r/Nok • • Jun 01 '26

Discussion Insider buying at NOK is not as bullish as it seems.

3 Upvotes

Apparently it’s very common in Finnish/European companies to require senior leadership to hold 200-300% of their salary as stock.

So the CEO/CDO buys were to fulfill this obligation. Sure, they didn’t have to but right now, at near ATH - but they were required to buy a large amount of stock open-market anyways.

From Claude:

“Nokia's investor relations website explicitly states: "The shareholding requirement for members of the Group Leadership Team is two times their annual base salary within five years from their appointment.

Executives on the GLT are subject to "the same remuneration policy framework as the President and CEO. This includes being subject to clawback and shareholding requirements" So it's not just the CEO who has structured share accumulation obligations — every member of the Group Leadership Team has a 2x base salary shareholding requirement to meet within five years.

Most of what looks like "insider buying" at Nokia is structurally-incentivized compensation accumulation rather than discretionary conviction. The one clean exception is the Board Chair's ~$532K April buy. The rest contributes signal but with significant caveats that the aggregate dollar figure doesn't capture.

Shareholding requirements are basically standard practice for CEOs and senior executives at large European companies.

Typical thresholds: • CEOs: 2-3x base salary (Nokia at 3x is at the higher end, but not unusual) • Other Executive Committee/Leadership Team members: 1.5-2x base salary • Time to achieve: typically 5 years from appointment

This is now expected practice across Finland (Finnish Corporate Governance Code 2025 references it), the UK (FRC Corporate Governance Code), Germany (DCGK), the Nordic countries broadly, France, Netherlands, and most other major European markets.”


r/Nok • • Jul 17 '26

Discussion Goodbye NOK, lesson learned.

8 Upvotes

It’s been a rough ride watching my position drop to $9.96. The reality of the price action, combined with the upcoming earnings volatility, convinced me it’s time to call it quits. Farewell to the $NOK gang


r/Nok • • Jun 14 '25

Discussion Is the Finnish mentality holding Nokia back?

1 Upvotes

Despite Nokia’s engineering excellence and its critical role in global infrastructure, the company has failed to deliver sustainable shareholder value over the past decade. One possible reason is the company’s largely Finnish culture and deeply Finnish leadership structure: 4 out of 10 board members are Finnish, as are both the Chair and Vice Chair. The largest shareholder is Solidium, a Finnish state-owned investment firm. This structure has brought stability but most likely at the cost of agility and ambition.

It’s worth asking: how much has the Finnish mentality, such as patience, modesty, consensus-seeking, and nostalgic pride in the “old Nokia”, contributed to Nokia’s chronic underperformance in the stock market?

A few telling examples:

  • Leadership wasn’t changed swiftly enough (the Suri case, in particular).

  • Nokia backed itself into a technological corner in the early 5G era, resulting in years of playing catch-up and the loss of Verizon as a RAN customer.

  • The Alcatel-Lucent integration was slow and extremely costly.

  • Analysts and shareholders were never offered a bold, growth-oriented vision.

If Nokia had moved its headquarters to the U.S. a decade ago and built an American-style Board while retaining the core of Finnish engineering skill and integrity, the company might be in a very different position today. A U.S.-centric Board would likely have:

  • Demanded and rewarded more ambitious execution;

  • Pushed for faster strategic moves to drive growth and profitability;

  • Attracted more international capital and top-tier talent;

  • Elevated Nokia’s valuation closer to that of American tech peers.

So the question is: despite its admirable qualities, is Finnish corporate culture poorly suited to the high-speed, high-pressure world of global tech? Can Nokia evolve from within, or does it need to grow out of Finland’s shadow to level up?

The answer isn't black and white. However, personally I believe excessive Finnish dominance is a burden. Nokia needs more American-style dynamism and a high-performance mindset. That’s why I’ve proposed a structural split of Nokia:

  • A company based on Network Infrastructure (NI): the faster-growing, more scalable division, with headquarters and listing in the U.S., to improve valuation and international visibility.

  • Another company based on Mobile Networks (MN): a slower-growth, R&D-intensive unit whose engineering talent could remain in Finland but even this company might benefit from U.S. relocation in order to elevate its market value.

Now the hope is that even in the absence of the most effective remedy, a structural split, the new American CEO, Justin Hotard, can overcome internal resistance and inject much-needed dynamism into Nokia. The Board must give him the mandate and freedom to do whatever it takes to finally break the cycle of chronic shareholder value destruction.

