r/NewIran • u/Attlai • Mar 18 '26
Discussion | گفتگو Can we please stop with the omnipresent left-hating circlejerk of this sub?
This is a meta post that's related to the atmosphere of the sub and expressing irritation at the constant left-hating circlejerk. Despite (I believe) not breaking the rules, I am not entirely sure if that post is okay, because it's not directly about Iran. So, I would understand if moderators decide to remove it. No hard feelings.
I'm a leftist. A western leftist even, in that I'm French. And I can't claim to speak for all leftists, but I believe my voice and my thoughts to be much more representative of the opinion of most western leftists than that of a vocal, chronically online, minority of dumbasses, who do exist.
But that minority is constantly used in this sub as a scarecrow in order to build strawman arguments with the aim of derailling discussion about Iranian struggle into western-centric left-hating. And the sub looks more and more like one big left-hating circlejerk. It's frankly annoying, and makes for a very bad look.
I'm not gonna pretend that I'm a huge advocate of the war. As a leftist, my thoughts have been all over the place since the start of the war, and it's been hard to reconciliate my ideals.
I want the regime to fall. I want the Iranians to be free. And I can't pretend I don't feel satisfaction to see any of these regime buffoons dead(even tho in an all-pink world, I would have wanted them put on trial instead), and that I don't feel hopeful to see the regime so weakened.
But the war also makes me deeply worried, because there are still so many ways it can go wrong and lead to a shitty outcome for the Iranian people. Plus, this war happens in a broader context of constant attacks on the international rule of law in the past years by countries like Russia, Israel, the IR and the USA. Which makes me worried in the long term for overall world stability.
So I could never be an advocate of the war. And I still don't believe it will bring anything good for Iranians outside of killing IR leadership. But on the other hand, I don't have any realistic alternative solution either, and I fully understand the desperation of Iranian people after the massacre of January. And if something good truly comes out of the war for the Iranians, I'll be happy to have been wrong, and I'll be cheering along with everyone.
I don't care about being morally right, or right at all, or about being on the "side" of the winners. I just want Iranian people to have a better future and to smile again. And that desire takes priority over all my other thoughts.
In short, I can't bring myself to support the war, out of principle and out of worry. But I don't actively oppose it either, because there is still a chance that it could bring something good for the Iranians.
Not being fans of the war doesn't mean we don't want the regime to fall. And I believe that this complicated position is how most of us "western leftists" actually think.
So, I would appreciate if the left-hating circlejerk could at the very least be tuned down, and that people stop implying at every occasion that we're supporting the regime, which is insulting.
We, "leftists", stand with the Iranian people and their desire for freedom, even if our ideals are all over the place and our thoughts conflicted. We dream of the same better tomorrow than the people who suffer at the hands of the IRGC, and those who wait anxiously for the call of their family and beloved. We also cry for each drop of blood that was spilled by the murderers who are draining the country of its future. We also desire from the bottom of our hearts to see the children of Rostam, Cyrus and Rûmi to stand proud and tall again. We also crave to see the daughters of Iran to be free to sing in the street. And we also crave to hear the song of the morning bird singing the end of tyranny.
