before administering the Y-BOCS, the provider should talk with the client to make sure the obsessions and compulsions are clearly defined. Other assessments include The Obsessive-Compulsive Inventory (OCI) and The Maudsley Obsessive-Compulsive Questionnaire (MOCQ). International OCD Foundation | Measuring Obsessive-Compulsive Symptoms

OCPD: There are many assessments for evaluating personality disorders, e.g. Millon Clinical Multiaxial Inventory (MCMI), Personality Assessment Inventory (PAI), Personality Diagnostic Questionnaire (PDQ), and OMNI Personality Disorder Inventory (OMNI).

TREATMENT

OCD: The gold standard treatment is Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) and Exposure and Response Prevention (ERP). Some people with OCD benefit from Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy (MBCT) and Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT). Medication can reduce OCD symptoms.

Best Online Therapy For OCD, OCD Treatment and Therapy | NOCD, Living with OCD, Find an OCD Therapist

Exposure and Response Prevention, How ERP works, Things That Complicate The Success Of ERP

OCPD: The common therapy approaches for OCPD are Psychodynamic Therapy, Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT), Radically Open Dialectical Behavior Therapy (RO DBT), and Schema Therapy. Some people with OCPD find trauma therapy (e.g. EDMR) and Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) helpful. Finding Mental Health Providers

CO-MORBIDITY

Research indicates that about 25%-33% of people with OCD also have OCPD. Some people meet the criteria for one disorder and just have tendencies of the other disorder.

EGO DYSTONIC VS. EGO SYNTONIC

Dr. Todd Grande: Why Don't People Know When They Have A Personality Disorder?

People with OCD usually view their obsessions and compulsions as separate from themselves—intrusive, distressing, and not aligned with their beliefs and desires (ego dystonic).

OCPD is usually ego syntonic. Individuals view their habits as rational, logical, justified, and as expressions of their values and beliefs. They often don’t realize that these behaviors impact them negatively (e.g. contributing to depression, work difficulties, and relationship difficulties).

There are exceptions to the ego syntonic vs. ego dystonic pattern.

People with OCD are more likely to seek therapy to find relief from their symptoms. When people with OCPD seek therapy, it's often due to depression, anxiety and/or difficulties with work or relationships, rather than maladaptive perfectionism and other OCPD symptoms.

DIFFERENCES

The intensity and frequency of OCD symptoms tend to fluctuate over time. For example, they can be exacerbated by stressful life events. OCPD symptoms are more consistent.

OCD tends to develop at an earlier age.

People with OCPD often have a very strong habit of delaying gratification.

“People with OCD are more likely to feel anxious when specific things aren’t the way they want them to be. People with OCPD are more likely to feel angry if things aren’t the way they believe they should be."

"People with OCD don’t necessarily restrict their emotions.…People with OCPD often try to control their emotions ...They are more reluctant to be vulnerable than those with OCD, and may not even be aware of any underlying anxiety.”

“People with OCD have specific obsessions (thoughts that are intrusive, involuntary, repetitive, irrational, and anxiety-provoking) and specific ritualistic compulsions (repetitive behaviors they can’t stop, such as checking and washing).” (emphasis added). In contrast, “the entire personality of someone with OCPD is affected by an overwhelming need to prioritize control, perfectionism, and order.”

“People with OCD often believe something terrible or catastrophic will happen if they do not follow through with their compulsions. They may fear harm to themselves or others, contamination leading to illness, or consequences from not adhering to rituals.”

Sources: OCPD vs. OCD: What Is The Difference?, Alexa Donnelly; Do You Have OCD or OCPD? Know The Difference, Gary Trosclair

Situation/ThemeOCD: Ego-DystonicOCPD: Ego-Syntonic
Contamination and CleaningExcessively washing due to fears of illness despite knowing risk of getting sick is low; wishes to stop.Strict cleaning routine seen as responsible; believes others who clean less are “wrong.”
Orderliness and SymmetryRearranging items to relieve anxiety that something bad might happen while knowing it’s unrealistic.Maintaining strict organization and order (e.g. alphabetized books) because it’s “correct.”
CheckingRepeatedly checking locks/stove to prevent imagined harm; frustrated by wasted time.Double-checks tasks to ensure perfection; sees as necessary to do good work.
Rule-FollowingPerforming actions in exact sequence to avoid feared harm even though it’s not logically connected.Insisting that chores follow a set sequence because it’s “the right way.”
Reaction to OthersNoticing others don’t have the same rituals and feeling envy, wishing to be free from the compulsion.Noticing others are more relaxed about cleanliness or order and feeling like they are careless or irresponsible.

From The Obsessive-Compulsive Personality Disorder Workbook (2026), Anthony Pinto, pg. 21

ADAPTIVE POTENTIAL OF OCPD SYMPTOMS

"OCD efforts are usually maladaptive, except insofar as it helps them to maintain good hygiene. In contrast, some OCPD traits can be adaptive in a practical way, allowing them to succeed in the outer world...Because they are very conscientious, meticulous, energetic, and committed, they can make significant contributions in many fields...Most successful performers and athletes are compulsive to some degree.” (“Do You Have OCD or OCPD?”, Gary Trosclair)

“Obsessive-compulsive personality traits in moderation may be especially adaptive, particularly in situations that reward high performance. Only when these traits are inflexible, maladaptive, and persisting and cause significant functional impairment or subjective distress do they constitute obsessive-compulsive personality disorder.” ("Obsessive-Compulsive Personality Disorder: A Review of Symptomatology, Impact on Functioning, and Treatment," Anthony Pinto et al.)

IMPACT OF UNDIAGNOSED OCPD

In an Internet talk radio show interview, Dr. Anthony Pinto explained why untreated OCPD interferes with Exposure Response Prevention (ERP), the gold standard treatment for OCD:

ERP “involves the individual facing those situations or the particular triggers for their OCD and not doing their compulsions or their rituals. So when somebody has perfectionism [OCP or OCPD]...they tend to perseverate over details of therapy instructions and they become really worked up about whether they are doing the treatment correctly. They can also sometimes be argumentative about the rationale for the treatment, and feel like it is wrong not to do rituals, and so that can impact their compliance or their adherence with the treatment...

“Sometimes individuals with perfectionism...might avoid doing the exposures on their own for fear that they're not doing them correctly....[They] might be more sensitive to feeling like a failure if the progress in treatment is moving slowly."

BOOKS 

The Healthy Compulsive (2020) by Gary Trosclair, a therapist who specializes in OCPD.

Too Perfect (1992) by Allan Mallinger, a psychiatrist who provided individual and group therapy for people with OCPD.

Brain Lock (2016) by Dr. Jeffrey Schwartz, a psychiatrist who provided therapy to more than one thousand clients with OCD, and started the first therapy group for people with OCD. Four Steps Treatment Method for OCD

PODCASTS 

OCPD: The Healthy Compulsive Podcast. Episodes 5 and 12 focus on OCD and OCPD.

OCD: 10 Must-Listen Podcasts For People With OCD | NOCD, OCD Family Podcast, The OCD Stories

BEST RESOURCES

Best Online OCD Resources

Best Resources For People With Suspected OCPD Traits and Recent Diagnoses


r/OCPDPerfectionism • • Sep 28 '25

offering resource/support OCPD and Defensiveness

Post image
9 Upvotes

From Gary Trosclair's Wield Your Shield Wisely: How to Not Be Defensive:

Safety. Personal insecurity is the most frequent cause of defensiveness. When we feel our worth, dignity, or reputation is fragile and threatened, we don’t feel safe. We shoot first and ask questions never.

Assumptions. Defensiveness also occurs when we assume we know what the other person is feeling and thinking. The assumption is not only inaccurate, but it also typically assumes the other person is being very critical...

Projections. These assumptions often result from projections, in which we confuse our own feelings (e.g. self-loathing) with what the other person is saying...One of the assumptions we make is that what people want from us is perfection. But that’s our value, not theirs. They may value openness, authenticity, and a simple willingness to hear other people out without getting defensive.

Over-confidence. Some people assume that they’re always right and have all the answers. It’s hard to be open when you’ve decided you’re right before a single comment is made...

Driven. When you’re on a mission and it feels like the other person’s feedback will block you or slow you down, you raise up your Shield to push them out of your way.

INTENTION VS. IMPACT

Improving the ability to accept feedback without defensiveness improves relationships.

I found it very helpful to keep in mind that my intentions when communicating with someone might be very different than the impact on the other person.

In The Healthy Compulsive (2020), Gary Trosclair explains, “People may perceive your determination to make things better differently from the way you intend it. Even if you don’t apply your personal standards to other people, they may assume you do, and feel that you’re always looking down your nose at them. This could easily be the case if you aren’t very uncommunicative. What may feel to you like well-intended efforts to help may be experienced by others as mean-spirited criticism, control, or hostility.” (122)

ARTICLES

Dr. Allan Mallinger’s Substack, post 19

I’m tired of hearing that I think I’m better than everyone, tips for changing?

