r/NewIran • • Mar 18 '26

Discussion | گفتگو Can we please stop with the omnipresent left-hating circlejerk of this sub?

4 Upvotes

This is a meta post that's related to the atmosphere of the sub and expressing irritation at the constant left-hating circlejerk. Despite (I believe) not breaking the rules, I am not entirely sure if that post is okay, because it's not directly about Iran. So, I would understand if moderators decide to remove it. No hard feelings.

I'm a leftist. A western leftist even, in that I'm French. And I can't claim to speak for all leftists, but I believe my voice and my thoughts to be much more representative of the opinion of most western leftists than that of a vocal, chronically online, minority of dumbasses, who do exist.
But that minority is constantly used in this sub as a scarecrow in order to build strawman arguments with the aim of derailling discussion about Iranian struggle into western-centric left-hating. And the sub looks more and more like one big left-hating circlejerk. It's frankly annoying, and makes for a very bad look.

I'm not gonna pretend that I'm a huge advocate of the war. As a leftist, my thoughts have been all over the place since the start of the war, and it's been hard to reconciliate my ideals.
I want the regime to fall. I want the Iranians to be free. And I can't pretend I don't feel satisfaction to see any of these regime buffoons dead(even tho in an all-pink world, I would have wanted them put on trial instead), and that I don't feel hopeful to see the regime so weakened.
But the war also makes me deeply worried, because there are still so many ways it can go wrong and lead to a shitty outcome for the Iranian people. Plus, this war happens in a broader context of constant attacks on the international rule of law in the past years by countries like Russia, Israel, the IR and the USA. Which makes me worried in the long term for overall world stability.
So I could never be an advocate of the war. And I still don't believe it will bring anything good for Iranians outside of killing IR leadership. But on the other hand, I don't have any realistic alternative solution either, and I fully understand the desperation of Iranian people after the massacre of January. And if something good truly comes out of the war for the Iranians, I'll be happy to have been wrong, and I'll be cheering along with everyone.
I don't care about being morally right, or right at all, or about being on the "side" of the winners. I just want Iranian people to have a better future and to smile again. And that desire takes priority over all my other thoughts.

In short, I can't bring myself to support the war, out of principle and out of worry. But I don't actively oppose it either, because there is still a chance that it could bring something good for the Iranians.
Not being fans of the war doesn't mean we don't want the regime to fall. And I believe that this complicated position is how most of us "western leftists" actually think.

So, I would appreciate if the left-hating circlejerk could at the very least be tuned down, and that people stop implying at every occasion that we're supporting the regime, which is insulting.

We, "leftists", stand with the Iranian people and their desire for freedom, even if our ideals are all over the place and our thoughts conflicted. We dream of the same better tomorrow than the people who suffer at the hands of the IRGC, and those who wait anxiously for the call of their family and beloved. We also cry for each drop of blood that was spilled by the murderers who are draining the country of its future. We also desire from the bottom of our hearts to see the children of Rostam, Cyrus and Rûmi to stand proud and tall again. We also crave to see the daughters of Iran to be free to sing in the street. And we also crave to hear the song of the morning bird singing the end of tyranny.


r/NewIran • • May 11 '25

Can we stop waving the Lion and Sun Flag at Pro-Israel protests and stop waving the Israeli Flag at Anti-Regime protests?

0 Upvotes

This cross-pollination needs to stop. Our cause is being hijacked and diluted.

At the Reza Pahlavi-led pro-sanction protest in Washington DC, there were just as many Israeli flags as Lion and Sun flags. The same thing happened at a demonstration in LA’s Capitol building, ostensibly about Iranian freedom, yet filled with Israeli flags and slogans. Why is that acceptable? Why are we letting outsiders redirect the narrative of our struggle?

Let me be crystal clear: opposing the Islamic Republic does not mean supporting Israeli policies or interests. If you are Pro-Israel, that's fine, I disagree but I'm not going to stop you. But waving the Israeli flag at Iranian protests makes us look like pawns in someone else’s geopolitical game. It's not solidarity, it's co-optation. Israel has its own foreign policy agenda regarding Iran, and it's not driven by a concern for human rights or the wellbeing of ordinary Iranians. It's about regional dominance, military containment, and pressure campaigns. We shouldn't be seen as cheerleaders for that.

