So, I've been lurking this forum for a long time now and I'm really interested in the concept. I'm not a great singer myself (good pitch, bad tone) but I like creating dynamic layered rock music. Stuff that really needs solid, "feature" vocals.
However, I'm always caught in the "is this actually good, or do I just like it because I made it?" loop. I played in original rock bands professionally for a bit over 7 years in the 2000s but there I always had other collaborators; I've never done anything 100% on my own. I don't want to waste time and reddit space posting stuff if it's crap.
So, vocalists, I'd like your opinions. I'm not asking you to sing on this stuff (though if you find yourselves inclined I'll be legitimately stoked to work with you!), I just want to know if you think it's good enough to ask someone to sing on it.
(As an aside, these are rough cuts/quick mixes. Also, Soundcloud does some weird compression. Don't judge on the mixes, please; I know the guitars are too loud in places.)
Instrumental
With proposed vocal melodies/harmonies played on guitar
Title stands for "Why Am I So Tired?" Incidentally it's also the only lyric I insist on being in the song (following the melody at 3:30 through the end); I have other lyrics but I think they're pretty much garbage. 90's grunge meets 80's shoegaze with Pixies dynamics. I'm thinking Alice in Chains-style vocal harmonies on the verses, more garage-rock bark on the pre-choruses, and more dream-pop type vocals on the choruses and coda (maybe with some whisper tracks drenched in reverb for that atmospheric feel).
Instrumental excerpt
Me trying to write something "epic." Nods to U2. This is just a sample/excerpt; structure isn't 100% there but the idea is a very "feature vocal" song that's one long crescendo that cliffs to quietness, then quickly builds up to hammer you in the face again. Have some vocal melody ideas that I think suck; no lyrics (just a working title; it was the 7th song I'd written that day). Conceptually I like the idea of lyrics reflecting a "yeah, the world is in the toilet right now, but we can have hope for the future" thing because that's what was going through my mind as I was writing.
So, I invite your opinions. Please don't pull punches. Is my stuff worth working on? Is it crap? Should I bother pursuing vocalists on this sub?