P.S. I'm a Finn myself but one not fearing to speak out. I have been invested in Nokia since 2012 and closely followed the numerous restructurings, strategic pivots and the painful shareholder value destruction.


r/Nok • • Nov 01 '25

Discussion Is Nokia’s structure blocking its AI upside?

0 Upvotes

Nokia’s Q3 2025 figures highlight a high-growth story buried inside the group. As the data center and AI infrastructure boom drives valuations sky-high, Network Infrastructure (NI) looks increasingly out of place within a slow-growth telco portfolio.

  • Optical Networks (ON): €782M, 29% AI and cloud customer exposure (14% for NI as a whole), growing 19% organically year on year

  • IP Networks (IPN): €578M, around 8% AI and cloud customer exposure but likely to rise as heavier R&D starts paying off

  • Fixed Networks (FN): €594M, mainly telco customers, steady mid-teens margins

For comparison, Ciena’s optical business grew 33% and trades at a price-to-sales multiple of about 5.5, while Arista Networks trades about 20 times sales thanks to its profitability and pure data center focus. Nokia as a whole currently trades around 1.65 times sales. That gap says a lot about how the market values focus and growth visibility. Furthermore, US tech companies typically have a much higher valuation multiple and locating part of Nokia's growth assets into a US-based "GrowthCo" (e.g. named Lucent) could help unlock a lot of latent shareholder value.

At least these issues are currently problematic in spite of NI being to a large extent run out of Sunnyvale:

  • Conglomerate discount weighing down on NI

  • NI is not a US company and many US funds thus don't invest in it = this tends to mean a lower valuation multiple compared to a similar US tech company

  • NI does't have total autonomy and cannot make structural deals with its shares, which would be a much more valuable currency without the drag of MN

QUESTIONS:

  1. Does keeping the faster-growing NI business inside Nokia represent a major missed opportunity to unlock shareholder value? As of now, investors may focus too much on the sluggish MN and too little on the growth and margin opportunities ON and IPN can achieve in the AI supercycle. I believe there is a major conglomerate discount on ON and IPN and setting them free (possibly along with FN) along with assets from CNS, Bell Labs and Nokia Technologies, could make the hidden gem less hidden to investors seeking the next growth story.

  2. Does NVIDIA’s equity investment make a spin-off more or less likely?

  3. If a spin-off is logical, as I believe, should FN stay in Nokia? Or should it join a US-based spin-off with ON and IPN to capture possible R&D synergies?

I’d like to hear your reasoning, not just opinions, on how Nokia could best structure itself for both growth and value creation. For reference, another post I wrote on the subject after q2.


r/Nok • • May 09 '25

Discussion Should Nokia Keep or Sell Mobile Networks? A Strategic Breakdown by ChatGPT

0 Upvotes

Let's see what AI concludes about whether Mobile Networks (MN) should remain a part of Nokia. This analysis was elaborated after a lengthy discussion between me and ChatGPT so as to make it analyze the issue from various angles.

*****

Summary

Nokia’s Mobile Networks (MN) division has been financially underwhelming and capital intensive, but it remains deeply embedded in the company’s long-term value drivers: licensing revenue, 6G standardization, and private wireless. Given limited buyer interest and strategic risks tied to divestment, keeping MN—paired with a sharp refocus—is the most rational path for shareholder value creation.

The Case for Selling Mobile Networks

1. Profitability Concerns
In Q1 2025, MN posted a €32 million operating loss (excluding one-offs), marking continued underperformance. The segment suffers from:

  • Price erosion due to aggressive competition and limited pricing discipline

  • High R&D spending required for 5G enhancements and early 6G development

  • Volume pressure as telecom operators slow infrastructure spending post-5G rollout

2. Capital Intensity and Strategic Distraction

  • MN ties up billions in long-cycle development with lower returns compared to Nokia’s Network Infrastructure (NI) unit.

  • Some investors argue it distracts from higher-margin, faster-growth opportunities in IP networks, optical, and private enterprise solutions.