On the flip side, what are Iranian flags doing at pro-Israel rallies? Those events aren't about Iranian freedom; they're about boosting Israel’s global image, often in the context of brutal military campaigns. By showing up and flying our flag, we're making our cause look like a side project of theirs. That’s dangerous. We also end up looking selfish and like we want attention.

This blending of movements that have very different goals is dishonest and self-defeating. It sends the message that our opposition to the regime is tied to Israeli or U.S. foreign policy, not because we believe in justice, dignity, or freedom for our people.

Let’s be principled. Let’s be clear. Our cause is not a vehicle for Israeli geopolitics. And it loses its legitimacy every time we let others hijack it. Again, if you are Pro-Israel, that's fine. But separate the causes they have nothing to do with each other.


r/NewIran • • Mar 24 '26

Discussion | گفتگو I don't love the posture this sub is adopting

0 Upvotes

Premise: I know Iranian people living in Iran, but I'm not Iranian myself, so I understand I'm not very much entitled to criticise most of the users of this sub.

I've been very vocal with many people I know about the struggle of my Iranian people, telling them what my friend in Iran is going through, denouncing the atrocities the IR has committed over the past years.

I'm a supporter of the liberation, even if violent, of the Iranian people, I'm a supporter of this military operation even if scared about the possible outcomes given that Trump and Netanyahu are untrustworthy.

All this said, I've been reading increasingly intolerant comments about dissenting opinions, political attacks, demeaning comments about leftists, europeans and so on.

I understand that these are really tense times and the stakes are extremely high, but I think we should accept that not everybody who ever so slightly disagree with us is a regime goon or a coward. For example, Macron calling Pezeshkian on the phone is just doing his job, and it's possible that many european countries just have a tradition of non-intervention instead of being active supporters of the IR.

I know I'll be downvoted, but please try to understand my point of view. I'm not posting this to criticize the opinions some of us have, but mostly the way we convey them. We should always express our views but also care about finding middle ground and not alienating potential supporters, since even the countries who most advocate for a free Iran are skeptic about this war.

I truly and sincerely hope the Islamic Republic repression apparatus and government is torn to pieces and burnt to the ground.


r/NewIran • • 12d ago

Iranian Discussion | گفتگوی ایرانی “Iranians know the price of freedom because we watched it die. People died on the streets of Iran for the freedom you already have. When we tell you to protect it and to vote Republican to make this country better and stronger, it's not politics - it's experience.”

29 Upvotes

r/NewIran • • Oct 10 '23

93% of Hamas funding comes from the IRGC and the Islamic Regime occupying Iran.

Post image
53 Upvotes

r/NewIran • • Feb 25 '26

Revolution ❤️‍🔥 خیزش Reza Pahlavi Needs to Change His Politics and Rhetoric Regarding Kurds and Other Minorities

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Reza Pahlavi has posted a Kurdophobic message on Twitter that benefits nobody other than the regime. Do not fall for the misinformation it contains!

​Pahlavi refers to the Kurdish coalition that formed this week as "separatist" when this is explicitly and provably false. While one of the five Kurdish parties entering the coalition has separatist aspirations, they were able to set these differences aside and UNIFY in their objective of protecting Iran's Kurdish region and demanding federalist autonomy within a UNIFIED IRAN. ​They have even avoided using the Kurdish flag in all insignia and their photo opps to drive home the message that they are not seeking state autonomy but merely federalist autonomy within an Iranian state.

​This political demand does NOT threaten Iran's borders. It is not a demand to carve up Iran! Many countries are federalist: Canada, Germany, India, Switzerland, the USA, and many more. It is a perfectly legitimate way to distribute power within a state.

​But instead of reaching across the aisle to further unify regime opposition as only these groups have done so far within the Iranian opposition landscape, Reza Pahlavi has come out swinging, and with what? Empty threats and insinuations.

​The Kurdish groups are armed, they are trained, they are effective. Instead of creating dialogue, he is oppressing them and claiming their coalition benefits the regime. Is that plausible to you?

​From where I sit, he is the only one benefiting the regime. His abject refusal to work with other opposition groups is shocking! It's hard for me to understand how it is the Kurdish coalition benefiting the regime and not Reza Pahlavi's tribalistic response about one inch of Iran this and one inch of Iran that.

​Is NUFDI open to comment from Iranians? How can we reach out to let them know they need to find a new strategy that is INCLUSIVE instead of manufacturing false divisions that literally do not even exist at this point?


r/NewIran • • May 06 '26

Discussion | گفتگو I am getting really tired of these constant bickering about Trump.

