r/NoParticipation • • Sep 16 '14

I am confused by this.

63 Upvotes

I am more of a lurker on reddit, opting instead to comment only selectively. Recently, I went on one of my favourite subreddits, /r/civ, and saw that I could not post, comment or even vote on anything in it. This particular instance, as I have experienced it in the past and did not know why, I noticed the np in the URL. Not knowing what that was, I decided to google it, upon which I found this subreddit. Reading through the previous posts made here, I noticed a lot of people thought that this system was flawed. I can understand what /r/NoParticipation is trying to do but I feel like it is going about it the wrong way. It seems to hamper discussion in subreddits that include the np. prefix simply because some users choose to browse in a certain way, ie. following the front page and not using tabs.

What confuses me even more is the fact that, after looking at many of the top posts here, the creator of this gives methods to get out of NoParticipation. That, to me, seems counter-intuitive as it says that there are ways around it. That would, in my opinion, slow down vote brigades rather than prevent them while also muffling the less frequent redditors that might have something to say.

What severely bothers me most is the fact that, according to numerous other posts made here, I could have been banned for interacting in these subreddits when I had no idea that this even existed. I do not use RES, so I never got a notification about why I was not allowed to interact in these subreddits. That seems so exclusionary and against the principles of reddit that it is baffling that this is used in so many subs.

I can understand what NoParticipation is trying to achieve, but the fact that this follows users who are not aware that it even exists to subreddits that they frequent often is wrong and not the right way to go about ending vote brigades. The users affected by this the most are likely the ones that don't have a strong understanding of technology and who would not know how to use a script to get rid of it. NoParticipation feels way too intrusive to be good for the community. That's my two cents at least.


r/NoParticipation • • Oct 20 '16

This shit is fucking garbage, please get rid of it.

36 Upvotes

The whole "reddit will ban u if u participate :)))" thing is full of shit, this is a RES function, not something built into reddit itself. This shit is, in fact, encouraging vote brigading, not eliminating it.


r/NoParticipation • • Dec 08 '19

Why is this so useless?

35 Upvotes

If people really want to downvote or comment on something they can just remove the np from the url this is so fucking stupid


r/NoParticipation • • Jul 03 '18

np.reddit.com is cancer, I hope the reddit admins get rid of your hack.

23 Upvotes

Your stuff breaks the site regularly and breaks subreddits.

And it doesn't prevent "brigading" or whatever anyway.


r/NoParticipation • • May 09 '19

Huh?

21 Upvotes

I got linked something with 'np.reddit' just earlier, it gave me some scary warning about 'respecting the community and not voting', even though it was literally just a silly AskReddit question. After I looked it up, I found this. What the hell is the point of this? If anyone wants to vote on it they can just remove the np. part. I see what you're trying to do here but it just seems absolutely useless. Anyone with half a brain that wants to vote on something will do so anyways.


r/NoParticipation • • Aug 08 '18

i don't participate in reddit at all, and even *i* think your entire concept is trash

20 Upvotes

see title.

this place overall isnt worth my input, and most of its utility, to me, comes in laughing (anonymously) at idiots whom i would never even bother to taunt (i tried taunting some of the stupidest ones, it was counterproductive)

i just had to log in when i found out about this absolute hilarity and utter nonsense

step back and look at yourselves, your concept, and what you're really doing with your life

if you're going to waste time on reddit like the rest of us, more power to you, but do you imagine for one second that an organized "brigade" is going to be so utterly incompetent as to fall for your fake website template? it's like you're phishing, but you're also kindergartners. crazy!!!

i dont know who you are, but your whole thing here is seriously dumb as fuck. i can only pray for your families, that the utter retardation of this concept isn't an accurate representation of exactly how mentally capable you happen to be.


r/NoParticipation • • Apr 25 '16

Why would anyone ever want or need this?

17 Upvotes

[blank]


r/NoParticipation • • Aug 12 '14

I don't see anything about "NP" or "No Participation" in the rules or reddiquette links

16 Upvotes

As far as I can tell, there's nothing about not participating in discussions linked from elsewhere in either the Reddit Rules or Reddiquette pages. However, I've seen links to these pages in the RES blurb and by others, supposedly to justify the legitimacy of the "NP" idea as coming from part of Reddit's rules. As far as I can tell, it's at best a weak interpretation of a couple of points on the Reddiquette page. What am I missing?


r/NoParticipation • • Jun 16 '15

YesParticipation: A workaround for chromium users

14 Upvotes

Hi. I see there's currently no rules against posting this, so I'm just going to go for it. Hell, maybe I'll get a rule named after me!

