Because of the nosleep moderators' recent statement regarding recent drama, I have decided to come forward now instead of holding my peace any longer.
To say that our SubReddits have never experienced any drama is a wishful lie. All of us have experienced some tough times in the past, with varying degrees of notoriety. Whether it be moderator infighting, massive disinformation campaigns or plagiarism and copyright violations, many incidents have left their stain on these subs.
The ongoing drama concerning at least four SubReddits including r/fivenightsatfreddys, r/nosleep, r/nosleepOOC, and r/26FrightsOfFreddy is no exception. This very precipitous situation has proven to be a massive wakeup call for the horror writing and FNaF communities a at large. Therefore, it is with the desire to prevent the circumstances from escalating even further that we as a group issue this statement of apology and clarification as an olive branch and offer of truce on behalf of Freddit and the 26FoF team.
26 Frights of Freddy is an ongoing project that can be considered perhaps the largest horror collaboration in all of reddit, outracing its immediate inspiration Alphabet Stew, with a total of at least 74 and counting stories spanning several months, all of which have been or will be posted on Freddit. Some of you may have seen our work appear on r/nosleep during the purge, where over the course of three days, 22 of the 23 unique authors returned and made a coordinated effort to put the stories on nosleep. You may also have listened to the recent nosleep podcast featuring the letter entry written by one of our authors more prominently known in the community. Some of the authors of this series were also from Alphabet Stew, the last of which has been behind the scenes coordinating the second installment of the series, key elements of his work also appearing in it.
Having said that, recent conduct on the part of the team, precipitated by my mistake no less, led our subs down a path that could have ended very badly for all involved, perhaps affecting thousands over the long term.
On July 28, 2018, the 26FrightsofFreddy subreddit had been informed that one of their authors would be forced to drop out of the project. In a stunning lack of foresight, I posted the message in full to the nosleepOOC discord in an attempt to find a replacement. This was considered spread of personally identifiable information and led to my ban from discord. In my haste, I posted the message in its entirety so as to request a replacement and explain why. I now realize that my actions were uncalled for as the situation constituted a serious breach of trust and that they warrant the measures I received. My coauthors who were also associated with the nosleep community were understandably furious with how I handled the situation and I write this to let everyone know what I did and that I’m sorry.
Having reviewed my message history both on discord and on reddit, I realize now that my actions could easily have been construed as singling out users and spreading gossip, though that was never my intention. I was under the impression that the message would only be read by a few active authors at best, authors who would have been very aware of the situation involved. I erroneously believed that the information I had disclosed was common knowledge among the community and had forgotten where I was posting and the potential consequences. You correctly presume that people are confiding in me with the expectation of privacy and usually I hold to that standard. However, my consistent misinterpretation of context has proven to my detriment and this behavior is very unbecoming of a user in my position. As organizer of one of the largest reddit horror collaborations, as well as the fact that I can be said to speak for a fandom infamous for its more egregious—and arguably “cancerous”—aspects, my mistake is compounded and only serves to reinforce the stereotypes singling out that fandom. My actions as of late reflect poorly not only on myself and the team, but also on the fandom as a whole. I hope that none of the affected have any hard feelings against me for this.
Having said that, I do not attempt to justify myself with the following events, which led to the entire situation spiraling out of control in ways perhaps even the nosleep mods did not anticipate.
On July 29, the author who would have been slated to post the entry N is for Neglected, attempted to back out of the project, presumably as response to this mishap. Since we have had no problems in the past, and he was not only eager to participate but also he and I actively worked on the document together, it can only be assumed that his retraction was a direct result of said drama.
Normally, this would not have been an issue, since we have had authors back out before. The difference, however is this: his story had been considered finished MONTHS before the drama, hell, even before the hiatus we took due to my China trip.
This presented a very dangerous precedent because this constituted a unilateral retraction of a completed story entry that had already been approved and used to form the basis of canon used by other authors. After much deliberation regarding the matter, we informed him that his petition for retraction had been denied and had his entry been incomplete we may have considered the retraction and possibly transferred the ideas to the sub; having said that, since his story was basically complete, it would not have been in the best interest of the team to have it withheld from the target audience.
This ultimately prompted him to post his entry on his personal subreddit with the following disclaimer:
Author’s note: this content is exclusively belonging to [REDACTED], and was originally intended for a planned collab however I chose to back out of that collab for personal reasons. That being said, this content can not be used in any form or referenced to by any one else and this content is my property , any violation of this will be reported to the Reddit admins
To say that this kicked the hornets' nest cannot be understated.
Much of the team was divided over this decision, some choosing to let it slide and look forward to the sub's work, while others argued that it deserved to be shared to the target audience, i.e. r/fivenightsatfreddys, and since its author had, in essence, posted the story on a public forum, it would be beyond unfair to withhold his story, especially not one that was based on an established universe and used characters created by other people. Some even considered the retraction an outright betrayal and that once he had posted the story on reddit, he had no right to withhold it from other audiences. One of the teammates who were of the last opinion hijacked a dummy account that was intended for roleplay purposes and crossposted it to the 26Frightsoffreddy sub, which led to a substantial degree of collateral damage and the powder keg that is today.
Having said that, I realize that I had horrendously mishandled the situation and allowed these transgressions to take place. I have since identified and removed the offending team member and reported him to Freddit admins. This was a MAJOR shitshow that could have been handled much better, and I accept responsibility for my sheer lack of foresight. If there are any further actions you feel are necessary to repair the relationship between nosleep and Freddit, please inform us; in the meantime, I will try to coordinate with my team better and choose my authors more carefully in the future. Please do not hesitate to reach out to any of us if you need us to take any specific actions.
I hope that nosleep can eventually come to forgive us.
That is all I have to say for now. I wish everyone in this project the utmost luck in their endeavors and hope that we could come to work with you again soon.