Post image
19 Upvotes

I'm getting really tired of the whole discussion around Trump: whether he is going to make a deal with the regime, whether he's going to attack the regime, whether he will do anything, or whether he'll just pack it up and go. This constant back and forth, this constant bickering, is getting really annoying at this point.

I have been active, giving news articles and sharing information on this sub for months. I have been a member of this sub for years. I have seen everything. I have heard basically everything that there is to hear.

And I am begging you to think. Just think.

For over a month, while I was giving you guys information, signs, and everything there was to show that there is actually going to be kinetic action, that there are going to be strikes on the regime, many of you mocked me, called me delusional, denied the information, and questioned the information for no reason other than your crazy obsession with Trump and how he is backing down, or how he is after a deal for his own good.

For 60 days, people would say "Trump is going to make a deal with the regime and take their money" and when the 60 days was up and war started, people suddenly went quiet.

Same is happening right now and this behaviour makes no sense.

This makes zero sense. This makes no sense.

If you know Trump at all, if you have paid any attention to this man since he started his political journey, you would know that this guy just isn't the way you are talking about him. You would know that this guy is all about legacy.

If you paid attention to Trump before he became president, you would know that he's about ego.

Ego and legacy.

This is a man who has put his name on everything he has had anything to do with. He loves to leave a legacy behind that will be remembered for ages, not years, Ages!

A person obsessed with their legacy will not do some haphazard, half-baked deal because some people on the internet think that he is about to do it. He has a vision for himself. He sees himself in a certain light, and he wants to leave a reputation behind that he feels he deserves.

I'm not talking about whether he actually does deserve it or not, but he wants to leave that reputation behind. He wants that legacy. He actually wants that legacy. He wants to be remembered alongside the likes of Lincoln and Kennedy. He wants to be remembered for decades, if not for centuries.

If you want to have a legacy, you will not ruin it by making a deal that you yourself have, time and time again, called a bad deal. You will not back down when you have the fucking upper hand.

Get this thing into your head: do not listen to his words. Look at the actions.

You do not spend millions, hundreds of millions of dollars, to move your fucking huge-ass ships across the world for no reason whatsoever. You do not deploy thousands upon thousands of soldiers for no reason whatsoever.

This is money. And these governments run on money, and they have to answer for the fucking money that they spend.

Think. For once, think.


r/NewIran • • May 06 '25

Discussion | گفتگو Three generation of Pahlavi, 1st one overthrown a rotten dynasty, 2nd one modernized Iran but was back-stabbed out of power, 3rd one puts out statements.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/NewIran • • Apr 02 '26

Discussion | گفتگو The EU and NATO really f*cked themselves.

19 Upvotes

The United States wasn’t obligated to help Europe in WWII, as it had previously taken a position of neutrality and isolationism. But they answered the call of the allied forces and did what was right for the betterment of the global community. Even prior to the attack on Pearl Harbor, the US provided arms to the allied forces. Even though there was no public support of war involvement at that time, the US still did *something* to help.

Over the past month, EU member states (though not all of them) have blocked the US from accessing air bases, increasing flight times for pilots and making missions more difficult. Reps from these states have called the war in Iran “Trump’s problem.”

The Islamic Republic has committed terrorist attacks on European and US soil, has murdered European and US nationals, and has taken hostages. But aside from the west, the IR is a threat to the ENTIRE WORLD as it has funded terror proxies, continued its nuclear weapons program, fired missiles at every surrounding middle eastern country, and has further developed missiles in an attempt to reach longer ranges.

If these members of the EU consider this Trump’s problem, then their defense moving forward will be their problem. There isn’t much of an incentive moving forward for the US to have as many bases and as many troops deployed in Europe, or for the US to remain a member of NATO which has proven itself to be a useless financial drain as of late.

To all those chanting “No War” in the EU, which has become a safe haven for Islamists, I wish you the best of luck. You’re no better than Iranians, so let’s hope the next 47 years play out better for you than the last 47 did for us.

Fin


r/NewIran • • Oct 12 '26

Discussion | گفتگو USA Elections

0 Upvotes

Please vote Republican (USA) in November. This is part of freeing Iranians from the brutal Shia Mullahs.


r/NewIran • • Dec 16 '22

Revolution انقلاب I consider any anti-religion posts here as IRI propoganda.