 

Install the extension Switcheroo Redirector. Click the button it puts in the top right, put in a np.reddit.com and redirect it to www.reddit.com. Test if it works, and then right click the button and select the "Hide Button" option to declutter your screen.

Simple as that. Enjoy participating.


r/NoParticipation • • Apr 13 '15

If admins ban for vote brigading (who knows how this is even determined), why isn't NP enabled by reddit instead of a CSS hack?

14 Upvotes

Oh, and when you follow a .np link, all other links you follow from the same tab will be .np too. just a kink in how it works. not really a problem with multi-tab browsing, though.

I don't think vote brigading is even in the official reddit rules, and even if it is, it's absolutely not clear at all. The admins seem to like to make up rules however they want without telling the users, and then this CSS hack exists that confuses users even more because the NP link sticks around even as you use the rest of the sub.


r/NoParticipation • • Apr 29 '13

How do I get out of No Participation mode?

13 Upvotes

I'm just a lurker, except for a few comments here and there, Why am I being punished for not bothering anyone?


r/NoParticipation • • Jun 01 '16

NP should be fully automated, and shouldn't rely on subreddit CSS

12 Upvotes

Why not disable voting entirely when viewing np links? Right now, we have some subs with custom CSS to block voting (but that's overridden by my Gold theme), creepy threats of bans in the rules that have some users scared of accidentally voting, and RES is pretty passive-aggressive about telling me not to vote.

We are conditioned to vote every time we see the arrows. If we shouldn't vote, don't give us arrows, regardless of subreddit or CSS. The current np links are a half-measure.

Furthermore, the NP wiki makes it sound criminal to post links without NP. Again, this is nuts when all links could be converted to np links automatically. Then the problem is solved with a few lines of code, which is more reasonable than expecting a few million users to comply with an optional rule.


r/NoParticipation • • Feb 14 '15

The official reddit twitter account has started using np links

Thumbnail
twitter.com
11 Upvotes

r/NoParticipation • • Oct 23 '14

[RES NP Module Feedback]

10 Upvotes

This is quite possibly the dumbest thing ever. You are overcomplicating this site. Next thing, you will need users to download a PDF manual to use this site. Strip the voting system then if you're so inclined on whatever logic that it's pollution, geez.


r/NoParticipation • • Jan 07 '14

[Serious] NP links are currently blocked in Saudi Arabia

10 Upvotes

There are some subreddits that are blocked in that country, but recently np.reddit.com (No Participation domain) is currently being blocked. I have told /r/saudiarabia about it: http://www.reddit.com/r/saudiarabia/comments/1u8ff9/psa_no_participation_np_reddit_links_are_possibly/


r/NoParticipation • • Jul 17 '17

[RES NP Module Feedback]

9 Upvotes

I have absolutely no idea what you are talking about. I followed a link off the front page and, after reading the link, decided to upvote the main response in the thread. Then I bet THREATENED with a ban because of some unclear NoParticipation crap that I know nothing about. If you are going to ban people you should make it obvious that they are about to do something you don't approve of and you should provide some kind of warning.


r/NoParticipation • • Oct 08 '14

"www.np.reddit.com" creates problems with HTTPS; use "np.reddit.com"

9 Upvotes

reddit recently added (nearly) side-wide HTTPS encryption. You can, and should, set your preferences to use HTTPS by default at https://www.reddit.com/prefs/security.

However, if you go to https://www.np.reddit.com, your browser will probably give you a huge scary warning that you're possibly being hacked, because reddit's SSL certificate is not valid for that domain. It's better to point your links to np.reddit.com, regardless of whether the particular URL you're typing is HTTP or HTTPS, because users who have HTTPS enabled with be redirected to the https:// version anyway and with np.reddit.com they won't get the huge scary warning.

People have been treating these domains interchangeably and it hasn't really mattered before, but now np.reddit.com is better (at least in terms of the HTTPS issue).


r/NoParticipation • • Aug 10 '14

2 questions, Why support the silencing of people, and why use a NP. prefix?

9 Upvotes

Why does Reddit support the silencing of people who are genuinely interested in a topic they see, and when they click the link, are forbidden from voting for that link? When we go to a topic, we are prevented from voting for that topic and from voting for/against any commentary in the thread. I strongly disagree with silencing anyone, and don't think any admins should prevent peoples voices from being heard.

I thought NP. prefix was a hacking attempt. I almost drove myself to distraction trying to fix it until I received the RES message about the NP. prefix. Why use a prefix at all? Why not just post a banner telling people they cannot vote, or make the page static?


r/NoParticipation • • May 20 '15

Why doesn't np mode block votes and comments?

