r/NintendoSwitch • u/gregoryph • Apr 25 '22
Discussion Why doesn't the Switch have functionality like FindMy Phone? Why does Nintendo make it so easy for people to use stolen devices?
My kid left his switch on an airplane as we were getting off. We discovered it was missing the next day. We filed all the lost item reports. Changed the passwords on our accounts, etc... A few more days go by and someone seems to be playing the switch, this I can tell from parental controls app. They used up allotted time and entered the password wrong.
I call Nintendo, they explain that I need to deactivate the console as the primary console for both my user and my kid's user. Done.
And now, whoever has the Switch basically has a free switch. Nothing I can do to stop them from using it.
Nintendo Switch's security is a joke compared with many other devices (iOS devices).
Why is there no:
Master lock/access code? This seems like a complete no-brainer. 4 digit access code to unlock the device. Device lockout after multiple failed attempts.
Remote disable? If you could brick the device so that no one could use it, reset it, etc... there would be less incentive for a thief or "finder" to keep it.
GeoLocate by internet connection? I know this wouldn't help you find it, but it could give you a sense of where it is so that you could search craigslist or marketplace for someone trying to sell it, or file a police report for it.
Having spent the past week diving into the world of trying to find a lost (now stolen) Switch, I know that it is not uncommon, and the solutions provided by Nintendo absolutely suck. I have the SN for the lost switch. Nintendo should be able to prevent that SN from ever connecting to the estore or being associated with any other switch account. If someone does login with that switch account, they should know that it is a lost/stolen switch and notify the account holder that their information will be transmitted to the switch owner and authorities.
We had our contact information on a label stuck to the back of the device. So if the person who has it wanted to find us, they could easily give me a call to arrange safe return.
33
u/prest0x Apr 25 '22
A Switch is a toy compared to a mobile phone. It's not going to need any of those features, and won't be worth the extra cost to implement and pass onto customers. Consider it an expensive lesson for your kid to keep track of his stuff.
-23
u/gregoryph Apr 25 '22
You can buy iOS devices in the same price range that have the same features, especially when you consider the cost of game cartridges and other accessories that might be in/with the device.
I'm not saying it wasn't my kids fault, or mine or my partners for not double checking his backpack before getting off the plane. But go hang out in r/FindMySwitch or r/FindYourSwitch, and you will see plenty of people (full grown adults even) who have either lost a switch or had one stolen. The features I suggest above would have zero hardware cost. It's just software.
I already dropped another ~$400 to replace the switch, the memory card, the lost games, etc... It is frustrating and it is a frustration that far too many people experience and nintendo could do something that might help some of those people.
8
Apr 25 '22
Why did you buy your child a new one so quickly?
14
u/gregoryph Apr 25 '22
because he was going under the knife for surgery and wasn't going to be able to do much other than play video games while recovering.
11
Apr 25 '22
Ok that makes more sense, not getting him a new one would be putting yourself in a undesirable position in that case. Hopefully the surgery and recovery goes well.
1
u/Hestu951 Apr 26 '22
Even so, after the surgery and recovery (I hope all goes well), you might devise a plan to make him "pay" for the lost item, not necessarily monetarily, but in some kid-equivalent way. Extra chores for a set period of time? Not my call, obviously. Just a suggestion to promote personal responsibility.
2
10
Apr 25 '22
I have the SN for the lost switch. Nintendo should be able to prevent that SN from ever connecting to the estore or being associated with any other switch account.
I'd be pissed at the person who stole my device too, but all this will do is create e-waste. Nobody benefits from an unusable Switch.
12
u/socoprime Apr 26 '22
Nobody SHOULD benefit from a stolen Switch. That's the point. It should become a worthless brick if stolen.
2
u/MittenFacedLad Apr 27 '22
And how would you determine what's actually stolen? What stops someone from selling a used switch then saying it was stolen and getting it disabled? This doesn't make any sense. It's not viable.
1
u/BlazingSpaceGhost Apr 26 '22
Sure if you hate the environment. Personally I'd rather keep devices out of a landfill.
1
-3
Apr 26 '22
Nobody SHOULD benefit from a stolen Switch. That's the point. It should become a worthless brick if stolen.
Why?
