I recently had stumbled on Wikipedia’s page on neurodiversity.
I wanna say that I absolutely support neurodivergence — which is what I would use to describe neurocognitive differences that could be embraced as alternative patterns of thinking instead of seen as problems or pathologies because of rigid societal norms & lack of infrastructure. Essentially variations, and people with these often assert they don’t need to cure their differences. I quality for being neurodivergent, although I just identify as being pretty messed up outside of that
OCD, on the other hand, isn’t usually that. I mean, OCD is a leading cause of dysfunction, over half of victims become severe, impairing their ability to do things they’re otherwise fully capable of doing. Suicide rates are ~15% at least, & that isn’t typically because society doesn’t accept that my brain is telling me to stab myself with this fork.
An article for this idea says,
“Viewing obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) as a difference rather than a disorder aligns with the principles of neurodiversity. Neurodiversity recognises and respects variations in human cognition and behaviour as natural aspects of diversity rather than pathologising them.
Many health organisations propose a shift towards understanding OCD through a neurodiversity lens and not as a mental health condition. People with OCD may experience the world differently, and these differences can contribute to unique strengths and perspectives.” (Cited below)
Excuse me…? I do not want these unique strengths.
Yes, I can absolutely agree I have a unique perspective of knowing howto make a quarter-mile walk to class into an hour-long expedition so I could save my— oh darn, is that a scuff on this sidewalk? Gotta go and redo my steps AGAIN!
I mean, you could celebrate my strength of body since I somehow survived recent starvation when my brain decided food is dangerous— still, I would rather have a magic pill that just makes it go away.
So yeah for me I consider it a mental illness.
Articles mostly use these comparisons between autistic or ADHD behaviors & OCD, things like rigid ways of thinking or pattern recognition. But, that’s a little like saying “if an animal is a dog, it possesses four legs & my creepy quiet Uncle Phil also possesses four legs (two in ‘his basement), so he must be a dog too!”
I think the fact that it’s ego-dystonic also should imply that it isn’t “neurodivergence,” because it literally is antithetical to that person’s typical cognitive patterns. Also often the main underpinning of neurodiversity is that it usually is an innate structural or neurological difference in one’s brain, whereas OCD’s strongly associated with diathesis-stress model (genetic patterns activated by clinical stress) even if there obviously will be observable differences in brain function & activity.
I am not saying people shouldn’t accept those of us with OCD, or that it should be viewed as wrong by society. I do not disagree that a more open-minded, accepting approach to treatment would be helpful. Actually, I can even agree that I have unique experiences & neuroscience clearly shows differences in brain structure because of my OCD. Overall, I can also say, I think mental illness as a category often oversimplifies underlying causes of these disorders (often attributed purely to brain chemicals when it’s actually, finally, being seen as more complicated).
However, I can definitely assert that I don’t think it’s a part of me or should be embraced outside of trying to improve it — instead I view it as a monster bent on destroying things I enjoy & my typical patterns of thinking. That is not to mention enabling OCD, typically, doesn’t improve it
Also if you hadn’t ever heard OCD called that, I read these articles among others:
Article, Article, Article, Article, Article.
Edit: so the things I wanna add:
—I realize now that there’s lots of different perspectives & identification with neurodiversity, & I am super sorry that my assumptions that people would agree enabled me to write a post that didn’t seem considerate enough & used stupid humor
—I think the main stipulation I attempted to explain is that of activation vs neurodevelopmental processes being a starting point & of identification with one’s condition