VIDEOS

How to Stop Getting Defensive About Everything

Complex Trauma Leads to a Hypersensitivity to Disrespect

Defensiveness: Why We Feel It & How To Transform It Into Assertiveness


r/OCPDPerfectionism • • May 25 '26

The Unconscious Beliefs That Drive OCPD Symptoms

8 Upvotes

In The CBT Workbook For Perfectionism (2019), Sharon Martin explains, “We talk to ourselves continuously. Most of this self-talk isn’t even in our consciousness. We get so accustomed to our steady stream of thoughts that we don’t pay attention to most of them. However, our unconscious thoughts are important, because they reflect what we believe about ourselves and influence our feelings and actions.” (66)

In Too Perfect (1992), Dr. Allan Mallinger theorizes that people with OCPD believe that "mistake-free living is both possible and urgently necessary."

They believe, "If I always try my best and if I’m alert and sharp enough, I can avoid error. Not only can I perform flawlessly in everything important and be the ideal person in every situation, but I can avoid everyday blunders, oversights, and poor decisions…

It’s crucial to avoid making mistakes because they would show that I’m not as competent as I should be...By being perfect, I can ensure my own security with others. They will admire me and will have no reason to criticize or reject me...

My worth depends on how ‘good’ I am, how smart I am, and how well I perform.” (37-8)

In post 24 of Allan Mallinger's Substack, he describes the unconscious beliefs of people with OCPD--“With enough effort, I can exert control over anything that might affect my well-being, and thus ensure lifelong protection against serious harm. I can control my own thoughts, emotions, and behavior; the opinions and behavior of others that might affect me; and life’s many dangers—illness, accidents, misfortune, even death."

"By discovering and understanding the facts, laws and formulas that govern life, I can impose order and predictability on my universe, and thereby remain safe."

In "The Ten Commandments of the Obsessive-Compulsive Personality," Gary Trosclair states, “Based on personal and professional observations, here’s my best guess as to what the commandments that people with OCP adopt most often are:

1.      I will never make mistakes.

2.      I will always keep things in order and I will never leave a mess.

3.      I will always be productive and I will never waste time.

4.      I will never waste money.

5.      I will always do what I say I will do.

6.      I will always tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth...

7.      I will never be late. Even if it doesn’t matter.

8.      I will never let others get away with doing or saying the wrong thing...

9.      I will never disappoint others.

10.  I will always complete my work before relaxing.”

Do you have any of the beliefs that Mallinger and Trosclair describe? If so, how have they affected your life?


r/OCPDPerfectionism • • Jan 17 '26

offering resource/support Dr. Allan Mallinger's Screening Survey For OCPD

8 Upvotes

Dr. Allan Mallinger is a psychiatrist who shared his experiences providing individual and group therapy to clients with OCPD in Too Perfect: When Being in Control Gets Out of Control (1996). The Spanish edition is La Obsesión Del Perfeccionismo (2010). The German edition is Keiner ist Perfekt (2003). You can listen to Too Perfect with a free trial of Amazon Audible. Audiobook preview.

Pages 11-13 (1992 edition):

  1. Do you get caught up in details, whether you're preparing a report for work or cleaning out the garage at home?

  2. Is it hard for you to let go of a work project until it's just right -- even if it takes much longer than it should?

  3. Have you often been called picky or critical? Or do you feel you are?

  4. Is it important to you that your child, spouse, or subordinates at work perform certain tasks in a certain specific manner?

  5. Do you have trouble making decisions? (For example, do you go back and forth before making a purchase, planning a vacation, or choosing what to order from a menu?)

  6. After you do make a decision, do you find yourself second-guessing or doubting your choice?

  7. Do you find it embarrassing to "lose control" and be emotional (e.g., to look nervous, weep, or raise your voice in anger)?

  8. At the same time, do you sometimes find yourself wishing it were easier for you to show your feelings?

  9. Do you have a particularly strong conscience, or do you often feel guilty?

  10. Is self-discipline important to you?

  11. Are you especially wary of being controlled manipulated, overpowered, or "steam-rolled" by others?

  12. Is it important for you to get a "good deal" in your financial transactions, or are you often suspicious of being "taken"?

  13. Do you think you're more guarded than most people about sharing your possessions, time, or money?

  14. Do you tend to be secretive? That is, are you reluctant to reveal your motives or feelings?

  15. Is it hard for you to let yourself be dependent on others, rather than self-reliant? (For instance, are you uneasy about delegating tasks at work or hiring help with taxes or home repairs?)

  16. Do you have trouble putting a problem out of your mind until it's resolved, even when you're doing other things?

  17. In thinking about some future event, such as a vacation, a dinner party, or a job report, do you dwell upon the things that might go wrong?

  18. Do you worry more than most people?

  19. Do you derive a great deal of your sense of worth from being able to perform your job flawlessly?

  20. Do you get extremely upset when someone is unhappy with or critical of a piece of work you have done, even when the criticism is mild or valid?

  21. Do you feel that your family life, social life, or leisure-time enjoyment is being damaged or compromised by the amount of worry, time, or energy you put into work?

  22. Do you feel guilty when you aren't getting something done, even in your time off (no matter how hard you've worked all week)?

  23. Do you make lists of things you "should" do, even in your spare time?

  24. Do even occasional "white lies" bother you?

  25. Do you find it hard to trust that things will probably turn out for the best?

"If you find yourself answering 'yes' to more than just a few of these questions, you (or your loved one) are probably at least somewhat obsessive. Now look once again at the questions to which you answered 'yes,' and for each one, answer a second question: Does this characteristic cause difficulties in relationships, work, or leisure activities, or does it interfere with your ability to enjoy life in general? If you answer 'yes' to this even once, you will benefit from learning more about obsessiveness and about the possibility for change.

"Before beginning, however, I offer this cautionary note: If you are strongly obsessive, you're a careful person who finds security in sameness and predictability. You're more wary of change and newness than the average person --and changing isn't easy for anyone! But change is always possible. It may involve time and struggle. It may occasionally be painful. But it can be a journey toward a happier, more relaxed and fulfilling life." (13)

When I had OCPD, I would have answered 'yes' to 21 out of 25 questions. Hmm. I'm a little disappointed; that's 84%. I would not have earned an A for perfectionism.


r/OCPDPerfectionism • • Oct 04 '25

offering resource/support Self-Care Books That Helped Me Manage OCPD

Post image
8 Upvotes

When I was in my 20s and early 30s, I 'got away' with neglecting my physical health. Then I developed three health conditions, and had constant medical appointments and phone calls. I was told that I might need surgery. (I ended up only needing a minor procedure). It was overwhelming beyond words. I had a lot of anxiety in medical settings due to OCPD and a few negative experiences with providers. I managed to turn my health around. I wished that I had learned healthier habits when I was younger; it would have been much easier.

Taking steps to improve my physical health has been a healthy way to increase my feelings of control. I made very small changes as consistently as I could and slowly increased difficulty. "It's Just An Experiment"

Practicing Self-Care Breaks The Cycle of Maladaptive Perfectionism

I lost more than 100 lbs. in 18 months by following the Harvard Medical School Diet and walking as much as possible. I was diagnosed with sleep apnea and made many changes to my sleep habits. I have more energy, confidence, and productivity. All of the positive changes in my physical health positively impacted my mental health. These are the books that helped me.

SLEEP

“Often we are totally unaware of our own reduced capabilities because we become habituated to low levels of alertness. Many of us have been sleepy for such a long time that we don’t know what it’s like to feel wide awake.” Dr. James Maas

Power Sleep (1998) and Sleep for Success (2011) by Dr. James Maas, a sleep specialist and former Psychology professor at Cornell

The Harvard Medical School Guide to A Good Night’s Sleep (2007) by Dr. Lawrence Epstein, a former Harvard professor and director of the American Academy of Sleep Medicine

Sleep Smarter (2016) by Shawn Stevenson, a life coach and fitness expert who overcame insomnia

The Sleep Fix (2021) by Diane Macedo, a journalist who covers medical news for ABC and overcame insomnia

Dr. Mark Burnhenne’s The 8-Hour Sleep Paradox (2015) and Dr. Steven Park’s Sleep, Interrupted (2012) focus on the epidemic of undiagnosed sleep disorders.

A good first step to improve sleep is asking your primary care doctor to give you the Epworth Sleep Scale, a screening survey for sleep disorders. It's not 100% reliable so your doctor will ask you for details about your sleep habits and difficulties. Your doctor can authorize a sleep study. Sleep studies can be done at labs or with take-home devices. The lab studies are more accurate. Schedule your lab studies as soon as possible, as there is typically a long wait.

If you want to consult with a sleep specialist, note that they have subspecialties (e.g. sleep apnea, cognitive behavioral treatment for insomnia).

Long-term use of sleep medication can worsen the symptoms of untreated sleep disorders.

