Over the past few weeks I've been doing a lot of research on barnevernet, I've been reading tons of stories on why exactly it's a controversial topic in Norway specially for immigrants. I've been reading a lot of comments, takes and stories coming from both sides, meaning the people who have been affected by barnevernet and also Norwegians who defend the institution (either here on Reddit or on YouTube).
According to Norwegians as long as you don't beat your kid which includes spanking your kid, pulling their ears, locking them up in a room (etc), don't abuse alcohol, don't do drugs, don't neglect the child's health in any way (physically, mentally or hygienically), don't live in bad conditions that can affect your kid, don't sexually abuse your kid in any way, don't raise your voice at your kid etc, everything should be fine. I have no issue with any of that, in fact I agree with all of that, I agree those are justified reasons.
Now the reason why I'm still concerned about barnevernet is because after reading a lot of stories from people who lost custody of their kids some of those stories seem to be way too excessive, it's like they've lost their kids due to very minor inconveniences.
This is an example of what I'm talking about:
This is a little girl who admits on camera she was just angry at her parents and she completely made a lie and told the teachers something that wasn't true and just for that barnevernet took her away from her parents and now she's pleading in that video she wants her parents back and all of it was just a misunderstanding caused by herself, a little girl.
In fact if you read the first comment in that video it's a person who says they now the case closely and this is what they say regarding this specific case:
Björn Korf:
I know the family and I know the details of this case. But even more important: Norway's CPS takes children away for the most flimsy reasons, and every week families flee Norway in order to stay together. Last year a Norwegian mother and her child received political asylum in Poland. But back to the girl in the video: her lie was about a lunch. She said her mom didn't prepare lunch for her and she was hiding the lunch box in her school bag. So the school phoned the CPS, which is called "Barnevernet" in Norway. This is nothing unusual as in Norway professionals such as teachers, doctors, nurses ... etc. are being trained to contact Barnevernet immediately about any kind of slight suspicion (instead of talking with the parents first). So Barnevernet came to the family's house along with the police at 9 pm at night while the kids were already peacefully asleep, and they ripped these kids from their beds and placed them into foster care. The parents were put in jail for 24 hours immediately and they were interrogated for 3 hours afterwards. The first accusation was child mistreatment. The parents were threatened not to talk to anyone for about two weeks or otherwise they would get fined with a 2 year prison sentence. This behavior happens very often in Norway. But the police closed the case, saying that there is nothing wrong with the parents. However Barnevernet would not return the children. They are saying that the parents are not good enough and that the children don't have a proper routine at home, even though they haven't observed the family at home. They have no compelling reasons to keep the children, but instead of returning them home they have placed Brigita in an other foster home (that's where she has recorded the video). And now they're preparing the way for forced adoption, because the parents were now told that they can only see their kids 3x per year. Of course the parents can appeal against this, but this is usually quite a long procedure in Norway. And Barnevernet will then say that the children have already attached to their new care givers and that it would cause psychological damage to cut these new bonds. Apart from this case Norway was just found guilty by the High chamber of the European Court of Human Rights for violating Human Rights in an other child removal case which also included forced adoption. The court stated that the mother's and the children's rights were violated. And there are 26 other cases pending before the European court, which shows that Norway has a serious problem with their child welfare system. In fact it is totally dysfunctional. And many professional experts in Norway say that the Barnevernet system needs to be shut down completely and replaced by a system that actually works.
Is it possible to lose custody of your children just because they've lied like that girl admits in that video?
There are many other stories like that on Youtube, I won't link them here becase the post would be too long but you get the idea.
Not only that but Norway also has a lot of cases at the European Court of Human Rights and they've actually lost more than dozen child welfare cases before the Strasbourg court, here's a case Norway lost:
The Ladickych family
Maxine, the then-2-month-old daughter of Sara and Andrej Ladickych, was removed from her parents’ care by the Barnevernet in 2015. The authorities were suspicious the Slovak couple were neglecting the baby, citing Maxine's “minimal eye contact” with her parents during a series of in-home visits.
The Strasbourg-based rights court's Firth Section concluded that the restrictions were severe and would likely keep Maxine from being returned to her parents, effectively condemning her to grow up in foster care.
“Family reunification cannot normally be expected to be sufficiently supported if there are intervals of weeks, or even months, between each contact session,” the court wrote. It ordered Norway to pay the family 25,500 euros ($29,000) in compensation.
So barnevernet completely destroys this family and after taking away that girl from her parents now they can't give her back because a lot of time has passed, how do you even fix that? It's impossible, no money in the world will be able to fix that.
It feels the first thing they do is take away your child and instead of trying to fix the issue, instead of trying to teach you how to raise your kid properly or giving you another chance so you can fix your problems and the kid can be raised by their biological parents who will always love the kid and will give them unconditional love forever, they just take your child away from you and you don't even get another chance. In most countries they always try to help the parents to fix their issues so they can raise their kids but in Norway it's actually the opposite, they take away your kids and you don't ever get a second chance and as you see it leads to barnevernet/Norway making a lot mistakes and losing a lot of cases at the Strasbourg court.
Are my concerns valid? I'm not a troll, I'm genuinely concerned about this topic, what do you guys think?