14
u/socoprime Apr 26 '22
Bro you seriously asking why a thief should not benefit from stolen goods?
1
Apr 26 '22
No, I'm asking why people would rather have Nintendo contribute to unnecessary e-waste when it's ultimately the owner's fault the device gets stolen. You yourself don't benefit when your stolen device gets bricked, so why do it? The thief isn't going to go "oh, this device is reported stolen, guess I better return it to its rightful owner".
It sounds like people just want to get back at the thief(s) without any other concern. Your device is gone, get over it, contact your insurance, and/or buy a new one. Going out of your way to have it go to a landfill instead of being used elsewhere is silly and spiteful.
This isn't a high-end tech device, expensive, nor does it do much with personal information like a phone or laptop. It's a toy.
3
u/socoprime Apr 26 '22
it's ultimately the owner's fault the device gets stolen.
It is never, ever the fault of the victim in any way, shape, or form when something is stolen from them. The decision to steal always lies solely and exclusively on the thief.
1
u/calithe Apr 26 '22 edited Apr 26 '22
No but they could ditch it and a Good Samaritan could find it and contact the owner. If a switch could be bricked when stolen, it disincentivizes stealing them, thus preventing the original owner from buying another one and putting less stuff in the landfill.
Expensive is relative, not everyone can afford to replace their lost/stolen switch on a whim.
6
Apr 26 '22
If a switch could be bricked when stolen, it disincentivizes stealing them, thus preventing the original owner from buying another one and putting less stuff in the landfill.
Has it been proven that bricking stolen devices disincentivizes stealing them? Worst-case, the device can be stolen and stripped and sold for genuine parts still.
0
u/socoprime Apr 26 '22
It still prevents the thief from being able to flip it or benefit from it as easily. Still worth it.
Besides, by the "rationale" that its "bad" for the environment, we might as well not send police on any calls involving stolen goods as the fuel used by their cars and the wear on them that will necessitate new parts for them being needed is "bad" for the environment too.
-5
u/gregoryph Apr 25 '22
much better that there is a robust market for stolen $300 devices.
2
u/socoprime Apr 26 '22
much better that there is a robust market for stolen $300 devices.
Its hard to believe that guy was defending thieves benefiting from stolen goods. Then again, its the internet, so maybe its not hard to believe at all.
-3
u/MOM_Critic Apr 26 '22
People are even downvoting OP when they make solid points, just because they originally made a couple bad ones. I find it funny that they still get consistently downvoted despite starting to make a lot more sense. The amount of people who will make excuses for Nintendo to not implement something that would cost them almost nothing is really funny too. iT wOulD coSt tOo mUcH tO aDd A LoCk ScReeN.
Nintendo fanboys are the worst. I should know, I am one.
59
u/ookiespookie Apr 25 '22
I get the frustration, and I understand that lashing out at Nintendo and all is probably a great way to try and feel better when at the end of the day you lost it. It is a Nintendo switch, there is no GPS.
You did what you can, hopefully it works out better in the future.
24
u/Dondoz Apr 25 '22
perhaps best thing to do is attach an AirTag hidden inside the switch case? At least you may know where is it.
11
u/Fireball926 Apr 26 '22
The infrastructure to set up and maintain this is a non-starter for a company like Nintendo.
5
u/TomozD89 Apr 26 '22
100% agree. The person who took the switch has access to all your games etc. It's 2022 they should have these basic added features.
1
6
u/link3710 Apr 26 '22
What would stop someone from selling their system, then activating this?
0
u/thecrabbitrabbit Apr 26 '22
Why would anyone do that?
10
u/link3710 Apr 26 '22
Because people are mean and/or vindictive? Especially teenagers, but anyone who didn't want to have to sell their system might.
1
Apr 27 '22 edited May 28 '24
flowery growth aspiring disgusted mourn hard-to-find humor squeal encourage late
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
1
u/link3710 Apr 27 '22
Would that legally be considered theft? Good luck enforcing it.
Edit: ...also, how many stores track the information on who sold them systems?
3
u/Murderturtle12 Apr 26 '22 edited Apr 26 '22
I would love love love to have a access code on my Switch. If not the whole game system let us at least restrict access to games for Pete’s sake. Even my old af PSP has the ability to restrict access to the games.
8
u/collegetriscuit Apr 26 '22
I just want to say that I straight up can't believe the complete lack of empathy or critical thought in this thread. Why does everyone feel so personally attacked by the suggestion of a tracking feature to locate your lost Switch? A standard feature on even the cheapest Android and iOS devices. Yes, even the tablets that only have wifi.
Yes, it's unlikely for Nintendo to implement it given their history of Switch OS improvements. But why is it such a bad idea to want this?
8
u/Hestu951 Apr 26 '22
Oh, I empathize plenty with the plight of this parent--sympathize, even. (I've had my share of frustrations with my kids.) I just don't agree that any of what happened is Nintendo's fault, or even their responsibility to mitigate. Most consumer items, even consoles, don't have iPhone-level theft-protection features. It's an unreasonable expectation.
2
-2
u/MOM_Critic Apr 26 '22
Aside from the fact of it not having GPS and adding it could add a cost, I completely agree. OP started by suggesting something that would require GPS to implement. Fair enough. But the rest of their suggestions mostly varied from decent to great idea, and people are downvoting them and defending Nintendo's baffling decisions as if they're Nintendo defense attorneys. But I guess fanboys really don't surprise me much anymore.
Even the vita had a model where you had 3g lol, but yea, it's way too hard to implement a feature that remotely locks your switch if it's stolen and is connected to the internet. Do people even think before they defend big corps to toxic levels? OP may not be perfect but people are going above and beyond to intentionally antagonize them even when they make good points. Awesome community mucho good.
1
-4
u/Zearo298 Apr 26 '22
It’s Reddit. For some reason, people on here always need to feel like there’s a winner and a loser, and they need to be the winner. Even if it’s a situation non conducive to that mindset, they’ll twist it around to make it that way.
2
u/Einlanzer99 Apr 26 '22
I don't play mine on the go often, in fact it's rare and only because the power was out but it was fully charged. Still, there are times where I want to take it to work and I think a pin number would be a great asset.
There have been several posts here where people have had their Switch stolen and then their cards used to buy games and stuff. A pin would prevent that and the hassle of dealing with refunds/charge backs.
2
u/AWFUL_COCK Apr 26 '22 edited Apr 26 '22
Well, if you think about why those features are important on a phone, you quickly see why they’re not very important on a portable game device. You need to be able to lock people out of your phone because it’s basically a depository for personal information. Your passwords, bank accounts, emails, basically everything you do online is all accessible from there, not to mention your contacts, photos, notes, etc. So, not having the ability to lock others out of it can compromise your identity as well as financial and personal security.
What does your Switch have? Games you downloaded and maybe a credit card saved into the shop. Both of those things you get to keep once you move the primary account off the lost Switch and deactivate the credit card or account or whatever. There just isn’t the same need for these sort of recovery/security functions on a game device. Lots of things that suck to lose don’t have this functionality.
Last, it’s probably just not enough of a problem to warrant working on a solution. How many lost Switches in the world compared to lost phones? People lose their phones constantly because they bring them everywhere. Switches stay home 99% of the time. Why waste money on security features that only 1/100,000 users (very rough estimate) will ever need to use?
2
1
u/Tropolopolo Apr 26 '22
Well, do consider that Nintendo is coming off of dedicated home console before the switch. These types of features haven't exactly been under consideration since home consoles aren't as easy to steal.
Not to say they should not have this feature, they should. But I think it will take some time before Nintendo starts considering these things.
Furthermore, that kind of tech would probably require hardware that isn't on the switch, so it might also just be incapable.
They could do it through wifi, but then the thief can just turn off the wifi. Or the switch might never connect to wifi at all after being stolen (due to wifi passwords and such blocking connection). Moreover, there is no separate satellite service on the switch, so it can't connect that way either (also indicates no gps service).
As much as the switch is a tablet, the design philosophy behind it is definitely isn't tablet/phone-like, so considerations like this were probably not in the discussion. If they were then it was probably ignored due to costs.
Anyways that is pretty much just conjecture though. Sorry for your loss.
edit: spelling
1
u/weirdlittleflute Apr 27 '22
Apple is the gold standard. https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT201472
Not sure but it could be an expensive upgrade.
1
u/Hestu951 Apr 26 '22
Most consumer devices are not protected from theft or loss. That includes tech items. High-price phones are an exception, not the rule. I'm sorry your kid lost that Switch. Maybe a valuable lesson was learned that will prevent such losses in the future. (We all learn the hard way at one time or another.)
1
u/Wolflmg Apr 26 '22
100% agree, anytime we take our expensive toys out of our home we have to have a certain accountability when it comes to taking care of them regardless of our age. How many kid lost their gameboys, long before the days of wifi?
This is why on the airline they always tell you before you get off the plane the make sure that you have all your belongings. When I’m on a plan I make a point not to put any of my belongings in anything but my carry on bag, just just I don’t leave it behind.
1
0
u/Slothjitzu Apr 26 '22
As others have said, the switch doesn't have GPS. It can't be remotely disabled like a phone can.
With that in mind it's probably not worth the extra cost to the consumer to fund R & D and implementation of a way to disable the device remotely tbh.
As for your personal situation, just move on. Your kid lost his switch. It happens, kids are forgetful. He made a huge mistake and you fucked up by not checking he had it before leaving somewhere.
If it doesn't find its way back to you then what happens after you lost the switch is really not something I'd waste time worrying about.
The real solution here is to make sure your kid doesn't forget his switch, and for him to stop being so forgetful. Then none of this is an issue.
1
0
u/Morvisius Apr 26 '22
Besides the GPS thing, even the cheapest android devices can store personal data that can compromise your security ( email access, bank accounts, passwords, notes, etc etc ) The switch doesn’t. The phones have this system because of law and data protection and regulations. If those didn’t exist, probably those devices wouldn’t have those remote bricking options either
0
0
u/Wolflmg Apr 26 '22
There’s really not a reason for it. The Nintendo switch is not a phone. I’m sorry this happened to you, but it just a lesson in learning to be responsible. When I was a little kid I lost my gameboy, losing it taught me to be more responsible and not to leave things, even if it was my moms car where when my my dad took my sister and her friends sledding and somehow through the process they accidentally kicked it out in the snow and it got lost.
0
u/linkchidori Apr 26 '22
I understand your feeling, however, i think we should also take in account the purpose of each device. As far as i know, no gaming console right now has a system to lock it down in any way (if someone could correct it me would be great). In the case of Nintendo, as many has said, they see their consoles as toys, so theres not really an specific reason to implement something like this in their consoles plus it would make things much more complex. For example, imagine if a kid accidentaly locks his console for whatever reason, and he has parents who are not knowledgable on this kind of things (it may happen), ideally he should be able to navigate the console in any way, except if the parents prohibit it. Im not justifying it, but just to remember a reason they may havent done that, as their main public is the kids and not adults. However, i wouldnt be surprised if they do it in their next systems.
-1
u/Walnut156 Apr 26 '22
Usually Nintendo is behind on a lot of tech stuff but even ignoring Nintendo handhelds there hasn't been really any other handheld consoles with thos functionality. It sucks to lose or have your devices stolen but Nintendo or Sony isn't gonna be doing that
-6
u/socoprime Apr 26 '22
Remote disable? If you could brick the device so that no one could use it, reset it, etc... there would be less incentive for a thief or "finder" to keep it.
This should be the universal standard for all mobile devices. And do it in such a way that it literally destroys some of the wiring in the device itself making it so it simply cant be hacked and unlocked.
9
u/ryunocore Apr 26 '22
Having a remotely-activated hardware "poison pill" built into any device sounds like a lawsuit nightmare waiting to happen. A malfunction or exploit could lead to the complete failure of an entire product line. It's a horrible idea.
2
u/MOM_Critic Apr 26 '22
Exactly. Remote temporary disable could even be exploited but I agree with it. An actual straight up full on hardware brick? Yea, that'd be very easy to do depending on the device, but why make it even easier? Then it could be exploited en masse.
Now a days a lot of devices can be overclocked from the OS, so it's conceivable a good enough hacker already could adjust cpu voltage and brick tons of a device if they developed the right exploit. His idea would just make it even easier so that now a script kiddy could even do it lol.
Like I said I get having a remote deactivate but actually destroying the hardware seems excessive lol
79
u/GreenMan802 Apr 25 '22
Your phone has GPS. The Switch does not.