CHRONIC PAIN

Trauma and chronic stress can cause chronic pain. After consulting with a physical therapist who specializes in the mind-body connection, my back pain ended after nearly two years. Chronic Pain and Perfectionism

The Way Out (2022), Alan Gordon

Healing Back Pain (1991), John Sarno

They Can't Find Anything Wrong (2007), David Clarke

SELF-ADVOCACY

These books are about navigating medical care in the U.S.

How To Be a Patient (2019), Sana Goldberg, RN

How Medicine Works and When It Doesn’t (2023), F. Perry Wilson, MD

The Take-Charge Patient (2019), Martine Ehrenclou

HEALTHY EATING AND PHYSICAL ACTIVITY

Obesity is a public health issue, not an individual failure.

Eat, Drink, And Be Healthy: The Harvard Medical School Guide To Healthy Eating (2017, 3rd ed.): Dr. Walter Willet is the most cited researcher in journal articles about nutrition. All of his recommendations are based on valid and reliable research studies, with an emphasis on larger studies and longitudinal studies. For example, one study tracked 7,000 women over 10 years. Following the Harvard Medical School diet significantly reduces the risk of developing type 2 diabetes, heart disease, and stroke. For many people, it’s the safest and most effective way to lose weight and maintain a healthy weight for life. Eat, Drink, and Weigh Less (2013) summarizes the content of the first book using less technical language, and includes recipes.

Mini Habits For Weight Loss (2016): Stephen Guise offers strategies for improving eating and exercise habits. He asserts that setting small daily goals is the best way to acquire new habits and maintain them for life. The insights in this short book are especially helpful for perfectionists. Mini Habits – Animated Book Summary

My most helpful eating habit is mindful eating—eating slowly and savoring food. I found that practicing mindful eating for short periods of time every day was a better approach than trying to practice it for long periods of time. Setting aside more time for meals is helpful. It takes about 20 minutes for the brain to register the feeling of fullness. Savoring food makes you feel satisfied eating a healthy amount of food. When I have the urge to ‘stress eat,’ I identify my feelings, and try to wait 5-10 minutes before eating. After waiting, if I eat, I try eat slowly.

52 Ways To Walk: The Surprising Science Of Walking For Wellness And Joy, One Week At A Time (2022): Annabel Abbs-Streets explains research findings about the extraordinary physical and health benefits of walking regularly. Annabel Streets | mbg Podcast. She describes ways to add variety to walking routines--keeping them engaging and maximizing the benefits.

The National Weight Control Registry analyzed survey data from thousands of people who maintained a weight loss of 30 or more lbs. for more than a year. The results showed that walking is the most popular exercise among participants. Studies have documented the health benefits of daily walks as short as 12 minutes.

Ep. 83: 7 Ways Spending Time in Nature…–The Healthy Compulsive Project Podcast

I came across an interview with a therapist who states that his #1 recommendation for his clients with depression is to have a walking routine. Walking every day significantly reduced my anxiety. I started walking for two minutes around my apartment building when I arrived home from work. A few weeks later, I increased to 7 minutes, then 15, 20, and so on. Now I can easily walk more than an hour.

Using a lectern for my computer also helped a lot with weight loss. I stacked three large Tupperware containers instead of buying a lectern. I started using it for short periods of time and slowly increased.


r/OCPDPerfectionism • • Jun 04 '26

Therapists Specializing In Perfectionism Offer Insights on Denial of Pleasure

7 Upvotes

From The Perfectionist’s Guide to Losing Control (2023), Katherine Morgan Schafler:

“Maladaptive perfectionists are perpetually on some version of a joy diet.

- The low-calorie version: Sure, I’ll have a little joy, but just a taste, because I’m working really hard on X project right now.

- The intermittent-fasting version: Thank you, but I only allow myself joy for the half hour before bed.

- The paleo version: I only consume joy from a single source, my children.

Joy is healthy in any amount. Like the air you breathe, you never have to worry about having too much joy.” (259)

"When you put your desire on mute, you also mute your intuition. This forces you to rely exclusively on your thoughts—you think you’re hungry all the time, and you can’t stop eating. Or you think you’re not hungry all day until you find yourself ravenous in your kitchen after work…” (261)

“A self-punishment is consciously or unconsciously returning to something that you know will hurt you, or denying yourself something that you know will help you. Punishments are designed to create more pain. When you’re punitive with yourself, the grand plan is to hurt yourself in order to teach yourself a lesson…

"Punishment doesn’t work. When you punish someone, the person doesn’t learn how to change; they learn how to avoid the source of the punishment. If you are the source of your own punishment (through critical self-talk, for example), then you learn to avoid yourself by numbing out. Numbing out looks like overeating, overspending, overworking…mindlessly watching TV or scrolling social media, and so forth.” (122)

From The CBT Workbook For Perfectionism (2019), Sharon Martin:

Perfectionists “miss out on a lot of life’s pleasures because of fear. Our fears can be so deep that we actually convince ourselves that we don’t want to do things rather than tap into the awareness that we’re afraid of failure, embarrassment, criticism, rejection, and not being as good as everyone else….our fears hold us back from doing things that might enhance our lives. These could be business opportunities, forming new relationships, traveling, or hobbies.

"We like to stick to things we know we’re good at; this way, we’re assured success and accolades (or at least not embarrassment and criticism). Because our self-worth hinges on our performance, we work really hard at avoiding things that are new and different.” (22)

From Too Perfect (1992), Allan Mallinger:

Dr. Mallinger’s clients often report that they “feel compelled to use all their time productively. [They are] usually armed with lists of ‘things to do,’ and they’re much more apt to fret about the items left undone than to savor the accomplishment of those they’ve checked off. They shudder at the thought of wasting time. Even in their ‘free’ time, they feel they should be working on chores, projects, or other productive or educational tasks.” (161)

“One painful consequence of the conversion of ‘wants’ into ‘shoulds’ is that at some point [people with OCPD] come to regard even potentially joyful activities as burdens…[even though they started] a project or hobby with a pleasant sense of anticipation.” (98)

MY EXPERIENCE

As a young child, I stopped experiencing joy. My estranged parents are trauma survivors who did not exhibit joy. They barely smiled. I started experiencing joy when I was 40. Working with a trauma therapist, having a walking routine, and listening to The Healthy Compulsive Project Podcast were most helpful. I also thought of the time in my life when my OCPD symptoms were the lowest, and re connected with activities, places, and people from that time.

How has habitually denying yourself pleasure affected your life?


r/OCPDPerfectionism • • May 25 '26

Alexithymia: Difficulty Identifying, Understanding, and Expressing Emotions

7 Upvotes

You can listen to this article at Gary Trosclair's "The Healthy Compulsive Project" podcast: Can't Identify Your Feelings? You May Have Alexithymia

The term alexithymia means no words for emotions and unspeaking heart. People with alexithymia have difficulty identifying, understanding, and expressing emotions. Research indicates that about 13% of the general population has alexithymia. It is common among people with OCPD, autism, depression, dissociative disorders, and suicidality. People with alexithymia may experience emotions as somatic symptoms (e.g. fatigue).

"Alexithymia doesn’t mean an absence of emotion. Contrary to how it might look at first, people who are born with predispositions to alexithymia censor feeling because it’s too intense."

"Alexithymia may become your default early on if emotional signals are not named, mirrored, and supported by caregivers early in life. This could happen if caregivers are neglectful, absent, distracted or otherwise unable or unwilling to help the child understand and express their feelings."

“If you have alexithymia people may experience you as distant, flat, restrained, uninterested, controlled or emotionally unavailable. They may not know that you’re upset when you’re hurt, or when you’re lonely, or when you care about someone. It can make you difficult to read and confusing to others because your expressions are indirect, at best. Not expressing yourself is an expression—whether you like it or not. It sends a message.”

"Emotions provide direction because they lead to our values, what’s most important to us. They fuel our passions. Without them, we’re paralyzed, or, at best, wandering aimlessly.”

“If you’re not sure what you’re feeling, start by asking yourself whether your experience is pleasant or unpleasant. Then ask which of seven basic emotions you may be having” (fear, sadness, anger, joy, disgust, shame, or hurt).

“Imagine a radio signal from a distant planet that you have to concentrate on to tune into. The signal may be very faint at first, but tune into it by tuning into your body. Take the risk that you may not get it just right. Don’t let perfectionism get in your way….

“Once you can [identify your basic emotion]…branch out into more nuanced expressions. Use this chart to find other words that may more accurately describe what you’re experiencing—however subtly. Keep checking in with your body to see if the term resonates…

“Finally, let go. In your effort to tune in, try to monitor if you get tense or work too hard. Just notice. The process is much more about letting go so you can hear what wants to be heard, allowing it to surface…While some of your emotions have been painful, remember that there is an entire world of positive emotions in there as well. I hope that you can permit them safe passage. Your heart is waiting.”