Why Nokia Should Keep MN

1. Strategic Value to Licensing

Nokia currently earns approximately €1.4 billion per year in IP licensing revenue. This comes primarily from:

  • Mobile phone vendors

  • Infrastructure OEMs

  • Some growth from emerging IoT and automotive sectors

Without MN, Nokia’s influence in global wireless standardization—particularly 6G—would diminish. This could significantly weaken its position to:

  • Shape future technologies

  • Maintain a high share of standard essential patents (SEPs)

  • Enforce licensing terms across verticals

Licensing Value Comparison:

Source2024 Run Rate2030E (if MN retained)
Telecom SEPs (4G/5G/6G)€1.1–1.2B€1.2–1.4B
Non-telecom (IoT, auto)€200–300M€300–500M
Total Licensing€1.4B€1.5–1.7B

Losing MN could jeopardize Nokia’s 6G position and long-term licensing revenue stability.

2. Private Wireless: High-Margin Growth

The private wireless market is projected to exceed €8–10 billion by 2030, growing at a CAGR of 15–20%. This market includes:

  • Enterprise 4G/5G networks

  • Secure government and defense networks

  • Industrial IoT communications

Nokia is currently a global leader in private wireless deployments and MN provides the core technologies (RAN, small cells, custom base stations) for these solutions.

This business is:

  • Higher-margin than traditional telco contracts

  • More stable, with long-term industrial partnerships

  • Synergistic with Nokia’s Network Infrastructure (NI) and Cloud & Network Services (CNS) units

3. Enabler of Enterprise and NI Growth

MN supports the broader Nokia ecosystem by:

  • Creating full-stack solutions combining RAN, transport, IP, and software

  • Enhancing competitiveness in bidding for data center interconnects, government systems, and AI-driven enterprise networks

  • Supporting synergy with Infinera’s hyperscaler client base post-acquisition

Sale Feasibility and Valuation Outlook

1. Few Credible Buyers

Potential buyers are limited:

  • Samsung is subscale in RAN and losing money. While a strategic fit exists, there’s no sign of willingness to acquire.

  • Ericsson is the closest peer but blocked by antitrust concerns.

  • Huawei is politically untouchable in Western markets.

  • Private equity might consider a purchase, but likely only at a distressed valuation (< €4 billion) due to the need for restructuring and capex.

2. Low Sale Value Relative to Strategic Worth

Selling MN would bring in a lump sum that likely undervalues the segment’s embedded value:

  • Forgone licensing leverage

  • Loss of private wireless momentum

  • Strategic dependency on external RAN partners

MN’s Strategic Value to Nokia

Value LeverImpact if MN Retained
Licensing sustainabilityHigh – protects 6G SEP base
Private wireless growthHigh – MN core to delivery
Hyperscaler accessMedium – supports integrated bids
Standardization influenceHigh – crucial for 6G relevance

What Minimum Divestment Price Would Justify Selling MN?

While Nokia’s Mobile Networks (MN) is currently underperforming financially, its strategic value—especially in supporting licensing, private wireless growth, and integration with Network Infrastructure (NI)—means that any potential sale must be evaluated not only on immediate proceeds but also on foregone future value.

1. Licensing Revenue at Risk

If MN is divested, Nokia could lose influence over wireless standards, weakening its SEP (standard essential patent) portfolio. This could reduce licensing income by an estimated €200–300 million per year over time.

  • Present value over 10 years (10% discount rate): €1.3–2.0 billion

2. Lost Private Wireless Profitability

Private wireless is expected to become a €8–10 billion market by 2030, with Nokia well positioned. MN plays a central role in delivering these networks.

  • Potential EBIT contribution by 2030: €100–150 million per year

  • Present value over 10 years: €700 million–1.0 billion

3. Loss of Strategic Integration Value

MN enhances Nokia’s competitiveness in hyperscaler and enterprise markets by enabling bundled offerings with NI and CNS. These synergies, while harder to quantify, have strategic importance.

  • Estimated strategic value: €500 million–1.0 billion

Total Strategic Value of MN

ComponentValue Estimate
Lost Licensing Value€1.3–2.0B
Lost Private Wireless Profit€0.7–1.0B
Strategic Integration Value€0.5–1.0B
Total€2.5–4.0B

Nokia would need to receive at least €4–5 billion to justify selling MN without destroying long-term shareholder value. This threshold reflects not just MN’s direct revenues but the broader ecosystem it supports.

  • A sale at < €4 billion likely erodes long-term value.

  • A price ≥ €5 billion may justify a sale if proceeds are redeployed into higher-growth, higher-margin businesses like Network Infrastructure or returned to shareholders via buybacks.

Thus, unless a compelling bid in this range emerges—which appears unlikely given buyer constraints—the logic favors keeping and transforming MN rather than divesting it.

What Should Nokia Do If It Keeps MN?

1. Refocus Strategy

  • Exit low-margin, price-driven national telco contracts

  • Prioritize private wireless, defense, and enterprise networks

2. Rationalize Cost Base

  • Focus R&D on software-defined RAN and Open RAN

  • Co-invest in 6G R&D through EU/public funds to reduce internal burden

3. Integrate with NI and CNS

  • Build solutions targeting AI/ML-driven data center architectures

  • Leverage Infinera’s presence with hyperscalers to create end-to-end offerings

Conclusion

MN is a financial underperformer today, but it remains strategically valuable to Nokia's IP portfolio, private wireless leadership, and end-to-end enterprise offering. The licensing income and 6G influence it supports cannot be replicated by a licensing-only model.

With few viable buyers and unattractive sale pricing, divesting MN would be a short-term move with long-term consequences. Instead, Nokia should transform MN into a focused, lean, and integrated division that supports growth in licensing and enterprise infrastructure.

Selling would be easy—but keeping and fixing MN is the smarter long-term strategy.

***

MY COMMENT: While I don't agree with everything and knowing ChatGPT isn't error-free I find the analysis pretty compelling on the whole. While u/oldtoolfool for instance has repeatedly advocated divesting MN so I think there are strong reasons to keep MN if cost discipline is maintained. I also believe selling MN for €2B is likely to be met with a different market reaction than if the divestment price is for instance €10B. In practice, I find it difficult to imagine any other buyer than Samsung. If it makes a very generous offer then divesting MN may be the right thing to do.


r/Nok • • Mar 20 '21

Position Sold nok

1 Upvotes

I’m sure it’ll be great in the long run but it wasn’t worth the wait for me.

Not worth waiting a year or more for a small return when I can use that money elsewhere.

I put that money into Tesla and covered my loss and even managed to make a bit more.

Fyi that’s just my strategy I’m a fan of the risky stuff and Tesla is known to be volatile.

Nok is a good reliable stock for long term but not so great for those with no patience

EDIT: no need to get butt hurt that I sold it’s my decision and my money at the end of the day. This stock isn’t a cult.

Also as stated in the comments I SOLD TESLA FOR A PROFIT THAT COVERED MY NOK LOSSES AND THEN SOME. I no longer own Tesla nor do I plan on holding it long term ever.

I’m not comparing nok to Tesla. I’m just stating that Tesla is volatile so you can either make money fast or lose money fast.

My risk tolerance is difference therefore my trading strategy is different.


r/Nok • • Feb 16 '21

Discussion Everyone is like I still believe in $NOK. But is that really gonna skyrocket? Already doubt it

3 Upvotes

Just a couple thoughts I bought a couple shares of $COTY for simply checking my analysis 🧐. And already got + 9% on it. Made only a couple bucks, but I’m happy that it works, anyway.

I bought 106 shares and keep buying, cause I believe and wanna experience that I’m right and just have to wait or I’m wrong and a lose, but that will be my experience.

And now I doubt. I know all the fundamentals, all good news, we talk here a lot, and that definitely helps. But.

Does anyone like see things, that could help Nokia go up?


r/Nok • • Nov 02 '21

Discussion Is a deal to acquire Nokia on the horizon from a US Company?

0 Upvotes

I'm seeing a lot of chatter over the last week about Nokia being acquired through an agreed or hostile takeover bid before the end of the year.

I've thought for a long time that US Banks, US Firms, the US Gov't, and many others would like to see Nokia or Ericsson brought under ownership of a US Company to compete directly with China in the Communications & Technology future of 5G & 6G.

Both (Nokia & Ericsson) are significantly undervalued as compared to US Companies like Cisco which trade at 5x revenue. If an acquisition was in the future, you would think Nokia & Finland would be doing everything they could to keep this type of acquisition from happening by promoting a higher stock price. In addition to recent performance (4 Quarters in a row of beating expectations), buybacks would be a good start to propel Nokia to double digits to keep from a potential hostile takeover, but maybe Nokia & Finland are open to it as they see their competitors having much higher valuations and they need to combine with a US Company to maintain their long term future in Finland.

Was the BofA Analyst and the hit job/correction supporting this effort? Is Barclays involved as well which prompted their muted Hold rating after impressive Q3 earnings? Does the US Gov't want this done before NASA heads to the moon early next year where Nokia has been engaged to build a wireless network?

