r/Netrunner • u/[deleted] • Sep 27 '22
Discussion Why Null Signal is a bad (and stupid) move for NISEI.
Let me start by giving some examples present on NISEI's cards. I will go from sarcastic to serious to further prove my point.
Red Team - Red is an English word that sometimes has political affiliations with radical rightwing Conservative groups in America. Red can be linked to a political party that is linked to Donald Trump, white nationalism, January 6th riots, and many other things that are violent towards other cultures.
Tithe & Retribution - Tithe and Retribution can be a word that strongly relates to Christianity. Surely we wouldn't want any form of reference to a religion that has been the source of death, judgment, wars, and most offensively, bigotry, would we?
Chastushka - Chastushka are old Russian folk songs. According to Wikipedia, here is an example of an extremely offensive, bigoted, sexist Chastushka:
Lieutenant, lieutenant,With polished boots,If the girls won’t put out,Ask the cat!
Not only this, but we must recognize that Chastushka is Russian. How dare we magnify and glorify Russia as they are currently at war with the Ukraine? Are we to support Russia by lifting up their words in Netrunner?
Mestnichestvo - Mestnichestvo is a, okay screw it. Just read here. You get my point.
Before I get into this, I want to state that Null Signal can do whatever they want with their company name. I am just here to expose the half-baked commitment, the ridiculousness, and the sheer absurdity of this stunt in the name of social justice and virtue signaling.
First, Null Signal has admitted that nisei is not a "bad word". Sure, it has some contexts where the word is used to describe a part of American history that is a shameful blemish, but that in and of itself is not a reason to axe the word. If this is the case, then why aren't the four cards above being reconsidered as well? If this is our measuring cup, then these words (yes, even Red Team) are just as offensive.
Next, Shut Up and Sit Down took the time to speak so highly of NISEI and the amazing work they're doing. I truly hope that that video (which has exposed tens of thousands) isn't put to waste when people go to type "NISEI" in Google, see "Null Signal", and don't click it because they think NISEI doesn't exist anymore and passes over the hobby altogether. This was questionable business move and will definitely affect the bottom line. In the name of virtue signaling, Netrunner takes a hit.
Thirdly, Null Signal claims that they are not "nisei", so they cannot be named something that they are not. "It is an identity we as an organisation cannot claim," they stated.
Foolish. Nisei means "second generation", not "oppressed Japanese-American second generation immigrant". Null Signal IS nisei. Null Signal is the second generation of the Netrunner series. It blows my mind that in one sentence, they claim that the word isn't bad, but then in the name of "cultural appropriation", they aren't to use the word. Is a word in another language cultural appropriation? If so, we better throw away half of the English language and never dare order any food from any restaurant ever again. God forbid you order a "taco" and say the word "taco".
Nisei is nisei.
Now, do I think the cardback change is a good idea? Yes, entirely! The cardback looks much more slick without any words on it. Font styles ebb and flow in popularity over time and I think the art on the back is truly fantastic. But changing the name of your entire company to Null Signal, well...
It kind of reminds me of that book from back in middle school. Remember The Giver? A dystopian future where culture ceases to exist.
Everything is gray.
No taste.
No joy.
No love.
No feelings.
No color.
No beauty.
Everything is just a... well, a Null Signal.
I guess you have achieved what you were aiming for.