RESOURCES

Toronto Alexithymia Scale (available online)

Identifying and Responding to Feelings (article)

How to Process Emotional Numbness and Dissociation (video)

How has alexithymia affected your life?


r/OCPDPerfectionism • • Apr 08 '26

offering resource/support Insights From Therapist Specializing In Emotional Neglect

7 Upvotes

Dr. Jonice Webb published Running On Empty: Overcome Your Childhood Emotional Neglect (2019, 2nd ed.) after working as a therapist for 28 years. Her co-author is Christine Musello, PsyD.

The rating on Amazon is 4.6 out of 5 stars, based on 5K+ reviews. The book has Spanish, Portuguese, and Dutch editions. The sequel is Running on Empty No More (2017).

Facebook (clip of Dr. Webb)

Dr. Webb describes her typical client who experienced childhood emotional neglect (xx):

-has difficulty asking for help and relying on others

-presents as aloof or distant

-struggles with imposter syndrome

-uncomfortable in social situations

-prone to harsh self-criticism

-often feels irritable for no apparent reason

-has difficulty identifying their feelings and calming themselves

-feels empty inside...

I identified with 21 of 22 items from the list. Similar to Dr. Webb’s typical clients, it took me a long time to recognize the extent of my emotional neglect, and its impact.

Dr. Webb’s clients who experienced emotional neglect often have counter dependence: “the drive to need no one, or more specifically, the fear of being dependent. Counter-dependent people go to great lengths to avoid asking for help, to not appear, or feel, needy. They will make every effort not to rely on another person, even at their own great expense.” (77)

Symptoms of emotional neglect often "masquerade as something else: depression, marital problems, anxiety, anger...Since [people who experienced childhood emotional neglect] have not learned to identify or to be in touch with their true emotional needs, it’s difficult for therapists to keep them in treatment long enough to help them understand themselves better.” (xviii-xix)

Introduction

“What do you remember from your childhood?...Perhaps you have some positive memories, like family vacations, teachers, friends, summer camps or academic awards; and some negative memories, like family conflicts, sibling rivalries, problems at school, or even some sad or troubling events.

"Running on Empty is not about any of those kinds of memories. In fact, it’s not about anything that you can remember or anything that happened in your childhood. This book is written to help you become aware of what didn’t happen in your childhood, what you don’t remember. Because what didn’t happen has as much or more power over who you have become as an adult than any of those events you do remember.

“Running on Empty will introduce you to the consequences of what didn’t happen: an invisible force that may be at work in your life…Many fine, high functioning capable people secretly feel unfulfilled or disconnected. Shouldn’t I be happier? Why haven’t I accomplished more? Why doesn’t my life feel more meaningful? These are questions which are often prompted by the invisible force…” (xv)

Well-Meaning Parents Can Be Emotionally Neglectful

“It is entirely possible for a parent who loves and wants the best for his child to emotionally neglect her. The truth is, to love your child is a very different thing from being in tune with your child. For healthy development, loving a child just isn’t enough. For a parent to be in tune with his child, he must be a person who is aware of and understands emotions in children.” (65)

Dr. Webb describes a parent who has the skills to develop a secure emotional bond with their child: “The parent feels an emotional connection to the child. The parent pays attention to the child and sees him as a unique and separate person, rather than, say, an extension of him or herself, a possession or a burden. Using that emotional connection and paying attention, the parent responds competently to the child’s emotional need.” (6)

Emptiness Is A Common Problem

“In many ways, emptiness or numbness is worse than pain. Many people have told me that they would far prefer feeling anything to nothing. It is very difficult to acknowledge, make sense of, or put into words something that is absent. If you do succeed in putting emptiness into words to try to explain it to another person, it’s very difficult for others to understand it. Emptiness seems like nothing to most people. And nothing is nothing, neither bad nor good. But in the case of a human being’s internal functioning, nothing is definitely something. Emptiness is actually a feeling in and of itself…that can be very intense and powerful. In fact, it has the power to drive people to do extreme things to escape it.” (112)

Suppressing Emotions

Dr. Webb’s clients often responded to emotional neglect by suppressing their emotions.

“When you grow up receiving consistent direct or indirect messages that you should keep your feelings to yourself, it is natural to assume that those feelings are burdensome and undesirable to others.” (132)

RESOURCES

Childhood Emotional Neglect Questionnaire | Dr. Jonice Webb

The Purpose of Feelings (more excerpts from Running on Empty)

4 Ways You May Be Keeping Yourself Running On Empty (article)

Heidi Priebe's videos on the avoidant attachment style also gave a me a lot of insights about emotional neglect: How Does An Avoidant Attachment Style Develop?


r/OCPDPerfectionism • • Jan 19 '26

trigger warning OCPD, Depression, and Suicidality

7 Upvotes

TW references to past suicidality (fully recovered), child abuse

Perfectionism destroyed my family and almost ended my life. My mother is a perfectionist. My father and sister may have OCPD. My parents have untreated childhood trauma. The unspoken message in my childhood home was ‘Take care of your own problems.’

After early childhood, I did not experience joy in my childhood home. I had a suicide plan at age 12. My mother found the stash of pills in my room and removed them (along with the medicine in the kitchen), and never said anything.

My sister was physically abused more often because she stood up for herself. The emotional abuse we experienced was just as damaging. When I was a teenager, my mother came to my bedroom at night and said, "Can you stop crying? I need to get up early for work tomorrow." I don't remember why I was crying hysterically.

I attempted to overdose at age 15. A year later, I called the police on my abusive father. My parents responded by punishing me. I was relieved to leave home from college, but I still had suicidal thoughts. On several occasions, my mother told me and my sister that our visits home disrupted her routine. I gave her the final copy of my thesis, but quickly took it back when she started marking corrections. She looked confused.

For me, the worst effects of childhood trauma were losing the ability to trust anyone. I was not able to maintain friendships from high school and college.

My undiagnosed OCPD and trauma disorder led to depression, constant anxiety, and binge eating. My parents did not offer support when they learned of my past suicidality; I ended communication with them. When I was 30, I had no job, friends, or family, and very little hope. Misdiagnosed with OCD, I was hospitalized for three days in a psychiatric ward.

The cognitive distortions caused by my OCPD and trauma made me view the world through a very dark lens. Having OCPD and suicidal thoughts is like carrying a 100 lb. weight on your back and criticizing yourself for not walking faster.

Participating in a trauma therapy group ended my 25 years of suicidal ideation. I'm fully recovered. The world is a safe place. My mind is a safe place.

Books saved me during my childhood; they were my only reliable source of comfort. It’s fitting that I found the answer to my mental health problems in The Healthy Compulsive (2020) at age 40. I realized that if someone offered me one million dollars to change one habit for one day, I would hesitate.

I resumed individual therapy after a nine year break. I made enough progress to no longer meet diagnostic criteria for OCPD. Recovering from OCPD was like slowly waking up from a nightmare. Working on OCPD helped me overcome binge eating and lifelong social anxiety. Insomnia is my only remaining trauma symptom.

The OCPD resources from Anthony Pinto, Gary Trosclair, and Allan Mallinger helped a lot to supplement my therapy. Learning to manage OCPD was like trying to find my way out of a desert. The psychoeducation resources were my map. I knew when I was going in the right direction, and when I was stuck. I will promote OCPD awareness for the rest of my life.

Recently, I drove to the town where I was hospitalized. I felt empowered in a place where I once felt completely hopeless, isolated, and ashamed. I have friends and a therapist that I trust. I enjoy my job, and use my OCP to my advantage.

DEPRESSION AND OCPD

A 2001 study by Rossi, Marinangeli, Butti, et al. found that OCPD was the most common personality disorder among participants with depression. (“Personality Disorders in Bipolar and Depressive Disorders,” Journal of Affective Disorders)

Source: "Introduction to Radically Open Dialectical Behavior Therapy," video from Florida CBT Association

Research indicates that about half of people with OCPD experience depression during their lifetime. ("Good Psychiatric Management for Obsessive-Compulsive Personality Disorder," Ellen Finch, et al.)

Gary Trosclair, an OCPD specialist, reports that people with OCPD are more likely to have 'high functioning' depression.

In Cognitive Therapy of the Personality Disorders (2004), Aaron Beck and colleagues explain, “Due to their rigidity, perfectionism, and strong need to be in control of themselves, their emotions, and their environment, compulsives are very vulnerable to becoming overwhelmed, hopeless, and depressed. This may happen when they experience their lives as having gotten out of control and their usual coping mechanisms as being ineffective.” (321)

SUICIDALITY AND OCPD

The DSM notes that 2.1-7.9% of the population has OCPD. Studies suggest that about 23% of hospitalized psychiatric clients have OCPD. About 30-40% of people with PDs (in all categories) experience suicidal ideation during their lifetime. 

The ‘black and white’ thinking associated with OCPD contributes to suicide risk. People in imminent danger of ending their lives experience tunnel vision, and see suicide as the only way to escape their pain.