A 2x or 3x 2021 annual revenue of $26B + $5B Net Cash could do it if pushed to a shareholder vote. That's a $10 to $15 per share offer.


r/Nok • • Nov 03 '24

Discussion Nokia and the possible arrival of Trump

2 Upvotes

If Trump wins the election one of his decisions could take the US out of NATO in the face of the refusal of many European countries to allocate 2% of their GDP to NATO. Trump already said many weeks ago that he would encourage Putin to invade whoever he wants. I don't think Putin wants to expand the conflict to more areas but if I were wrong Finland is one of the countries that border Russia. I wonder to what extent moving Nokia's headquarters to the US could be a good thing in case Trump governs for another 4 years.

Translated with DeepL.com (free version)


r/Nok • • Jul 10 '26

Discussion how am i profiting from these options even though it didnt reach the value?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Nok • • Feb 03 '21

Discussion this forum is compromised....

1 Upvotes

Don't buy - either let them sink the ship then buy @ $3.50 OR sell at double of what you paid! if neither of those, HOLD.


r/Nok • • Jul 23 '25

Discussion How to make Nokia investable

0 Upvotes

A Hungarian Nokia employee wiseguy incorrectly called me a liar and said I don't know what I want from Nokia. Let's say it now so it becomes crystal clear.

What I want: Nokia's split into MN- and NI-lead parts and headquarters in the US, which will lead to a greater share of American investors among Nokia's owners, a more American BoD (now both the chair and the vice- chair are Finns), more ambitious and meritocratic corporate culture as well as a more shareholder-oriented attitude in top management and finally thanks to the preceding issues a higher share price.

To sum up:

  1. Split Nokia (conglomerate discount ends)

  2. Move Nokia's HQ to the US (Nokia as a US company gets more American shareholders who mainly invest in domestic companies)

  3. More Americans on the BoD (more ambition, dynamism and sharper shareholder focus)

  4. More growth, higher profitability (thanks to better leadership)

  5. Higher share price (partly due to higher growth and profit, partly due to higher tech valuations in the US)

That is the chain reaction I want to see. That may not be the ideal for change-resistant Nokians or Finnish patriotic/nostalgic/emotional shareholders, but it would in my conviction be the best solution for creating shareholder value.

Nokia needs disruption not timid incrementalism led by overly prudent shareholder-ignoring Finns. And this I say as a Finn myself but first and foremost as a frustrated Nokia investor.


r/Nok • • Jul 29 '26

Discussion Great news for NOK!

Thumbnail x.com
0 Upvotes

r/Nok • • May 24 '26

Discussion Nokia info

6 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I’ve seen a trend in Nokia and just wondering if anyone can leave some insightful information for me to read up on and then do further research as I am looking into investing!


r/Nok • • Mar 08 '26

Discussion I'm worried after seeing this.

1 Upvotes

If the AI ​​bubble bursts, Nokia will follow

https://x.com/recuncho34/status/2030591759210676395?t=uaimnPKf1m09iWoZnMJt0Q&s=34

What do you think?


r/Nok • • Jan 24 '23

Discussion Earnings

0 Upvotes

I think Nokia will keep the earnings modest...the company will not allow the stock to rise much over $5.00....... Price has to be kept down in order to repurchase their shares at a low price.... maybe after the repurchase program is completed the stock will get to $6+ as analyst have written.


r/Nok • • Apr 21 '21

Discussion How long are you planning to stay on with Nokia?

2 Upvotes
173 votes, Apr 24 '21
14 3 months
159 6 months

r/Nok • • Feb 26 '25

Discussion Why shouldn't NOK sell MN??????

1 Upvotes

Seriously, what is the upside?


r/Nok • • 10d ago

Discussion You're a bag holder for a reason

5 Upvotes

For context, CIEN is down 61% compared to peak earlier this year.

It is up 46% from 52-week low.

In other words, CIEN price is closer to it's lows than it's 2026 high.

On the other hand, NOK is down 53% from 2026 high but up 41% from 52-week low.

If you're an investor, this is "not great, not terrible". There is inherent risk when picking individual stocks.