8 Upvotes

I know they can be blocked by RES but why doesn't Reddit block it by default? It just seems like a booby trap especially for new users that don't know the rules and drama of Reddit.


r/NoParticipation • • Feb 04 '15

My 2 Cents

8 Upvotes

So I see a thread which I feel I have a strong and valued response for.

I took the time to log into my rarely used reddit account.

I'm put in this system that restricts me from using reddit, because I don't use reddit.

Not using reddit again.


r/NoParticipation • • Aug 21 '13

Why do I get this from my mailbox?

8 Upvotes

I see an orangered, a reply to an ongoing discussion. I'm not coming from an external subreddit, I'm coming from this one, just later. I know I can bypass this, but it's annoying. Is there any way this could be worked around so that it only actually applies to actual external links?


r/NoParticipation • • Jul 28 '17

[RES NP Module Feedback]

7 Upvotes

I'll vote where I want, when I want. Thanks.


r/NoParticipation • • Jan 21 '16

[RES NP Module Feedback]

7 Upvotes

I still don't understand what this is or why it is in place. I was reading a link about how the military and media are lying to the public about what is really going on. I started to read some comments and found a comment I liked and hit the upvote button. Immedietely I'm presented with this warning that voting for a comment I liked that was posted 8 hours ago, may get me banned from reddit? WTF?

Many will try to defend this by quoting the 'rules' of reddit, but all I see is a site doing what it said it would never do, and that's filter content or prevent people from commenting if the hive mind doesn't like your comment. I thought reddit was a place to go where you can speak your mind and comment without fear of getting banned like we were on a private game server and got caught cheating.

It says I shouldn't vote on anything, but goddamnit I'm not removing my vote on a comment that I thought was relevant. I didn't post my own comment and I didn't downvote or upvote any other comment, so why am I being threatened with a ban for agreeing with someone in the discussion?

Reddits rules are changing for the worse it seems. I get that you have to protect against trolls and what not, but at the same time you are segragating the site into their own cliques which no outsiders can see or comment on. If I want to tell a hardcore christian follower that god isn't real, I should be able to do so. There are lines that shouldn't be crossed, I get that, like replying 'dick' to every comment in a thread, but that's not what most of us are doing.

I dunno, I'm not removing my upvote regardless of what your rules say. If I want to upvote a pro Nazi comment, It's my damn right. You take these rights away from people and you lose the originality that got reddit it's fame in the first place. You may as well just set up a subscription fee and make people pay to join subreddits while displaying their real names, because that's how you are treating us now.

If that post was supposed to be NP, why the hell where there so many comments and votes already? Is this NP thing really just discrimination against me and other users because somehow the points that don't matter actually DO matter but only in a hidden way? Do I not have enough points or pro-topic comment upvotes to be able to upvote this comment on this thread? I want to know what gives.


r/NoParticipation • • Jan 12 '15

Is it always necessary to use NP links when linking from one sub to another? Are subscribers to one sub banned from participating in all others?

7 Upvotes

I have never gotten a satisfactory explanation of this.

Is it against any rule to link from one sub to another?

If I subscribe to one sub that links to a post in another sub, am I forbidden from voting on that post? Even if I am subscribed to both subreddits?

I understand that instructing readers to vote a certain way in a post on another sub is against the rules, but is simply linking?

If I am subscribed to /r/news and /r/conspiracy and the same post appears on both am I forbidden from participating in the post on /r/news?

This topic seems to come up often on /r/conspiracy in particular. I have never gotten a satisfactory explanation. The only thing I hear repeatedly is that subscribers of /r/conspiracy have been shaddowbanned for participating in default subreddits. I would like clarification. Are there special rules regarding /r/conspiracy as opposed to other subreddits?

I would imagine that if a story about new technology were posted to /r/technology and /r/science it would be fair for a user to participate in both threads because the story fits into both categories and the user has an overlapping interest. If i find a post in a default subreddit relevant to the interests of a specific subreddit what are the exact rules on linking and participating. As long as I don't give instructions to participate or how to participate it's all good, right?

Are there any instances were participating in one subreddit can exclude a user from being allowed to participate in another subreddit?

If a moderator wants to shaddowban a user for posting or voting in a thread that has been linked in another sub does there have to be an intent to brigade?

I would like some clarification from mods, specifically on crossposts between /r/conspiracy and default subreddits such as /r/news and /r/science.


r/NoParticipation • • Dec 03 '14

[RES NP Module Feedback]

7 Upvotes

This is absolutely ridiculous. I just click links on the front page. If I end up on a NP thread and like it or make a comment, I can get banned? I understand the whole vote brigade deal, but now I am scared to participate for fear of getting booted. This is ignorant. Way to scare off people from participating. If it's not intended for people like me, then be VERY clear about that in your warning.