24 Upvotes

Hello to all my brothers and sisters. Let me explain the title. in a country of about 40% muslims and about 50-55% religious people, dissing religion only causes division and confusion for us religous people. And ultimately failure of this revolution.

This revolution is about Iran, not religion

We are all fighting for a FREE Iran, our slogan is woman life freedom (as in freedom of speech), we are fighting beside each other disregarding our religion, faith, skin colour, ethnicity, etc.

I think we should all fight these anti-religion posts because they are of no good, will only lose us support from the people, and this sub isn't about religion it's about Iran.

If we stick together, we will win. Much love.


r/NewIran • • Oct 08 '23

Discussion | گفتگو Iranians who "Stand with Israel", why?

2 Upvotes

r/NewIran • • Aug 08 '24

Discussion | گفتگو Very disappointed with the White Supermacist tendencies that has been shown in this community

10 Upvotes

Iranians who support the far right protests in the UK, who go around attacking all brown and black people they see are no different from the Islamic republic. 0 difference. Just because you hate the Islamic republic it doesn’t make you white, it doesn’t make you better than other immigrants you share the countries you live with in the diaspora. You are just like everyone else.

It seems like we forget that after the Iranian hostage crisis the people who gave American Iranians a place to stay safe in and safe communities were Lebanese & Syrian Americans while Iranians were being beat in the streets for something their goverment did.

How can we a as community that has to constantly tell Europeans and Americans that the government & extremist don’t represent our peoples opinions go out and attack people for what other immigrants did?

Absolutely embarrassing . We could do better.


r/NewIran • • Jun 15 '26

Discussion | گفتگو You laughed at me on day one of this war for predicting exactly this (Fuck Trump)

7 Upvotes

I'm living here in the US. Unlike 60-70% of you, I was born in Iran and spent my formative years there. I know Trump's politics and genuinely have no single clue as to how so many of you thought he'd be Iran's savior. Don't even get me started on Netanyahu.

You all say that leftists are delusional, but nothing a leftist has ever said is as delusional as the posturing and wishful thinking going on in this sub for the last few months. The AI images and memes of dead Iranian officials have now been replaced with AI images and memes of Trump, someone who, until a few weeks ago, was "Amoo Trump".

You have 50 years of history telling you that the west has never effectively and successfully implemented regime change in a way that benefits the people. Yet you continue to imagine that an air campaign and the systematic destruction of oil infrastructure is what will result in the Iranian people's salvation?

The evils committed by the Islamic regime over the last ~50 years, and especially since 2018, don't overshadow the role of Trump in our current predicament. The backwards slide in progress clearly started after 2018. No one can convince me that ripping up the Iran deal in Trump's first term benefited anyone other than Israel; it certainly did not help normal Iranians.

I don't want to hear any more praise for Trump from Iranians. This is a man who, driven by hubris and ego, single-handedly uprooted the lives of millions, twice. Now, we're sitting at the end of a war that did not result in freedom, did not uproot the Islamic regime, and did not irreversibly destroy the military capabilities of the regime. Trump is about to gift the regime a permanent foothold in the region, handing them control over the strait, and gifting a package ranging from a few billion to 300 billion USD of reparations and sized assets. At the end of it, he'll even give the regime a TRUMP STAMP of approval.


r/NewIran • • Jun 23 '25

Question | پرسش Why are we saying MIGA?

0 Upvotes

Disclaimer: I'm not Iranian, but hugely sympathetic to your cause. I wish only freedom and prosperity for the Iranian people, and I hope you can be free from the oppressive tyranny of the Islamic Republics regime.

But why are people here using the Donald Trump coined "MIGA" term? Donald Trump is the closest thing the US has had to a dictator for many years, and he is not exactly the poster boy for a society based on the core values of freedom, honesty and justice for all.

I understand that he bombed the nuclear facilities, and I understand that he wants the regime gone as much as you do, but I really think the movement of the Iranian people should be free of the influence of american demagogues and oligarchs.

Again, I am genuinely just curious as to why he is so highly favoured here, instead of remaining critical of foreign influence and focusing on the needs of the Iranian people.

Feel free to remove this post, if you don't think it is relevant to the discussion.


r/NewIran • • Aug 31 '26

Funny | خنده‌ دار US President destroys woke Reporter Asking If He Plans on Nuking Iran "I would never say that, but the answer is yes, I rule out nuclear. No reason for it. Here they are they're totally defeated, so now I defeat them and now I should use a nuclear weapon on top of it? What a STUPID question!"