TREATMENT

I researched suicide awareness and prevention for two years. Suicide Awareness includes information on finding mental health providers. Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT) is a common treatment for chronic suicidal ideation. The therapist who created DBT recovered from BPD and suicidality.

Finding Mental Health Providers has information on studies that show the effectiveness of therapy for perfectionism and OCPD.

RESOURCES

Perfectionism and Depression

If you want to hear more stories about recovery from suicidality, check out the Suicide Noted and Before You Kill Yourself podcasts.


r/OCPDPerfectionism • • Dec 05 '25

offering resource/support What grade do you give the DSM Criteria? How could it be revised? How do you define your OCPD?

7 Upvotes

Some providers choose to refrain from giving personality disorder diagnoses because of the stigma and hopelessness they can invoke, and because they can make the client defensive and/or disinterested in continuing therapy. Some providers build up a solid rapport with the client before giving the diagnosis, and explain that PDs are not a life sentence. Members of this group have disclosed that they reviewed their files and saw OCPD diagnoses that their providers did not disclose.

LIMITATIONS OF THE DSM

I love this comment from a therapist in another subreddit: The DSM is “designed for researchers first and foremost...a lot of clinically relevant content is left out of the criteria…The overarching goal is to standardized diagnostic language as to allow researchers to communicate their research more efficiently and accurately to each other. As much as there are patterns in human psychology to be found, treatment is going to be highly individualized to the person seeking services- a lot of factors such as environmental context, genetics, lived experiences, etc. defy standardization.”

A member of the Avoidant PD subreddit commented that their psychologist “tends to view the DSM-5 as unhelpful...Many therapists trained in experiential therapies don’t focus on assigning DSM labels they’re more concerned with the emotional patterns and underlying dynamics than fitting someone into a diagnostic box. A lot of psychs are very reluctant to diagnose PDs.”

Self-Diagnosis

The DSM is a quick reference tool for providers. Its value for the general public has limitations. It has 265 disorders. Different disorders can cause the same symptom; providers are trained in differential diagnosis. Ideally, clinicians diagnose PDs after a thorough process that ‘rules out’ other disorders. People with a variety of disorders can have a strong need to gain a sense of control, especially when they're overwhelmed by untreated disorders.

See my reply to this post for the DSM-5 diagnostic criteria for OCPD.

SUBREDDIT MEMBERS DEFINE THEIR OCPD

Where Has Your OCPD Originated From? What Is The Force Driving It?

One member of this group stated, “For me, the ‘label’ serves as a categorization to point me towards my tribe and towards the healing tools I might find helpful.” I have the same view.

Another member shared, "I see OCPD as a trait and mindset that we with OCPD grasp onto in order to build a sense of safety and control. We don't feel safe, we don't like the discomforting feelings in our body that we get when things aren't going to plan or if we don't have a well thought out plan -- because it feels like everything is going to explode into chaos that we can't handle or recover from.

"We are productive, creative, and efficient. But it's all in the name of...staying safe, staying in control to not feel disappointed, shame, guilt, fear, or uncertainty. It's exhausting and filled with extreme anxiety which results in us being irritable and harsh at times... Because it feels like everyone and the world is against us, when really it's us trying to make the world conform to our idea of safety and perfection.

"The reality is we need to focus on building a sense of safety, accepting and embracing chaos and imperfection .. life is so much happier when you go with the flow and look out for the small pleasures... but for OCPD that's scarey to do, it feels dangerous, it feels impossible.. but with the right support and a lot of work, it is possible."

MY OPINION

I would revise the DSM criteria by renaming OCPD Maladaptive Perfectionism Disorder and note that it's distinct from OCD. I would state that the population of people with OCPD is more heterogenous than the other PD populations. OCPD can manifest in many ways (e.g. high and low productivity, no preoccupation with organization to debilitating level of preoccupation, presenting as reserved people pleaser to expressing extreme anger). Stereotypes lead to underdiagnosis.

The most important change...Why did they use a numbered list?! That's just cruel. We love to do lists. We have a strong drive for completion. If we can't check everything off, something is amiss. I think it's common for people to doubt that they have OCPD because they don't have all 8 symptoms.

THE OCPD ICEBERG

I view OCPD as a category of maladaptive coping strategies, not a permanent defect. These are my opinions, inspired by the ADHD graphic shown in my reply:

How other people may view someone with untreated OCPD:

1.      always judging others

2.      rigid, aloof

3.      lack of empathy, disinterested in relationships

4.      obsessed with work

5.      egotistical

Aspects of OCPD that may be more difficult for others to recognize:

1.      always judging oneself harshly (guilt complex)

2.      traumatized, hypervigilant, fearful, ashamed, anxious, depressed

3.      strong duty to serve others that feels overwhelming, scared of intimacy

4.      imposter syndrome

5.      insecure, self-esteem contingent on achievement

CLINICIANS' VIEWS

Resources For Learning How to Manage Obsessive Compulsive Personality Traits - Anthony Pinto, Gary Trosclair, Allan Mallinger, and Megan Neff have shared excellent descriptions of OCPD.

What do you think of the OCPD diagnostic criteria? How do you define your OCPD?


r/OCPDPerfectionism • • Oct 12 '25

Resources for Family Members of People with OCPD Traits

7 Upvotes

I used to have an OCPD diagnosis. After working with a therapist, I no longer meet the diagnostic criteria. The type of therapy that helped me the most was trauma therapy. My father and sister have OCPD traits.

The FamilyWithOCPDAdvice subReddit has resource posts for loved ones.

This post is most helpful for partners of people with OCPD traits. Here are Resources For Parents of Perfectionistic Children.

ABUSE

Sub Is Not Intended For Domestic Violence Survivors- DV Resources

Is My Partner Abusive?

THERAPY

Descriptions of OCPD From Specialists

Finding Mental Health Providers With PD Experience has information about 18 studies showing the effectiveness of therapy for clinical perfectionism and OCPD.

If you plan on providing information about perfectionism to your partner, I recommend that you consider The Perfectionist's Handbook (2011). Sharing the books that focus on OCPD will likely provoke defensiveness.

Secure Love (2024) by Julie Menanno includes scripts for encouraging a partner to consult a therapist.

Advice from The American Psychiatric Association: Individuals with personality disorders are usually aware that their life is not going well. Approaching a friend about their painful feelings or the frustrations and disappointments in their life, and offering to listen, might be a way to help them consider treatment. If you have had a successful experience in therapy, share that with your friend...Most people with personality disorders enter treatment with another problem, such as depression, anxiety, substance use, a job loss, a romantic break-up, etc. The challenge is to get your friend [or loved one] “in the door,” so to speak, not to commit to long-term treatment at the beginning.

PODCASTS

Gary Trosclair's The Healthy Compulsive Project Podcast has a wealth of information. Gary has worked as a therapist for more than 35 years, and specializes in OCPD. Episodes that are relevant to romantic relationships: 74, 72, 81, 69, 33, 4, 9, 14, 43, 46, and 47. Episodes 44 and 91 are about parents with Type A personalities.

Dr. Anthony Pinto is the leading OCPD specialist. His interviews about OCPD on "The OCD Family Podcast": S1E18: Part V, S2E69, S3E117, S4E154. The last interview includes one of his therapy clients, and the client's wife.

Dr. Tom Murray has a podcast about intimacy for perfectionists: Making Nice With Naughty

ARTICLES

The OCPD subReddit has more than 90 resource posts; they are duplicated in the OCPDPerfectionism subReddit.

Does Your Partner Have OCPD? | Psychology Today

GoodTherapy | How to Improve a Relationship with a Partner Who Has OCPD

OCPD & Relationships: Making the Most of a Challenging Situation

Perfectionist Partners and Moral Gaslighting

How to Get Along with a Partner with OCPD

What, Exactly, Do They Want From You? Demand Sensitivity

Exposing The Myths About OCPD

Are You in Love With a Controlling Perfectionist? | Psychology Today

I highly recommend Dr. Allan Mallinger’s Substack. He has 50 years of experience with clients who have OCPD.

VIDEOS

Mental Health Providers Talk About OCPD

Darren Magee:

Signs of a partner with OCPD

Darryl Rossignal (a man with OCPD who started the OCPD Foundation): 

What do I do if my partner has OCPD?

Can you find happiness living with someone with OCPD?

Question and Answer (3 minutes in)

Eden V. (a woman with OCPD): 

10 Ways to Talk to Someone with OCPD

OCPD and Our Insatiable Need to Control Everything

BOOKS

The Perfectionist's Handbook (2011): Jeff Szymanski, the former Director of the OCD Foundation, offers insights and strategies for reflecting on adaptive and maladaptive perfectionism. He draws on his experience providing group therapy for perfectionism.

Too Perfect (1996, 3rd ed.): Dr. Allan Mallinger, a psychiatrist and therapist specializing in OCPD, shares insights, advice, and case studies. He wrote a chapter about relating to a loved one with OCPD. The Spanish edition is La Obsesión Del Perfeccionismo (2010). Available with a free trial of Amazon Audible.

