Quick backstory: My Rogue SL AWD stopped working and I took it to a dealership far from where I live. They informed me it was under warranty so I would get it fixed and it would be free plus I would get a loaner vehicle.
This week my coworker hit my car while leaving the parking lot. I contacted their insurance company and they stated they would be responsible and would pay for 100% of the damages of course. I informed my advisor, and he stated he would let the rental manager know. The rental manager was sent an email and number for the claim number, insurance email and number to reach out to them since I am not the owner of the car. I then was called my car would be ready for pickup and I can return the loaner. I waited til Saturday (11/21) to call and confirm everything so I may be clear of everything. Nissan Dealership stated that I would be charged $500 for a deductible for their own insurance due to damages to the car. I was confused and wondered why because 1. My insurance is not paying it’s the other driver’s insurance 2. The lease agreement says I’m responsible for damages to the vehicle whether it is my fault or not my fault. My insurance or the insurance would cover damages if any were found due to incidents.
My loaner contract is up 11/29/26. My car is ready and they’re stating they need to collect $500 from me when I go turn in the vehicle or not. My question is should I pay the $500 or should I dispute it.
I personally think it is crazy they would do that since the other insurance company called to confirm they will pay damages and that I shouldn’t be responsible for anything. I don’t know what to do or what to say.
Since the claim is closing on the weekend for shop damages and items, they stated Monday should be the date all parties receive confirmation.