TL;DR: I started a backup subreddit in March, initially with no real intention of growing it. Six months later, it reached over 500K monthly views. Along the way, I've learned a few things about posting frequency, content creation and moderation that I thought might be worth sharing.
A little background
I originally created this subreddit as a backup after losing top moderator status in the first community I founded. I figured it wouldn't hurt to have another community ready, just in case the original top mod ever returned.
Well, that eventually happened.
The original subreddit had around 45K weekly visitors at its peak. Unfortunately, the remaining moderation team was largely inactive, and we had some disagreements about how the community should be run. I still believed in the approach that had helped build an active community, so I decided to focus on my new subreddit instead.
Fast forward to today, and the new community is averaging around 37K weekly visitors.
The numbers
According to Mod Insights:
April: 4,644 monthly views
August: 119K monthly views
September: 430K monthly views
October: 509,309 monthly views
November: 278K views by November 15.
Some other statistics:
2,353 members (2,340 joined, 181 left).
928 posts published.
27,767 comments.
35 posts removed (3.8%).
780 comments removed (2.8%).
One thing worth pointing out is that views don't automatically translate into members. There are plenty of people who browse without ever subscribing. That's something I still need to figure out how to improve.
1. Don't rely on just one post a day
Something I've noticed is that most posts receive the majority of their views shortly after being published, followed by another smaller increase the next morning.
Here's an example from one day:
Moderator post: 15.2K views, 10 upvotes.
Moderator post (not AI-generated): 17.2K views, 52 comments, but quickly downvoted.
Member post: 5.2K views, 1 upvote.
Moderator post: 6.2K views, 5 upvotes.
That's roughly 44K views across four posts in a single day.
My experience so far is that spreading 3–4 posts throughout the day works better than publishing everything at once or relying on a single daily post.
Of course, this isn't a universal rule. If one post is performing exceptionally well, there's no reason to keep publishing just for the sake of it. I also count posts submitted by members, not just moderator contributions.
2. Sometimes low-effort content performs better
This is probably one of the more surprising things I've learned.
I occasionally publish news summaries that take me around five minutes to prepare. These regularly outperform my own driving impressions, which can take up to five hours to write.
One of those summaries reached 124 upvotes and over 100K views.
I do use AI to help with summarising articles, but I edit the results myself before publishing. I'm also transparent about using AI when appropriate.
Obviously, a timely news story with broad appeal has a different audience than a detailed driving impression. Still, it made me reconsider how much time I spend creating individual posts.
Sometimes a simple, relevant discussion starter is more valuable than spending hours perfecting a single contribution.
3. Moderation doesn't always have to mean removing everything
I've also changed my approach to moderation over time.
I generally prefer using shadowbans rather than immediately issuing outright bans. I use Ban Extended for this, rather than relying on AutoModerator for everything.
I've recently introduced Hive Protector. It doesn't remove much content automatically, but I use it to flag accounts that participate in communities that might conflict with the purpose of my subreddit. I review those flags manually rather than treating them as automatic proof of wrongdoing.
I prefer having a moderation setup that helps me identify potential issues without constantly having to intervene in every discussion.
Final thoughts
I'm still learning, and I certainly don't have a magic formula for growing a subreddit.
But if there's one thing I've taken away from this experience, it's that consistency, timing and understanding your audience matter a lot.
I'd be interested to hear from other moderators:
How often do you publish moderator-generated content, and how do you balance that with encouraging members to contribute themselves?
And have you noticed that low-effort posts sometimes outperform the content you spend hours working on?
PS as English isn't my native language: I've also used AI to improve my post, in order to convey better what I wanna tell.