The Healthy Compulsive (2022, 2nd ed.): Gary Trosclair, a therapist with more than 30 years experience, shares his insights, advice, and case studies. He wrote a chapter for people who have loved ones with OCPD.

Chained to the Desk (2014, 3rd ed.): Bryan Robinson is a therapist who specializes in work addiction and a recovering workaholic. This book is useful for anyone struggling with work-life balance, although many of the case studies focus on extreme workaholism. Chapters 6 and 7 are about the partners and children of workaholics.

Please Understand Me (1998): David Keirsey, a school psychologist, shares theories on how personality types develop and impact perceptions, habits, relationships, school, and work experiences. The Rational Mastermind (INTJ) profile and a few others reference many OCPD traits.

Neglect's Toll on a Wife: Perfection's Grip on My Husband's Attention (2023): Lila Meadowbrook reflects on her relationship with her husband.

The Finicky Husband and His Obsessive Compulsive Personality Disorder (2017): Sammy Hill wrote a 23 page Kindle book about her relationship with her husband.

Women With Controlling Partners (2021, 2nd ed): Carol Lambert offers insights and advice, based on her experience of leading a therapy group for women with controlling partners for 20 years.

If You Had Controlling Parents (1999), Dan Neuharth, PhD, a family therapist, offers insights and advice to adults who had parents that exhibited controlling behavior.

Controlling People (2003): Communications expert Patricia Evans offers advice on verbally abusive relationships. Her website is verbalabuse.com. She has published four other books.

Impossible to Please (2012): Psychologists Neil Lavender and Ian Cavaiola wrote a short book giving advice on interacting with perfectionists who have a strong need for control.

Perfectly Hidden Depression (2019): Dr. Margaret Robinson Rutherford shares her insights from working with therapy clients with perfectionism and high functioning depression.

PARENTING

19 Tips for Compulsive Parents

Type A Parenting: 5 Unintended Effects

CO-MORBID NARCISSISTIC PD

Darren Magee explains that people with OCPD “tend to hold themselves to the same, if not higher standards than others. Many of their behaviors are driven by a need for perfection, routine, and structure, whereas narcissistic people are often driven by a diluted sense of superiority and entitlement.”

He notes that "a partner with OCPD may create tension by enforcing rigid rules, criticizing imperfections, or prioritizing tasks over emotional connection and intimacy. So, the partner might feel controlled and undervalued. But the rigidity in the thinking and the behaviors again stems from anxiety around chaos and imperfection rather than from a desire to dominate. A narcissistic partner, however, will undermine the partner's self-esteem through manipulation and belittling them just so that they can feel superior.” 

Studies indicate that about 16% of people with OCPD also have NPD.

Narcissism vs. Obsessive-Compulsive Personality Disorder Explained

OCPD and Narcissistic Relationship

Obsessive Compulsive Personality Disorder Vs Narcissism

Differences Between Narcissistic Personality and OCPD

Top 100 Traits & Behaviors — Out of the FOG | Personality Disorders, Narcissism, NPD, BPD

OTHER CO-MORBID CONDITIONS

Research findings: Common Co-Morbid Conditions. OCD and Autism can look similar to OCPD. Misdiagnosis is common. Studies indicate that about 24% of people with OCPD also have BPD. Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD) has resources for loved ones.

ATTACHMENT STYLES

The Avoidant Attachment Style is most common in people with OCPD.

Dismissive Avoidants: FAQ From Loved Ones

Resources For Improving Romantic Relationships (videos by Heidi Priebe)

Does Avoidant Attachment Cause Obsessive-Compulsive Personality Disorder?

BOOKS ON ROMANTIC RELATIONSHIPS

The Seven Principles for Making Marriage Work (2015): John Gottman offers advice on improving communication and intimacy, and resolving conflicts. Dr. Gottman is a leading research psychologist on romantic and family relationships.

Fight Right: How Successful Couples Turn Conflict Into Connection (2024): John Gottman and Julie Schwartz Gottman describe common mistakes that couples make during conflict, and strategies to use conflicts for building stronger relationships.

Boundaries (2017): Clinical psychologists Henry Cloud and John Townsend wrote this groundbreaking book about setting healthy boundaries. Other books in this series include Boundaries in Dating (2009) and Boundaries in Marriage (2009).

I have an acquaintance with OCPD who recommends:

Secure Love (2024): Julie Menanno, a couple’s therapist, explains how attachment styles impact romantic relationships. She explains that couples who are aware of their attachment needs and how to fulfill them in healthy ways can avoid having the “same fight” over and over. She offers suggested scripts for difficult conversations, and other strategies for maintaining respect and connection during disagreements.

Hold Me Tight (2008): Sue Johnson, the therapist who developed Emotionally Focused Couple Therapy (EFCT), helps couples learn how to be “open, attuned, and responsive to each other and to reestablish emotional connection.” She offers stories from her practice, advice, and practical exercises.

THERAPY GROUP

Carol Lambert has led short-term therapy groups for women with controlling partners for more than 20 years. Services - Carol A. Lambert, MSW, LICSW

DIVORCE

This is a presentation from Beth Wilner, a clinical psychologist and divorce mediator, and Kara Anast, a clinical psychologist who has worked with clients with PDs, and performs child custody evaluations: How Parental Personality Disorders Impact Parenting/Coparenting. The PDs they discuss are Borderline, Antisocial, Narcissistic, Histrionic, and Paranoid. These are the books they recommend to clients:

Susan Boyan, Anne Marie Termini- The Co-Parent’s Communication Handbook (2017), Cooperative Parenting and Divorce (2003)

Bill Eddy- Don’t Alienate The Kids (2020), Splitting (2021), BIFF For Co-Parent Communication (2020), High Conflict People in Legal Disputes (2016)

The Parallel Parenting Solution (2021), Carl Knickerbocker

This organization offers coaching services: High-Conflict Co-Parenting Support, Conflict Influencer | High-Conflict Situation Support

The Circles App offers audio-only support groups for abusive relationships, breakups, and divorce. Groups take place daily. Pricing starts at $30 monthly after a seven-day free trial.

ADVICE

I think it’s best to take some time to learn about OCPD, and consult with a therapist, before attempting an intervention for a loved one who may have OCPD. I agree with this advice from a LovedByOCPD member:

-You need to get a therapist for yourself as soon as you can. Everything changed for me when I knew I had someone in my corner who understood and validated me. [I would add, find a therapist for your children].

-Journal these incidents in detail before you act. I found this immensely helpful for me to look at things objectively and see that it was not all my fault. Also good to have a record of things to avoid gaslighting if that’s happening. Make sure your records are honest and include the bits where you messed up as well, you grow that way.

-Make a deal with yourself that you will STOP apologising for things that are not your fault to keep the peace. This is hard, because it means you can’t make the conflict go away quickly, but things will NOT improve ever if you keep doing this.

-Learn to be okay with your partner’s being disregulated. That is their issue not yours. Have a plan for what you can do to self-soothe or protect yourself. Can you leave the room/house, go for a walk with the dog, get a coffee etc. If it goes on for a long time you will need a longer strategy.

-Have scripted responses in your pocket to respond to attacks and attempts to draw you in or elicit an apology. This is why journaling is good because you already have an objective understanding of why you don’t need to apologise. Eg ‘I am not going to be yelled at about X, if you keep yelling I will Y’. ‘I don’t see it that way, I’m happy to have a conversation about it when you are calmer.’ ‘I understand that you think (reflect what they said), but I don’t agree that that’s how it was.’

-Know that you can’t fix this person, be prepared to leave, you are not obligated in any way to put up with abuse. Don’t go to couples counselling IMO, unless they are in a place where they admit they are controlling and are doing their own work. YOU CAN LEAVE THEM. But you will need to address your own boundary issues regardless, otherwise you could end up back in the same position with another controller.


r/OCPDPerfectionism • • Sep 28 '25

offering resource/support Types of Perfectionism

7 Upvotes

MALADAPTIVE AND ADAPTIVE PERFECTIONISM

In The Anxious Perfectionist (2022), Clarissa Ong and Michael Twohig explain that maladaptive perfectionism is “characterized by self-criticism, rigid pursuit of unrealistically high standards, distress when standards are not met, and dissatisfaction even when standards are met." (18)

"Adaptive perfectionism is a pattern of striving for achievement that is perceived as rewarding or meaningful.” (18)

“In adaptive perfectionism, the motivation is typically to approach a desired consequence…whereas in maladaptive perfectionism, the motivation is to avoid or escape an undesirable consequence…Generally, adaptive perfectionism is about seeking achievement that is experienced as fulfilling, whereas maladaptive perfectionism is about avoiding failure.” (19)

In Challenging Perfectionism (2021), Dawn Starley explains:

-“High expectations and aspirations are helpful until they are combined with a low tolerance for failure and mistakes.