13 Upvotes

r/NewIran • • Jun 24 '25

Discussion | گفتگو Unfortunately there will not be regime change

2 Upvotes

We all fell for it. Pahlavi, talks of the fall of the ayatollahs. Israel decimated their military/nuclear program. But the ayatollah’s iron grip on the country remains. The only way it can happen is if the Iranians want it to badly that they’re willing to die for it. And they’re not. They just want to survive.


r/NewIran • • Jun 02 '26

Revolution ❤️‍🔥 خیزش Iran will certainly be a secular and democratic republic

5 Upvotes

Becoming a secular and democratic republic with a new constitution consisting of people’s indestructible rights and freedoms will instigate civilizational rebirth of Iran that has never occurred since 550 BC. Iranians supporting a secular and democratic republic and opposing the Islamic Republic at the same time need to lead and dominate the opposition movement and become the loudest and most lively faction of the movement, regardless of non-extremist positions across political spectrum. However, all other factions should not be ousted from the movement, and the movement needs to be united. The US and UK should pay reparations to Iran for the 1953 coup detat by supporting the opposition movement against the Islamic Republic and giving financial aid to the movement. Both the principlists and reformist movements in the Islamic Republic of Iran have done nothing but preserving and maintaining the oppressive, inhumane, and patriarchal regime. Armed uprising with weapons from ethnic insurgents must be organized if necessary.

I stand with the Iranian people in opposing and overthrowing the immoral Islamic Republic with a democratic revolution.

 

Edit:

I'm Singaporean here,and have updated this post due to concerns some of you have told me,so thank you for letting me know.

Despite what I said in this post,it is undeniably better that Iranians will utimately have the final sovereign mandate with a referendum on deciding a government system after the Islamic Republic is overthrown and avoid the mistakes of the 1979 referendum.Seeing that Iranians suffered bloody and tyrannical oppression from the Islamic Republic government since 1979,I made this post to express support for the fearless Iranians taking to the streets to show defiance on a government that is mindlessly killing its people everyday.

I have removed the slogans that are proven to be problematic.If any of you are upset by it,I am sorry about it and my ignorance.

Besides,I am NOT a MEK supporter and I have no positions in the political spectrum.


r/NewIran • • Dec 27 '24

This sub is dead....

0 Upvotes
  1. When you search "iran" it does't even pop up, because the full keyword is "newiran", which will never show up, it needs to be "irannew" or anything "iranTHIS". SEO for reddit is basically ZERO.

Since "New" is infront of Iran, no matter what part of "Iran" you type it doesn't even show up lol.

2. Since there are [age 19+] posts on here you can't even access the subreddit without a reddit account.

3. The subreddit is basically shadowbanned too, because when you search "newiran" (keyword for keyword) rarely does this subreddit show up.

4.It's so dead, that the original "Iran" subreddit which basically has NOTHING going on has been growing and this one has been literally stagnant since post zan zendigi azadi event....


r/NewIran • • Jun 16 '25

Damages in Farabi Hospital in Kermanshah, Iran after Israeli attack

0 Upvotes

r/NewIran • • Jun 13 '25

Iran launches missiles at Israel as retaliation

2 Upvotes

Retaliation has begun

Fvck Khamenei and Fvck Netanyahu

Civilians in Iran are dead. They didn’t hit just military targets

They should all stop this shit, it is harming people


r/NewIran • • Oct 21 '23

Palestinian people are not our enemy.

1 Upvotes

Our movement is a lost cause if we’re outright siding with Israel, they’re as much oppressors as the Islamic republic.

We need to have solidarity with the Palestinian people, they’re not our enemies just because Islamic Republic funds Hamas and Hezbolla. The people are being murdered like pawns just like the Iranian people are.

Outright support for Israel will be the death of our movement when it comes to public opinion. And don’t think for a second that Israel’s going to remove the Islamic Republic for free.

We must stand with the Palestinian people, we must condemn genocide and we must continue our fight against the Islamic Republic.


r/NewIran • • Feb 21 '23

Discussion | گفتگو “Why are you saying ‘zan, zendegi, azadi’ has been hijacked?”

3 Upvotes

r/NewIran • • Oct 03 '25

News | خبر Haaretz: The Israeli Influence Operation in Iran Pushing to Reinstate the Shah Monarchy

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes