There was no permadeath. Yes yes, I know you hardcore fanatics will screech at me for saying this, but hold those kneejerks for just a second.
How about give the player a choice: permadeath, or drop-all-items-on-death. That way everyone wins, and no one misses out. No, the game isn't balanced around ONLY permadeath. That's a silly notion. A game that has item gathering, crafting, quests, and even Choose Your Own Adventure style event insta-deaths has no business being permadeath only. Its similar to playing Dark Souls, except instead of losing your currency, your save is deleting and you play back from square one. Neo Scavenger is far too tedious for permadeath to be a good game mechanic, and I doubt you'll convince anyone but dedicated fanatics otherwise. It gives more incentive to uninstall rather than start again. Also, Darkwood is the perfect example of how to do survival scavenging right - offer softcore, mediumcore, and hardcore difficulties for all types of players.
Its just tragic that Neo Scavenger panned out this way, because it had a huge amount of potential. But seeing as though the dev moved on to different projects, I doubt we'll ever get any meaningful updates, let alone any fixes to the grievous flaws with the game (the UI especially). I just hope Blue Bottle Games makes a Neo Scavenger 2, but with more content, items, story, better UI, not made in Flash, more variety in general, and not based solely on permadeath. The premise and foundation of a great game is here, its just a matter of it becoming a reality.