-Attention to detail is helpful until it is combined with an inability or refusal to see the bigger picture.

-Determination to succeed is helpful until it is combined with an inability to relax and unwind.

-Being able to put aside emotion to get a task done is helpful until it is combined with not allowing emotions to be felt at all.

-Valuing achievement is helpful until it is combined with having no other areas of value or interest to balance this out.” (96-7)

In the video "Understanding The Psychology of Perfectionism," Chris Williamson offers this distinction for healthy and unhealthy perfectionism: When things go well, do you feel happy or do you feel the abatement of fear? Do you feel joy or relief?

In “The Myth of Perfection,” Dr. Allan Mallinger explains that the perfectionism of people with OCPD is different from a “healthy desire to excel…that is under conscious control and can be modulated or turned on and off as desired. People who appropriately exercise perfectionistic behavior realize that in performing eye surgery, for example, it is crucial to avoid errors, but not in choosing a tie, preparing dinner for friends, or deciding upon the best route for a vacation trip.

People who have a healthy desire to excel are "flexible enough to adjust their investment of time, energy and emotions accordingly. At times, they might pursue excellence as vigorously as do [people with OCPD], but they are not as easily crushed by [minor failures and] their self-esteem does not plummet when they are criticized or make a mistake, or when they make a decision that turns out poorly. Nor are they as likely to explain, rationalize, or defend their errors.” (106)

For people with untreated OCPD, perfectionism “impacts a wide range of one's endeavors and experiences, from work to relationships to leisure time pursuits…the person cannot vary it appropriately or turn it off [and] generally cannot maintain a degree of flexibility or a perspective sufficient to enjoy many of their activities...In any endeavor, ability, or personal attribute they deem important, they are driven to avoid errors, criticism, poor choices, or a second-place finish…” (106)

THREE TYPES OF MALADAPTIVE PERFECTIONISM

In When Perfect Isn't Good Enough: Strategies for Coping with Perfectionism (2009), Martin Antony and Richard Swinson explain the three basic types of maladaptive perfectionism:

“Self-oriented perfectionism is a tendency to have standards for yourself that are unrealistically high and impossible to attain. These standards are self-imposed and tend to be associated with self-criticism and an inability to accept your own mistakes and faults.” (11)

“Other-oriented perfectionism is a tendency to demand that others meet your unrealistically high standards. People who are other-oriented perfectionists are often unable to delegate tasks to others for fear of being disappointed by a less-than-perfect performance of the job.” (11)

“Socially prescribed perfectionism is a tendency to assume that others have expectations of you that are impossible to meet. Socially prescribed perfectionists also believe that to gain approval from others, these high standards must be met…” (11)

What types of perfectionism do you struggle with?


r/OCPDPerfectionism • • Sep 27 '25

offering resource/support Genetic and Environmental Factors That Cause OCPD

7 Upvotes

GENETIC FACTORS

Studies of identical twins who were raised in different homes and studies involving brain scans of people with OCPD indicate that there is a collection of genes that predispose people for OCPD traits.

In The Healthy Compulsive (2020), Gary Trosclair lists the “character traits that research indicates are at least partially inborn:

·        A capacity to imagine the future, predict, control, plan, and engage in goal-directed behavior

·        A greater than normal capacity to perceive details

·        A tendency to be pressured, hard-driving, and ambitious

·        A tendency to be perfectionistic

·        A capacity for self-restraint

·        A capacity for grit, determination, and perseverance

·        A motivation to master skills and problems

·        Conscientiousness

·        Prudence (including frugality, cautiousness, carefulness, discretion moderation, and being prepared)

·        Moral indignation; criticizing others for laziness or stinginess

These genes serve a purpose. Nature is happy to have some of us evolve with a compulsive style to improve our chances of surviving and spreading our genes. Thinking ahead and being careful have kept us alive—though rather anxious…being driven has helped humans to endure…” (28-29)

Trosclair theorizes that “the genetic components of OCPD helped us to adapt and survive as we were evolving.  Being meticulous, detailed, reliable, driven, determined and conscientious planners helped us procure food, protect our young, and get along in a tribe of 75 people. These traits made it more likely that these genes were passed down." ("Compulsive Personality: A New and Positive Perspective")

“The human capacity for vigilance, analytical thinking, careful planning, and preventive action has served our survival and evolution. And, especially in so-called developed, hi-tech countries, people who can think carefully, analyze information and predict outcomes often seem to have an advantage in school and in many of today’s careers. So a solid streak of obsessiveness in our psychological makeup is a good thing to have.” Autonomy and Rigid Character (1981), David Shapiro

ENVIRONMENTAL FACTORS

In The Healthy Compulsive, Trosclair states that his clients with OCPD often report these perceptions of their childhoods:  

“1. You experienced your parents as rigid and critical, or shaming of behavior that was messy or playful. If there was love or affection, it felt conditional, based on compliance: how ‘well’ you behaved or how much you achieved.

2. It seemed that your parents disapproved of any strong feelings you might have had, including anger, sadness, fear, or exuberance,

3. You experienced your parents as intrusive. They may have been so affectionate, hovering, or smothering that you feared losing yourself in enmeshed relationships. Your need for privacy and independence was not recognized.

4. Your household felt chronically chaotic…leaving you feeling powerless and helpless.

5. You perceived your parents’ overprotectiveness as an indication that the world is a dangerous place.

6. You perceived your parents as anxious and needy. This could have been because their insecurity was extreme, or because you were especially sensitive to their condition. In either case you felt you needed to attend to their needs to the exclusion of your own.

7. Your early relationships felt disappointing, and you felt that you couldn’t depend on others for security.

8. Your parents did not provide clear standards, leaving you to develop them for yourself before you were ready to…” (30-31)

“Notice that I speak of your experience of your parents, not historical facts. We’ll never know exactly what they were like as parents, and children don’t always perceive or remember their parents accurately. Yet still, your experience of your parents is very real…and that has played a role in the development of your personality.” (31)

“Children will find a way to grow and survive psychologically, bending and twisting their personalities however they need to in order to adapt to their situation.” (33)

Perfectionism and Trauma

Trosclair theorizes that children with driven personalities who have insecure attachments with their caregivers “use their talents to compensate for the feelings that they [are] unworthy or unloved.” This habit may continue in adulthood because “When all you’ve got is a hammer, everything looks like a nail.” (34)

Insecure children with OCPs “use their natural energy and diligence to give their parents and culture what they seem to want from them, [and then resent] having to be so good. Their resentment leads them to feel more insecure because they aren’t supposed to be angry. Then they try to compensate for their transgression with more compliance, which leads to more angry resentment, and so on.” (34)

From Allan Mallinger's Too Perfect (1992): “The child destined to become a perfectionist views perfectionism as the only fail-safe way to ensure that he won’t be vulnerable to such dangers as criticism, embarrassment, anger, or the withdrawal of love by his parents and others.” (38)

Trauma and Personality Disorders 

CHANNELING THE DRIVE

In The Healthy Compulsive (2020), Gary Trosclair explains, “If you have a driven personality, you know and value what it means to work hard—but [working on OCPD traits] will be a very different form of hard work for you. You will need to harness your natural energy and direct it more consciously, not so much with the brute force of putting your nose to the grindstone, but rather in a more subtle way, using that energy to stop relying exclusively on productivity and perfection, and instead venturing heroically into other activities...” (9)

“The problem for unhealthy compulsives is not that they respond to an irresistible urge, rather they’ve lost sight of the original meaning and purpose of that urge. The energy from the urge, whether it be to express, connect, create, organize, or perfect, may be used to distract themselves, to avoid disturbing feelings, or to please an external authority…Many compulsives have a strong sense of how the world should be. Their rules arise out of their concerns for the well-being of themselves and others. Yet that same humanistic urge often turns against others when the compulsive person becomes judgmental and punishing, losing track of the original motivation: the desire for everyone to be safe and happy.” (7)

“There is a reason that some of us are compulsive. Nature ‘wants’ to grow and expand so that it can adapt and thrive, and it needs different sorts of people to do that…People who are driven have an important place in this world.…Nature has given us this drive; how will we use it? Finding that role and living it consciously solves the riddle…[of] what are these compulsive urges for? Finding and living our unique, individual role, no matter how small or insignificant it seems, is the most healing action we can take.” (179)

“Genes are not fate and whether you become a healthy or unhealthy compulsive is up to you. These genes create tendencies that we can cultivate and enlist in healthy or unhealthy ways. Someone who is energetic, ambitious and determined may use her strength for leadership and the good of the tribe, and therefore for her own good as well. Or she may use her traits to amass power and sow discontent. Same genes, very different outcome. In order to be happy, you’ll need to figure out just what your adaptive traits are and how best to use them…There are potential gifts in the compulsive personality. What will you do with them?” ("Compulsive Personality: A New and Positive Perspective," Gary Trosclair)

Episode 31 of The Healthy Compulsive Project Podcast is about the causes of OCPD.