If you're a swing trader or gambler, I have nothing to say that will change your mind either way. GLTA


r/Nok • • Apr 19 '22

Discussion I am loading up puts for the upcoming earnings and here is why

1 Upvotes
  1. In the past, good earnings always leads to a huge drop anyway

  2. Ericsson report excellent earnings while dropping a lot

  3. Overall market is very volatile.

Wish me luck on this


r/Nok • • Jul 22 '26

Discussion How will $NOK react after earnings ?

0 Upvotes
1183 votes, Jul 25 '26
676 Up
507 Down

r/Nok • • Feb 08 '25

Discussion Nokia Partnership

0 Upvotes

The partnerships between Nokia, Meta, and Amazon have the potential to greatly benefit consumers by enhancing their digital experiences and access to cutting-edge technologies. Here are a few ways these collaborations might impact consumers:

Enhanced Connectivity and Immersive Experiences

Nokia's collaboration with Meta focuses on improving network infrastructure and connectivity, which is crucial for the development of the metaverse. As a result, consumers can expect:

  • Faster and more reliable internet connections: This will enable smoother and more immersive virtual experiences, such as VR and AR applications.

  • Innovative digital interactions: With enhanced connectivity, consumers can enjoy more interactive and engaging experiences in the metaverse, including virtual socializing, gaming, and online shopping.

Improved Cloud Services and 5G Applications

Nokia's partnership with Amazon, particularly through Amazon Web Services (AWS), aims to advance cloud-based solutions and 5G use cases. This collaboration can lead to:

  • Better performance for cloud-based applications: Consumers will benefit from faster and more efficient cloud services, improving their experience with applications such as streaming, online gaming, and data storage.

  • New 5G-enabled technologies: The deployment of 5G networks will pave the way for innovative applications like smart homes, connected devices, and autonomous vehicles, enhancing convenience and efficiency in everyday life.

Cutting-Edge Technologies and Innovations

Both partnerships contribute to the development of advanced technologies, which can result in:

  • Access to the latest tech advancements: Consumers will have the opportunity to experience and adopt new technologies as they become available, staying at the forefront of digital innovation.

  • Affordable and widely available solutions: As these companies work together to develop and deploy new technologies, economies of scale and increased competition can lead to more affordable and accessible products and services for consumers.

In summary, the partnerships between Nokia, Meta, and Amazon are likely to bring numerous benefits to consumers, including enhanced connectivity, improved cloud services, and access to cutting-edge technologies. These collaborations have the potential to transform the way consumers interact with digital technologies and enrich their overall experiences.


r/Nok • • Feb 20 '24

Discussion Nokia investors are parasites and destroy company according to a Nokia insider...

4 Upvotes

Part of a discussion (repeated here as maybe not seen by everyone) following Mustathmir/Abu's letter to Nokia's board showing the mentality of a Nokia (or Solidium?) employee that may be representative for Nokia's culture.

Discussion participants: Mustathmir/rAin_nul/DutchOptimist

-Mustathmir/Abu= Nokia investor since 2015 (and serious poster on Nokia boards) -DutchOptimist=Nokia investor since 2019 (and very disappointed about the lack of urgency to show results within NOK) -rAin_nul = "Insider" (working for Nokia or Solidium?)

"M" and "r" started the discussion, "D" joined later:

Quote: "

r: They won't really care when your message is full of factually incorrect statements.

M: Thank you for your statement, the correctness of which you didn't care to substantiate.

r: Would that change anything? You already sent this letter. And also, some of those points are already corrected by me in other threads, you just did not care at all. But fine here's some:

A) Nokia is not firing people just because of the sake of firing. Like you said, it is cost savings. So when they "only" fired 4k, it was also possible that the intended saving was achieved. We also need to notice that 2021 and 2022 were good years for Nokia. So it is possible that they needed to adjust these numbers and fire less people to achieve those good numbers. The same way how Pekka mentioned regarding the recent job cuts that the job cuts will depend on the market conditions. So if NAM awakes, then they will cut less jobs on the scale of 9k-14k.

B) I already mentioned couple of times this, but MN is not just about RAN, and AT&T still makes deals with MN, just not about RAN, so they did not lose it as a customer.

C-1) This is one of the stupidest ideas and already talked about it. If you fire the management even if it's not their fault that they missed the target, you are forcing them to set lower targets or achieve short term progress even if they ruin the company long term. Normally you only want to take responsibility when it was your mistake. In this case, it wasn't Nokia's fault. The market spent less money. That's all. The same way how the market spent more money in the previous 2 years.

C-2) While I don't know how they exactly set the targets, but they said that these are based on industry analysts' opinions, so it is not Nokia that set these independently.

C-3) It's called marketing and that generally helps companies. There are also investors whom care about being green and they are more likely to invest in companies with ESG plans.

M: Thanks for your comments. You are right with what you wite except having reached the savings target: out of the €600M of savings, only €500M were reached and thew final €100M will be cut this year in parallell with the new cuts.

Like I told Larry Talbot I removed some repetition and edited some other issues so I think I will send today a new version which the recipients will probably get before opening the first version. I did now consider the first three points you just made when editing my letter.

Remember, I'm not a Nokia hater and what I write here is meant to help improve the performance of the company while making it more profitable as an investment. And I do listen to criticism in order to correct errors and make improvements. I hope Nokia does the same!

r: Obviously Nokia employees also talk about stuff like long-term plans, cost savings, reorganizations etc. So who do you think Nokia would listen to? An employee who worked for Nokia for decades and Nokia knows that they have at least some kind of knowledge about the market or you who need to send multiple letters, because it is incorrect and Nokia has zero knowledge on your background.

Writing multiple letters already proves that you don't have the necessary knowledge, so why would they listen to you?

M: I have sent the letter also to Solidium (and Blackrock although I don't think anyone will notice my letter there) and I think Nokia is more likely to listen to Solidium, should they choose to be inspired by my letter, than to me...

r: But it matters who wrote the letter. If someone without any knowledge read your letter, that person needs to decide what to do with the letter. And while you could be someone who won a Nobel prize, you could also be a homeless alcoholic.

I don't know who's job is to read these mails, but I find it unlikely that someone with the right knowledge in the right position would read it.

Solidium is also looking for long term plans and that's something that your letter does not contain.

M: I did not intend to rewrite Nokia's strategy, although I did give some ideas on MN. This letter is meant to spar Nokia (perhaps via Solidium) to always and everywhere remember the primacy of shareholder value and to act accordingly.

r: I'm happy that they don't care about parasites, so no, they are actually doing a great job. Though the share buybacks were still too high and they shouldn't increase the dividend.

Like I said, shareholders destroy most of the companies and that's why when you are leading a company, you don't want to listen to them.

M: Happily for shareholders (i.e. the owners of the employer which pays your salary) you are in no position to decide on how much of a shareholder focus a company should have.

r: Lol, no, shareholders do not pay for anything. I got my salary from the deals we make with other companies.


(here I join the discussion)

D: What a bunch of crap you are ventilating here! If only 1% of your ideas represent the mentality of Nokia employees in general it shows why Nokia is in the dolldrums for such a long time. You have absolutely no idea what the role of stakeholders is within Nokia. You must be a low level employee missing basic economic principles and hopefully you are dismissed in the next firing round.

If there is no balance on the stakeholder level (owners/investors-management-employees) to have the same ideas how to operate a company it will ultimately go down.

And you my friend can look for another (probably less paying) job.

If you think you are right take a look at Nokia's share price over the last 15 years. Or look at the general poster feeling on Reddit and Yahoo boards.

Nokia is nothing more than an NGO, where civil servants, like you, pretent to work for a high class IT company.

r: I'm actually also a shareholder, so I have a pretty good "idea" what the shareholders role are. But if you fail to see it, then the problem is with you and not with me. As for me, it's ok, they don't fire me for multiple reason that they already told us.

No, they don't have the same ideas, because they have different purposes goals. You can clearly see this in this subreddit how lot of people just waiting to sell everything and don't care about the future of the company. That was my point. Normally shareholders have nothing to do with the company because they have no idea how to lead one. Only exception is when someone tries to destroy it, e.g. when they fired Musk from Paypal.

Btw, no, if I switch job, realistically my salary would be 60-70% higher compared to what Nokia pays me. But they don't fire me/us. There are some stuff that only we know in the whole Nokia.

The past of Nokia's share price is actually bad because of the investors. And that btw proves my point. When shareholders don't see the profit they leave and try to destroy a company.

If this is an NGO, why are you here? Then stfu and leave. You only have right to say anything if you admit or accept that it is a high-class IT company. :)

I don't know why I have to deal with children here....

D: The expected answer from a nerdy technician or software engineer who thinks he knows how the world turns...till he really finds out. Now back to writing code.

r: *Sigh*.... Okay, then let's ask the experts...

Originally what shareholders think about this topic comes from Milton Friedman who said (in around 1970) that the shareholders drive the economy, so the companies' purpose is to please them, so they have to maximize returns to shareholders. It's called the Friedman doctrine.

For the next like 30 years this was very influential and many people thought how clever this was. Then it showed the problems. In 2007-2008 a financial crisis occurred because of this logic and since then the experts are saying that this is not the way.

Harvard Business School professors for example said that the Friedman doctrine is "distracting companies and their leaders from the innovation, strategic renewal, and investment in the future that require their attention". The Friedman doctrine focuses on short term targets, playing with numbers, job cuts without long term plans.

Feel free to educate yourself, because this was just pathetic from you: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedman_doctrine

D: Ahhh, you read books. And learn from doctrines. And from counter arguments. Any insight you gained why -US companies comparable to Nokia have market values often 10x higher? -Nokia's institutional shareholders are a measely 5.8% ("We don't want to invest in losers...")? -Nokia's top management has never invested in Nokia stock on the open market? -Socialist societies and corporations are beyond NGO's a thing of the past? -Your mentality might be in place in Russia but not in a competitive world?

Enjoy your automatically distributed to underperformers free Nokia stock.

r: >-Any insight you gained why US companies comparable to Nokia have market values often 10x higher?

There are different factors when we talk about this.

  • Firstly, simply being American. Yes, a US citizen more likely invest in an American company than a foregn one. And in the EU less people with less money invest in companies. This is difference in culture. If you want to change it, it's a long term project. https://www.jstor.org/stable/1344655

  • Secondly, this is actually a fallacy. You talk about successful companies, but not the failed ones and that was my point. Because of this culture many-many companies fall, when they try to please the investors instead of coming up with a long term plan. https://edition.cnn.com/2023/06/09/investing/premarket-stocks-trading/index.html

-Nokia's institutional shareholders are a measely 5.8% ("We don't want to invest in losers...")?

You know that they became investors in 2018? And they started with 3.3%, so they slowly but surely increased their position. Even when Nokia was a better position like in 2005, the biggest Finnish investor only had 0,46% of all the shares. Like I said, there's a difference in culture.

-Nokia's top management has never invested in Nokia stock on the open market?

The top managements get a lot of benefits in shares. So I think that's the normal reaction. I would keep my shares, but it is unlikely that I would put more money in it. We are still talking about a job that you could lose.

-Socialist societies and corporations are beyond NGO's a thing of the past

I can name several companies that started as a socialist company (or more like a company in socialism) and still exist. So this is just factually incorrect.

-Your mentality might be in place in Russia but not in a competitive world?

This is also simply incorrect. Like I showed you that link or quoted Harvard professors what I'm saying is actually inline with the academic position. Yes, it is a fact that what I wrote to you above is what the scientists think as - let's say - best practices when it comes to how to lead a company.

Actually in Russia, it is more closer to what you are proposing but from a different angle. You are saying that a shareholder has the right to destroy a company if he doesn't like it. And in Russia they also think this but from the "leader"'s POV and not from a shareholder POV. I was actually against this.

D: Final last words: Go work for a family owned private business and learn that owners (=investor) demand the biggest ROI. Why? Because the owner runs the highest risk. Not the staff that is hired.

Solidium as Nokia's biggest investor is just another lazy government type institution. Not ROI oriented but focused on employee relationships.

Yeah, I learned my lesson and sell my stock as soon as I break-even. Goodbye.

r: And this proves my point. Shareholders are parasites who don't care about long term plans. They are willing to destroy any company for the short term profit.

" unquote ‐---‐------------- Comments welcome on the mentality of an insider that might give longs an idea why Nokia has a culture that hates retail investors.


r/Nok • • Apr 08 '21

Discussion We can help NOK in a non-standard way

4 Upvotes

Walstreetbets has nearly ten million followers (9.75m) and 80% of them have joined in the last few months. Millions of them are influenced by the popularity of a company by looking here WSB MENTION TRENDS. For Nokia here: NOK.

The two Nokia subreddit ( r/Nok and r/Nokia_stock ) have a total of 20.4k members. Thousands of us can join the r/wallstreetbets Daily Discussion and to write one sentence about Nokia every day, and they MUST mention the symbol or the company (or both). This will send the company among the most discussed, which can attract hundreds of thousands of new investors (and why not millions) of those who are influenced by memes.