just wrote this all out for a friend playing the game and thought it may be useful to put here for anyone looking for recommendations. this is all my opinion, obviously everyone will have their own favorite familiars depending on how they play the game :) with that out of the way here's my list! apologies for any misspellings :)
₊‧.°.⋆✩*•˚₊‧⋆.*
in my experience, it’s best to have each player have at one ⚔️attacker and one 🛡“tank” (high defense, both magical and physical). third familiar is usually dealers choice, sometimes you can opt for a ✨spellcaster/healer or another attacker/tank, depending on how you like to fight. when choosing between two final evolutions, pick which one has better stats and abilities suited to fit any gaps in your party. i put a star ✩ next the ones i consistently pick, but all are valid options!
oliver’s best familiars are:
⚔️✩catastroceros (evolved from dinoceros found on the genie’s steps, need tengri to get there)
⚔️petramander (evolved from sillymander, found in vault of tears)
🛡✩claptrap (evolved from whippersnapper, found in deep dark wood)
✨✩obscuroboros or flouroboros (evolved from oroboros, found in world map near ding dong dell and that whole grassy area)
⚔️batterhorn or splatterhorn (evolved from little bighorn, found on base of old smoky)
esther’s best familiars are:
⚔️✩grimray (evolved from hooray found, in the sea near castaway covet)
✨nightcap or ✩madcap (evolved from napcap, found in golden grove, make sure you compare stats and learnable tricks to decide which final evolution works best for you)
🛡✩wildwood (evolved from lumberwood found on no longer mine island near hamelin/teeheti, this one is a huge pain but SO WORTH IT!!)
⚔️grifurnace or grifrigerator (evolved from griffy who you get from exchanging griffy ticket at temple of trials)
swaine’s best familiars are:
⚔️✩aye-aye sir (evolved from the lemur you get in ding dong dell)
🛡✩paleolith (evolved from monolith found in grassy area near castaway cove)
⚔️✩bone baron (evolved from bonehead found in shimmering sands near al mamoon)
✨supercogdenser or supercogductor (evolved from cogger, found in pig iron plain near hamelin)
4th characters best familiars are:
✨sugarplum sprite (evolved from seed sprite you get at golden grove)
✨✩greater naiad (evolved from naiad, found on islands near shipwreck shore/castaway cove where the crab was)
🛡✩eldrich empress (evolved from ice maiden found on winter continent)
⚔️✩evil idler (evolved from idler, can be exchanged for idler ticket at temple of trials. to get idler ticket, you have to cash in 25,000 chips at the crypt casino in the tombstone trail.)
⚔️grimpaler (evolved from shrimpaler found in old smokey)
✨any form of toko! (this one is mostly for show but if you REALLY want to put in the effort it can be a great healer. tokos found on ugly duckling isle, tokotokos found near perdida)
i hope this is helpful!