Gary Trosclair has worked as a Jungian analyst and psychotherapist for 35 years. He specializes in OCPD. He is the author of The Healthy Compulsive book, blog, and podcast.

What do you think caused your OCPD?


r/OCPDPerfectionism • • 20d ago

The DSM VI Could Make A Difference For People with OCD and OCPD

6 Upvotes

I just finished Jeffrey Lieberman's book about the history of psychiatry. He's a former Head of the American Psychiatric Association, the organization that publishes The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM V)--the reference book for mental health providers in the U.S.

Dr. Lieberman wrote about the seven year process of revising the DSM for the 5th edition, published in 2013. Patient advocacy groups used the internet to lobby for the process to be more transparent to the general public. See the reply for the current diagnostic criteria.

I will look into how to advocate for changes to the OCPD criteria. What grade do you give the DSM Criteria?

NAME CHANGE

The name of OCPD needs to be changed to distinguish it from OCD. Misdiagnosis is a major issue, and clinical obsessions are not a symptom of OCPD.

HOARDING

Hoarding is not a common trait of people with OCPD. Because people tend to question their OCPD diagnosis when they don't have all eight symptoms, I think hoarding should be removed.

People with OCPD could have a co-morbid diagnosis of hoarding disorder.

DIMENSIONAL VIEW

Changing from the categorical view of personality disorders to the dimensional view would be an excellent update but it's probably a long shot. I think this issue was debated and voted down for the DSM V. Debate About Personality Disorders Among Professionals

EXCESSIVE DOUBT AND CAUTION

Outside the U.S., mental health providers often use the International Classification of Diseases (ICD-10). The ICD lists "excessive doubt and caution" as a symptom of OCPD (called Anankastic Personality Disorder).

Excessive doubt and caution is a common characteristic of people with OCPD. Dr. Megan Neff believes that the core feature of OCPD is “an ever-looming sense of impending failure, where individuals constantly anticipate things going wrong, a flaw being exposed, or a profound loss of control. [It causes frequent] self-doubt, doubt of others, and doubt of the world at large..."

DEMAND-SENSITIVITY AND DEMAND-RESISTANCE

Demand-sensitivity and demand-resistance could be listed as a new symptom. In Too Perfect (1992), Dr. Allan Mallinger observes that OCPD causes a “special sensitivity to perceived demands or expectations…[Many of my clients are] sensitive to demands, either real or imagined…[and have a] tendency to ‘hear’ demands or expectations in an exaggerated way...[They are often very] attuned to unstated obligations hearing them as if they were shouted through a bullhorn...

"Demand-resistance is a chronic and automatic negative inner response to the perception of pressure, expectations, or demands (from within or without).”

Dr. Mallinger has provided therapy to people with OCPD for 50 years; he created the terms demand-sensitivity and demand-resistance after observing these issues in many clients with OCPD.

What changes to the OCPD criteria would you like to see in the sixth edition of the DSM?


r/OCPDPerfectionism • • May 31 '26

OCPD, Perfectionism and Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD)

6 Upvotes

Studies indicate that about 25% of people with OCPD also have BPD.

People with BPD have the highest rate of childhood trauma, compared to people with other PDs. One study found an average of 14 years of physical and/or sexual abuse.

ARTICLES

Perfectionism in Borderline Personality Disorder | Psychology Today

Borderline Personality Disorder and Perfectionism | HealthyPlace

Understanding Perfectionism in Borderline Personality Disorder

VIDEOS FROM MENTAL HEALTH PROVIDERS

BPD and The Fallacy that Perfect = Safety

Obsessions, BPD, and OCPD

How Childhood Criticism Shapes Self-Esteem & Mental Health

RO-DBT: Addressing Perfectionism, Emotional Loneliness, and "Quiet" BPD

VIDEOS FROM WOMEN WITH BPD

BPD Perfectionism

Perfection in My Borderline Personality Disorder

LEADING SPECIALIST

After receiving inpatient psychiatric treatment as a teenager, Marsha Linehan overcame BPD and suicidality. She became a therapist and developed Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT), the gold standard treatment for BPD.

Should Thinking

In The Cognitive-Behavioral Treatment of Borderline Personality Disorder (1993), Linehan notes that her patients often have “invalidating” families of origin. When they engage in ‘should’ thinking, they are—in a sense—re enacting their traumatic upbringing. (237)

People with BPD “often express extreme anger, guilt, or disappointment in themselves because they have behaved in ways that they find unacceptable. Almost without exception, such feelings will be based on some belief system that they ‘should not’ have acted in the manner they did, or that they ‘should’ have acted differently. In other words, these patients place unrealistic demands upon themselves…” (237)

“The use of magical ‘shoulds’ by a borderline individual is one of the most important factors interfering with behavioral shaping. Believing that she should be different already prohibits the patient from putting together a realistic plan to bring about desired changes.” (237)

Small Goals

Linehan encourages her clients to let go of the “belief that people change complex behavior patterns in a heroic show of willpower,” because this “sets the stage for an accelerating cycle of failure of self-condemnation” (152).

She explains that “Borderline patients typically believe that nothing short of perfection is an acceptable outcome” (152). Over time, her clients learn to ‘think small’ and accumulate small achievements.

Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD) Resources (e.g. therapist directories)


r/OCPDPerfectionism • • Apr 16 '26

offering resource/support Recognizing Cognitive Distortions Breaks the Cycle of Maladaptive Perfectionism

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

“The lens of perfectionism colors everything you see, which makes it difficult to conceive of a space free from its influence…it’s critical to get a good look at the very lens through which you’ve been experiencing the world.” (17)

The Anxious Perfectionist (2022), Clarissa Ong and Michael Twohig

Being unaware of my OCPD symptoms was like wearing dark glasses all the time, and never realizing that my view of myself, others, and the world was distorted.

Maintaining self-awareness was half the battle in learning how to manage OCPD. That gave me the opportunity to develop healthier habits.

Questions for Challenging Perfectionist Thinking

-Is this situation really as important as it feels?

-What if this situation doesn’t go my way? Does it really matter?

-Do I need to control this situation?

-Is my way the only way to view this situation?

-Would another person necessarily see this situation the same way I do?

-Do I know for sure that things will turn out badly if I don’t get my way?

The CBT Workbook For Perfectionism (2019), Sharon Martin, 217-18

*

How do I know if this thought is accurate?

What evidence do I have to support this thought or belief?...

-Is this thought helpful?

-Are there other ways that I can think of this situation or myself?

-Am I overgeneralizing?

-Am I making assumptions?...

-Can I look for shades of gray?

-Am I assuming the worst?

-Am I holding myself to an unreasonable or double standard?

-Are these exceptions to these absolutes (always, never)?

-Am I making this personal when it isn’t?

-Is this a realistic expectation?

-Am I expecting myself to be perfect?

When Perfect Isn’t Good Enough (2009), Martin Antony, Richard Swinson, 191

Recognizing and Talking Back to Cognitive Distortions

When I was diagnosed with OCPD, I started to pay attention whenever I thought:

-I’m just not good at...

-I’ve always had a hard time...

-I just don’t know how to…

-I don’t believe in…

-I hate/ I’ve never liked…

-I just don’t/ I always/never…

-I don’t like/trust people who…

-I just don’t get why people...

-People who…are strange.

I found it helpful to ‘talk back’ to negative thoughts (as soon as possible when they arise) with certain phrases. When I was by myself, I sometimes said them out loud: big picture (when I’m lost in details), overthinking, ruminating, not important, pure speculation, not urgent, slow down, good enough, and move on. I used an assertive tone, not a harsh tone.

When I recognize that I’m ruminating on a trivial issue, I exaggerate my thoughts and say phrases like devastating, disaster, tragedy, life-or-death decision, life changing decision, emergency, and this is critical. "This is the greatest injustice in the history of the world" is one my favorites. The rebuttal "I know you are, but what am I?" (talking back to OCPD) is a fun one.

For about seven months, I habitually framed upsetting thoughts with, “I’m having the thought….,” “I think…,” and “I’m feeling…right now,” and “I’m thinking…right now.” This is a reminder that feelings are not facts and that they won’t last forever.

This strategy helps even when my self-talk is harsh. There’s a difference between thinking “I am stupid” vs. “I think I’m stupid,” “I’m having the thought ‘I’m stupid’,” and “I’m feeling stupid right now.” The framing makes it easier to stop ruminating.

I try to reframe "I should" thoughts into "I would prefer to" or "I could."

I knew about cognitive distortions many years before I learned about OCPD because I was a psychology major. Saying phrases in respond to distortions made a huge difference.

It's helpful for me to identify what feelings are contributing to self-critical and ruminating thoughts. Identifying and Responding to Feelings  

Resources

Cognitive Distortions: Part 1

Cognitive Flexibility: 'Two Things Can Be True' Concept

This sub has reached 600 members. Please upvote posts you find interesting or helpful.